How long until the campaign hits crisis point and Boban is freshened up?

By Justin Cinque / Expert

“We’ll freshen him up” are the dreaded words an owner almost-certainly doesn’t want to hear.

They usually come after a campaign hits crisis point and they’re usually uttered because a horse is not showing spark racing over distances that are too long for their liking.

Sometimes, the freshen-up is part of the plan. After all, there are horses that race well with their runs spaced.

But the old-fashioned freshen-up, the dreaded freshen-up, coincides with the abandoning of Plan A. It comes after a bad run or bad spate of runs and sees a horse’s trackwork lighten in order to return speed to its legs.

Then, after a three or four-week break without racing, that horse is entered in a race over a shorter, more suitable distance. And ideally, the horse will show a return to its best form.

The freshen-up is something we see each spring after the Caulfield Guineas (1600m, Group 1, three-year-olds).

Every year, almost without fail, a sprinting three-year-old (or three of them) disappoints in their big shot at a stud career, after being extended to the mile of the Guineas.

The distance and pressure of the Classic too much to bear.

Equally as predictable, the next morning, Andrew Bensley reports on Sky Channel that same horse (or three horses) will be freshened for the Coolmore Stud (1200m, Group 1, three-year-olds) on Derby Day three weeks later.

Last year the recipients of the post-Caulfield Guineas freshen were Éclair Big Bang, who was last in the Guineas, and Divine Calling, who was a fantastic second to Long John.

For Diving Calling, the freshen was part of the plan. But for Éclair Big Bang it was panic stations.

Éclair Big Bang was joined in the Coolmore Stud by Sidestep and Fast ‘N’ Rocking, who had both been subjected to the freshen after disappointing in Caulfield Guineas lead-up races.

How did they fare in the Coolmore? Terribly! In a field of 11, Éclair Big Bang was eighth, Divine Calling tenth and Fast ‘N’ Rocking last. Sidestep was a bit better – he finished sixth.

Zoustar, who won the Coolmore, was off a four-week break but he seems to love racing fresh. Off a break of three weeks or more, he’s won four out of five times.

Perhaps, all I’ve done is show that a spell should be the preferred option to a Plan B that is titled ‘freshen’.

But, in the case of Chris Waller’s out-of-form sprinter-miler Boban, a freshen could do the trick. And it might not be that far away.

The best of Boban is exciting. Here’s a horse that can unwind a sprint – carrying any weight – that no other horse in a race can match.

We saw it in the spring – five times in each of his five races. It carried him to narrow victories in the Epsom (1600m, Group 1, handicap) and Emirates (1600m, Group 1, handicap) and perhaps, most impressively in the Moonga (1400m, Group 3, handicap) at his favourite seven furlongs.

Have a look at his Moonga victory. At first, maybe you think Boban is flattered by the fact he saves ground around the home bend. But soon, what is so obvious is that, despite lugging top weight, he is the only horse to make significant ground in the race.

And as the footage begins, Boban is recovering from interference that he reacted badly to and lost ground from. That interference happened 600m from home.

This is an extraordinary victory.

Boban’s split from the 400m mark to the 200m mark of 11.05s is 0.32s (about two lengths) faster than the next best in the race – very rare. Not many horses have the turn of foot to win a Group race in a 200m space like Boban can.

That split was 0.57s (nearly four lengths) faster than both the median and mean 400-200m split in the race.

This wasn’t a vintage Group 3 outfit but Boban conceded weight to them and made them look average. It was a top-class performance.

And a performance backed up in the Emirates, when he became the first horse in 27 years to do the Epsom-Emirates double.

Boban has returned in the Autumn in weight-for-age races. And he looks a shadow of his former self. Racing against what cannot be described as vintage weight-for-age opposition, Boban was fifth in the Expressway (1200m, Group 2, weight-for-age) and then fourth in Saturday’s Apollo (1400m, Group 2, weight-for-age) comprehensively beaten by the mare Appearance both times.

After the Expressway – when Boban plugged up the straight after being held up – we were told by Waller to be patient. Boban was being prepared for the Queen Elizabeth (Group 1, weight-for-age) at 2000m and he had plenty of improvement left.

Unfortunately, the bid to get Boban to race at 2000m has robbed him of his turn of foot. And that’s his killer asset.

Even on Saturday, when he was a lot better in the Apollo, he still lacked punch in the straight. He was exposed early in the race and began to pull hard on the side of the course, no doubt blunting his finish.

Boban has always had bad manners but if he’s pulling over his pet distance of 1400m, how’s he going to settle over a mile and a quarter when the pace could be even slower.

Last year in England, the champion three-year-old miler Dawn Approach was extended to the 2400m Derby (Group 1, three-year-olds) trip and – almost literally – pulled himself out of the race.

Remarkably, he pulled so hard he was completely finished at the 400m mark and was beaten by a furlong as an even-money favourite.

Dawn Approach was simply too fast for the stayers he was racing. With similarly bad manners, its not impossible to think Boban could suffer a comparable, if not as dramatic, fate.

Boban’s next race will almost certainly be the Chipping Norton (1600m, Group 1, weight-for-age) over the mile at Warwick Farm.

There he will meet his two-time autumn conqueror Appearance at her pet trip and arguably the best horse in the country in It’s A Dundeel. Boban could show us his spring form and still be beaten three or four lengths.

But it’s much more likely we see another lacklustre performance. And then what? Does Waller push on to 2000m and the Ranvet (Group 1, weight-for-age) a fortnight later?

I’d say it’s highly unlikely. I’m guessing Waller is already planning to freshen Boban after the Chipping Norton in preparation for the George Ryder (1500m, Group 1, weight-for-age), which is three weeks after Warwick Farm and is the perfect Doncaster (1600m, Group 1, handicap) lead-up.

After the spring, I was happy to see Boban trained for the 2000m Queen Elizabeth.

Now that we’re seeing what a middle-distance preparation has done to Boban, it should be abandoned as soon as possible. Hopefully, with a bit more speed in his legs the old Boban will return.

I believe Boban can still prove himself be a force at weight-for-age but I can only see it happening after we hear of a freshen-up plan. And right now, it can’t come soon enough.

The Crowd Says:

2014-02-26T23:44:25+00:00

Bondy

Guest


If Boban's not in top form which he isn't ,I'd freshen him up for the Brisbane carnival ,races such as the Doomben 10.000 and then to the Stradbroke " unfortunately not mile races ", Waller should find clarity there at least and if you can't win in Brisbane then you've got no hope venturing south.

2014-02-26T10:38:07+00:00

Sammy

Guest


Michaelangelo still has his Plums! He's 5yrs old so might not make a difference, but surely every things on the table to try? He came last again in a trial again this week. The money is now a sunk cost, cut him and see what happens. Or send him back to Europe? Maybe he doesn't like the hard tracks or training regime in Australia. Seemed to work sending Tac De Boistron home ?

2014-02-26T10:13:08+00:00

andrew

Guest


what about if you take a line through speediness as a barometer. there has not been much between then in both their runs so far this autumn. there was not much between them in the emirates either. toydini and speediness went to the line together on cox plate day in Waterford mile, and toydini and boban went to line together in Epsom. so, if boban is struggling, then equally so to is speediness. or - are just the booms/wraps on boban a bit high, given in reality at last spring not much between him and speediness (a neck at best) and that is still the case (so far this autumn).

AUTHOR

2014-02-26T08:12:00+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Really fair comment Alice. You're last line is spot on too - it would be a lot more concerning if he peaked too early.

2014-02-26T07:05:16+00:00

Alice

Guest


Well, "strong" was relatively speaking--the fields are certainly tougher than what he faced in his handicaps. It's quite possible that he's just not a weight-for-age horse. Weight-for-age is a totally different caper than handicaps. Some horses can only do well in one or the other; Green Moon comes to mind. But I just think that it's a little premature for everyone to declare that he's useless for the autumn when he hasn't been given an opportunity to show his best. Surely the fact that he improved from his first-up run to his second-up suggests that he has upside left in him, and I'd be more worried if he showed signs of peaking too early.

AUTHOR

2014-02-26T01:33:44+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


The 1400m comment is an opinion. I've no doubt he's better at 1400 than a mile. His strength in the last 100m of mile races is not as strong as it is over 1400m. He's a bit vulnerable at a mile, at 1400m he's strong all the way. The concern I have is that these weight-for-age races are not strong at all. Appearance aside, there is hardly another proven WFA galloper amongst the fields Boban has contested. Sure, he hasn't been that bad but as one of the better horses in the country, so we thought, we expect more than those fourths and fifths that look better on paper than how they present on TV. I mean time will tell. I think he's lost his dash, Chris Waller knows he's not flying. You may be right, he may be going ok... It could be a lack of fitness or maybe the step up to WFA that is hurting him. I think its deeper and I know I don't stand alone in that opinion.

2014-02-26T00:59:39+00:00

Alice

Guest


I think you're being a little bit harsh on Boban. His runs haven't been as bad as people make out; fifth and fourth in strong weight-for-age races is nothing to be ashamed of, especially for a horse whose grand final is still months away. Has he been a little disappointing this time in? Yes. But you've got to keep in mind that he has never been a fresh horse, his record first up is 5:1:0:0, his record second up is 5:2:0:0, and that his wins at those stages came against very ordinary opposition, which may have flattered him a bit. I don't know where you got that statistic that 1400 is his best distance--he won his two Group Ones at 1600! So personally I think it's far from "panic stations" as Boban goes. He's running just as well as he usually does--just in stronger competition where the weights don't favour him. Next start will be day, I think, and I'll be happy to chance my money on him if he pops up at good odds.

AUTHOR

2014-02-26T00:19:31+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Yep, Alcopop was a star in the spring. In the autumn we didn't really see his best. Maybe Boban will be a spring horse too.

2014-02-26T00:17:58+00:00

Alfred Chan

Expert


Boban reminds me a little of Alcopop. There was that year when Alcopop was dominating the handicap races and even worked his way up to be the Melbourne Cup favourite. The following year he morphed into a donkey and found himself going around in the Kilmore Cup. Then two years later, he comes out of nowhere to run second in the Caulfield Cup before stepping it up to roll the Cox Plate winner in the Mackinnon and run third in the Hong Kong Cup.

AUTHOR

2014-02-26T00:17:33+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Maybe he should be spelled in an attempt to recapture his best form later in the year. You don't want him to lose the plot. Right now, Boban is at the crossroads.

AUTHOR

2014-02-26T00:16:11+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


It's possible. Maybe he hasn't come up. In which case, should he disappoint at WF, maybe the question asked of Chris Waller should not be - 'will you freshen him up?' but 'should you spell Boban?'

2014-02-26T00:02:39+00:00

Cameron Rose

Expert


Boban is shaping as one of the intriguing storylines of the Championships. You might be spot on with your assessment Justin. Is it possible for a horse to race above himself in the way we might say a football team plays above itself? His spring was simply awesome, and perhaps he's fallen back to a more moderate level. Maybe he just hasn't come up after a big campaign.

2014-02-25T23:44:14+00:00

Sledgeross

Roar Rookie


From memory, a spell might just do the trick for Boban. From his winter spell he seemed unbeatable in the spring which led to his many impressive victories. Will be at the Farm cheering him on though (given its walking distance from home!).

AUTHOR

2014-02-25T22:45:25+00:00

Justin Cinque

Expert


Full-time schooling is Michaelangelo's calling. He could be a common fixture at the Bool.

2014-02-25T21:59:19+00:00

onlythebestcount

Guest


Michaelangelo is having a nice freshen up... #racingjokes

2014-02-25T20:27:11+00:00

Drew H

Guest


Amazing how the final 600m is the most important time. Horses need to come on with 500- 550m to go. How they do it or cope with it forms the merits. Perhaps leaders are the exception, needing a different feel. We all love a good leader. I really see how racing does share around the prizemoeny. One campaign needs to be sort, and it does eliminate another. The champs get many things right, and if they truely are champs, they can be called upon in many ways.

Read more at The Roar