Buddy Cola has no fizz in Blacktown

By mds1970 / Roar Guru

The heavens opened on Thursday evening, and traffic on the M4 was heavy. Most of them were commuters, but some were heading to Blacktown International Sportspark for some AFL action.

The AFL’s pre-season program, with a game every night, is nearing its conclusion.

But a weeknight game in Sydney’s west, well away from Swans heartland, against a team from the other side of the country was never going to draw a crowd.

The rain would have prompted many to stay away.

And those who did come found themselves stung with costs of $18 to get in and another $10 for parking – a bit steep for a pre-season game.

Hardly surprisingly, barely 3,000 fans made the effort to come.

But for those who were there for the Sydney v West Coast game, the star attraction was Lance “Buddy” Franklin.

Controversially recruited from Hawthorn in the off-season, Franklin’s signing has attracted plenty of attention and scrutiny of the Swans’ use of their Cost of Living Allowance.

But he’s in Sydney now, and this was his first competitive match in his new colours. However it was hardly an impressive one.

The Eagles ran on, followed by the Swans. Buddy was there, his tattooed torso bearing the number 23.

But he was further up the ground than most were expecting, not the anticipated spearhead. And where he went, the ball didn’t go.

The Eagles made the early attacking, but could only manage behinds before Callum Sinclair broke through for their first goal. But the Swans had a quick reply.

And it was a heart-warming story. After a horrific leg break two years ago, the question being asked was whether Gary Rohan would ever walk again; it was assumed his playing career was over.

But the red-headed forward was back, and showed he still had his touch as he guided a set shot through.

The rain had eased; and although many fans preferred the shelter of the grandstand, a smattering of fans spread around the hill.

Most were in red and white, but the Eagle fans were there in their blue and gold. And reflecting the area, a light sprinkling of orange was seen among the crowd.

But there was little noise made, the fans preferring to watch and analyse the action. But after the quarter time break, with the Swans leading by a point at the first change, the crowd soon found their voice early in the second.

The ball had gone forward for the Swans, and Buddy finally found a slice of the action. Marking the ball just outside the 50 metre line, kicking to the railway end.

Here was a chance for the Swans’ new marquee to announce himself with a super-goal. But his nine point attempt sailed wide for just a behind.

The second quarter was a defensive scrap, with the Swans leading by four points at the long break. But the Eagles took the upper hand in the premiership quarter, six unanswered goals setting up a match-winning lead.

For all the talk of Buddy; it was another former Hawk, Xavier Ellis, who impressed with plenty of possession.

Scott Selwood was looking classy, and Chris Masten was a ball-magnet. Scott Lycett was dominating in the ruck, exposing the Swans’ loss of Shane Mumford.

Buddy was rarely sighted, and he wasn’t alone in a lacklustre display by the Swans. They lifted slightly in the last quarter for Gary Rohan to finish with a bag of three goals.

But the biggest cheer for the night came in the dying minutes, as draftee Aliir Aliir was subbed into the game. He wasn’t on long enough to make any impact; but if he makes it to senior level he’s sure to attract a big following.

But with the rain increasing in intensity, and a poor standard game being beyond doubt, many of the crowd had gone before the final siren sounded and the strains of “We’re the Eagles, we’re flying high” rang over the PA system.

Those that remained faced long delays getting out of the car park. Those who caught the shuttle bus to Doonside Station found themselves waiting up to half an hour in the rain for a train.

The facilities at Blacktown are fine for training, except for the roped-off wicket square. They’re great for local games and academy trials. But they were never intended to handle attracting crowds.

Another night of footy action was done. The Swans will be hoping that pre-season form is no guide to the season ahead. The Eagles will be hoping it is.

And Buddy will need to lift his game when the real action comes. His expensive contract and high profile demands it.

The Crowd Says:

2014-04-18T00:44:36+00:00

Storm Boy

Guest


GWS looks to poker machines to fund operations http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/gws-looks-to-poker-machines-to-fund-operations/story-fnelctok-1226888977676 Good move. Sydney loves the pokies.

2014-03-16T08:54:15+00:00

Brent Ford

Roar Guru


Whoops wrong article...

2014-03-16T08:53:30+00:00

Brent Ford

Roar Guru


Sally the Giants play at Homebush at the old Showground, it's now called Spotless Stadium.

2014-03-02T04:49:31+00:00

Penster

Guest


The NAB cup is only another training tool in the coach's arsenal, not an honour and glory thing. Hawks won 1 out of 5 NAB cup matches in 2013, going down to Bulldogs, Suns, Lions and Richmond. I wouldn't pay to go and see a training session.

2014-03-02T02:29:46+00:00

Steve of Blacktown.

Guest


So many people are making a big deal about this game when it was only a practice game and against West Coast. Or course the crowds were low. All this talk about Buddy winning Western Sydney? I mean wait until the Swans are playing on the SCG and they are getting their average crowds then you can see if there is a Buddy factor or not. Plus Buddy does not play for the Giants and some of these nRL fans bring it up about the Giants are not winning any ground in western Sydney and that this is the AFL's Vietnam. A war they can not win. Well hello there? Buddy doesn't play for the Giants and get over it because it was only a NAB cup game.

2014-03-01T04:19:46+00:00

Mal

Guest


Why exactly did the Swans play out there - isn't it supposed to be GWS heartland? They played at Canberra and today at Wagga - another snub to the area they are supposedly representing. This dysfunctional mob are quickly becoming circus.

2014-03-01T02:06:50+00:00

Ian Whitchurch

Guest


Olivia, Nope. It was a game of footy designed to get players fit for the season and be played at a ground where Foxtel could broadcast, but was cheaper to rent than the SCG.

2014-03-01T00:46:36+00:00

Jack Russell

Roar Guru


Most country venues wouldn't have had broadcast quality lighting, and Fox demands a 7:30 EST start time.

2014-03-01T00:24:24+00:00

Australian Rules

Guest


Unbelievable that the ground management charge effectively $28 for people to see this game...a practice match. Surely the AFL should cover these costs and make entry free.

2014-02-28T23:49:58+00:00

Olivia

Guest


@Sally, even the TV broadcast was afflicted with gremlins due to satellite issues. As a game of football designed, presumably, to foster interest in the GWS heartland, it was a dismal failure. Mr Franklin was on a hiding to nothing. Play well and he was doing what was expected of one so highly paid. Play poorly - and believe me, he was woeful - and all the "only in it for the money" comments gain impetus. That said, I have never seen him play a worse game and I hope I never do. In fact, save for the Weagles getting a tick in the win column, the game in those conditions at that location wasted everyone's time and money and all the AFL achieved by trying to further GWS recognition was to harm the Swans brand, All in all, it was a game to be forgotten by all and moved on from, The real loser was Aussie Rules.

2014-02-28T22:46:08+00:00

sally

Guest


Overall sounds like it was a good game to miss especially with the weather. Why play the Swans at Blacktown wouldn't a country town have had more attend?

Read more at The Roar