AFL should be about the game, not media

By Dan Lonergan / Expert

The AFL is a huge business and is getting bigger by the minute, with saturation coverage this off-season greater than ever before.

While there was no footy, the longer trade period, introduction of free agency and the anti-drugs investigation that has engulfed Essendon were all big news items.

It could be argued that the AFL would have been delighted with all the coverage of the draft and the free agency recruiting extravaganza.

They could probably have done without the performance enhancing substances issue.

However, with investigations regarding the matter continuing and so many people employed solely to cover the game, there will be many different angles brought up as the various media outlets try and stay ahead of each other to get the next exclusive or breaking story.

It’s the job of many of the individuals at these organisations to break stories and it can’t be denied that these are pressure filled roles with editors and news directors breathing down their necks to stay ahead of the opposition.

But as a long-serving member of the media I am concerned that the game is becoming more about media personalities, their egos, conflicts and clashing with other high-profile members of the media.

In recent years there has been too many examples – in fact one is too many – of football journalists or broadcasters criticising each other because they didn’t like the way a story was covered, or they got the exclusive before them, or even made it about them instead of the game.

We all got into the industry in the first place our love of and passion for footy – well I think that was the reason, wasn’t it?

All of us who work in the media covering the footy need to remember that we are lucky to be doing what we are doing.

It’s a pretty good life to go to a sporting event and not pay to get in and then actually get paid to watch it or write on it or talk about it.

However, chief football writers or reporters have had a tendancy to make it about themselves.

I am not sure why the Herald Sun’s Mark Robinson needed to criticise Damian Barratt, Craig Hutchinson and Channel Nine for the Dane Swan interview on the first edition of the season of The Footy Show last week.

‘Robbo’ is well-respected within the industry as a leading AFL journalist, but in some circles his column may have seemed like sour grapes.

Barratt on the Austereo Radio Network the next day certainly thought it was and was personal in his attack on him as the new chief football writer of the Herald Sun, saying he wasn’t in the class of the man he replaced, Mike Sheahan, or words to that affect anyway.

Ok! That’s his opinion and in the words of the late and great rugby league player, Arthur Beetson, opinions are like backsides! We’ve all got one, but it’s getting coverage and shouldn’t.

We have a great game and product and if it’s the role of the reporter or journalist to go out and break stories and get a scoop, well, that’s great. Good on you.

Your direct opposition then has to up the ante and find the next exclusive.

I know that’s easier said than done from an ABC sports broadcaster and journalist, whose main role is to broadcast sport and I am very lucky to do it, but I still have the responsibility of trying to find a new angle for every on or off field story in the game.

However, it’s not my sole duty and as outlined earlier it would be tough with so many journalists accredited, if that is your main role.

The people who are in the position such as Caroline Wilson from The Age, Mark Robinson, Mark Stevens from Channel Seven and Damian Barratt wouldn’t have been given that duty if they couldn’t do it.

There are many other experienced journalists and broadcasters, who have gained fine reputations for their news breaking in AFL footy along with their analysis and storytelling.

But maybe even after 16 years in the game achieving my dream, I am still too ignorant to think that we could all leave our egos at the door and not get involved in public spats with each other.

Just break the story or find the exclusive if that’s your go in the media or cover the best part of it, what happens on the field, if that’s what you do best or are employed to do.

Like the onfield competition in the AFL, the media is extremely competitive, but that should be behind the scenes, it shouldn’t be the story.

The Crowd Says:

2013-03-16T08:11:41+00:00

Harry

Guest


Total and absolute rubbish Geronimo - back to the reservation for you.

2013-03-15T14:21:31+00:00

Floyd Calhoun

Guest


ALF was an American comedy series from the eighties. Not particularly funny, but still way ahead of your efforts.

2013-03-15T14:01:19+00:00

Paul Roach

Roar Guru


Dan, there's such a fine line between 'the game' and the media coverage around it. Your point is not altogether irrelevant. You talk about concern "that the game is becoming more about media personalities, their egos, conflicts and clashing with other high-profile members of the media.". Well, yes, but isn't that just that the inevitability of footy (irrespective of code) becoming more commercial? Or at the very least, cable TV networks seeking out content for their 24 hour sports channels? That is the nature of the beast. And therefore the expectation on/of the player. It'd be great if footy coverage was confined to footy itself, but there are plenty of even the most die-hard supporters who are still interested in what I will euphemistically call 'the periphery'. It's hard, if idealistic, to draw the line, and I don't pretend to have the solution. Disclaimer: I host 'More Than Just a Game' on ABC Grandstand Digital: mtjag.com

2013-03-15T13:11:47+00:00

albatross

Roar Pro


What is this ALF of which you speak?

2013-03-15T11:51:21+00:00

Martin

Guest


In almost all workplaces we are in competition with our collegues. After all, life in general is all about competing, like just trying to get a seat on a bus is all about being first there. Finding a partner is about competiting. Life is a rat race because of competition.

2013-03-15T07:50:15+00:00

Reccymech

Roar Rookie


Our game is bigger than the personalities in it, be it player, administrator, and/or media. The home & away season cannot come quick enough, although in fairness, the NAB Cup has been an excellent intermission. Maybe, it's just frustration of all the 'circus' events that have taken place since the 2012 Grand Final that has brought it to this.

2013-03-15T06:10:30+00:00

cuzza

Guest


Who are there people you talk about? I live in rural Perth and I love it.

2013-03-15T05:40:18+00:00

Geronimo

Guest


I'll have to take your word that the Age is death riding soccer as they call it but its stablemate Sydney herald is in love with the A-League/football (why do newspapers in the same family call it by a different name)) perhaps due to some strategic advertising....

2013-03-15T05:21:35+00:00

Brodie

Roar Guru


YES YES YES YES. This frustrates the heck out of me. Give me ABC Grandstand or NIRS commentators during a game and give me pure sports reporting/ opinion online and in the newspaper. Great article man.

2013-03-15T04:38:12+00:00

Redb

Roar Guru


Comparing anything to the AFL in Sydney is a win of sorts for the AFL.

2013-03-15T04:05:27+00:00

Franko

Guest


Just as the Age are death riding A-league, and so it goes on...

2013-03-15T02:44:05+00:00

Geronimo

Guest


Do you think its tough in Melbourne media. Heres a quote from a Rugby Union columnist in the Sydney Herald you know in a city where Rugby league is the big game "School's in The latest education numbers from the Rugby Union Players Association are in and they're extraordinary, with 43 per cent of contracted and national academy players enrolled at university this year, a figure almost double the enrolment numbers in the AFL." No mention of comparable numbers for the the big code in that city Rugby League. Perhaps because they are a lot lower than the AFL. This is just one example of the Sydney herald writing stories that dont show the AFL in its brightest light - the Fairfax papers as they are constantly death riding the AFL.

2013-03-15T01:18:53+00:00

Adrian

Guest


TO often we hear about off field issues on players if I am to hear from a sports reporter I want to hear about the sport not some outside issue Caroline Wilson has no ability to talk about the sport so i dont lisen or read anything she has to say let her write for a glossy mag not a sports page in a news paper !!!

2013-03-14T22:15:02+00:00

Happy Hooker

Guest


Yep, enough about me. What do you think about me?

2013-03-14T18:48:21+00:00

VerbosityAbridged

Roar Rookie


Maybe my comment shouldn't be about me but let me tell you a bit about myself ...

Read more at The Roar