Dear Gus, Rabs and Sterlo: Just show us the game

By Ben Pobjie / Expert

My thoughts on Origin 2? I am glad you asked. First of all, an overwhelming sense of tear-stained relief that indeed, beauty and joy are still possible in the world.

Secondly, such great admiration for the heroes of NSW. They had to overcome so many hardships, as Queensland resorted to all sorts of underhanded tactics – time-wasting, forearms to the face, kicking so-called ‘penalty goals’, etc.

And yet, even when Johnathan Thurston attempted to draw them into a good old-fashioned schoolgirl slap fight, they held their nerve.

So many heroes – from Paul Gallen, who overcame the brain injury that caused him to spend the entire second half under the impression that he was playing halfback, to Anthony Watmough, continuing an amazing career as a professional sportsman despite having been born with no limbs, to Aaron Woods, who is now an Origin winner after already becoming the first player to be picked for NSW directly from the cast of Puberty Blues.

It was a great game, in the sense of ‘a game that ended the way I wanted’, and there’s much to say about it. But I’d like to say a few words about the unsung heroes – the TV commentators. And the few words I’d like to say are: shut the hell up.

Not during the game, of course.

Well, maybe during the game. I mean, eventually you start wishing Ray Warren would spend more time learning about the game of rugby league and less time calling the players by their first names to convince us he’s a personal friend. It might be nice if the commentators would admit that State of Origin rules are actually the same as regular rugby league rules. And I did start hacking at my own ears when Phil Gould said, “They have to start playing football” for the six hundredth time.

But look, I get it. If you televise sport, you need commentators and it’s a bit unfair to expect them to stay silent while the match is on, no matter how fervently you wish they were all Terry Wogan.

But I want to make a revolutionary suggestion here. How about, when a football game is on TV, the telecast starts, say, five minutes before the game does? Enough time to say, “Welcome to State of Origin Game 2”, ask each of the assembled experts who they think will win, and cut to the freaking action.

Once, back in the 1990s, a State of Origin game was preceded by a skit where Paul Vautin pretended to read fairytales. That night has since become known worldwide as western civilisation’s lowest ebb, but every Origin since, Channel Nine has made a brave stab at exceeding it.

It took 50 minutes for Wednesday’s game to start. 50 minutes from the “welcome to Origin 2” to the point at which Origin 2 began. It gives the welcome a cruel irony. Like being welcomed to a dinner party and made to sit in the bath for an hour before being offered a drink.

Because here’s a tip, TV tastemakers – nobody wants to see your pre-match rubbish. I mean nobody. If the commentators were at home watching themselves, they’d be screaming “Start the cocking game!” with the rest of us.

Nobody, I tell you. Nobody.

Nobody wants to know what you think about how tough Origin is, and how it’s the supreme test, and how it’s all about heart and passion and pride and pineapples.

Nobody wants to hear your thoughts on who will or will not be focusing their attack on the left edge – if they focus their attack on the left edge, we’ll see it when it happens. Do these people think that if we’re not already on the lookout for footballers playing football, it’ll escape our notice during the game? Are there production meetings where producers say, “Make sure you tell people to look out for Reynolds running off Gallen’s offloads, because it’ll be pretty hard to spot otherwise”?

Nobody wants to hear Gorden Tallis trying to form sentences. Nobody wants to hear Darren Lockyer trying to dislodge the live frogcatcher from his trachea. Nobody wants to see Andrew Johns standing in front of that goddamn TV screen and talking as if he’s under the impression that being made a rugby league Immortal means he died some time ago. The man played rugby league like he was created by angels. He reads an autocue like he was made by a box factory.

And no, we don’t want to go down to the rooms. When we go down to the dressing rooms we see what happens in dressing rooms: large men in a confined space awkwardly wandering around and occasionally tossing a ball to each other. There is no insight gained by change-room access that could not be made more entertaining by playing an episode of Cheers instead.

But even if the preamble wasn’t so dire and clichéd and irritating and dull; even if Gorden was articulate; even if Darren sounded like George Clooney; even if Joey had any insight to offer; even if Phil Gould wasn’t the sort of person you’d take out an AVO to avoid having a conversation with; even if Ray Warren was younger than many palaeolithic cave paintings…

Guess what?

We turned on the television to watch a frigging game of football! Show. It. To. Us.

For the love of Artie, show us the game.

The Crowd Says:

2014-08-21T09:11:22+00:00

Robert Pearson

Guest


How come with all the criticism of NRL coaches no body has bothered to mention the abysmal past 10 years of coaching of Ricky Stuart. Wooden spoon in 2013, maybe again in 2014. His excuse, no representative players. Has everyone forgotten that he had 8 years of full teams of representative players and could not win a single series. Please someone on television at least discuss this matter My vote, Ricky Stuart NRL's worst coach, definitely not worth the money clubs pay for his services.

2014-08-15T11:23:45+00:00

Julie

Guest


Seriously Phil watch Friday nights game. Dogs v Parra. You never have anything nice to say about the dogs. All you did was bag them. It got so annoying while watching the show I had to mute it so I wouldn't hear. You went on and on about the dogs not making meters. Don't know what your issue is with the bulldogs but it's becoming a joke listening to you commentate on of there games

2014-07-01T00:54:55+00:00

Jill Wilding

Roar Rookie


Surely there must be someone that can call a Rugby League game without going into ramblings about rels or pre years or 'whatever', whilst the game goes from one end of the field to the other. Occasionally a players name is called but most of the time what they are doing is not. I would hate to be blind and relying on the TV call of a game because, honestly you would not know what was happening. B@#%-+ disgraceful !!

2014-06-30T06:21:28+00:00

da plane

Guest


mmm there is a device called a remote control if you dont like the call turn it down or off- gees some people

AUTHOR

2014-06-23T01:49:54+00:00

Ben Pobjie

Expert


If you know a way to write about something on TV without knowing what it was, let me know.

2014-06-22T07:27:39+00:00

oli

Guest


Someone should invent the "commentator on - off" button. Just me, the game and the crowd ... how good would that be?

2014-06-22T05:17:13+00:00

Jono

Guest


It's not that hard to comprehend. You can like something in a general sense without liking every aspect of it. For example, you can like a TV show without liking every episode or like music without liking every artist or genre.

2014-06-21T23:11:01+00:00

Adam

Guest


Andrew johns selling a tv doesn't compare to analysis of plays before an NFL match

2014-06-21T23:09:36+00:00

Adam

Guest


The origin lead in on abc grandstand was fantastic compared to the tripe channel 9 spews out. Same applies to cricket coverage.

2014-06-21T12:38:15+00:00

Andy_Roo

Roar Guru


Hey Ben, I agree with you. I don't give a stuff about the pre-game stuff and the commentary is sometimes awful. Heres the solution for you. Don't turn your telly on until 5 minutes before that game actually starts and hit the mute button. Problems solved.

2014-06-21T10:43:15+00:00

Cathar Treize

Roar Guru


He said it was the biggest crowd since the stadium was 'reconfigured'. So he is correct as those 100,000 plus crowds in NRL/Union were while the stadium was still configured for the Olympics.

2014-06-21T09:56:54+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Guest


I'm pretty sure I heard Warren claim that the crowd was going to be the biggest since the Olympics. I guess those league and union crowds of over 100k were just a myth eh Rabs?

2014-06-21T09:53:02+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Guest


Infinitely preferable to the drivel served up by the commentators.

2014-06-21T09:51:47+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Guest


I'm complaining because there is no reason the game can't start at 7.30. That way it can finish at a reasonable hour, which would allow more kids to watch it.

2014-06-21T09:50:06+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Guest


So you both like and dislike the lead ins. Well that made sense...

2014-06-21T01:37:37+00:00

Jackson Henry

Guest


Further to what I've said below/above, I hate how the RL tribalism tries to force you into unthinking blind agreement with whatever course of action your own state's powerbrokers take. And if you disagree, people call you a turncoat or a closet Qld/NSW fan or whatever. Let's think for ourselves I say. I know the tribalism is great, and its what drives a lot of things that make our game great, but let's not be left behind here. We already struggle with the stereotype of being a game for Mungos (I don't even know what a Mungo is). Let's make our game inclusive.Ban the punching. Let's have Mums all over Australia wanting their sons and daughters to play our game. Make the analysis actual analysis. Treat the fans with respect. HD, more live games, banish Hadley, get Voss back, the list goes on. There's great diversity in our support base - the Roar here demonstrates that on a daily basis. Let's facilitate and celebrate that. Off the soapbox now.

2014-06-21T01:29:23+00:00

Jackson Henry

Guest


Absolutely. Absolutely. Absolutely. RL is crying out for intelligent and informed discussion of the game - we are about two decades behind the AFL, NFL and the NBA. I hate how RL feels like it has to apologise for tbeing "too technical" (both Gould and Slater have actually done this before) and that something like the Footy Show, which is one of the the only free to air programs for RL, has to actually put time limits on how much discussion they're allowed to have of actual issues (5 in the bin or whatever it was called?). And even then, they give us...Ray Hadley...as one of the participants. We know what you think dude, you have the biggest microphone in Australia anyway, and a whole lot of us don't care what your opinions are. Give someone else a go who's actually interesting and who doesn't steal everyone else's time. I mean, it's to the point where I actually look forward to James Hooper's air time! James Hooper!

2014-06-21T01:08:30+00:00

yoyo

Guest


foreplay is for girls...

2014-06-21T01:07:02+00:00

Aaron

Guest


Wow. Such insight.

2014-06-21T00:39:31+00:00

Meesta Cool;

Guest


Look at the crap that Channel Nine gets it's best ratings for!. Is it any wonder that they treat the rest of us as mindless Nabobs. Yup .. No wonder!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar