Which rugby stocks should you buy and sell?

By Elisha Pearce / Expert

It’s time for your favourite market update, where we throw about the Super Rugby identities that are on the rise or decline in 2013.

Here is who you should be buying or selling.

The stock market is a funny place. It takes no prisoners and you need to have your wits about you to succeed. If you’re feeling a little rocky this year, don’t worry.

Your faithful adviser is here to help you see through the fog.

Buy: Jesse Mogg

It’s hard to believe but I think Jesse Mogg’s stock has only risen since he has been out of action for the Brumbies. Calls for his inclusion in the Wallabies have only grown louder in his absence due to Kurtley Beale’s indiscretions and a lack of other contenders playing the house down.

The Brumbies have faltered a little in the last fortnight, especially when it comes to scoring points. Fans of Mogg and the franchise will hope he returns quickly to add his spark and verve to the side.

He’s been on the rise for some time now, but his value is only becoming more apparent.

I’d be buying major stock in MOG no matter the price right now.

Negotiate an opt-out after 10-15% profit to be safe. The last decade in Australian Rugby has been full of inflated value and bubbles bursting. Make your money and split. Don’t get greedy.

Chiefs coaching staff

Headed by Dave Rennie with Lieutenants Wayne Smith, Tom Coventry and Andrew Strawbridge, the Chiefs coaching staff have done a stellar job since they took office.

These guys are obviously rated pretty highly already, but the longer they keep steering a team that was always high on promise and low on delivery onto bigger and better things the more their stock will rise.

After taking over for the 2012 season, coming off a poor 2011 that featured nine losses, this coaching staff have led the Chiefs to 19 wins including a championship and only five losses.

All the while they’ve delicately balanced promoting new players, polishing the talent of the Sam Canes, Sonny Bill Williams and Gareth Anscombes and keeping a cutting edge of hunger and determination in the squad.

I think it’s safe to say all the men involved aren’t going to be Super Rugby head coaches or assistants forever.

Particularly for those of you closer to retirement wanting to get a kick before you cash it all in to get that house by the water; these guys aren’t going to let you down soon. They’re full of sound decisions, good principles and get the basics done well.

Sell: Scott Higginbotham

Higginbotham is the forgotten man of Australian rugby at the moment. For the last 24 months many had predicted he was one of the keys to a dominant Australian rugby future. Now, hidden in an under-performing side and among a forward pack that doesn’t do enough of the hard yards, Higginbotham has almost been anonymous this year.

Toiling away without any go-forward ball nullifies the best part of his game – running through broken play, creating space, being generally athletic and trying different skills on the fly.

You haven’t heard many people clamouring for Higginbotham’s inclusion in a Wallabies side this year and there’s a host of replacements vying for caps.

I can only remember two standout moments for Higginbotham this year, scoring a try to reduce the deficit to a mere 57 against the Sharks and a run and great pass that almost set up a try off a turn over against the Reds.

Higginbotham is a 3D television sitting in your lounge room: It sounded like a good idea at the time but it hasn’t been used in so long you barely remember it exists.

Super Rugby is a long season and Higginbotham’s stock has already started to dip, get out before it rips a black hole in your portfolio.

Ma’a Nonu

It may shock some, but I think Nonu’s best days are just behind him and the next generation of inside centre is gunning for his position.

Nonu has been accomplished enough for the Highlanders and still displays an all-round game but he doesn’t appear to be playing with the same kind of burst and energy for 80 minutes anymore.

Now we are two years out from a world cup and it would be the perfect time to try out a few young bloods in Nonu’s position at Test level.

The player I’d be keeping an eye on is Francis Saili. This guy seems to have the game to play inside centre for New Zealand. He’s big and strong, tackles well, runs the ball very strongly and has a great pass too. One such rainbow that put a player in to score against the Bulls elicited an audible reaction when this viewer saw it.

Over at the Chiefs there are two fantastic inside centre options looming. Andrew Horrell is a very strong runner, while Bundee Aki literally eats opposition ball carriers for fun. His tackle counts are very high and helps protect the five-eighth which is very helpful at Test level.

Returns on Nonu might have topped out. Time to hedge your bets.

Watch list: Elton Jantjes

In Jantjies we have one of the most interesting people in Super Rugby this year.

After winning the regular season in 2012 the Stormers fell prey to a rampaging team in the finals.

The decision makers understood that strong defence can win you the percentages over a full season but in a few tight games you need some extra creativity and explosiveness to break open your opposition.

For that reason they’ve given the reigns of a team in its championship window to this sometimes volatile but undoubtedly skilled young fly-half.

Jantjies could be the key to unlocking the beast, or he might wear down under the spotlight and immense pressure of expected success and tank the season for the Stormers.

Already they’ve taken the goal kicking weight off his slim shoulders.

He needs to keep improving in the big games to justify his coach’s gamble. His ability to jink through holes is very good. Also, the late passing is quite something when on time – see the inside ball that put Gio Aplon one-on-one with Robbie Coleman against the Brumbies.

Watch this stock closely. The Jantjies Indicator (TJI) will be a good barometer of how the Stormers sector of the market is travelling this year.

The Crowd Says:

2013-04-05T02:54:46+00:00

ohtani's jacket

Guest


There was a Kiwi journalist who made a comparison between Nonu and Frank Bunce recently. Apparently, Bunce never set the world on fire during the Super Rugby season, which led to annual selection debates until he was finally dropped in '98. Hansen's not going to axe Nonu at this stage anymore than he was willing to axe Weepu and Williams last season. He doesn't have the midfield stocks to do something like that.

2013-04-05T02:41:40+00:00

Kuruki

Roar Guru


Nonu was poor last season until he hit the All blacks. He seems to flourish when surrounded by the Carters and Smith's. Nonu still has a big part to play for the All Blacks this season. I just hope Hansen gives others quality time in the position to develop also.

2013-04-04T23:13:28+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


The Force buying Reds players - unheard of! He will be a good fullback for them though, leaves you Mafi and Dellit for the wings and Cummins into 13. I would have thought that the Force would have done better to chase Matt Lucas of Nick Frisby for scrumhalf and Jono Lance for flyhalf. (Lance and Godwin at 10-12 would excite me).

2013-04-04T22:39:06+00:00

Stephen Kyranis

Guest


Just heard news that Luke Morahan has signed a two year deal with the Western Force!! A good buy!

2013-04-04T11:55:12+00:00

Jonny Boy Jnr

Guest


Another great read Elisha. Is there any chance you could replicate this financial model on the Australian Cricket Team? I would expect at least 200 responses - which would have been 400 had not half the fans deserted them over the last fortnight. By week 10 I wouldn't mind seeing how each team's scrums are ranked too

2013-04-04T08:36:17+00:00

handles

Guest


Guilty of not having seen a lot of him. Need more research. Explains why I am still poor probably.

2013-04-04T08:03:47+00:00

Myles Stedman

Roar Guru


Good list Elisha. I'm adding to it. I'll buy Kade Poki and the Blues' outside backs. All performing spectacularly. So spectacularly I may even sell Israel Dagg. I'll watch list Folau and even Rene Ranger...both seem to be coming into their own...

2013-04-04T07:57:58+00:00

Mantis

Roar Guru


Pocock is only 24... He'll be around for a long time yet. As will Hooper.

2013-04-04T07:56:48+00:00

Mantis

Roar Guru


How about Kuridrani as a genuine 13?

2013-04-04T07:54:57+00:00

Mantis

Roar Guru


Higgers has been the most overrated forward weve had in ages. Playing in a solid QLD side made him look better then he is. Seagulls too much and shirks the work.

2013-04-04T05:06:06+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


As I was reading this I was thinking about long term bets and wouldn’t you love to take a team early 20s Australian Players, a kind of Future Wallabies project team, and give them to Jake White with the instruction “In two years time I want them ready to lift the RWC”. Scott Sio (1.87m, 116kg, 21), James Hanson (1.81m, 102kg, 24), Dan Palmer (1.80m, 112kg, 24) - future Wallaby front row. Rob Simmons (2.00m, 115kg, 23) and Luke Jones (1.97m, 111kg, 22) – Future Wallaby second row. Curtis Browning (1.90m, 108kg, 20), Liam Gill (1.85m, 94kg, 20), Lachlan McCaffrey (1.94m, 108kg, 23) - future Wallaby back row. Add in Slipper (1.85m, 117kg, 23), Siliva (1.77m, 112kg, 21), Ryan (1.89m, 120kg, 24), Neville (2.02m, 120kg, 24), and Hooper (1.82m, 97kg, 21) as reserves and that is one hell of a young forward pack!

2013-04-04T04:30:04+00:00

Handles

Guest


Buy F'Sautia. The first genuine 13 with the combination of pace, ball skills and strength I have seen for a while. Buy Sio, and Mogg, and put anything left over including the house on Liam Gill. Curtis Browning is your real 'penny dreadful' at this point, but if he isn't a Wallaby in the making I am a very poor judge. I am stuck holding bags of Higginbotham, my choice is to dump at a loss or average down. If I hadn't just bet the house on Gill I might be tempted to average down, because Ithink he will improve.

2013-04-04T03:03:45+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


And I agree with it, for what it's worth. I mentioned in a preview of sorts the Stormer's ability to convert defensive strength into attacking opportunity probably rests on how quickly Jantjies can find his feet at Newlands. So I reckon you're bang on the money (pun intended ;-) )

2013-04-04T02:21:38+00:00

Rebel

Guest


That combination may pay big dividends in 2015.

2013-04-04T01:14:35+00:00

mania

Guest


elisha - agree mogg, higgers and chiefs. nonu - imo he's still got it but agree that at this stage he should probably be thinking of a mentoring role with the next up n coming. francis saili i'd wait another season. being a good player in your 1st season is easier than maintaining it for a 2nd season. in season 2 the oppn know u.ditto with aki

2013-04-04T00:32:59+00:00

Elisha Pearce

Guest


Saili seems to have the good doesn't he? I've enjoyed watching him this year.

2013-04-04T00:14:59+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Playing for Grenoble next season (one year + one year option) - that's why I said long term :)

2013-04-04T00:10:54+00:00

Elisha Pearce

Guest


Have I heard correctly that Palmer might be considering a NH switch?

2013-04-04T00:05:25+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


A speculative futures buy on a Sio-Hanson-Palmer Wallaby front row is worth a long term investment in my opinion.

2013-04-03T23:44:24+00:00

Patty K

Guest


C'mon Steve Hanson, Pick Andrew Horrell for the AB's. (might be slightly biased coming from Hawkes Bay) And what about a buy on James Hanson. He's been in great form at the moment.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar