Australia's number two Test team

By Arthur Pagonis / Roar Guru

With a repeat of the NSW Blues V Western Warriors now confirmed for the Sheffield Shield final to be held in Canberra, and after stoic efforts from Victoria and Tasmania in the last round, and with Queenslandand South Australia falling at the final hurdle, this has been a magnificent season for Australian cricket.

Knocking off the Poms 5-0 and the Proteas 2-1 and winning T20 and 50 over contests at will has been a huge fillip for the game in this country.

And to underline just how great a season some players have had, here’s a list of people who currently cannot hope to make the Test XI in the next 12 months, injury notwithstanding.

Openers and number 3s : Ed Cowan, Aaron Finch, Marcus North, Joe Burns, Nic Maddinson, Rob Quiney, Michael Klinger, Usman Khawaja

Middle order: Shaun Marsh, Tom Cooper, Phil Hughes, Chris Lynn, Glenn Maxwell, George Bailey, Travis Head

Wiketkeepers: Chris Paine, Sam Whiteman, Tim Ludeman

Quicks/All-rounders: Mitch Marsh, Jason Behrendorff, Josh Hazelwood, Doug Bollinger, Mitchell Starc, Jackson Bird, Pat Cummins, James Faulkner, Nathan Coulter-Nile, Kane Richardson, Sean Abbott, Michael Neser

Spinners: James Muirhead, Fawad Ahmed, Adam Zampa, Ashton Agar, Cameron Boyce, Ashton Turner

From that group we could make a second Test team.

1. North (vice captain) 2. Finch 3. Klinger 4. S Marsh 5. Hughes 6. Bailey (Captain) 7. Paine 8. Faulkner 9. Starc 10. Cummins 11. Behrendorff 12. Muirhead

There are some people in that 12 who have scores to settle and points to prove. James Muirhead could replace Faulkner in the line-up given suitable spinning conditions.

They are an older group, like the number one Test team, and that speaks to the Australian method of bringing people into Test cricket when they are mature enough to cope with the screaming and yelling of fast bowlers going beserk.

Notice how seamlessly Alex Doolan fitted in at three in the first Test team? He has the right mentality.

Players such as North, Finch, Klinger, Marsh and Hughes have failed to excel when given the opportunity. This is their chance. All have acquitted themselves well, but not well enough over time.

Marcus North, it must be said, has had one of the great seasons by an opener in Sheffield Shield history. He has propped up WA’s shaky top order and middle order countless times while averaging over 60.

Players such as David Lynn from the Bulls and Nic Maddinson from the Blues have age on their side. Doug Bollinger does not, but he has been a crackerjack worker for NSW and they are in the final in Canberra much in part to his leadership at the bowling crease.

As to the upcoming Shield final, Justin Langer and Trevor Bayliss have had shaky times trying to prop up WA’s batting and I daresay the result of the current game this week in Canberra might have been different had Steve Smith not propped up both innings for NSW.

That should boost WA’s stocks.

They only made this Shield final because Victoria held Queensland out on the final day. But after falling at the final hurdle last season, and actually taking a tumble against NSW by scoring just 82 in the first dig of the game just completed, Langer and Western Australia will be completely relieved to know they have a chance to win the title at all.

If Mitch Marsh recovers from his injury, if Coulter-Nile is available and if Langer is looking to steal a match on NSW, I would open with Shaun Marsh and North, pick either Mitch or Nathan or both, and drop Cam Bancroft, Ash Turner and Ryan Duffield.

One off games played at the opposition’s park call for thinking outside the box.

Batting first will decide the match. If WA can restrict NSW to less than 300, and post 450-500 in their first knock, spinners North and Agar and possibly Turner can be match winners.

It all depends upon how aggressive a stanec WA’s brittle batting takes.

The Crowd Says:

2014-03-20T05:55:57+00:00

eee

Guest


How do you not include forrest and who is david lynn

2014-03-16T03:58:10+00:00

lolly

Guest


They already do name all-star teams every year.

2014-03-16T03:43:56+00:00

Ducko

Guest


No he's not. North, Cooper, Cartels, Forrest, Voges & Quinney have all scored more runs than White.

2014-03-16T03:39:00+00:00

Ducko

Guest


Also overlooked that the best spinner, in the comp. was SOK.

2014-03-15T07:36:29+00:00

TheCunningLinguistic

Guest


I'm sorry, Art, but if your list did not include O'Keefe, then you cannot be taken seriously. He wasn't even mentioned as a Spinner??

2014-03-15T05:05:37+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Cameron White is the leading run scorer in shield this year.

2014-03-15T04:23:16+00:00

Jammel

Guest


Interesting article. If the first Test XI is as follows: Warner Rogers Doolan Clarke Smith Watson Haddin Johnson Harris Siddle Lyon Then the Second XI atm would be: Hughes SMarsh North V Lynn Bailey C Voges Wade + Faulkner OKeefe Pattinson Bird 12th man = Starc

2014-03-15T03:55:17+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


When you get to the second 11 and even a third 11 its interesting how variable the teams are being suggested

2014-03-15T03:22:40+00:00

Anthony D'Arcy

Roar Pro


If it were a B team based on the shield performances from this season, it'd probably be... Marcus North Ryan Carters Phillip Hughes Tom Cooper Peter Forrest Glenn Maxwell/James Hopes (Depending on whether it's a seaming or flat wicket) Sam Whiteman (WK) O'Keefe Behrendorff Feldman Sayers Captaincy would probably be out of Marcus North or Hughes.

2014-03-15T01:40:55+00:00

ak

Roar Guru


There cannot be a second team because it is not world class. In 1995 in a one day tournament you had an Australia 'A' also. But that is not possible today.

2014-03-15T01:01:36+00:00

art pagonis

Guest


all the players mentioned above are excellent mentions, and that is what I would like CA to consider. An All Star Bupa Sheffield Shield Squad, Ryobi 40 and KFC T20 side be named every season to honour those players who have done so well. If we start to foster Domestic Cricket with these kinds of awards then the game will grow. I have a view that Domestically , franchises numbering 8-12 be licenced to play in the National Australia Cricket League. I would like to see those franchises play Day/Night 1X T20, 1 x 40 overs and 1 X 80 over innings games each week. If you follow my logic, players in the franchises will get as much cricket or more than they do currently. They will be skilled in Day/Night, they will play to large audiences such as was seen at last nights Eng V Windies T20 match, and they will be fully professional. Professionals do not play to audiences of less than 200 people, which is currently the case in Bupa and Ryobi Cups.

2014-03-15T00:33:15+00:00

SuperEel22

Roar Guru


Shaun Marsh scored a century, he will therefore be unable to pass 20 for the next 12 months and still get into the Test squad.

2014-03-15T00:23:24+00:00

James T

Guest


Second 11 Hughes Carters North Marsh Voges McDonald Whiteman Hopes Okeefe Starc Cummins Third 11 Silk Burns Maddinson Cooper Forrest Lynn Paine Faulkner Siddle Hilfy Bollinger

2014-03-14T23:12:36+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


I'm going to assume that the test team for UAE will be Rogers' Warner Doolan Clarke Smith Watson or Marsh Haddin Johnson Harris (Starc if injured) Siddle Lyon Based on this my second test side would be Silk (Maddinson of he's injured) Hughes Maddinson (or Khawaja) Lynn North (or Burns) Maxwell( Whitehead Faulkner Starc (or Sayers) Behrendorff (or Bird) O'Keefe

2014-03-14T22:43:45+00:00

Kris Swales

Expert


You seem to have overlooked the fact that the best performed quick in the Shield this season was... James Hopes.

2014-03-14T20:20:28+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


The last couple of seasons the Shield has been very good. Last season in particular was a ripper.

Read more at The Roar