What happened to equality on the AFL's 'field of dreams'?

By matt.nolan / Roar Rookie

As Eddie McGuire used to say, ‘what a big week it has been in football’.

I would go as far as to say what a big year it has been in football, and we are only just over halfway.

In a season where off-field issues have arguably overshadowed the on-field heroics of many individual and team efforts, it’s easy to wallpaper over the social stances the AFL has taken, directly or indirectly.

These issues have been present in society for a long time. Some for hundreds of years.

Alleged performance-enhancing drug-taking, racism, cheating, the stench of the tanking saga still lingering, we’ve had the whole box and dice in the football world.

I want to preface this article by stating that I am a massive advocate for indigenous players being icons of our game, and believe everyone associated with footy should celebrate their sublime talents.

The Adam Goodes ‘King Kong’ saga involving our man Eddie was, in my opinion, somewhat blown out of proportion.

Racism undoubtedly has no place in our sport, let alone our community.

The fundamental idea of being discriminated against based on colour or where a person is from is to be considered in today’s society archaic.

In saying this, every case needs to be afforded a level of understanding and looked at without rose-coloured glasses.

Eddie was silly. He shouldn’t have said what he said and is very lucky to have all his regular media hats still firmly on his head.

The 13 year-old girl that was crucified a week earlier however was unfairly belted across media circles and the football public.

Firstly, she had no idea it was indigenous round. Secondly, she apparently didn’t know it was racist to call someone an ape.

Would this have even been an issue if her barb were directed at Kurt Tippett rather than Adam Goodes? I think not.

The issue has been discussed at length, so rather than flogging a dead horse I will simply say it seems the emotion of indigenous round saw a young girl severely punished for an everyday mishap.

The very next week an experienced media personality fuelled the fire with an extreme case of foot-in-mouth after previously flying the anti-racism flag.

Last week the AFL announced a plan to field an indigenous team to represent Australia in the International Series against Ireland in October this year.

According to the AFL’s deputy chief Gillon McLachlan, the idea gained momentum following the success of the Indigenous All-Stars game in the 2013 pre-season.

Frankly the idea, not to mention the timing, couldn’t have been worse. Celebrate indigenous culture, celebrate with a round of football and celebrate them every week when we cheer on Buddy, Ryder, Yarran, Goodes, Thomas etc.

Yet when it is all laid bare, isn’t having a solely indigenous side available for selection in the game’s only international fixture robbing any AFL player that is not indigenous the chance to represent their country?

If it is promoted as an Australia vs Ireland International Rules series (which it is) surely every single player from our code should be eligible to pull on an Australian jumper?

We are all Australians; the team should be picked on merit, not race.

“To the best of our knowledge, the all-stars representing the AFL in this IRS series will be the first all-indigenous team to represent a sporting code at senior level overseas since that first cricket team toured England in 1868,” McLachlan said.

There is a good reason for that Gillon. Sport and society have moved past isolating players on the basis of their skin colour.

Could you imagine the uproar if the AFL were to field a Caucasian side as our international rules team?

This event is the one and only chance our AFL footballers get to play an international version of our game.

Showcasing Australian footballing talent has always been the centrepiece of this venture along with the fact that anyone who works hard enough can make it as an AFL star, regardless of where they are born.

Now some are being deemed ineligible based on their racial heritage? Multiculturalism in football called, it wants its dignity back.

The credibility of the series has been brought into question over the last few years with players not being available under a thought that it was too much of an injury risk in the off-season.

Despite this, there are no other avenues for AFL footballers to represent their nation.

Regardless of how much it is looked at by society as a ‘real’ national team, as a player if you ask any of them would they be honoured to play for Australia, the answer will always be yes.

Celebrate culture, indigenous players and the wonderful things they can do a on a football field.

Have an indigenous round, have a pre-season game, even have an All-Stars vs Ireland game as well but don’t penalise all the players that are not indigenous by excluding them from playing in the national series.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2013-07-16T02:16:24+00:00

matt.nolan

Roar Rookie


My point exactly. There was also an article from Nathan Burke written in Inside Footy covering the topic. A shame the best players can't play for their country.

2013-07-12T08:23:58+00:00

A Mans Not A Camel

Guest


http://www.irishtimes.com/sport/australia-to-pick-indigenous-all-stars-for-international-rules-series-1.1451876 not scathing, but very mixed reaction. there was a different one I read, can't find it now.

2013-07-12T08:13:33+00:00

A Mans Not A Camel

Guest


pretty sure I read an article actually, where the Irish were not overly impressed on the idea that this Australia v Ireland contest was getting diluted. Will see if I can dig it up. I agree with you Matt, it's actually racist I believe to deny the dozens of other racial background players from the chance of playing for their country. it is an honor AFL players rarely get, and to deny nearly 90% of the AFL players a chance to play...it's likely an over reaction initiative from the AFL specifically in relation to the recent issues. Tom, I understand where you're coming from, and this will be a huge honor for our indigenous players, and probably one Krakuer of a game. and yes, a lot of AFL stars have dropped out in the past. But does that mean the majority of players in the AFL should no longer get an opportunity to play international footy? my understanding was that Judd, Ablett and swan were among a number of non indigenous players to put their hands up... stars of the game getting denied a shot at international rules footy. that's disappointing for me.

AUTHOR

2013-07-12T06:35:12+00:00

matt.nolan

Roar Rookie


Apart from giving history lessons what are you actually arguing? The 13 year old jibe reaction was my opinion. Because this is an opinion based site. Obviously a very tender subject for you so I'll be blunt. You have completely missed the whole point of this article, which was to highlight the denial of the best players in the AFL being selected on a national level because of race, not merit. I wonder if the Irish are worried about playing a team that is selected from 11% of our talent pool? It would be like them saying we're only selecting players from Cork and Kerry to represent Ireland, I'm sure that would go down well. Just finally before you load the rocket launcher up again I am in no way challenging the merit of an all indigenous team. I am challenging the way the AFL has handled it... And it just happens to be Multicultural Round? How ironic.

2013-07-12T05:53:48+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


I'm not confused at all. The fact that I found your article ignorant and disgusting isn't because I'm confused. It's because your article is ignorant and disgusting. To argue that a racial barb wouldn't be offensive if directed at a player not of that race is so self-evidently stupid it's hard to know where to begin. To cite the hypothetical response to a caucasian team being selected is just daft. Of course there would be uproar if a caucasian team was selected. There has been a long, deplorable history of caucasian-only groups and teams in post-colonial western societies, including Australia, which you could not possibly have missed. The reasons why such a team would be met with bewilderment and fury have absolutely nothing to with the merits of an all-Indigenous team, as should be immediately obvious to everyone. I don't have any time for idiots at any moment. But if there was ever an issue or a time where people needed to be respectful and thoughtful with their words, it's the issue of race in the AFL right now. You just don't have the capacity to discuss this issue. And you shouldn't. Stop now.

AUTHOR

2013-07-12T05:09:35+00:00

matt.nolan

Roar Rookie


You seem a bit confused TomC. What perspective are you after? The one that celebrates every single culture that plays the game? The one that is promoting us as an equal? The AFL are denying 89% of players in the competition a chance to play for Australia. I'm not talking about caucasian, I'm talking about every single culture or background that is NOT indigenous. Bachar Houli, Nic Nat, Majak Daw - all from different cultures but still Australian and should be eligible. Like I said, have an All-Star game but why can't they have an All-Australian game too. Hopefully that's the 'perspective' you're talking about.

AUTHOR

2013-07-12T04:58:47+00:00

matt.nolan

Roar Rookie


Not confused at all. In fact I have grown up with different cultures and backgrounds and can honestly say if people think that is flat out racism, they are yet to live in a real world.

2013-07-12T04:01:25+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


Oh god... This is dire. Absolutely dire. How many all-caucasian teams have been fielded already, without anyone needing to announce it. I didn't think anyone was unclear on whether or not caucasian were a disadvantaged group in Australian professional sports, until I read this drivel. Awful stuff. The writer needs to get himself some perspective.

2013-07-12T03:49:51+00:00

Savvas Tzionis

Guest


You get all upset about the Indigenous team, yet have you considered that this is the only viable option? No one else cares!!!! And it proves that blood is thicker than water. Good luck to them.

2013-07-12T03:43:26+00:00

dockersfan

Guest


I see you're very confused by racism. Maybe you should find someone who has been subjected to it and get them to educate you. You need it.

2013-07-12T02:50:44+00:00

Trev

Roar Rookie


"She didn't even know it was indigenous round", heard that so many times and I still fail to see how her knowing or not knowing what round it was matters, if it's racist it's racist, the round/day/time doesn't change that. But to the main point, I agree 100%, I can't see how the AFL can sit there and tell us this is a game for all cultures,races, backgrounds etc then announce the International touring team will be made up purely of players from a certain race. Seems to conflict the message they've been trying to send.

Read more at The Roar