The power problem in cycling

By Lee Rodgers / Expert

“How did it go?” I asked a young Frenchman when he’d finally retrieved something akin to a normal breath after the 7.2-kilometre individual time trial at the recent Tour of Friendship race in Thailand.

“Ah, putain!” he exclaimed, working his facial muscles into a look of disgust. “My SRM console screwed up, stopped working, so I didn’t know how hard to go…”

I just stood there looking at him, unable to find a comment that wasn’t going to insult his intelligence.

I mean, seriously? The guy had become so dependent on his power meter that when it ceased to function he didn’t know how to judge his own body’s effort.

This obviously is an extreme case but, as ever in life, it is often only at the extremes where we really begin to learn anything.

This guy had gone over the edge, way beyond the line where a power meter went from being a tool, a guide, to a point where it had become his own personal cult leader.

This guy was living in Jonestown and already three litres of Kool-Aid up.

“Yes,” you may be thinking, “that guy went too far. But I use my SRM to tell me my limits.”

But therein lies the problem. Accepting limits.

Two examples why. The first involves a guy who used to be on my team, who would never attack but who always finished in the pack, seemingly content with a 24th place and not getting dropped out the back.

Now, some kids on my teams come up and ask me for advice, and I can talk to them all day about training and recovery, about how to limit lactic acid build-up in a race and about when and how to attack.

It’s a pleasure to have young riders seeking ways to get better, and to be able to help them.

On the other hand you have guys who blatantly need help who never ask anything. Whether it’s shyness or arrogance I don’t know, but I’m not about to start telling someone ways to improve if they don’t first seek it out.

But this guy, he obviously had talent, and one day I’d had enough of him soft-pedalling in.

“Why do you never do anything in the race?” I asked.

“What do you mean? I always finish.”

“Finishing top 40 is worse than attacking and a DNF! You never attack. How do you expect to ever learn anything or to get better?”

“Yeah but my heart rate monitor tells me I’m near my limit. If I attack and get caught, I’ll get dropped.”

So, ‘knowing his limits’ – and worse, accepting them – was leading this kid to play it safe every race.

Yes, if he did attack with 5km gone he would probably get dropped once he got caught. But so what? Getting dropped through hitting the wall toughens you up. The first time he might only have managed 50km.

But the next time he might manage 60. Then 70. Then… well, who the heck knows?

And that’s it – nobody knows how good he might become with real dedication and a willingness to risk it all. But if he rides forever thinking ‘I know’, with his current attitude, he’ll never improve.

Second example. A guy is on his indoor trainer, riding with power. He does a test. He finds he can do X watts for 60 minutes.

He trains each week for six weeks to get ready for a race, using the power meter each time he rides, indoors and out.

Studies the lines, crunches the numbers. Examines data. Goes on Facebook to tell his pals he is improving. Then, race day comes.

Boom! Straight off the line the pace is mad, he’s looking down and can barely see straight, then it goes uphill and ‘HolycrapIcan’tdothis!’ – and then, sure enough, he pulls the plug.

The fact is his beloved numbers have obscured from him the fact that almost always in a race, without fail, you are going to be riding harder – a lot harder – than you can in training, no matter how regimented and serious you may be.

Improving is not always about a steady progression, in anything in this world. Every once in a while, among the grind and the slow push, you need to get turned inside out, strung out, dropped from a great height and just plain old battered.

You need, from time to time, to glimpse the other side of the wall. To hang in there with someone who is on another level for as long as you can and to go home with a footprint on your backside – but one well earned.

I remember my first race. Once my 15-year-old self had just about gotten over the size of the muscles on the legs of the older guys around me, we then went up a hill that I rode all the time alone at a speed I couldn’t even begin to get my head around.

But I went up it. With the pack. And we did it another five times in total, and I almost won after being in a three-man break for 30 of the 50km race, but bonked so hard with just a few km to go that I fell over and just lay there for a minute until a car came by and asked if I was ok.

Despite having entered another dimension of time and space, I think I said ‘UGH’, and they left me there, my feet still strapped to the pedals and half of my sweaty face covered in small pebbles and the odd cigarette butt.

Possibly a rabbit dropping or two.

Next race it was the same story all over again, except for the ending: this time I won.

My solo attack almost petered out and the pack was just 100m behind me as I crossed the line, but goshdammit, I won. I fell off the bike straight away yet again, but this time with a smile the size of Lance Armstrong’s mini-fridge on my face.

We are surrounded by limits. We encounter our first at home, then a truckload more at school, the ‘do this’ and ‘don’t do that’ – some perfectly reasonable, some less so – along with the ‘you can’t that!’ lot, which are far more insidious.

We have tests that tell us we are dumb and play games that tell us we aren’t good enough, and then we trundle off, after all that, to the ‘real world’ where it all continues apace.

As if there weren’t enough limitations imposed us by society, we then begin to impose them upon ourselves.

I’m too fat.

I’m too old.

I’m too ‘me’.

Well, shove all that. You’ve all no doubt heard those tales about mothers driving down the highway. The car flips. The woman gets out. Her child is inside. There’s a flame. It’s growing. She runs to the car and tries the door, no good.

Then, knowing that she must do something or her child will be dead, she gets a grip and heaves and strains and lifts the car.

Extraordinary strength brought on by extraordinary circumstances. Think she’d have done that if she was using a power meter?

Exactly. Not a chance.

We are extraordinary beings. We are of stars, of this universe, from this universe, yet the universe, perhaps most miraculous of all, is within each of us.

Whenever we say ‘I can’t do that’ – however essentially, unarguably true it may seem – we are denying the limitless potential of the human mind and spirit, of will and the determination to succeed.

You don’t start riding to accept limitations, you start, by and large, to be free. To escape. To just ride, and ride fast.

Then we become more ‘serious’ and start to get into the science of it all, and that’s fine, I love science, I wish it would shine its light on more of the world and our befuddled attempts at existing in it.

Yet to allow it to rule us is to deny the very unscientific elements that, ultimately, make people achieve such wondrous and unfathomable feats.

It’s the immeasurable that makes it all so worthwhile.

Roald Amundsen and Robert Falcon Scott didn’t have power meters. Neither did the first men to set off on rickety vessels across the great oceans. Nor the early climbers of the high mountains. Neither did Eddy Merckx.

Now, I’m no Luddite, and yes, modern technology and power meters and the like can be extremely useful, but let them guide, not rule.

Put them away a few days a week. Try not using an SRM in a hilly race. I’d wager that something like 85% of people who have them don’t use them properly.

I know because I was one. SRM sponsored me for a year, and console just stopped working after two weeks. It was six months before I sent it back, and to be honest, I just kept it on the bike to scare people. Because it meant I was serious. Ha!

Riding is so much in the mind that your philosophy or riding can have a profound effect on everything you do.

See what you can do. Feel your body and its incredible ability to adapt.

And, most of all, feel limitless. Go on, give it a try.

The Crowd Says:

2013-05-29T00:36:28+00:00

Jono Lovelock

Expert


I'm a bit late to the party, but this is a cracker.

2013-05-26T05:20:31+00:00

SjD

Guest


Fantastic article Lee. Thank you so much for your inspiring words.

2013-05-24T18:02:46+00:00

John Jones

Guest


Hey Lee, I live in Singapore. What race are you competing in?

2013-05-23T17:25:35+00:00

Al-Bo

Guest


A parallel example with climbs - you will always produce more power on the steepest climbs simply because you bloody well have to. Try and match that power output for the same duration on a shallower slope and it won't happen. You have to challenge yourself and explore your limits.

AUTHOR

2013-05-23T07:38:06+00:00

Lee Rodgers

Expert


Thanks for the kind words Jeznez, great to know people enjoyed this article! I'm just about to board a plane to go race in Singapore, where I intend to ride according to my VM - my internal Vomit Meter ;-) A saving of about $2300 US over the other meters on the market...

2013-05-23T04:51:48+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Superb article, and like Elisha above I am a non-cyclist (love watching the Tour and listening to Phil Liggett though!) The lessons from your piece are applicable in so many arenas - busting yourself and getting outside your comfort zone can cause failure but that is temporary in the long run it will make you so much stronger. From rugby which I did play - if you weren't puking up in your pre-season training you weren't doing it right. Similarly during the pre-season trials you had to have a go, no point doing just enough to win or be in the game as it put you in no shape to impose the performance you want to deliver when it counts. Really enjoyable read, thanks.

AUTHOR

2013-05-22T17:03:39+00:00

Lee Rodgers

Expert


Thanks again guys, Tim, Bruski, Steve and Bones, comments much appreciated. And yes Tim, I always say train to race. Everything else is essentially a waste of energy.

2013-05-22T13:57:50+00:00

Tim Renowden

Expert


Totally with you, Lee. I know a few guys who can train the house down, all year, any conditions, any session, straight up smash it. Come race day, it all falls to pieces, whether it's because of the pressure, because others lift their intensity, or because racing is unpredictable and they can't cope. It seems to me that when you're racing, you have to be responsive to the race, not to your training efforts. It's that old cliché - you're training to race, not racing to train. SRMs/HRMs/other diagnostics should be a tool to make sure you're training properly for different race conditions, not to set the limits of your efforts during races, imho.

2013-05-22T10:26:16+00:00

bruski

Roar Pro


Awesome read, applies as you said not only to cycling but life..

2013-05-22T10:16:10+00:00

Steve

Guest


Great article, i can relate as I found I had to cover my Heart Rate when racing for similar reasons, the limitations we place on ourselves - fascinating!

2013-05-22T03:58:48+00:00

Bones506

Roar Guru


I have 3 bikes and two PMs. I like the PM for training and it is useful for racing but can go without. I Do like to have my HR numbers around me all the time. With that said I did my second TT on teh weekend and in the last 5km I just buried myself. I can't remember being so broken after finishing - i went well past my red zone. To Delbeato's comments - I love getting off the front and attacking. It is the best way to get fit and improve. Sitting in the entire time doesn't do much for me - I get bored. Usually when I do sit in for an entire race I win b/c I am so fresh. i guess it just depends on the rider. I am known as being ultra aggressive and that concerns riders which is somethign I like.

2013-05-22T03:51:17+00:00

delbeato

Roar Guru


Fantastic article Lee! I've been saying this for ages. I ride C-grade and it annoys the hell out of me the way riders who turn up for their weekly hit-out are happy to follow the bunch around, without ever trying an attack. One race recently, someone in the bunch was vocalising his disapproval of a rider who was hanging off the front - "What is he doing?! He's just hanging there!" He's giving it a go! That's what he's doing. Unlike you, who will just roll in mid-pack. And if you do attack - and I'm talking club races without teams (A grade is different) - riders will spring into action and chase you down like a greyhound. What tactical reason do they have for firing all their ammo that way? Stuff your limits, attack and see if you can raise them, or 'die' trying.

2013-05-22T03:46:02+00:00

Sam

Guest


Great article Lee and so true

2013-05-22T03:28:47+00:00

ed

Guest


I strongly disagree with the calls for a rider's power stats to be part of the tv coverage. DSs would watch in the car & tell their riders when to attack others.This would remove any element of suprise & the ability for a rider to bluff when they are having a bad day. They often say the smartest wins not the strongest. If power stats were broadcast the smarter riders would win less.

AUTHOR

2013-05-22T03:11:29+00:00

Lee Rodgers

Expert


Cadel? Shouldn't you be getting ready?!

AUTHOR

2013-05-22T03:11:03+00:00

Lee Rodgers

Expert


Thanks guys! Ed, like I mentioned, they are very useful as guides and to check just how strong you've become so yes, worth a whirl every once in a while, but all the time? To most this is, as I tried to say in my article, damaging. There's a great but slightly cheesy vid on YouTube, called The Most Astounding Fact, by DeGrasse Tyson - that's kind of a parantheses to this article...

2013-05-22T01:44:24+00:00

Cicero

Guest


Terrific article, better to reach for the stars and just miss than aim for a skunk and hit it. :)

2013-05-21T23:38:14+00:00

ed

Guest


I don't have a power meter. I would be interested in the numbers but strava and my polar CS 200 is enough for me. I am of the opinion that power meters are making pro racing boring as riders know how long they can can sustain an effort for. Euro pros are supposed to ride on "sensations" - refer to the official rules. Don't get me started on race radios

2013-05-21T23:27:15+00:00

Sean Lee

Expert


Hallelujah!

2013-05-21T22:46:51+00:00

Cuddles

Guest


Sensational write up

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar