A Wallabies squad to face Gatland's 37 British and Irish Lions

By Rob9 / Roar Guru

Well it’s official, we know who we’re up against. 37 names from England, Ireland, Scotland and Wales will head down under on a ten-match safari including three tests against our beloved Wallabies.

Now that we know who’s coming, I’d like to throw my bucket of water into the two-week tidal wave of articles from expert selectors before Robbie makes his ‘Lion Tamers’ official.

In slipping my ‘dingo cap’ on, I’ve beefed up my squad numbers to 38 to closely mirror the amount of Lions coming with Gatland.

This is in an attempt to acknowledge all those I believe are legitimately deserved of a Wallaby call-up and are more than up to getting the job done against our tough opposition should they be called upon.

So let’s get into it:

Starting props

Benn Robinson and Ben Alexander – it’s a case of going with our incumbents on each side of the front row.

Both showed they were up to the job on last year’s end of year tour and they’ve continued their impressive form into this year’s Super Rugby season.

Prop is one of those positions where experience is gold and this is especially true against a side that will count its scrum as one of its great strengths.

With 104 Wallaby caps between Robinson and Alexander, these guys have oodles of it.

Bench props

James Slipper and Sekope Kepu – Slipper bolts down a bench spot on the back of some the best form of his career.

Some inspirational carries and his bone-jarring defence has made him one of the most valued members of the Reds pack in 2013.

A great guy to bring on when one of the Ben(n)’s start to tire. If ‘hands for feet’ Sekope could get his ball handling under control, I’d have him starting.

One of our most mobile props with the ability to play effectively on either side of the scrum, he’s a handy ace to have up our sleeve.

Squad props

Dan Palmer and Paddy Ryan – Palmer has also had one of his best seasons to date and he was rewarded with a spot in the 30-man ‘admin camp’.

Ryan didn’t make the cut but I’ve been impressed with him this year. A big unit who’s great with ball in hand and scores more tries than props are allowed.

It’s unfortunate for him that he’s at a club with two other Wallaby regulars.

Starting hooker

Tatafu Polota-Nau – I’d really love Taf to sort his throw out to make this selection a bit easier.

He gets the nod ahead of Moore due to his impressive work around the field and I think his lighter feet could come in handy against the Lions pack.

Bench hooker

Stephen Moore – In my eyes he’s just behind Tatafu Polota-Nau. We’re blessed to have two rock-solid hookers to call upon.

Squad hooker

Saia Fainga’a – hopefully we don’t have to use him as it’s a bit of a drop from second to third best in the hooking position.

In case Moore or Polota-Nau hit the casualty ward, it’ll be handy to have a third hooker with the squad. He gets the nod over his Reds teammate James Hanson due to his slightly larger stature and his greater test experience.

Starting locks

James Horwill and Hugh McMeniman – I can’t wait to see Horwill back in a gold jersey. He’s going to be so vital to this Lions campaign.

First and foremost because of what he brings to the tight five but also because we lack depth in this position.

Put the ‘c’ back next to his name and enough said. Before his recent injury, Hugh came back home with a vengeance.

Fingers crossed his form continues on his return and he adds to his Wallaby caps after a five-year hiatus.

Bench lock

Rob Simmons – this was a tough one for me. Rewind to before the start of the Super Rugby season and I wouldn’t have had him near a full-strength Wallaby 22.

But I’ve been impressed watching him with the Reds this year and am happy to have him come in to give either of the two starters a breather.

Squad lock

Sitaleki Timani – when he’s on, he’s on. But that’s the Tongan Tower’s problem, for mine he’s just too hot and cold.

And at full strength I don’t think I can justify handing him a bench spot either. My initial thought was he’d be a handy impact player to bring on to wreak havoc but I just feel that he could go missing and not have the desired effect.

Starting blindside

Ben Mowe – I thought Deans was bananas not to include him in any Wallaby squads last year but it looks like he’s finally ready to get the nod.

The Brumbies captain has been a vital part his clubs revival and as they look to build on the platform that was established in 2012, Mowen will be an integral of their finals campaign.

An absolute backbone for the Canberra franchise and after a year in waiting, I believe he’s ready to have a similar affect for the Wallabies.

Squad blindside

Scott Higginbotham – it was a tough call to leave ‘Higgers’ out of the 23 all together but his consistency is the big issue I have with him.

One option could be to go with just Kepu (who can play on both sides of the scrum) on the bench and use Higginbotham as an impact player.

But with a starting lock that’s able to slot in at six with ease, I just can’t find a role for the Rebels backrower.

Starting openside

Liam Gill – let me start off by paying homage to David Pocock and suggest that if David Pocock had a Super Rugby season of being David Pocock behind him then I’d have him as my starting seven.

That said, for the amazing open side that Po’ey is we’re blessed with some amazing backups.

If a Horwill or a Genia went down (as in 2012) then we might as well hand over the Tom Richards Trophy, but losing another inspirational player like Pocock is one gap we’re able to effectively plug.

It’s common knowledge that this is going to be one of the most hotly contested positions in the 2013 Wallabies.

There’s the incumbent Hooper, who showed under similar circumstances that he’s more than up to test match standard.

Then there’s the comeback kid Smith who has that all important experience on his side and looks revitalised after a stint in the Top League.

I’ve gone with Gill purely based on form. He’s impressed me the most of the three contenders this Super Rugby season and that’s why he falls over the line.

Bench openside

George Smith – he’s close if not back to his best. A handy old head to inject into a game.

Squad openside

Michael Hooper – I’m so sorry Mike! Such a tough call to make after the season he had last year.

When there’s this level of competition around the seven jersey, it can be a quick fall from the top.

Unfortunately he’s started life as a Tah a little quieter than he finished as a Brumbie and for this reason a red-hot Gill and Smith leapfrog him.

Starting number eight

Wycliff Palu – Ok Cliffy’s injury prone, but get him on the field and keep him there and he’s an asset.

Recently he’s shown glimpses of his best form which suggests that he should be at the back of the Wallaby scrum come June.

He’ll be integral in nullifying the Lions loosies that will be out to prove a point and hulking tight five that will expect to dominate ours.

Squad number eight

Fotu Auelua – Fotu’s had an explosive season for the Brumbies so far in 2013. Questions over his ability to go the distance keep him out of a Wallabies starting role.

At 29 and having never experienced the speed and intensity of test match rugby should ensure that this remains the case during the Lions tour.

Injuries may see him sneak onto the bench but I’ll look forward to seeing him take his chances beyond this important series.

Starting scrum-half

Will Genia – it’s Will Genia!

Bench scrum-half

Nic White – we all would have loved to have seen Nic running around in his first season of test match rugby instead of lying under a surgeon’s knife last year.

I believe he’s grabbed Genia’s understudy spot with daylight his only competition for the bench. Sorry Phipps, but you have no business playing test rugby in June or July.

Starting fly-half

Quade Cooper – yep, as stupid or as genius as it sounds I’m going to put my chips down on Quade.

He’s played himself into form with the Reds this year. He’s kicking with more purpose and running with more confidence and those infamous brain farts are becoming rarer.

His distribution remains an issue for me with a few too many momentum breaking bounce passes and cut out or long passes to players with a defender breathing down their necks.

This will have Roberts, O’Driscoll, Tuilagi and co. licking their lips. My hope is he can eradicate this from his game in the next month.

He’s obviously had issues transferring his Super Rugby form over to the test match arena, but I truly believe that we have a new Quade Cooper in 2013.

He just looks more mature and my theory was confirmed for me when he spoke on Rugby HQ a couple of weeks ago.

He’s starting to look and sound like a legitimate team man which is what you want from your 10. You also can’t discount his combination with Genia.

Bench fly-half

Christian Lealiifano – I’ve put him in the fly-half category because I believe that’s his best position.

That said, he’s on the bench because he’s more than up to the task of covering both 10 and 12.

He had a breakout season last year and was unlucky to not be considered for Wallaby selection due to injury.

If the stars lined up for him last year, I believe he’d have a more serious case to be considered for a starting role against the Lions in one of the two central positions that he covers.

Despite his lack of international experience, he’s been playing too well not to include on the bench.

Squad fly-half

Berrick Barnes – another one unlucky with injury in recent times. He’s a proven performer on the international stage and is able to cover 10, 12 and 15.

If we can maintain a full strength backline I don’t believe we should see him against the Lions, but he’s a handy guy to have on the fringe of the squad.

Starting inside-centre

Ben Tapuai – ‘Taps’ is solid in defence and brings so much more in attack than Deans favourite Pat McCabe.

Most importantly, he’s up to the challenge of containing the traffic that will be heading his way in the midfield and in attack he’ll be sure to keep those on the opposite side of the field on their toes.

Squad inside-centre

Anthony Fainga’a – I went off Anthony last year but he’s impressed me since coming back from injury for the Reds this year.

Again, at full strength he’s one of those ones that wouldn’t get a gig but if called upon to warm the pine I have no doubts he’d step up.

I believe he’s more suited to 12 but obviously he’s more than capable of playing 13.

Starting outside-centre

Adam Ashley-Cooper – he’s the form 13 of the Australian conference if not the entire competition.

I’ve always believed that outside centre is Adam Ashley-Cooper’s best position and you’d see the best of him if he was given an extensive amount of time in the position.

Finally he’s not being used as the Tahs and Wallaby Mr Fix-it and his game is flourishing as a result.

Squad outside-centre

Rob Horne – Rob’s similar but opposite of Ant Fainga’a … let me explain.

I’ve never been a huge fan, but suddenly in 2013 he’s caught my notice. I believe he’s a 13 but there’s a better option playing there so he’s filling in at 12 and doing an impressive job.

Not a starter or even a bench warmer but a good guy to have around and deservedly so after a decent 2013.

Starting wingers

Digby Ioane and Israel Falou – for mine Digby is still one of the first picked in a Wallaby XV.

Obviously not the most skilful winger in world rugby but he’s always looking for work and loves munching up meters which will be imperative for keeping the Lions defence on the back foot.

I really didn’t think I’d put Izzy up there at the start of the year but he’s really starting to incorporate his exceptional footballing skills that he developed in league into his game with the Tahs.

Considering his previous ‘big game’ experience in league and watching him learn and grow over these last nine games leads me to believe that he’ll be ready to take a wing spot against the Lions in June.

On a couple of side notes, I don’t believe a Ioane/Falou wing combo is ideal but I think it will work with Quade as a 10 defending at the back along with a 15 that also has a tactical boot.

I also don’t believe Izzy is up to playing the Lions from fullback. He doesn’t yet have the rugby brain or the vision required to effectively cover this position at an international standard.

Squad wingers

Dom Shipperly, Nick Cummins and Alfi Mafi – Shipperly’s part of a very cluttered Reds outside back roster while also having some injury issues over the last 12 months.

That said, I think he’s a genuine talent with a bright future ahead for both the Reds and the Wallabies.

He’s shown glimpses of this in the opportunities he’s had with the Reds this year and I look forward to seeing him get a start in Perth this weekend.

I’m not sure when Cummins is back for the Force but I still can’t forget the raw toughness he displayed in the chances he got for the Wallabies last year.

Another big (literally) and exciting wing prospect for the Wallabies and if he can get a handful of games for the Force before June and show some of his form from last year then I’d be happy to have him in this squad.

If they’re called upon, guys like Shipperly and the Honey badger could be handy to come up against the likes of North and Cuthbert.

Mafi has been Australia’s form winger of this Super Rugby season.

I don’t think he’s quite ready to be thrown into a game against the Lions but if he can maintain his electrifying form for the Force, Wallaby caps will no doubt appear in the not too distant future.

Starting fullback

James O’Connor – ok, this is where it gets a bit tricky I don’t think this represents JOC’s best position by any stretch.

I still believe he’s our best 12 but it’s a case of this spot needs filling and he needs to be a part of this backline somewhere.

He has the potential to provide some big headaches for the Lions defence so his inclusion is paramount.

Due to his versatility, I believe he is more than capable of playing 15 effectively at this level.

This versatility is also going to come in handy because I don’t know how much time he’s going to get at fullback between now and the first Test.

Bench fullback

Kurtley Beale – he’s another one of those supremely talented players but unfortunately recent events are going to make it hard for him to push for a starting spot.

His skill and ability to cover 10 and 15 will make him a great asset to have on the bench.

That said, if he plays the house down between now and the first Test, I could handle shifting JOC closer to the action and slotting Kurtley in at the back.

That’s going to be a long road though and I guess we’ll get some indication on whether this could become a reality this weekend.

It’s also going to depend on what Damien Hill does with his two star play-makers.

Squad fullbacks

Jesse Mogg and Jono Lance – I really want to have the guts to select Jesse Mogg in the starting 15 but I just can’t bring myself to do it.

The kid has been an absolute dynamo for the Brumbies in 2012 and 2013 but when I watch him I can’t help but get the feeling that he’s going to slip up (to his credit he hasn’t seemed to yet).

It could be something to do with his lanky frame that takes on the form of what Izzy’s frame should have been at GWS.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m a big Mogg fan and believe there are plenty of Wallaby caps on the horizon, but I just don’t want to be right about my feeling during a Lions series.

Lance looks more like a rugby player (physically) and he’s impressed me with the Reds this year too. We haven’t really seen it yet, but he has great versatility having the ability to cover 12 to 15.

Another one that I wouldn’t throw to the Lions if it could be helped, but he’s an in form player with a bright future.

Ok, we got there. A 38-strong squad with my starting 15, eight reserves and another 15 fringe members that hopefully won’t be needed but will benefit from the experience and help with opposed sessions.

I’ll look forward to reading other coach selector articles over the coming weeks before the only one that counts is announced.

The Crowd Says:

2013-05-18T01:02:22+00:00

GED

Guest


1. Robinson 2. Moore 3. Slipper 4. Horwil 5. Timani 6. Higginbotham 7. Gill 8. Paul 9. Genia 10. Beal- if fit 11. Ioane 12. Tapia 13. Ashley- Cooper 14. O'Connor 15. Mogg RESERVES 16. Pelota- Nau 17. White 18. Palmer 19. Smith 20. Folau 21. Mcmeniman 22. Lealiifuno 23. Alexander

2013-05-06T01:47:56+00:00

Mrs J Taylor

Guest


Yes, Quade Cooper No 10. The Lions will have heard such bad comments on his erratic play that he will fool them being superb!!

2013-05-04T02:03:34+00:00

Rob9

Guest


I agree, Mogg's been electrifying for almost 2 seasons now. I just can't bring myself to idea of throwing him into a Lions series. My fault, not his. But if Beale can kick on till June now that he's back, leaving him out will be a bit easier. If you were going to put a someone on the bench who could cover wing, there's plenty of specialist wingers getting around that are a class (or 10) above PMC. If you wanted someone who could also cover 13, if Cummins can get back in time and show some decent form  he'd be the man for the job over McCabe. I'd even throw Lance or Shipperly into that role before PMC. I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure all test matches will be played with an 8 man bench from now on. 

2013-05-04T00:22:46+00:00

Ian

Guest


Thanks. I put Mogg in there due to his ridiculous form this year and because Beale was MIA until last night, if Beale keeps it up then yes. Timani in there until McMeniman gets his first run off the bench, then probably swap them. Not really a fan of Taps (solid super rugby player though), McCabe's got a bad rap, due to being played at inside centre, which he clearly isn't, at outside or wing he's good. I'm sort of questioning putting Smith in there now, seems unfair that he comes back for half a year and gets his test spot back, then leaves again, Hooper and Gill definitely worthy. Are they doing the 23 man squad in southern hemisphere rugby now too?

2013-05-03T23:41:37+00:00

Rob9

Guest


I actually dig this one too. Agree with Beale for Mogg. Get McCabe out of there and go for Taps on the bench, may be (both starting centres can be shuffled around to play wing if needed). Kepu the 2nd prop on the bench and that's as good a match day 23 you'll find! I really like JOC at 12 but unfortunately I don't think it will ever happen at the Rebs again (now that Cipriani's gone home, maybe he'll go back there if they manage to sign a 3rd recognized ball player) and Deans hasn't used him there much if ever.

2013-05-03T22:11:33+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Gill has more talent and a more rounded game than both Hooper and Pocock - he will be the best of the three without a doubt. I realise that is hard to swallow as a long suffering Waratah supporter.

2013-05-03T13:21:17+00:00

Joe22

Guest


Yes. Closest yet. Beale for Mogg Not sure about Timani

2013-05-03T03:11:28+00:00

Rob9

Guest


It’s scary that after all this time of PMC showing nothing more than being a solid defender, he could still get the nod at inside centre (a bloody important position) in a series that will be the biggest thing to happen in Australian rugby since the 2003 RWC. Surely he won’t do it after Taps delivering so much more for the team when he got his chance and after JW leaving PMC on the bench in favour of with a creative, ball playing 12 who’s ignited the Brumbies backline to become one of the most potent in the competition. Someone has to infiltrate Dingo’s stand-up paddle boarding club and get the message across that enough is enough!

2013-05-03T02:09:33+00:00

WOLF

Guest


worlds biggest, i think hooper has potential to be one of the bests no.7's australia has produced. i know theres alot of different views on whos better, gill or hooper.i am a long suffering tahs fan, and i know reds fans will point to that fact, as the reason why i prefer hooper. Red Kev claims that some people like me don't want any reds in the wallabies. to me, thats not the case at all. digby, genia, slipper, tapuia, simmons,hanson and gill, i believe are great players, and deserve their spots in a wallaby squad. the main area where i disagree with RK is cooper. we all know what the cooper debate, consists of, and i don't see any point getting in to it again. anyhow the gill v hooper argument is an absolute no brainer

2013-05-03T01:35:09+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


Interesting reading everyones starting XV's and McCabe isn't in any of them. That said everyone seems to be reading the tea leaves and realise that Pet McCabe will be picked despite not cracking the Brumbies team. If Deans goes conservative which is more than likely at least pick Taps at 12, he and AAC played together on gthe EOYT. Taps is just a good a defender as McCabe.

2013-05-03T01:01:53+00:00

Benny A's Tackle

Guest


Patty came of the bench and played 13 for the Brumbies last start. His skill set it textbook 13, I didn't say I'd pick him but I wouldn't be surprised if Deans is thinking along those lines.

2013-05-02T23:24:59+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


Hooper doesn't have an ARU top up either. The decision should come down to the type of gameplan the Wallabies are taking into the Lions series. Hooper-Higginbotham is good for pace and running and attacking. If it is a tighter conservative style then Gill and Mowen are a better combination. However I doubt very much that Deans will have a gameplan.

2013-05-02T23:11:47+00:00

WOLF

Guest


RK, hooper is a proven performer at test level. Gill hasnt shown enough at test level, no falt of his own.If anyone needs reminding how good hooper was last season the youtube clip, in my opinion answers the "gill v hooper" arguement. With pocock coming back from injury, and hooper if he holds his form, i think it may leave Gill on the outer. seen as though he wasn't offered an ARU top up contract, and with digby getting offered $2.5 mill to go to france, i wouldnt be suprised if he follows suit

2013-05-02T22:54:43+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


RK, I completely agree with your assessment that Gill was superior over the opening 8 or so rounds and have him pencilled in at the moment. If Hooper continues to out perform over the next 5 rounds then I would change my opinion based on the more recent form. Gill still just in front in my view but the gap has closed.

2013-05-02T22:46:18+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


I actually think starting Slipper at no.3 is worth considering.

2013-05-02T22:43:12+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


The "go" with Gill over Hooper is simple. Until last two weeks he was performing better, period. That made it eight weeks of Gill out peforming Hooper, compared to two weeks of Hooper performing better than Gill. There's nothing to pick between them in terms of tackling. Hooper is fast, strong in contact but often too eager in his play, his work lacks the maturity that Gill's has. Gill is also stronger in tight (metres made in close favour Gill heavily) and stronger over the ball in the ruck. He is also a sometimes lineout option at no.6 which Hooper is not. He has a better linking game than Hooper (although a weaker running game). I realise that admitting a Queenslander is a better player is something you are constitutionally unable to do, but it is simply true in this case.

2013-05-02T22:34:52+00:00

Red Kev

Guest


I am "happy" with any of the three playing because I believe all three would do the job. However if it were up to me George Smith would be in the Wallaby set up as a non-playing consultant. He's been there for a Lions tour before, has good experience but I wouldn't be selecting him to play this time. Hooper and Gill will get the job done and deserve it more. Initially I had been favouring Gill to start with Mowen and Hooper on the bench because Gill does harder better work in tight than Hooper and Hooper is the better impact player. However I have since adopted KPM's idea of starting Hooper and Higginbotham for pace and dynamic ball running and (as much as it pains me) I think the best bench sub behind those two is actually G.Smith. So it would depend on the type of game plan Deans has, what type of game he wants to play. As for McCabe. JOC 10, McCabe 12, AAC 13. Lock it in now. I can see Deans' but clenching over the Welsh backrow and a Roberts-Tuilagi centres combo; he'll go conservative.

2013-05-02T21:42:08+00:00

Ted

Roar Rookie


Come the moment - cometh the man . Given the ridiculous decision of ARU not to have a wam up test against anybody - Nauru iIsland or Essendon AFL would do - Deans is forced to give higher consideration to past test performers versus current form - at least for first test . Hooper had such an impressive performance in the Autumn - proving he rises to big matches. Beale has on several occasions shown that extra bottle (genius) to pull games off at the death - true class - he only has to play a couple of good games ( and no bad) to be in . JOC has performed at test level for Deans - his form now is not the issue - avoid more than one bad game and he is in . On other side, dozens in these comments all slot Quade clearly at 10 - his play lately with Genia is the best in our conference . Lets not forget Genia has gone public that it is Cooper that makes Genia play better . This is the winning combination for 1st test . BIL are not quaking in their boots about Toomua or LLO or Barnes . If this was match play Cooper has the wood on Farrell and Sexton - this is the point . Will Deans pick him ? And as for standing up when it counts - and BIL counts - it's impossible to not go with George Smith - he's shown his form now and his record is peerless at lifting his game for the big ones . Also Deans will find a slot for McCabe - in the face of heavy competition and form - he won't be able to help himself putting containing Tuilagi/ Roberts ahead of his own penetration - this may be a good thing . Debate able Finally , Deans will have one wild card to play - Folau will start . This is a big risk for Deans and against character - but Izzy has proved his class in the hottest cauldron of Rugby League and won't be daunted by the occasion . There will then be no room for other experiments . However this is a long 3 test series and injury and performance could see a quite different setup in Sydney if it is a decider .

2013-05-02T21:25:00+00:00

Rob9

Guest


PMC possibly at 13 and I'm the one not paying attention???

2013-05-02T21:22:44+00:00

Rob9

Guest


Yea you've got to wonder how one of our most creative, exciting and free running 10's has come to that conclusion. I like AdamS's theory below about Deans odd selections being shoved in front of us for too long and it's starting to take it's toll on the Australian rugby public. I think Ella was just a bit nervous eg. Referring to Farrell as 'Owens'. Clearly the McCabe thing was a slip of the tongue. He even forgot his name there for a while. I just hope Deans has forgotten it too!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar