Blame Twenty20 for the demise of Australian cricket

By Linedropout / Roar Pro

It brings people through the gates, revenue and attention to the game like no other format does, but Twenty20 is doing more damage to the traditional game than good.

Given Australia is about to start the Ashes tour against Somerset, I again watched the famous footage of Allan Border yelling something along the lines of “If you ever do that again you’ll be on the next plane home!” to Craig McDermott when the pace bowler refused to come over to his captain for a chat.

Could you imagine Michael Clarke pulling one of his stray troops into line with such dominance? No. Because he wouldn’t.

What hits me as the most obvious problem with the Australian cricket team at the moment is that it is totally bereft of any influential, dominant or unequivocal leadership.

In bygone eras there would have been at least one player in the team with a take-no-rubbish attitude. Ricky Ponting, Steve Waugh, the aforementioned Allan Border, Greg Chappell (to an extent) and many before them had near perfect captain’s attitudes.

But it doesn’t always need to be the man at the helm with the spine to affect a no-nonsense attitude within the team; Simon Katich, Matthew Hayden and Rod Marsh fit the bill as dressing room enforcers – a position which is desperately needed in the current national team.

It should merely be as simple as picking a player with the qualities that are needed at the moment, but in my opinion there are no players in the domestic scene that care that much about Test cricket. This has had a direct effect on Australian Test cricket.

Promising domestic players with the potential to become the next Allan Border dream of playing Test cricket, but it only takes so many setbacks and omissions from Test squads for said players to turn their backs on the traditional form of the game. The hit-and-giggle format provides a much more secure career and income.

David Warner is a player I believe has the qualities needed to keep the troops in line if ever put in a position of power. I also believe that he, and indeed Cricket Australia, will waste the perfect opportunity of putting him in such a position through disciplinary suspensions and the lure of T20 cricket.

It’s only a matter of time before David asks himself the question: “Why should I put up with this Test cricket nonsense when I could make a living off T20?”

I know Twenty20 is an irreversible evolution of the game but if Cricket Australia is serious about once again being a dominant force in world cricket, a line needs to be drawn in the sand between the different formats.

Players need to pledge their allegiance to one of the formats. Cricketers who want to reach the pinnacle of the game can only play Shield cricket and four day matches for Australia A. Players that want to perfect their ramp shots and slog sweeps can only play BBL, IPL and T20Is.

Such a drastic overhaul of the domestic scene would never happen but I’m sick of players not having the temperament or attention span to nut out a Test innings, let alone a Test career.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2013-11-01T03:10:46+00:00

Linedropout

Roar Pro


I'll direct you to the title of the article, Matthew.

AUTHOR

2013-07-29T02:22:15+00:00

Linedropout

Roar Pro


Wasn't aware the Champions Trophy became Test cricket...

2013-06-29T09:21:33+00:00

Matthew Parker

Roar Rookie


You have to ask yourself, why has it not affected all the other countries that play test cricket?

2013-06-29T02:09:37+00:00

Don Corleone

Guest


+1

2013-06-29T02:06:01+00:00

Don Corleone

Guest


The same purile rubbish is being hashed-out yet again. T20 and the Big Bash League is going nowhere, it's worth a fifth of the TV rights deal and will only get bigger with exposure on free-to-air. The English are playing their Friends Life T20 right now...only a fortnight before the Ashes! What do the Anglophiles on here who raise English preparation at every opportunity think about this? Yet there are endless complaints when BBL overlaps with the final 2 tests of the Australian summer.

2013-06-28T01:14:02+00:00

Ross Heaven

Guest


20/20 is killing all longer forms of cricket and hopefully will die off soon. 20/20 is only interesting to the short attention span of the youth of today and is nothing but a spectacle. It does not allow for players to improve in the longer and more important forms of the game and is destroying Sheffield Shield and Test Cricket in which the player has to spend time at the crease and accumulate runs. It may be a revenue maker but it is just a big show and has no intrinsic value whatsoever.

2013-06-27T18:46:01+00:00

Tenash

Guest


well I guess the author is willing to represent CA in courts around the country for restraint of trade when the players forced to play only tests & shield sue the living cra p out of CA

2013-06-27T13:47:07+00:00

Ahmed

Roar Rookie


We blame T20 for destroying our cricket. But our T20 ranking remains on the wrong side of 5th position. Well i think CA needs to raise the salaries of Top contract holders and offer the top contract to players who do well in Test cricket.

2013-06-27T02:28:53+00:00

matt h

Guest


What you are actually saying is that a lacki of hard heads is ruining Australian cricket. That may be true. I always thought James Hopes ran a tight ship in QLD but he is a bit old to be back in the frame for national honours.

2013-06-27T01:19:26+00:00

Don Corleone

Guest


+1 I remember watching the mid-80s Australian batting line-up with poor temperament and techniques crumpling to the likes of Holding, Marshall and Hadlee like rice paper. No T20 to conveniently blame back then.

2013-06-27T00:18:50+00:00

Chairman Kaga

Guest


Cricket has changed the last 5 years for the worse and it is exactly because of 20/20 and the IPL. I am a long term cricket fan, but I am really put off now. Heaven's hopes that 20/20 will die off because it is killing regular cricket. Maybe baseball will fill the vacuum one day if this persists.

2013-06-27T00:14:11+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Bingo. Blaming T20 is too easy.

2013-06-26T23:42:45+00:00

Johnno

Guest


T20 has ruined the schedule, put of real cricket fans, also stuffed up the sheffield shield and sheffield shield fans. And bringing in less money for ODI cricket, and test cricket. Less money for cricket is bad. There is no such things as real T20 cricket fans, unlike real test cricket fans, or sheffield shield fans.

2013-06-26T21:37:52+00:00

TheGenuineTailender

Roar Guru


You're very confused by an end and its cause. India is the home of the IPL and is T20s biggest market, but they just won the Champions Trophy off the back of a four-nil drubbing over Australia. How do you explain that? T20? Please...

Read more at The Roar