CA selectors have got it right

By Glenn Mitchell / Expert

In many ways, that adage ““we are taking it one week at a time” has become the mantra for Cricket Australia’s national selection panel in its naming of the touring party for the forthcoming Ashes series.

The bolter into the 16-man squad is veteran left-handed opener Chris Rogers.

His recall to the Test squad – his only match in the baggy green was against India at Perth in January 2008 – says two things.

Firstly, his sheer weight of first-class runs, especially in England, is hard to overlook.

Secondly, the fact that at age 35 is he is back in the frame speaks to the parlous state of Australia’s current batting stocks.

Rogers’s inclusion is a short-term fix.

And there is nothing wrong with that at all if Australia is serious about regaining the little urn.

Australia’s top order is far from a settled unit despite the incumbents having had enough opportunities to strongly stake an ongoing claim.

Whilst Shane Watson has not been used as a top-three batsman throughout his career his career average with the willow is a modest 35.3 after 41 appearances.

As an opener he has performed best with 1878 runs at 43.7 in 45 innings.

The bulk of that record came early in his sojourn at the top – against Sri Lanka, South Africa and India – as his last six Tests produced just 202 runs at 20.0.

He has gone 40 innings without a Test century and has just two from 75 innings all up.

Ed Cowan has been a constant in the opening slot since making his debut against India at the MCG on Boxing Day in 2011.

In 17 Tests to date he has averaged 32.9 with his Achilles heel being his inability to convert starts into large scores.

He has made one century and six 50s, but more damning is the fact that he has made ten scores between 20 and 50.

David Warner has blown hot and cold during his 19 Tests.

He has scored three centuries and passed 50 on a further seven occasions yet is average is still below 40.

Phillip Hughes’ most recent reincarnation came in December against Sri Lanka in Hobart.

He has played the last seven Tests for an unflattering return of 380 runs at 29.2, dropping his 24-match career average to 33.0.

The frailty and inconsistency of the top-three has seen Rogers rewarded.

He was named Victorian Shield Cricketer of the Year on the back of 742 runs and three centuries at 49.5.

A veteran of 233 first-class matches, he has scored over 19,000 runs at 50.0 with 58 centuries.

Many of those runs have been plundered in English conditions representing Derbyshire, Leicestershire, Middlesex and Northamptonshire.

In the past four seasons at county level he has made more than 5000 runs at 52.3 with 17 centuries.

Given the problems currently surrounding the nation’s batting stocks, and taking into consideration the recent retirements of Ricky Ponting and Mike Hussey, his choice as an experienced and sound opener is a sensible one.

The lead-in form in the two four-day warm-up matches against Somerset and Worcestershire heading into the first Test will no doubt consolidate the selectors final choice for the top three batting positions.

Many believed Shaun Marsh should be on the plane but his first-class record this past season for Western Australia was lamentable – 152 runs in four matches at 19.0.

His introduction to Test ranks was stellar with scores of 141 and 81 in his first two innings in Sri Lanka in September 2011.

However, he was axed in January 2012 – after seven matches – following 17 runs in his last seven innings which included four ducks.

Aside from his performances in the BBL he has done little at first-class level since his omission to indicate that he is a better Test prospect now.

Brad Haddin, as widely mooted in recent days, is not only back but returns as vice-captain.

With that honorific alongside his name he seems certain to replace Matthew Wade for the Ashes opener at Trent Bridge on 10 July, although Wade is in the tour party.

Like Rogers, he brings experience to the table and in a squad that lacks leadership credentials he is the obvious back-up to Michael Clarke.

He will captain the Australia ‘A’ team that will be in action in England in the lead-in to the Test series.

Despite being a full-time drinks waiter during the recent four-Test series in India, Usman Khawaja still has the selectors’ faith.

He too will get to press his claims during the Australia ‘A’ matches, as will most of the frontline bowlers.

Peter Siddle, James Pattinson, Ryan Harris and Jackson Bird – all in the Test squad alongside Mitchell Starc – will all get valuable time with the English Duke cricket ball ahead of the Tests.

The omission of Mitchell Johnson suggests that his Test career may have come to an end.

Given his trials and tribulations on previous visits to England he was never likely to be chosen this time around especially as the fast bowling department is where Australia is currently strongest.

Nathan Lyon will also take part in the ‘A’ games.

Lyon is the only specialist spinner named in the official Test squad but NSP chairman John Inverarity has stated that a close eye will be kept on Ashton Agar during the Australia ‘A’ series.

James Faulkner, who has impressed in his limited-overs opportunities, has been selected as an all-rounder at the expense of Moises Henriques who debuted in India.

Approximately 30 Australians will be in England during the Ashes series and the NSP can avail themselves of any of those players should the need arise, a reason perhaps for naming initially only 16 players.

The selectors have gone with Rogers and Haddin with an eye to this series, and perhaps the return one in Australia this summer.

They have indicated for the moment that the nest ten Tests – against Australia’s oldest and fiercest foe – are the focus and the development beyond that can wait.

The Crowd Says:

2013-04-25T10:10:39+00:00

Boo Boo

Guest


I really like your 4 bowlers - think they are the best attack. But I would bat Haddin at 7 and at 6 have a bowling Watson or if he's not bowling then Warner at 6.

2013-04-25T00:36:39+00:00

Lancey5times

Guest


If Warner stays in the side I would prefer him down the order at 6. Or better still out altogether. My side would be Cowan Rogers Hughes Clarke Khawaja Haddin Faulkner Harris Pattinson Lyon Bird

2013-04-24T21:44:31+00:00

Baggy_green

Guest


Best thing is that NSP were not blinded bySmith's peformances in India....he is not a player that is suited to english conditions...he is much better player of spinners.than the swinging\seaming stuff I would drop Hughes and play Khawaja instead...makes for a much stronger top 6

2013-04-24T15:05:25+00:00

Baggy_green

Guest


Kev Mate - As is said in the other article... I think Rogers will come in straight away..i see no point in selecting him and keeping him out of the XI. Think one of cowan or warner will play down the order... I really hope that UTK gets a chance...needless to say he's a real talent....and talent is nothing without opportunity.. What ya say mates ?

2013-04-24T10:38:25+00:00

jammel

Guest


Great squad. Really happy with the inclusion of Rogers - and also Khawaja, Bird and Faulkner. It's a squad where we can pick 6 batsmen...ie, no Henriques, Maxwell, Smith, McDonald, White, O'Keefe, etc. as bits and pieces players. Even if Watson doesn't perform we can then select 6 proper batsmen! Well done!

2013-04-24T10:17:29+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Or perhaps a certain accelerated residency application will be finalised.

2013-04-24T10:01:56+00:00

Harry of Floreat

Guest


Amith - rubbish

2013-04-24T09:45:25+00:00

Martyn50

Roar Rookie


Lancey5times Great accurate comment

2013-04-24T08:58:25+00:00

Gezza

Guest


Looking back, you'd have to say there were some genuine mitigating circumstances for the '85 mob due to the rebel tours. How AB would have loved some experienced players like Alderman, Rackemann and Yallop, not to mention the lack of trust and poor morale in Australian cricket in the aftermath of WSC . Mind you, the result may have been the same anyway! The current situation depresses me a little more, given that we're full strength. On another note, I've been thinking recently about Warner as a middle order batsman - maybe No.5 or 6? I just feel his style of play is more akin to a traditional middle order player. I also think having this style of player can reduce the pressure on Khawaja if he's picked - Clarke at No.4, Warner at 5 and Khawaja at 6. Rogers can come in to give us more experience at the top. Still think we'll get done by the Poms, but the current team structure is just not working.

2013-04-24T08:32:08+00:00

Rob Barrow

Guest


I like this squad a lot more than the one which toured India... dropping Maxwell and Henriques is a good move because they are both better suited to short forms (especially Maxwell). Good to see Khawaja retained and Bird and Harris recalled.

AUTHOR

2013-04-24T07:40:59+00:00

Glenn Mitchell

Expert


As mentioned in the article, John Inverarity has stated that the squad an be expanded at any time, which is always the way. I suspect that Agar will be very closely looked at during the Australia A matches and if he performs he will be added to the squad.

2013-04-24T07:38:00+00:00

Nick Richardson

Roar Guru


I was surprised to not see Smith picked in this squad. I thought he would have done enough in India to book his ticket. Kinda funny to think they picked Smith, Henriques and Maxwell in India, but none of them made the plane to England. Maybe they have died down their love affair with all-rounders?

2013-04-24T07:33:12+00:00

Nick Richardson

Roar Guru


+1

2013-04-24T07:21:16+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Other than Clarke, who in the current side is obviously better than, say Ritchie, Wood or Hilditch, let alone Wessels? And who has the potential that Boon had?

2013-04-24T07:11:31+00:00

Timmuh

Roar Guru


If they had learned, they would not have picked Watson and Faulkner saying they were there as batting and bowling all-rounders respectively. Expect Watson to play every game if fit, and Faulkner to play otherwise. Faulkner may also play as the left-armer (like "all-rounder", "left-armer" has almost become a position in selectors minds) if Starc gets rotated out.

2013-04-24T07:09:24+00:00

Timmuh

Roar Guru


When looking at that 1985 team, you have to take into account that Boon had only debuted a few moths earlier against the West Indies and was nothing like the player he would later be. That negates some of the batting advantage 1985 holds. And Thompson was well past his prime, making the squad purely on the back of bans from the rebel tours to South Africa. On that basis, I'd say the 2013 team looks maginally better. That doesn't mean they'll win a game on this tour.

2013-04-24T06:48:54+00:00

Ben Thrift

Roar Rookie


Red Kev - With Cowan at Nottinghamshire and Rogers at Middlesex, I think we have a 10 week bat-off ahead

2013-04-24T06:43:06+00:00

mp

Guest


Lets just hope they have learnt their lessons with playing all rounders. 6 bats, keeper, 4 bowlers please. Watson doesnt fit into any of those categories and if Faulkner is a good enough bowler then ok pick him at 8. If not dont pick him.

2013-04-24T06:30:30+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Disagree about Smith and Faulkner - they are not alternatives. Faulkner is primarily a bowler who can bat. Smith is a fielder who can bat. SOK is the glaring omission but it seems that that ship has sailed until the 2021 Ashes when he'll be 36.

2013-04-24T06:26:07+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Indeed! Although his 424 runs in 6 tests is probably more than Watson and Cowan are going to manage.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar