Heart find their place in the City

By Mitchell Grima / Expert

Optimism within football in Melbourne has been significantly skewed to one side of the city this season; for the the last four A-League seasons, in fact.

While Melbourne Victory have thrived as one of the league’s top guns, with major signings and results to boot, their little brother has sat quietly in the corner in a place where no press is good press.

An early injury to marquee man Orlando Engelaar and the sacking of coach John Aloisi, as a result of the mind boggling winless run, compounded Melbourne Heart’s woes this season.

But for once, there is a buzz in the red and white towers after it was announced English Premier League side Manchester City have acquired an 80% stake in the struggling club.

While the news has been greeted with great shock, it comes as no surprise that City’s Australian partners have bought into the A-League after their mooted interest in a takeover of the Wanderers last year.

Although Heart will be seen as the greatest beneficiaries of this move, City are equally buoyed, now holding teams in Manchester, New York and Melbourne.

The ownership of New York City FC, which will enter the Major League Soccer competition in 2015, means City are truly on their way to becoming a global force in football and it is a ride that Melbourne Heart would have been more than happy to jump on.

Even the most cynical of followers will have difficulty finding a flaw in this deal. A club that has infamously struggled for identity has now had one forced upon them, and that ain’t such a bad thing.

Heart may already be an “established” club, but City essentially have a clean slate similar to the New York franchise.

Aloisi’s side hit rock bottom on the pitch this month, which could have potentially been a blessing in disguise. It was the most evident sign that a total overhaul is required and City are best placed to take Heart in a new direction which they so desperately crave.

Perhaps the most important aspect of the takeover is the financial stability Heart now possess.

For too long there have been doubts over the future of the club. Will there be adequate support from the owners? Are top shelf marquees a possibility?

With the 2011/12 English champions – who increased their revenues by $78 million according to the latest Deloitte Football Money League report – now on board, Heart’s financial problems take a much needed pump.

More worrying than the off-field dramas at AAMI Park this summer has been Heart’s state of play. Aloisi suffered much conjecture during his tenure for failing to instil a rigid structure in what appears to be a talented squad on paper.

In a promising sign for the embattled club and its fans, it appears football is firmly on the minds of City’s consortium – not always a guarantee in 21st century football.

New York’s inaugural coach, Jason Kreis, left his six-year stint at MLS outfit Real Salt Lake for the opportunity to head City’s newest project, purely because he was enthralled by the style and tactics he was encouraged to integrate into his new side. While it is a tad extreme to expect New York and Melbourne Heart to replicate Manchester City’s efforts, it is apparent that the employers will do their best to create a uniform playing style.

“The philosophies that they have implemented fall right in line with the way I see things,” Kreis said, according to the New York Times, adding: “I wouldn’t have come here had it been any other way. It’s a perfect fit.”

Any sort of input from Manchester City Director of Football, Txiki Begiristain – the former Barcelona player and director – could hardly be harmful.

Winning in a “special style” is his key objective, with Heart’s football philosophy in dire need of an overhaul.

Further encouragement can be sourced from City’s state of the art football academy currently under construction in Manchester. Complete with a 7000-seater stadium for youth matches, 12 pitches dedicated for players aged eight to 21 and an injury and rehab centre, it is testament to the focus of City’s operations.

Although Heart youngsters by no means have a free ride into English football, they will have some intelligent football minds watching over them and a path that promises quality career development.

A key talking point following the announcement was the ability of Heart to attract international quality. Heart are yet to make a statement on the marquee front. Although Fred was a great addition on the pitch, fans still yearn for a player of Del Piero’s stature, which was certainly not delivered by the signing of Orlando Engelaar.

No, Heart will not be signing Sergio Aguero; Patrick Vieira won’t be making a comeback. But there is suddenly something much more alluring about Melbourne Heart, with the cash now more likely available to back lofty ambitions in the transfer market.

Couple this with the prospect of Manchester City touring Australia in the future and there is plenty of reason to keep an eye on things at the Heart. The arrivals of Liverpool and Manchester United on our shores last July provided a platform for exhibition matches and we could do much worse than have City’s stars in Australia.

Melbourne Heart are far from rescued, but they have been handed a significant lifeline that could revive the fortunes of a struggling club and maintain the force of Australian football.

The Crowd Says:

2014-01-25T00:29:05+00:00

Chopper

Guest


It will affect the rivalries more so in the development of the game. If Melbourne city create an academy with the facilities espoused by the new owners, will that then push the other owners that have openly talked about facilities and academy's into action? Sydney FC have long talked about it and they lose so many potential players because of their lack of facilities and I am sure the Bakries at Roar have "talked" about their own facilities so maybe they will open their cheque books in an attempt to keep up. Further if MCFC get top marquees, will not the other clubs try to emulate it. Surely this generates a marketing win with other "World Class" marquees having their eyes opened up to the Australian A League. Perhaps other wealthy sports club owners may then invest in our A League , the possibilities are endless. The World Game is now showing its' true potential.

2014-01-24T13:14:39+00:00

Norfolk

Roar Rookie


Plenty of clubs have nick names. Colours should stay red.

2014-01-24T09:36:08+00:00

Mark

Guest


As someone who has started following Heart this season, it is sad but also kind of exciting to get on board (jump on the bandwagon?) for the "new" team. Ditto Man City. Never followed an EPL team and I always like the underdog (at least compared to Man U) so they'll do.

2014-01-24T06:15:43+00:00

Adam

Guest


What interests me the most is how this will affect rivalries. This will make the Melbourne Derby much more attractive, and will also create a rivalry between the Heart & Sydney FC. In the same way Del Piero has brought more spectators to all of Sydneys games (home and away), this will grow all clubs. The best thing about this for me in the short term is that Harry Kewell will get to have training at Manchester City in the lead up to the World Cup.

2014-01-24T06:12:02+00:00

Adam

Guest


I think the best name change would be Melbourne City, with a nickname of "The Heart", but the new owners have said they will listen to the fans. Maybe there could be a 2nd or 3rd guernsey that has the Man City colours or has red & sky blue or white & sky blue.

2014-01-23T22:29:05+00:00

Michael_Newcastle

Guest


As long as Manchester City FC (ahem Melbourne City) and Sydney FC don't have clashing kits when they play each other, it should be ok?

2014-01-23T21:48:26+00:00

nordster

Guest


Great opportunity mate :) for those of us not limited to local restrictions on doing things!

2014-01-23T21:45:15+00:00

nordster

Guest


Mental illness diagnosis and medication is much more subjective than high cholesterol....just sayin' ...im with those kooky scientologists on that whole pseudo science racket... ;)

2014-01-23T13:09:29+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Guest


A-League won't let it happen seeing as all playing strips need to get approval from HQ. So I'm afraid it looks like Heart won't get either their colours OR name changed. Speculation isn't off to a good start is it...

2014-01-23T11:50:50+00:00

mahonjt

Guest


Yes we will ;-)

2014-01-23T11:26:52+00:00

Steve

Guest


Fair enough. A great coup would be a player like Xavi or Pirlo. Someone who can show our young midfielders what it's like to control the game from midfield. With the ex-Barca management in place at City and Xavi's links to the new NYC franchise it's not beyond the realms if possibility that MCFC (?) Could be a target. Rinaldinho would be the dream signing for his skill and charisma.

2014-01-23T11:09:55+00:00

Stevo

Guest


All upside from my point of view. Good for HeartFC, good for HAL and good for Australian football. Another milestone moment in Australian football. Going from strength to strength.

2014-01-23T10:15:53+00:00

The Bear

Guest


or a heart transplant.

2014-01-23T10:05:18+00:00

Bondy

Guest


Steve Rosicky has resigned he will continue at Arsenal.

2014-01-23T09:53:43+00:00

Steve

Guest


Some players off contract at the end of the year (who are over 30) include Vidic, Eto'o, Berbatov, Rosicky, Diego Milito, Joe Cole, Rosicky, Lampard, Cambiasso, Drogba, Hleb. All would more than useful to an A-League club.

2014-01-23T08:32:25+00:00

Ian Whitchurch

Guest


Its both more and less important than people think. On the plus side, it pretty much guarantees two teams, neither of which are ethnically based, in a major market. On the minus side, Citeh wont be allowed to screw the rest of the league by playing games with the cap and so on - and I dont think they'll want to. There is no real point to stashing a depth player in Melbourne when there is Lille, 1860 and so on - it's all the same to Man City. On the long term side, Citeh's owner is betting on the long term success of the A-League, and that has to be a plus if you're a fan of association football in Australia.

2014-01-23T08:21:24+00:00

AGO74

Guest


Those livable cities studies (questionable in their measurement and frequency - I mean there is a new studies on livable cities released every week) are generally talking about regular citizens and not the megastars (and likely requisite lifestyles/egos) bondy refers to.

2014-01-23T08:10:12+00:00

Mantis

Roar Guru


Cmon...really?

2014-01-23T08:00:58+00:00

ciudadmarron

Guest


Who says they have to?

2014-01-23T07:46:42+00:00

Alex Kiefer

Roar Rookie


Surely the FFA has to draw the line at that. You can't get a foundation club like Sydney to suddenly change their colours.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar