Super Rugby Expert tips - Round 8

By Brett McKay / Expert

“Could well be one of those weeks where three or four is a good score, too.”

That may well be my high-point in prophecy in 2014, and after two upset results in the first two games claimed five of the seven Powerplays in Round 7, three or four was indeed a good score. Unfortunately, Biltong didn’t even manage that, and I don’t think he’s taken it well.

Aside from the upsets, the other big news from last week was that Tristan’s four points meant he’s not just caught the pack, but he’s now overtaking people. My four points – but mainly Biltong’s misfortune – means I’ve now got a little bit of lead that I’m not really expecting to hold onto for long in this company.

Although if everyone’s only as good as their last round…

Tristo and I have the honour this week, and Tristo doesn’t have time to dilly-dally around. Here are the experts’ Round 8 Super Rugby tips:

Tristan Rayner
Tips: Highlanders, Brumbies, Hurricanes, Reds (P/P), Chiefs, Crusaders, Waratahs.

Explain yourself: What a round! These are the rounds we tip for, the rounds that make or break.

Any result would be believable given this year’s results, and you could argue your tips in many ways. Home team advantage? Or backing the usual form teams, like the Crusaders, and hoping? Good luck to all, hope to see you from a place that’s not too battered.

Reds are an exciting Powerplay choice!

Brett McKay
Tips: Highlanders, Brumbies, Hurricanes, Reds (P/P), Chiefs, Lions, Stormers.

Explain yourself: This shapes as another tough round, I think, with a number of 50-50 calls, and not really any clear candidates for the Powerplay. That said, someone will jag a run and win the week handsomely.

The Rebels were great last week, but travelling to Dunedin represents a bigger challenge again. The Blues shape as a danger, but the forecast downpour in Canberra will tighten things up in the Brumbies’ favour.

The Bulls are playing well at the moment, but the Hurricanes have confidence and they’re at home. The Reds are building nicely, and it’s tough to pick the Force when teams coming off the bye haven’t gone well this season.

If the Chiefs can take three away from Pretoria, they won’t have trouble taking four in Bloemfontein. The Crusaders burnt me last week and have just landed up on the high veldt, while the Lions are playing well within their systems at home.

Stormers-Waratahs is a tough one. The Waratahs should be better for the Durban loss, but will come up against another tough defensive team with the added desperation of a 1-5 record. Israel Folau not being a certainty doesn’t help the flip-flopping.

The Reds served me well last week, so they get the Powerplay again.

Scott Allen
Tips: Rebels, Blues, Bulls, Reds (P/P), Chiefs, Crusaders, Stormers.

Explain yourself: Where do I go from here – 3/7 is pretty awful. But I’ve selected on gut feel again this week and came up with five away teams. Now I know that flies in the face of the stats for home team success this season but this may just be my week!

Away victories will come from the Crusaders – who surely have to get it together soon – over the Lions. The Chiefs came home with a wet sail last week, and will be too good for the Cheetahs. The Brumbies finished with their sail in the water and the Blues are making repairs, although there’s a good chance I have this one wrong.

The Rebels need to build  consistency and this match against the Highlanders is a great chance, and the Hurricanes are looking better but I think the Bulls are playing well.

The Stormers start the home team selections. Teams with aggressive defences have got the better of the Tahs this year, and the Stormers defence was good last week in Brisbane.

The Reds will beat the Force because I don’t think the Force can play any better than they have recently, and the Reds have plenty of room to improve.

I’ll spend my Powerplay on the Reds as I’m expecting them to respond to recent questions with a very fast-paced game plan which suits them.

Paddy Effeney
Tips: Highlanders, Brumbies, Hurricanes, Reds, Chiefs (P/P), Crusaders, Waratahs.

Explain yourself: Some nifty picking is in order for me to start climbing the tree, so I’m going for a mixture of away sides travelling well and a couple of less-fancied home sides.

The Waratahs, Crusaders, and Chiefs have to travel well – the Waratahs in particular against a Stormers side, who will no doubt relish playing at home again. The other controversial pick is the Hurricanes to topple the Bulls, but I’m hoping the Bulls will be tired after a journey across the Indian Ocean.

The Force has been a bogey side for the Reds in the past, with the overall 6-4 in the Reds’ favour with one draw. However, despite their recent wins I see the Reds taking this in Brisbane, where the record stands at a much more convincing 5-1.

My Powerplay is on the Chiefs to crush the ailing Cheetahs.

Elisha Pearce
Tips: Rebels, Brumbies, Hurricanes, Reds, Chiefs (P/P), Lions, Waratahs.

Explain yourself: By Round 8 I’m finding spending less time on picks is a good thing. Helps me enjoy the rugby more and watch it without wondering about the meta-score in my head.

I couldn’t even remember some of my tips last weekend – it was fantastic to watch the Bulls-Chiefs score and not realise until the next day what havoc it caused in the tipping!

I don’t trust the Rebels or Highlanders but on form I find myself tipping the Rebels on the road. The Reds should improve in their second week in Brisvegas after a tough trip, and will dispatch the Force (probably, maybe, ugh).

The Hurricanes haven’t won twice in a row yet and I’m backing them at home to do so against the Bulls, who are in form so don’t join me in this pick. Brumbies seemed a safe bet again until they laid a monstrous, cracked, runny egg (no one treats my Powerplay like that!)

Surely, that was a one off and the Blues will be suffocated by the Brumbies at home.

If the Chiefs start anywhere near the way they finished last week they’ll blow the Cheetahs apart. Take my Powerplay and be careful with it. #chiefsmana! [Brett’s note: #GoChefs!]

I’m taking the Lions against the Crusaders, probably the first time ever in that match-up. I just can’t reward losing to the Rebels, and the Lions are going for three on the trot at home!

I’m guessing the Stormers need a full week back home to reload after their trip away, and thinking the Sharks are that much better than everyone else right now gives the Tahs hope.

Spiro Zavos
Tips: Highlanders, Brumbies, Hurricanes, Reds (P/P), Chiefs, Crusaders, Stormers.

Explain yourself: Once again, I have taken a hammering. I went for the home team, with a couple of exceptions. The poor form of the Crusaders is taking its toll. And the inability of touring teams to win matches in South Africa is a challenge, too.

This round I am taking the home sides in most instances but betting on the Crusaders coming right and the Chiefs, too, winning in South Africa in two matches where I have picked an away side.

The Powerplay has been extremely hard to work out, given how even the sides are. But the Reds are generally unbeatable at home, so they are my pick.

Biltongbek
Tips: Highlanders, Brumbies, Bulls, Reds, Chiefs (P/P), Crusaders, Stormers.

Explain yourself: Trepidation and shame will follow me this week and redemption is my main priority as my standing in the tipping competition has dropped faster than a crash on the Johannesburg stock exchange.

Public sentiment usually will go into a panic and shout “sell, sell, sell” however I am going to buckle down and fix this.

The quick run-through: the Highlanders because of the injury list of the Rebels and of course home advantage, the Brumbies as they are at home, the Bulls due to their superior record over the Hurricanes over the past few years, and the Reds because nobody can perform that poorly in successive weeks – and of course they are at home.

The Chiefs as they are my rock. Stuart Berry won’t be officiating for the Lions, so the Crusaders, while the Stormers is more in hope than conviction.

Powerplay is on the Chiefs.

The summary

Round 8 Scott Allen Biltongbek Patrick Effeney Brett McKay Elisha Pearce Tristan Rayner Spiro Zavos
Overall 27 30 29 32 30 28 27
Last week 3 2 3 4 3 4 3
HIG v REB Rebels Highlanders Highlanders Highlanders Rebels Highlanders Highlanders
BRU v BLU Blues Brumbies Brumbies Brumbies Brumbies Brumbies Brumbies
HUR v BUL Bulls Bulls Hurricanes Hurricanes Hurricanes Hurricanes Hurricanes
RED v FOR Reds Reds Reds Reds Reds Reds Reds
CHE v CHI Chiefs Chiefs Chiefs Chiefs Chiefs Chiefs Chiefs
LIO v CRU Crusaders Crusaders Crusaders Lions Lions Crusaders Crusaders
STO v WAR Stormers Stormers Waratahs Stormers Waratahs Waratahs Stormers
POWERPLAY Reds Chiefs Chiefs Reds Chiefs Reds Reds
Sharks BYE

The Crowd Says:

2014-04-06T02:21:31+00:00

Crazy Horse

Guest


The Sea of Blue would like to extend our thanks to you experts for all for you help with the Reds this week. Here’s hoping you all pick the Tahs next week.

2014-04-06T02:19:16+00:00

Crazy Horse

Guest


The Sea of Blue would like to extend our thanks to you all for you help with the Reds this week. Here's hoping you all pick the Tahs next week.

2014-04-05T16:44:39+00:00

Nipper

Guest


I want to thank the panel for all picking the Reds, guaranteeing a Force win. Keep up the good work, boys!

2014-04-05T15:32:58+00:00

Common Sense

Guest


Let em' have it Bob! ;)

2014-04-05T12:25:21+00:00

Robert Stork

Guest


What an absolute joke. You the experts (along with those from Rugby Heaven in the past 4 matches (Reds, Chiefs, Highlanders and Rebels) have not to a person tipped the Western Force! What will be your tip come next w/end with the Force v Waratahs? Lets hope you keep up the good work and all tip the Tahs!

2014-04-05T02:08:46+00:00

bennalong

Guest


Aplon and De Villiers out. Aggressive but NOT rushing defence. So why pick the Stormers, other than they're at home Explain better please (particularly you Spiro but I'd like more from you too Brett)

2014-04-05T01:41:55+00:00

Bobbo7

Guest


Well I was completely wrong about that. Blues got smacked.

2014-04-04T11:26:05+00:00

Magic Sponge

Guest


Fair call Brett I'll pay that, go the Force

2014-04-04T06:58:34+00:00

WEST

Roar Guru


highlanders, blues, Hurricanes, chiefs. Reds, Lions, the Stormers.

2014-04-04T06:54:01+00:00

Atawhai Drive

Roar Guru


Australia's the centre of the universe . . . we all know that! Of course my wildly unrealistic idea will never become reality. And I'll always watch the Waratahs, live if possible and on delay when their match kicks off at 3.20am, as it does on Sunday morning. But the Waratahs have been largely invisible to the wider rugby public in NSW for almost 20 years. Never more so than this weekend.

2014-04-04T06:38:34+00:00

Redbull

Guest


Yeah, Bobbo is right. The rain will be an advantage to the Blues. 2 inches must be Canberra's yearly average.

2014-04-04T06:22:47+00:00

Mark Richmond

Roar Guru


Rugby HQ reported Alofa gone too.......are they incorrect?

2014-04-04T05:53:52+00:00

El Gamba

Guest


Must say I'm surprised that not one person has picked the Force. The Reds were atrocious last week against an atrociouser Stormers. Mind you I like the Force as underdogs and I've again picked against as I have done their last three games - prove me wrong again boys!!

AUTHOR

2014-04-04T05:49:33+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


It definitely is, mate...

2014-04-04T05:46:43+00:00


I didn't get my T-shirt Brett. ;) Must be in the post, eh? :D

2014-04-04T05:36:20+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


I agree! I'm not that confident in the Reds.

2014-04-04T05:33:25+00:00

Crazy Horse

Guest


We appreciate that Brett. Beale isn't going to appreciate being slammed into the deck by Godwin every time he touches the ball.

2014-04-04T05:25:19+00:00


I am not sure I should show my face around here after my performance last week, but then it gives me courage when Jean de Villiers can lose a fourth one on the trot in Australasia and still smile at the end in a post match interview. At least I can say I made a few risky plays which didn't come off, more than the Stormers captain could say all month. ;)

AUTHOR

2014-04-04T05:13:32+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Don't forget Melon, Horne himself through long and hard about going to the Force before re-signing with the Tahs for one more year. So yeah, at the time they signed Lance, they probably were thinking of him as a 12.. (Or a 15 I suppose, they mentioned early on they thought Folau's future was in the centres..)

2014-04-04T05:05:25+00:00

Who Needs Melon

Roar Guru


Yes I think you're right. But are you saying if Beale wasn't playing at 12, Lance would be? I don't think so - I think it more likely they would be playing Horne there ahead of Lance. He must have gone knowing he was only ever likely to be a bench utility player. Anyway, I don't want to knock the guy. Things happen, form wanes, you fall out with your employer and seek greener pastures.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar