Lemon's winners and losers, AFL Round 22

By Geoff Lemon / Expert

AFL finals will start early after results set up some knockout games for the last round of the season. Twelve teams can still make the finals, five can make the top four, and the rest can make the best of one last crack at 2014. So who won big this week?

Port Adelaide get my vote for the most important win of the weekend. Damn if the Power did not deserve the adjective ‘spectacular’ on Friday night.

Finally, after two months of limping, stilted football that delivered five losses in eight, the Power got back to the surging attacking style that had delivered them ten wins in their first eleven.

CATCH UP ON THE LATEST AFL HIGHLIGHTS

Don’t talk it down in retrospect: this shaped as a real danger game for Port. Carlton had been playing well for a couple of months themselves, pushing the top teams in the competition and growing in confidence. There was every risk they could upset the Power and put a hole in their finals chances.

Instead, Port came back to life. Full of confidence, full of attacking fervour, they swarmed the Blues. I don’t even think Carlton played badly, but they were taken apart to the tune of 103 points.

Robbie Gray took control of the game when it was there to be won, ending best on ground by a mile. Chad Wingard, Travis Boak, Hamish Hartlett and Jared Polec were all back to their sprinting, handballing best. The Power went coast-to-coast all night, scoring on the slingshot at will. Boak’s ability to pick out targets on the run from 60 metres away was footballing perfection.

10 goals in each half was a model of consistency, and if Port had been more accurate they might have won by 150. What they have done is boost their percentage above Fremantle’s, while staying only four points behind them.

Whatever happens from here, we’re in for a treat when Port travel to Perth to play the Dockers next week. The winner is guaranteed fourth spot and a double chance. They’ll need it, as they’ll go to Sydney to play the Swans, but at least they’ll be in with a shout.

Sydney sit first, Hawthorn’s comeback took second from Geelong, and that’s where it should stay. Geelong’s record for the highest ever AFL score was set against Brisbane, but the Cats would need to beat the Lions by 480 points this week to pass Hawthorn on percentage. The Hawks-Cats game was as always great to watch, but the result means little. Neither side will be cocky nor despondent, and their finals date remains set bar any last-round disaster.

Richmond were the sentimental winning favourites, notching eight in a row to get themselves back inside the eight. In classic Richmond tragedy though, they won’t stay there. Call me Buzzkill Lightyear, but a win against the Swans in Sydney is not going to happen.

How deeply they will regret those early losses to Melbourne and the Western Bulldogs. Admittedly the game is at ANZ Stadium, where the lack of atmosphere would help visiting teams. There’s also not much for Sydney to play for. But in the likely scenario that Richmond lose, they’ll spend Sunday arvo praying for two upsets: St Kilda to take out Adelaide and Gold Coast to beat West Coast.

It’s West Coast who really won out of the weekend, with a nice percentage boost against Melbourne. They may sit 10th, but with Richmond and Collingwood both likely to lose, they’ll Bradbury into the top eight with one more win.

Adelaide could still pip the Eagles from 11th, if they can righteously smite St Kilda by a much huger margin than West Coast can manage. Brenton Sanderson will be punching the nitro booster when he sends his side out at Adelaide Oval, so get ready for either comedy or carnage.

Of course Adelaide could have been in the eight already if they’d won on Saturday, their shortfall making North Melbourne one of the round’s big winners.

The Kangaroos set themselves up beautifully a game clear in sixth with only the speed hump of the tired Demons to roll over. Adelaide were never going to be as easy, with no clear advantage in the Kangaroos’ adopted home of Hobart, and it was arm wrestle all day as small leads swapped back and forth.

Eventually North were able to lock down scoring late in the game to preserve a seven-point lead, exactly the kind of play they’ll need to replicate against fiercer opposition. A home final is now assured, though almost certainly against Essendon.

Essendon also had an important win against a Gold Coast side that weren’t prepared to go quietly away, pulling level in the last quarter before the Bombers got away. They could only miss finals now if the Tigers and Magpies both pull out percentage-boosting upsets against the top two sides, and that’s not going to happen.

Coach Mark Thompson was justifiably proud but forgetful: “I’m glad they’ve got something out of [the season] and that was the reason why we’re all here, for them, because they’ve been treated pretty badly,” he said, another amnesiac regarding just who put Essendon’s players in their current position.

It’s been a tough run for Gold Coast, so hopeful of a first finals appearance before some mean kid broke Gary Ablett. They’re still a mathematical chance, but they’d have to spank West Coast while having three teams above them lose. Let’s hope they have a crack.

Finally there was Collingwood: a brave win, given their massive in-game injury toll for the second match running, but their season is gone regardless. They’ll go into a game against Hawthorn missing their three best midfielders, their most damaging tall and small forward, three running defenders and two key defenders, their best tagger and a handful of others besides.

The final ladder will come right down to next Sunday afternoon. Let’s meet here next Monday to see how it all turned out.

The Crowd Says:

2014-08-26T06:44:17+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Count on a derby...in the GF. WA's sense of theatre.

2014-08-26T06:42:28+00:00

Karl

Guest


Everyone said Richmond were no chance v West Coast at Subiaco and Adelaide at Adelaide Oval...... bring on Swans at ANZ Stadium. Hopefully the travelling masses for the Tiges will give the hovel some life

2014-08-25T23:07:06+00:00

Macca

Guest


I wasn't blaming Kane Lucas, just saying that if he was playing our depth was being sorely tested, I wouldn't have him in our best 30 players.

2014-08-25T19:20:42+00:00

Jason K

Guest


I don't have much to add, other than I love this column. The St. Kilda game was good in that it showed some potential for STK next year. Most of the footy this week was simply brilliant. An American friend and I watched the Geelong/Hawthorne game. He's just become the newest Hawks fan.

AUTHOR

2014-08-25T12:18:24+00:00

Geoff Lemon

Expert


Cheers Brumby, looking forward to it.

AUTHOR

2014-08-25T12:18:08+00:00

Geoff Lemon

Expert


Yeah, those derbies can have a life of their own. Would make for top viewing though. What's your tip?

2014-08-25T11:47:12+00:00

Peter Baudinette

Roar Guru


The 20000+ swans members since 1996, would probably feel just as faithful as I do about the Swans depth. Your are the biggest straw clutcher I have ever seen on this site. Yes, take all those players out of Sydney, in other words rip it to shreds in the same vein as Collingwood, and they probably would struggle against a top 8 team. Injuries, MRP, COLA, academies, get a grip champ. They can only win with what they have got and they are currently clear on top.....

2014-08-25T11:26:43+00:00

Carcass

Guest


They are thinking the same thing Collingwood is, 'MAD MONDAY'!

2014-08-25T10:44:59+00:00

Jonny G

Guest


[Comment deleted - Mods]

2014-08-25T10:08:43+00:00

Jack

Guest


I think Kane lucas can hardly be blamed

2014-08-25T10:03:02+00:00

Bosk

Roar Rookie


Gene I think you forgot to mention that Geelong "weren't really trying". Oh wait, yes you did. Many times. I find it hilarious that Cats fans like yourself have made such a big deal each and every time you've beaten Hawthorn in H&A games since 2008, yet suddenly you lose one and 'its not important, only finals matter'. Finals like last year's Prelim hey mate?

2014-08-25T09:59:09+00:00

Bosk

Roar Rookie


Then I must apologize and congratulate you on being one of the few Swans fans to have discovered the sport before October of 2005. Sure you're right about depth players pushing for selection being important, pressuring the veterans to deliver every time they run out always helps. Assuming you're telling the truth about being a 32 year member you'd know by now its experience that wins premierships, not youth. Crow all you like about champion teams having fringe players ready to slot in and get the job done and its a point I readily agree with but I would hardly put those rookie talls you named in that category. If any of those three find themselves in a Swans jumper this September at the expense of an injured Franklin or TIppett they'll likely be as badly exposed and exploited by opposition defenses as any similarly green 19 year old KPP of Geelong, Hawthorn or Freo would. Sydney's had the kindest run of injuries of any team this year and a suspiciously charmed run at the MRP so don't waffle on about how great your depth is when its barely been tested. Take Franklin, Richards, Pyke, Kennedy, Grundy, Malceski and Jack out of the side and then upset another top 8 team and maybe I'll be impressed, but until then talking up your unproven kids or mentioning how you managed to beat a team with absolutely nothing to play for without a few midfielders ain't gonna impress me.

2014-08-25T09:04:20+00:00

Nev

Guest


The cats had a game plan in the second half?

2014-08-25T08:55:55+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


[Comment deleted - Mods]

2014-08-25T08:47:22+00:00

Cos

Guest


No, Buddy was on the other side, choking big time. And Swans fans are kidding if they think 2014 Goodes is half the player 2012 Goodes was. He is simply not physically capable of being 'the' key forward in a GF.

2014-08-25T08:00:38+00:00

Peter Baudinette

Roar Guru


Depth isn't about big names, but if you want to go there, the Swans just flogged the dogs without Kennedy, Bird, McGlynn and Reid. They brought in Mitchell, that's that father son recruit (their first ever) out of Barry Mitchell. And these other two household names you speak of have handled themselves pretty well. When you look at depth, it isn't about the superstars waiting the wings, it's about the players that can slot in and get the job done. What makes a champion team is the ability of these young blokes, who have only played 13 games between them, to push for selection. I'm no band wagoner champ. I'm a 32 year member. I don't hide behind a cartoon.

2014-08-25T07:56:18+00:00

Jack Smith

Roar Guru


^ To Jim. That's freaky. My first live game too.

2014-08-25T07:54:11+00:00

Jack Smith

Roar Guru


Can't we just say Hawks played the better football? Why would Geelong put the 'cue in the rack?' (on purpose)

2014-08-25T07:52:11+00:00

Jack Smith

Roar Guru


Of course we do Bosk. That's why we haven't lost a game when he has been out this year. He is obviously so crucial we can't beat any team without him.

2014-08-25T07:51:53+00:00

Majestic Pavlova

Guest


Adelaide and North are on an absolute par with each other when it comes to inconsistency, who could say what you'd get out of that match other than more of the same.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar