Impact players: Test rugby's greatest non-starters

By Adam Julian / Roar Guru

The Waratahs scored more points in the last 20 minutes of matches than any other team in Super Rugby this year, a massive compliment to the quality of their bench.

This stat also reinforces the importance of tactical substitutions in the modern game.

Players like Will Skelton, Silatolu Latu and Peter Betham all had a huge impact during the season.

Last year when the All Blacks completed an unbeaten season, they outscored opponents’ 183-53 in the last 30 minutes of 14 Test matches.

The bench counts in modern rugby, but who are the greatest bench internationals? Think of players who might be more remembered for their feats as a non-starter than a starter.

Piri Weepu
Piri Weepu played 71 Tests for the All Blacks, but only completed a full game on three occasions. He made a world record 46 appearances off the bench.

His poise under pressure and versatility made him an ideal man for a crisis. During the 2011 World Cup, where he actually started most games, he kicked 23 points to help New Zealand win their quarter final against Argentina; Weepu was the All Blacks’ fourth goal-kicking option. Weepu was then was a major factor in the semi-final triumph against Australia.

His most notable bench performance was in Brisbane in 2008 when he scored a try against Australia which helped New Zealand win a gripping Test 28-24. A year earlier against South Africa, Weepu played a role in creating the winning try in a 26-21 win in Durban.

Ollie le Roux
The giant 136kg prop from South Africa played 43 of his 54 Tests off the bench. A colossus in the scrum, le Roux became a crowd favourite for his explosive runs. A member of the 1995 World Cup winning team, le Roux’s international career spanned nine years.

Ronan O’Gara
Fierce competition from David Humphreys and Johnny Sexton meant that O’Gara played 43 of his 130 Tests matches off the bench. Ireland’s all-time leading point scorer, with 1083, often changed games with his goal-kicking when he was introduced into the action. As early as 2001 he kicked two penalties to help Ireland beat England 19-13 at Twickenham.

In 2003 he kicked Ireland into the quarter finals of the World Cup after slotting two penalties in a 16-15 win against Argentina. In the 2011 World Cup, O’Gara landed two penalties to help Ireland close out a famous 15-6 win over Australia at Eden Park.

O’Gara was a durable and consistent performer who added value starting or warming the benches.

Beauden Barrett
Barrett has won all 19 Tests he has played, appearing as a substitute 17 times. He has scored 64 points and made memorable contributions in All Black victories.

Against South Africa in Johannesburg last year he scored a 30-metre solo try that won the All Blacks the Rugby Championship. In the same game he pulled of a try saving tackle on Willie le Roux.

Barrett scored off the bench with his first touch in Test rugby against France.

Viliame Ofahengaue
‘Willie O’ started 29 of his 41 Tests matches, but the powerful number 8 and flanker was later used in his career as an impact player with real success.

Perhaps his most memorable cameos were against the All Blacks in 1998. Australia swept the series 3-0 and Ofahengaue made a noticeable difference in all three games.

Sébastien Chabal
A hulk of a man, Chabal played 29 of his 62 Tests off the bench for France. An inconsistent performer, Chabel was capable of being truly world class in sporadic bursts, which made him ideal to introduce from the bench.

Owen Finegan
Finegan was a big man with nimble hands, a player almost ahead of his time with his rare combination of powerful running and subtle offloading. He played 21 of his 55 Tests off the bench and often caused headaches for the opposition when they were tiring in the second-half.

Finegan’s most famous bench performance was in the 1999 World Cup final against France. He gave the last pass to Ben Tune for Australia’s first try and then scored the second with a typically bustling run.

The Crowd Says:

2014-09-28T23:03:31+00:00

David

Guest


Sorry for the late reply but you missed the best impact player in modern rugby imo in Danie Rossouw . Not only was he back-up at the Bulls and Boks for Victor Matfield and Bakkies Botha but also a skilful back rower . Not to mention he is one of the most decorated rugby player in the world with 2xCurrie Cups , 3xSuper 14 titles ,1xTri Nations , 1xLions Tour Victory ,2x Japanese Top League ,2xHeineken Cup , 1xTop 14 and a World Cup (possibly game winning tackle while playing 8 in final , Pierre Spies was injured for the entire tournament) . Just based on these stats he has no equivalent as an impact player.

2014-08-15T11:52:10+00:00

MMaaxx

Guest


In more recent years Dannie Rossouw has been the man for SA. From 4,5,6,7,8 Danie had it covered, always made an impact and never let the team down.

2014-08-15T11:04:01+00:00

bigbaz

Roar Guru


No such thing as a kiwi Australian. You are either Australian or not, and you have a choice.

2014-08-15T09:23:11+00:00

Xenomorph

Guest


Not a long list? What about all those Kiwi Wallabies? I like a lot of Australians, my Mum for a start, but a few are a bit annoying, like Russell Crowe. ;-)

2014-08-15T02:54:38+00:00

Wal

Roar Guru


I did specify for the single penalty goal.

2014-08-15T02:42:17+00:00

Insomnia

Guest


Stephen Donald was the worst non-starter. Caused more negatives than positives.

2014-08-15T02:39:32+00:00

Markus

Guest


Cheers atlas, interesting that it was about 50/50 for Waugh in the end. I agree subs are not always impact players, but this discussion was focusing on players that would be considered impact players. The Smith/Waugh is an interesting case, as even when Waugh came off the bench it didn't seem it was him providing the impact as much as him allowing Smith to provide a different kind of impact - slightly less ruck focused, more ball in hand - while shifting out to blindside or number 8.

2014-08-15T01:27:12+00:00

Magic Sponge

Guest


Finegan and Willie O how we need these guys in todays team. Hard men not one track schoolboy type players

2014-08-15T01:11:39+00:00

atlas

Guest


Waugh - 44 starts, 35 as sub Smith - 93 starts, 18 as sub Subs are not always 'impact players' - Andrew Hore (2002-13) and Keven Mealamu (2002- still playing) - nearly 200 test caps between them, I think extended each other's career with neither being relied upon as the #1 hooker and being able to rotate through start/sub for much of their careers Hore 83 - 47 + 36 subs Mealamu 113 - 73 + 40 subs

2014-08-15T00:53:54+00:00

Markus

Guest


I'd be interested to see Phil Waugh's bench to starting ratio. My recollection is that Smith was regularly benched or moved to 6 in place of Waugh purely because Smith was more versatile and had greater impact. Waugh was a grafter, but I'd never call him an impact player. And if it wasn't for a dearth of blindside options for a long period, I'd think that his Test tally would have been much lower than what it was.

2014-08-14T23:27:04+00:00

Wal

Roar Guru


Phil Waugh - Great test starter only for a certain Smith Marty Holah - See Phil Waugh but for a McCaw bloke Stephen Donald for that one Kick Jonah Lomu - Only played 9 of his 63 Tests as a sub, mostly at the end of his career as illness robbed his fitness, however it never robbed him of his impact.

2014-08-14T23:03:58+00:00

atlas

Guest


Barrett this week: ''I just do as I'm told,'' he said today when asked about his role off the bench. ''Whether I'm starting or not, we all have to prepare as if we're starting, that way we know the game-plan inside-out and we're ready to go on in the first minute or the last.'' ''You do want to keep pushing for that spot and when you get on the field you want to make an impact. I guess it's just proving to the coaches you deserve the jersey.''

2014-08-14T22:50:49+00:00

atlas

Guest


I'm a Samo fan, but he wouldn't rate as 'super sub at international level - according to ESPN stats he played 23 tests over 9 seasons 2004-12 (but not selected 2005-2010), 15 of those were starts, 8 off the bench, scored 2 tries in those 23 tests (1 v USA, one v NZ)

2014-08-14T21:06:34+00:00

bigbaz

Roar Guru


Weepu, my favourite kiwi( not a long list),wish he been an Aussie!

2014-08-14T16:28:18+00:00

Sportym

Guest


How about Radike Samo? Can we go past the Fro???

Read more at The Roar