Socceroos: Always happy with one point?

By drom5343 / Roar Rookie

Warning: If you’re a die-hard Socceroos fan that believes a 1-1 home draw in a World Cup Qualifying match is a satisfactory result, perhaps stop reading now.

I’m quite surprised at the amount of positive feedback the Socceroos are receiving following their 1-1 draw with Japan in Brisbane.

If you hadn’t seen the game, and I told you that Japan, the away side, had outplayed Australia and were probably deserving of the win and that the home side weren’t deserving of a point, you might end up questioning me.

But I don’t believe I would have been lying. Why are we glorifying the fact that our players got out-played and out-thought, regularly cut up through the final third, but somehow managed to hold on for a draw?

Had it not been for a soft penalty decision awarded in our favour, I’m willing to bet the Japanese would have scored two more.

Let’s not forget, prior to Mark Milligan’s incorrect send-off, the Japanese were already knocking hard on our door. But in light of the send-off, credit is due for the Socceroos in holding on from that point.

The Socceroos in my opinion are living off the memories of the “Fritz Walter” and the Munich Olympic Stadium. The tactics and team selection are stale, and won’t provide any future success to match, or even exceed that of 2006.

Some might see this as being harsh, particularly following a tough few days culminating in an outing against a quality Japanese side, but frankly, this squad is a long way from where it needs to be.

Where does it need to be? Well I’d say the expectation of most Australian football fans and the players themselves would be to see the side at least get out of the group stage in Brazil. They have to get there first.

The Socceroos are fit enough, also strong enough. But I’m stumped if you ask me to describe how they play.

Spain, a great incisive and quick passing game. Italy, skilful but more defensive. England, direct and quick. Brazil, flare and style with great skill. Germany, skilful, organised and disciplined.

Australia. Physical, fighting spirit, hangers on… That’s one of the main problems. There is no real distinction or style of play. It’s remained that way since as long as I can remember, back to that heartbreaking campaign against Iran, with Azizi streaking away to bury us on away goals. But at least we had the likes of Lazaridis, Slater and a fit Kewell, who would more often than not take on their man.

These are the fond memories I’ve been left with of the Socceroos when I was growing up. This was the style, to take the attack to the opponent. Was the style, which provided the memories.

Aside from Cahill and Brosque who were work horses and actually provided some threat, the only real inspiring move or flare shown by the Socceroos last night was a simple turn on the ball by Wilkshire. You can probably remember which one I’m referring to.

Left and right backs are a major weakness. There is no positional certainty in defence, and certainly no attacking threat, lest I should hope at least for an overlapping run. In their defence though, our central defenders are not the fastest, youngest and most skilful and it wouldn’t be prudent should our wingbacks go marauding in a Danny Alves-esque manner and leaving themselves frequently exposed. Holger may also be held accountable on this.

Build up from the back is non-existent and the number of times Ognenovski or Schwarzer were left to clear up field left me fuming and frustrated, particularly when clear possession had been gained in the Japanese half.

Again, Holger may have instructed the style of play to favour this method more, with Cahill and Brosque to bully the Japanese centre backs off those long balls. But part of this can also be apportioned to a defensive or holding midfield that is there basically for that reason only, to defend and cover holes left by the central defensive pairing.

Xabi Alonso, Javier Mascherano, Michael Essien and Marcos Senna are among the better holding midfielders in the world. They are also among the best passers and distributors of the ball. I can’t draw any parallel with our holding midfield.

Please let’s not forget that part of the job of the holding midfield in building from the back, no, period, is to provide the link from front to back, provide passing options and create things when only small chances or windows of opportunity exist. Why are we playing two holding midfielders anyway?

McKay and Wilkshire toiled hard but similarly to our wing-backs, didn’t provide any width or thrust, and the attacking support was just not there for our strikers. We miss Brett Emerton in this regard. We miss Harry in this regard.

We miss Chippers in this regard (good luck to the local Wollongong side with their signing of Chippers by the way, possibly the signing of the season locally). The youth like Ruka, Spiranovic, Kilkenny and Kruse need to be given a meaningful shot.

The question also needs to be raised – where are our new upcoming youngsters? Or are these the ones who are constantly left on the bench to soak up the dreary play of the ageing Socceroos (yes Timmy, I mentioned age. Slick move on Mel in the post-game by the way).

Injuries and jetlag aside (we can’t use these as permanent excuses), the Socceroos are playing a staler version of 2006 football. Threats of the aerial raid against the Japanese are hiding the fact that we are resorting to playing a more polished version of park football.

Let’s define our goal, create our persona and style, and get the fans permanently on side and cause a stir. We have talented youth, but it’s in the thinking, mindset and coaching where the philosophies need to change. Let’s face it; I would honestly have preferred to lose 4-3 against Japan than that result last night.

I love the Socceroos, and have since I was a kid. I was in Sydney for the Uruguay game in 2005. I was in Germany in 2006. I was in Thailand in 2007 for the AFC. I’m all for promoting the game here in amongst the plethora of other mainstream sports, but let’s not paint the wrong picture of the game either.

Am I a cynic, or just being realistic? Am I even starting to sound like Fozzy?

The Crowd Says:

2012-06-18T06:10:49+00:00

Bondy

Guest


What other international sports do we have that we can genuinely gauage ourselves against ! None.

2012-06-16T05:26:38+00:00

Realfootball

Guest


One word in response to this article: yes. You are not alone, drom, and you will find 442 forums, for example, full of posts agreeing with you. A very ordinary Soccerroos side, poorly selected and poorly coached. Haven't read the previous responses, but no doubt that crusty old accountant Fussball was in there banging on about RESULTS and POINTS, missing the point completely, as he usually does. Still, its understandable if, like Fussball, you think that statistics are the meaning of life. After all, he though Pim Verbeek was God's gift to Australian football, and we all know how that turned out. No doubt you have one of your witty reposts ready to go, Fussball, but don't bother - I won't read it.

2012-06-15T01:15:16+00:00

michael

Guest


See Lucas Neill's comments in the SMH this morning where he suggests they only need to win all their home games and get a draw in an away game to get thru. I like it when get up beat, but Lucas has a tendency as he did in the last WCup to suggest that the bridge has been built when in fact we are still building the foundations. This type of mindset has the ability to bring everyone crashing down to earth hard when we don't get what we expected. Better to act cautious and take each game on its merits and on the day.... And as the saying goes only a fool and his money would not count Jordan and Iraq as walk overs on their home turf in a WC qualifier.....

2012-06-14T18:16:42+00:00

Fussball ist unser leben

Roar Guru


Excellent video commentary & the footage clearly shows AUS had more clear goal-scoring chances.

AUTHOR

2012-06-14T12:37:36+00:00

drom5343

Roar Rookie


Thanks for the feedback Damo. Hopefully things will only get better from here.

AUTHOR

2012-06-14T12:31:51+00:00

drom5343

Roar Rookie


Maybe a more balanced video source: http://youtu.be/Cuc9Tfwf_38 . If you don't see it that way, at least enjoy the commentary and graphics.

AUTHOR

2012-06-14T12:06:50+00:00

drom5343

Roar Rookie


My point exactly.

AUTHOR

2012-06-14T12:04:55+00:00

drom5343

Roar Rookie


Well, Japan is actually ranked 23rd in the FIFA rankings at present (http://www.fifa.com/worldranking/rankingtable/index.html). If you look further down the list, Australia is ranked 24th. If you look into those numbers a little more, you'll notice that the rankings released prior had Australia ranked 21st and Japan 30th. I wasn't implying anything about technical skill being a measure of a side, but you'd expect a World top 25 side to have some ability (good God, we're 24th??) We are smart and determined i guess, but those alone aren't going to get us far. What's Rinus Michels and Total Football got to do with anything I wrote?

AUTHOR

2012-06-14T11:39:43+00:00

drom5343

Roar Rookie


Thanks for the feedback Tom. I agree with your point about the results "given the circumstances" and maybe I should have recognised that a little more. Osieck is also doing a fairly good job with the resources at hand.

2012-06-14T02:06:47+00:00

bj

Guest


The evidence we would be happy with a point from this game is our team captain saying "if we'd been offered a point before the game we would have taken it"

2012-06-14T02:02:31+00:00

Kasey

Guest


St. Tim is a great player and far be it for me to tell him how to do his job. Honestly who the f*ck am I as a player? I’m (just) a fan. However if the world had paused before the trigger was pulled and the Devil asked me how much would you like to wager that the resultant shot would deliver a goal, I would not have a place to sleep at the moment. I’m sure once he re-discovers his scoring touch, he will get a bag of goals, form is temporary; class is permanent. I just hope he discovers his scoring touch whilst wearing a Green & gold shirt. I watch every Socceroos game, but rarely catch the toffees and I would love to see the great man gorge himself at the goal scoring table.

2012-06-14T01:50:25+00:00

Nathan of Perth

Guest


He really should have placed the shot better. Easy to criticise from the loungeroom I know but it was far too straight.

2012-06-14T01:10:24+00:00

Kasey

Guest


Fuss: IMO Cahill of 2006 vintage would have buried that shot, in fact I was waiting for the net to bulge when I realised who had the ball and was bearing down on the JPN 'keeper. I love St Timothy, but this year has been a terribly barren patch for him in front of goal. I hope he finds his scoring boots very soon.

2012-06-14T01:06:46+00:00

Andyroo

Guest


I'm hoping Japan win most of there other games so they are not giving points to other teams as the top 2 qualify. But if Japan are the clear leader then Australia is going to have a big target on our head from the Middle East teams as their realistic chance of qualifying. It looks like Iraq aren't going to do so well this time and Jordan could be the competition for 2nd spot. They are quite well connected in the AFC which is sadly a worry.

It was a very encouraging performance under trying circumstances drom5343. Credit where credit is due. We got a very lucky 2:1 win against Germany in a friendly recently but in comparison of the performances I'm more excited about this 1:1 against Japan.

2012-06-14T00:40:27+00:00

michael

Guest


And more importantly, if Japan wins its next game albeit it they may still have played one game more than the Socceroos at that point in time, Japan will be on 10 points……the pressure that will come into play on the Socceroos will not be good…..

2012-06-14T00:28:03+00:00

Andyroo

Guest


The problem with just a point at home is coupled with just a point away at Oman we now have two away games in a row. We are getting very close to having to win all 3 of our remaining home games. Which is doable but we are one bad referee away from being vulnerable. If we lose either of the next two we will be in real trouble mainly because that gives another team 3 points. I would be pretty happy if we can get four points from those two games. Last campaign we racked up the wins early and it was a lot less stressful as a fan.

2012-06-13T23:34:12+00:00

michael

Guest


The lack of younger players who should have been exposed and tested earlier on is a tactical error and will haunt later if it becomes necessary to blood other players on the fly due to injuries. Gaining only 2 points from two games will play on the Socceroos if they again draw or in fact lose in any of their next games and could create an air of desperation. The fact that Japan sit on 7 points from 3 games will act a boost to the other teams competing with the Socceroos. Its not a good position to be in for the Socceroos. I doubt the confidence displayed by Neill and Cahill about the Socceroos getting thru the qualification....

2012-06-13T13:44:37+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


I think this is an important point. It looks like we're competing against Oman, Iraq and Jordan for that second spot. So far each of those teams has had a chance to take maximum points against another team in that quartet and have all failed. We still have all of our home games against those teams. Funnily enough, it's not for another nine months that we actually play another home game in this qualification round. The side might well be radically different by then.

2012-06-13T13:15:38+00:00

The Cattery

Roar Guru


It's basically a carbon copy of the Pim years, except the the team is getting older.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar