The forgotten players of Australian cricket

By Marcus Taylor / Roar Rookie

While Australia’s regeneration is grittily struggling forward in the West Indies, it is worth looking at the golden boys of the previous selection panel. Those who were earmarked for greater success, and rightly or wrongly, find themselves on the wrong side of the current selection panel.

Still sailing
Usman Khawaja: Khawaja’s stock in Australian cricket has crashed faster than a US insurance company. Come last summer (2010/11), Khawaja’s rigid technique provided the blueprint for a resurgent Australia.

But for a bit of luck in Brisbane, Khawaja may have made a large score, securing his place at three for the rest of the summer. Yet despite Marsh’s troubles, and Watson’s failure to make the position his own, those clamouring for Khawaja’s name have gone silent.

It appears that Khawaja does not offer more to the side than runs, and when those are in short supply, may be considered a liability. However, a change in attitude in this regard is easily fixed, but one Khawaja will have to make if he wants to wear the baggy green again.

Callum Ferguson: For the most part, the Australian public, and now the selectors, have got Callum Ferguson wrong. He should never have been considered a future Test captain, or even a future Test prospect. Yet as a one-day player, Ferguson is arguably the best one-day batsmen not in that Australian side, and his numbers at ODI level (ave 41.43, strike 85.62) point towards that.

Ferguson had another consistent domestic one-day season, but struggles in other forms of the game appear to have swayed selectors from picking the talented South Australian.

Steve Smith: Smith suffers from the same fate as Phil Hughes, that is, he doesn’t play cricket the right way. It looks ugly, and to that end, easy to criticise. But he has a solid domestic record and has shown periods of dominance in the domestic game. Nor can it be overlooked that he is just 22, and at just 22, captained a T20 winning side, which takes a great deal of tactical nous.

Smith still has raw talent, but rather than try and make him into something, perhaps it would be better if he was just accepted for the player he is, and provided he has the form domestically, give him the chance to shine at international level.

Cameron White: Cameron White can still play for Australia in one-day and T20 cricket. There’s no doubt he endured a horror run that stretched from the home summer in 2010/11 through to the World Cup, and this year’s domestic season.

Yet, prior to that, White was a key weapon in the Australian side, and indeed was one of our better performers. An astute man with an outstanding temperament, White, at 28, can still be seen as a longer term investment than the Hussey brothers (mid-30s) if he can rediscover and provide some late innings firepower that the side currently lacks.

Missed the boat
Doug Bollinger: Doug is the hardest man to put into this category. There is not an Australian supporter out there who doesn’t have a soft spot for the big man, but ill-timed injuries and questions of fitness have conspired against him. It’s worth noting that Doug, at the time of his last appearance, had an imposing ODI record of 62 wickets @ 23.90, including several good performances on the slow pitches in the sub-continent.

Nathan Hauritz: This gentle offie was probably always suited to the shorter form of the game. In fact, his ability as a one-day performer was often understated. Yet it’s hard to escape the feeling that Nathan shot himself in the foot, notably selling all his gear in protest to his axing. Injuries, age and a questionable temperament all count against him.

Trent Copeland: Copeland had his first bad year domestically. While he performed creditably in Sri Lanka, he was not preferred for the faster South African tracks, and quietly slipped off the radar. One wonders whether the juicier pitches in Australia may have skewed his statistics into indicating that he was a better bowler than he actually is.

Mitch Johnson: The mercurial Mitch is gone from our Test team forever. It’s not that Mickey Arthur does not respect his ability. But this Indian summer has seen the development of a cohesive, disciplined attack, high on pressuring batsmen and not seeking to bowl the wonder ball. He may still have a role to play in one-day cricket, but his Test days are finished.

Should never have been in the boat
Steve O’Keefe: It’s no reflection on Steve O’Keefe’s attitude or professionalism that he’s been put into this category. Yet with O’Keefe, it has been a matter of a limited player getting the best out of his ability.

Jason Krejza: Krejza is another to benefit from the ‘specialist’ coaches Cricket Australia had in place towards the end of last decade, turning Krejza from a prodigious spinner to a dart bowler in the quest for accuracy. The selectors appeared never to look at Krejza’s actual record or performance for Tasmania, where he has consistently shone in the shortened forms of the game, never at Shield level.

Josh Hazlewood/Ben Cutting/Jon Holland/Peter George: These men may still have a faint chance of making it into Australian colours again, however, most of them owe their selections to periods of good form, or simply being in the right place at the right time.

The Crowd Says:

2012-12-31T13:26:57+00:00

Nathan Cann

Guest


Jamie Cox?

2012-08-21T08:08:51+00:00

Jimmy

Guest


Josh Hazlewood has missed the boat and were 'simply being in the right place at the right time.' That's ridiculous. He was an outstanding junior cricketer, way above the rest his age.. He debuted for NSW at 17, played consistent quality cricket for them and then rightly got picked for Australia. The only thing that has pushed him to the side is unfortunate injuries over 18 months. This summer he is back fit, still only 21 and if gets through injury free will be right back in the mix.

2012-04-21T03:17:50+00:00

Sherwin Campbell

Guest


Since when does T20 cricket require tactical nous?

2012-04-19T12:53:17+00:00

ManInBlack

Guest


A bit odd that one Andrew McDonald doesn't get a mention anywhere here. Especially for short form game. But, also, as a fine option in conditions such as presently in the Windies.

2012-04-19T10:09:47+00:00

ak

Guest


If they are not selected then they get to play the entire IPL which certainly pays more. They might be even wanting that secretly. Had I been in their place I would have loved to be in the IPL. Not selfish just being practical.

2012-04-19T05:35:04+00:00

Adam Ludeke

Roar Pro


Klinger never did enough to demand selection... an inconsistent and scratchy player.

2012-04-18T04:23:18+00:00

Disco

Roar Guru


I agree.

2012-04-18T04:23:00+00:00

Disco

Roar Guru


Khawaja certainly hasn't received any vocal support from Micky "Class is permanent" Arthur. The former's two terrific Shield seasons apparently count for nothing.

2012-04-18T02:27:21+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Andrew Mcdonald too e was handy and i think deserved more opportunities.

2012-04-18T02:19:23+00:00

john nischke

Guest


Brendon, I agree his confidence level was down upon coming back to last end of Shield. But that happens to everyone who is dropped from a team especially the Aussie team. Plus it doesnt help when you are dropped for simply to put back a player straight from injury and whom scores numerous ducks on return. Put yourself in Khawaja's shoes and feel how he must have felt. He was never never given more than 1 or 2 games in a row and only came in as a replacement for injured team mate, where others, no name mentioned are given numerous chance and full test series to prove there goods. Also his run out in Brissy by Ponting, where he looked the goods is open to opinions. Plus I never heard anyone spoke in support for Khawaja in the team like they did for Marsh and others. Look at Cowan right now , he has almost identcal stats as Khawaja with one extra 50 but no one is complaining about his overly defensive style of play. Fair is Fair.

2012-04-18T02:14:38+00:00

Bayman

Guest


Brendon, You do realise don't you that by your own contribution you are also one of those "armchair idiots on the Roar"? This is the Roar you are on, isn't it? Oh, and glad to see you're still pushing strike rate as technique.

2012-04-17T20:11:18+00:00

Disco

Roar Guru


Another success story for the "batting coach"?

2012-04-17T17:24:33+00:00

Brendon

Guest


Usman Khawaja has the technique but not the confidence yet to succeed at test level. His failures in the Sheffied Shield season in the second half of the season shows there is a mental and confidence problem. He obviously had some very bad advice when starting test cricket, or worse - listened to the arm chair idiots on theroar, and became overly defensive while batting. Letting bad balls go and offering no shot is almost as bad as playing reckless shows. Can't score a century on dot balls alone.

2012-04-17T12:06:20+00:00

Duncan Gering

Guest


AR, I thought that was Matt Elliott, but Hodge does appear to have broken some rule or another.

2012-04-17T10:32:43+00:00

Dane Eldridge

Expert


Great article. Peter George is a classic. You gotta feel for the bloke. At least he can say that he knocked over Sachin. Trent Copeland deserves more respect. He provided something steady at a time when we were all frothing for at least a few maidens from blokes like Mitchell Johnson. I'm always a fan of someone who can just block an end up for around 2 runs per over. I reckon he would be close to the fringes of the current bowling unit.

2012-04-17T08:30:01+00:00

Rhys

Guest


At least with the likes of Khawaja, they are guaranteed another shot at establishing a place in Australia's top six within the next 1-3 years. Ponting and Hussey will retire (or be retired) sometime in the next 3 years which opens two middle order positions for the long term. It's a case of head down and pile on the runs at first class level, and eventually the opportunity will come round again.

AUTHOR

2012-04-17T07:17:01+00:00

Marcus Taylor

Roar Rookie


There's no doubt that Copeland is a very good bowler, and it wasn't my intention to completely disparage his ability. The reason why he is in the 'missed the boat' category is partly to do with what you mentioned above. Arthur, and the selectors, clearly do favour bowlers who are able to move the ball at a greater pace than Copeland. For Copeland to maintain his spot in the side, he rightly or wrongly needed to make an immediate impact. Arthur has put together an even, disciplined unit that does not concede a lot of runs, and has the ability to bowl out a side. If the bowlers who are there don't concede a lot of runs, and can bowl out a side, what more does Copeland offer? On slower pitches, Copeland may still have something to offer. But on harder, faster pitches, his lack of pace can be exposed. County cricket has a number of bowlers with similar ability who have have been found wanting internationally. Players do have bad seasons, and you're probably right in saying that he shouldn't be condemned on the basis of that. But in a summer where bowlers again dominated, he had a really bad year. Those who had been taking wickets continued to do that.

2012-04-17T07:05:38+00:00

jameswm

Guest


Should never have batted at 6 in the test team though. For him to play as a spinning all rounder, you need a keeper who can legitimately bat at 6. Peter Nevill, anyone? He needs to focus more on his nowling though. I'd expected it to come on more than it has.

2012-04-17T07:02:27+00:00

jameswm

Guest


If you're thinking one of a certain three brothers, Klinger, I don't think so.

2012-04-17T06:38:09+00:00

john nischke

Guest


Khawaja, has been treated very harshly by his ommsion. Obviously people who wanted Marsh to succeed so badly, wanted him out with a cause. But as Marsh inclusion showed how bad the decision was and not choose Khawaja just sums up the case. You just have to see his first class record and Marsh would not stand against him or even Forrest. Khawaja had one opportunity against the Indians in the warm game and scored a half century. Well Im still baffled at the decision of Khawaja's omission.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar