Just watch: the Kennett Curse will finally be lifted

By Michael Cowley / Expert

A curse is a curse of course of course, but even the best of curses have to come to an end … don’t they?

Even one of the most famous curses in all of sport, The Curse of the Bambino, a hex bestowed upon the Boston Red Sox for trading one of baseball’s greatest – Babe Ruth – to arch-enemy the New York Yankees, came to an end, albeit 86 years after it began.

Surely now, after just four and half years, and 10 mostly agonising matches for their supporters, the Kennett Curse will finally be lifted on Saturday night at the MCG, when Hawthorn find a way to at last beat Geelong.

Surely … it’s time. Isn’t it?

Back in round one, on April 1, at the MCG, after I watched the Hawthorn players again shaking their heads in disbelief, some perhaps thinking another loss to Geelong was a cruel and twisted April Fools joke, I scurried to the AFL draw, hoping I might find what I found. Yes, July 6. Round 15.

I don’t have to wait until the finals to see the remarkable rivalry between these two talented clubs, continue.

Chances are they are on a collision course to meet in the finals, and possibly on September 28 in the last match of the 2013 season.

But first things first. Will the Kennett Curse extend to 11, or will the Hawks – who haven’t lost since that seven-point round one defeat – set a new club record of 13 consecutive wins, eclipsing the mark set in their premiership-winning season of 1961?

Let’s look at some facts. The curse: All came about because then Hawthorn president Jeff Kennett said after his team upset the Cats in the 2008 grand final: “What they don’t have, I don’t think, is the quality of some of our players . . . they don’t have the psychological drive that we have. We’ve beaten Geelong when it mattered over the last five years consistently.”

The Hawks have lost all 10 matches since, some from seemingly unloseable positions, eight of those games by less than 10 points, three by two points and one by a point, and two wins – one a goal from Tom Hawkins in 2012, and one a behind from Jimmy Bartel in 2009 – with a kick after the siren.

Curses, smurses! It’s not a curse, it’s a horrible, horrible coincidence for Hawks’ faithful. As Hawthorn captain Luke Hodge stated earlier this year, “the reason why Geelong beats us … the fact is they’ve been a better team than us.”

And he might be right.

From that 2008 grand final until the start of this season, the Hawks won 59 of their 95 games or 62 per cent of their matches, with one grand final loss, last year to Sydney.

Geelong in that same period won 76 of their 98 games – 78 per cent – and two premierships.

Even in round one this year, despite Hawthorn leading by five goals in the second term, maybe the Cats were again just the better team against a Hawks outfit which had a late start to their 2013 campaign after finishing up in the grand final last year.

But what about now?

Hawthorn have been impressive, ultra-impressive with 12 wins and by an average of seven goals. Included among those successes were big wins over Collingwood (55 points), Fremantle (42 points) and Sydney (37 points).

Geelong have only lost twice this season, both times by a kick, to Collingwood and then after the stunning last quarter fade against Brisbane. Their average winning margin is five goals, and they have beaten Essendon, Sydney and Fremantle.

Glance through individual player statistics and you will find standouts from both clubs in various categories and equally, both teams also take turns in heading various statistical charts.

If you looked at Geelong two weeks ago when they were beaten by Brisbane, you couldn’t get enough money on Hawthorn this week.

But there was a lot to like about the way the Cats methodically went about beating Fremantle last Saturday night.

Meanwhile, Hawthorn went on their merry way with a belting of Brisbane in Tasmania, continuing to show how they are not a team as reliant on two, three or four superstars in their team as they might have been a little in the past. The depth across the park has been a huge part of their success in 2013.

So who wins? The Hawks are favourites with the bookies, and are likely to be the favoured ones with the tipsters as well. But as they know only too well, that doesn’t matter when the ball bounces.

The players might all say it’s just another game, just the same as last week and next week, and still worth four competition points, exactly the same as every other game until the finals. That’s what they might say, but believe that if you want to. I don’t.

This one means a lot more than the four points to both teams. Psychologically, a win here is massive. Bust the curse, and the Hawks could be unstoppable heading to September. Fall to it again, and that fragility will be there for all to see.

But surely now the time is right for Kennett’s Curse to crumble. After all, don’t all curses have to come to an end some time?
Maybe, but don’t ask Chicago Cubs’ fans.

Their Curse of the Billy Goat started back in 1945. Legend goes that Billy Sianis took his pet goat Murphy to a World Series game at Wrigley Field. Murphy had his own ticket, but Cubs owner PK Wrigley ordered both goat and Sianis be ejected from the ground because of the goat’s smell.

Sianis put a hex on the Cubs, and to this day, they have not won a League Pennant or been to a World Series since.

Curses, smurses!

The Crowd Says:

2013-07-07T12:12:57+00:00

Cattery

Guest


Kennett curse lives on ... Eleven is heaven

2013-07-06T12:27:29+00:00

Ferret

Guest


Realy?

2013-07-04T12:18:55+00:00

Floyd Calhoun

Guest


Oohhh, you've really got me riled now NY Hawk! But, you asked for it! Geelong by 27!! Not so funny now, is it?

2013-07-04T08:32:47+00:00

Jack Smith

Roar Guru


Cats will win. What has changed - nothing? Come finals though, I would tip Hawks to win. Strange I know, but just this feeling I have.

2013-07-03T14:41:26+00:00

New York Hawk

Guest


"Closer than some might think. Geelong by 26." That is funny for two reasons. 1. not many people think it will be a 26+ point victory to either team (who are these "some" of which you speak?) and 2. 26 points is the exact margin of the 2008 grand final defeat your Cats suffered. Still funny. A flag in the hand is wort,h hmmm, how many games in the regular season bush?

2013-07-03T12:05:16+00:00

Floyd Calhoun

Guest


Closer than some might think. Geelong by 26.

2013-07-03T06:28:42+00:00

dahawkacup13

Guest


As much as I would like to see Hawthorn win this one.. I just don't see it happening this week. Geelong's form last week against Freo was amazing, they've flicked the switch, and we have too many outs this week. Gonna be a close one, really hoping that we can just get over the line.

2013-07-03T06:08:32+00:00

Geronimo

Guest


You forgot the curse of the billygoat which still troubles the Chicago Cubs...

2013-07-02T09:34:30+00:00

Professor Selwood

Guest


Hey Choke-Thorn! Ready for number ELEVEN?!....... God ELEVEN! .......That really is embarrassing! ....... Just think about how much worse it's going to get when we finally get another handful of stars back out on the park Squawkers :-) hehehe

2013-07-02T08:12:27+00:00

Simoc

Guest


And Kennett thinks Melbourne need him. They manage to lose ok without him.

2013-07-02T05:56:42+00:00

Imperious

Guest


How about the curse of Sydney Morning herald AFL writers? Any news on where Richard Hinds is going???

2013-07-02T01:42:49+00:00

Leigh

Guest


The time is now, the curse will live no more. The hawks will break their club record of 12 straight wins and Geelong will feel the wrath of the greatest football club. It will be a hard bruising game and Geelong will go home licking their wounds, wondering can that team be stopped. Simple answer, NO

2013-07-02T00:50:38+00:00

Ash of Geelong

Guest


Come on Kennett apologise , I hate the cats.

2013-07-01T23:56:58+00:00

Jeanette Stonehouse

Guest


Let the game begin ,Long Life the Curse.GO CATS.

Read more at The Roar