The sky is not falling on Australian rugby

By Phil Bird / Roar Guru

Let’s be clear about it, on Saturday night the All Blacks dismantled the Wallabies and put them back together broken. Still, there’s no cause for alarm, despite what most pundits in the press will be saying this week.

Here are five reasons why.

1. This was the performance the All Blacks have been waiting for
For the past two seasons the All Blacks have been a Ferrari running on ethanol.

Indeed the fact they’ve won 35-odd games during this time is a tad scary, however the point being there’s no team in the world that could have come out of that game without looking like a tier two nation.

There was no disgrace in this loss. Perhaps the harsher Australian critics need to examine the basis for expecting a level pegging with this team. It’s one of the best teams in history, period, and you can’t expect by some rite of passage to be near them when they play like they did on Saturday.

2. There are selection errors in the Australian team, which is an easy fix
The Wallabies have been playing with their team upside down. The bench should be swapped with their opposites on the starting team.

If Ewen McKenzie chose to play his best players from the first minute, rather than the 65th when the outcome has already been decided, then the Wallabies might actually have a crack at these guys in the black guernseys.

Scott Higginbotham, Will Skelton, Bernard Foley, Nick Phipps. These players are the best in their positions yet they’re warming seats in the dugout. This was highlighted on Saturday when they made an immediate impact, although far too late in the game to get their team back into contention.

They’re x-factor players and if you change the cattle you’ll get a different outcome on the field.

3. Australia has some of the best attacking players going around
Israel Folau can, by all rights, be considered the most exciting player in the world, and Kurtley Beale has had a renaissance this year. His carving runs, deft inside passes and solid game management is a pleasure to watch game after game – no matter who he’s up against he’s turning up.

Even with a backtracking forward back, or a backward pack, these two players put on a beautiful display on Saturday. They made stuff out of nothing – scintillating in combination and turned the All Blacks on their heels time and again.

Give them clean ball and a forward pack living up to their job description and the final result may prove very different.

4. Michael Hooper
The true test of a captain’s mettle is what he does with a team that’s going backwards.

Richie McCaw showed us true leadership over the past decade, and university lecturers could do worse than apply a case study on the man.

However Hooper’s display last night was equally inspiring; he dragged his men forward, leading by example and never giving up despite the trouncing. This culminated in the 14 points scored in the second half, including his standout try late in the game.

This proved the bloke has the mettle to lead his team to greatness. He’ll be Australian captain for the next decade, barring injury, and all the better for it. David Pocock is going to have to learn how to play number eight or blindside.

5. Ewen McKenzie can be replaced
Australians are renowned as being the shrewdest players in the game, although in the second Bledisloe they were totally outsmarted by a creative and progressive New Zealand outfit.

For example, the New Zealanders had an inventive set piece move where a couple of backs joined the lineout, only to peel away to the left when the ball was thrown in. This created a distraction while Richie McCaw and his men marched to the right and over the try line.

It worked so well they did it again six minutes later, McCaw getting a carbon-copy try.

It’s true the All Blacks were having a bit of fun at that point, but still, the Aussies need to try the kitchen sink and get some creativity into their play. Why not try Beale at halfback?

Why not bring on your best players in the first minute rather than the 60th? Why not sub off players after 15 minutes if they’re not giving you what you need? Where were the forwards putting their hand up to beat the advantage line?

Nothing could express this shift of rugby IQ better than the 10 minutes where each team had a man in the bin. New Zealand calmly played for penalties and territory, putting on 3-0 with McCaw in the bin, while Australia panicked and conceded 14 points with Rob Simmons off the field.

Whatever the case, Michael Cheika is around, he’s in Australia, and he’ll probably be Wallabies coach in a year or so, in whatever timeframe the ARU decides is face-saving enough to replace McKenzie.

There’s a lot of good in this team, and a couple of distinct yet simple changes will create a big shift in their fortunes against the world’s best.

The rest of the world? They’re already in hand.

The Crowd Says:

2014-08-27T21:20:33+00:00

johnnno1

Guest


On you mate. Those idiots cling to the one sport they're any good at like a dog and bone. They won the trophy yet I still feel sorry for them. Strange

AUTHOR

2014-08-25T21:37:01+00:00

Phil Bird

Roar Guru


Different tackle - youre talking about cruden i think. and yes, cruden got away with it

2014-08-25T11:23:31+00:00

Carcass

Guest


Because the Kiwi bloke almost tore his head clear off. Would have even been a penalty in gridiron let alone union.

2014-08-25T10:10:54+00:00

Knightblues

Guest


I agree Aussies in Rugby Union and especially the media here have big mouths, we are simply all talk and bravado but little action on the field.

2014-08-25T07:45:32+00:00

Rob9

Guest


No. You started saying ‘everyone’. You’ve now clarified that to mean everything coming out of the Australian media which is still off the mark. Before making such broad ranging comments, I suggest reading more than q or 2 articles on the roar. This Kiwi mentality that Australians (team, media and fans) are hell-bent on talking ourselves up and thinking we’re world beaters while verbally defecating all over the ‘all-mighty’ AB’s is rubbish. I understand you (after explaining yourself) are referring to our media, but the reality is there are a very small number of ‘shock-jock’ types in the media who blow smoke where the sun don’t shine and most of the time, this just simply serves to generate interest in the game. Our players and coaches have media duties and why on earth wouldn’t they project a picture of confidence? We’re reasonably successful in the sport and why bother turning up if you don’t believe you can win? As for the fans, we have a proud history in rugby and although it might not be particularly fair, we set our expectations high. I don’t see any of this as over the top which is exactly what your comment portrays it as. Most fans and media know and knew our weaknesses before and after Saturday night. Most were expecting a loss against the AB’s, although not by that much. There’s still a lot to be excited about in Australian rugby and one game doesn’t change that. There’s also a lot of work to do and most would have recognised that before Saturday as well. Furthermore, while we love to hate the AB’s and their fans, most have nothing but respect for them and are well aware of their current and historical standing in world rugby.

AUTHOR

2014-08-25T07:22:24+00:00

Phil Bird

Roar Guru


I am humbled. There's a pretty solid 6th reason!

2014-08-25T07:22:05+00:00

kesmcc

Roar Pro


How am I back peddling?? I have said I stick by my comments and i said from the start that I meant the media. You don't seem to accept that. And if you think there weren't loads of articles going round bagging the ABs you're dreaming. I accept that you're just arguing for the sake of arguing now so I'm not wasting anymore time on this.

2014-08-25T06:47:00+00:00

Tigranes

Guest


The problem I see it is that not once has the author (or any other poster) mentioned that we have a national rugby competition. Nor did it mention that an Australian team is currently the best provincial side in the world. This is why I would argue that "the sky is not falling on Australian rugby" - the day Australian rugby does not live or die by the performance of its national team is when we are ok.

2014-08-25T06:21:24+00:00

atlas

Guest


1 loss , 2 draws, 37 wins = their last 40 matches 1368 points v 591 Average score for those 40 matches is 34-15 156 tries v 50 Quite a stat.

2014-08-25T06:11:12+00:00

atlas

Guest


Yes, they lost that match. That was 20 matches ago - perhaps they learned from that game, having gone on to beat England four times since?, most recently 5 tries to 1, 36-13.

2014-08-25T03:40:38+00:00

Rob9

Guest


I’m not putting any words into your mouth. You responded to a fan article saying ‘everyone’ (who’s now just the Australian media) was saying this and that before the game and now supposedly it’s all ‘sack the coach and the players are rubbish’. It’s ironic you accusing others of backpedalling. You can back pedal all you like, but don’t accuse me of taking you out of context for simply changing a word from your original quote that still implies the same meaning. Even saying all (or even most) corners of the Australian media were throwing out the chat you’re suggesting is ill-informed.

2014-08-25T03:10:36+00:00

kesmcc

Roar Pro


Are you even reading my replys?? I said straight away that I didn't mean every wallaby fan. Only the australian media. You can keep putting words in my mouth if you like but I stand by my comment and I don't think it's out of context.

AUTHOR

2014-08-25T02:58:49+00:00

Phil Bird

Roar Guru


Easy to not notice it because we've had it for a decade. But if you stop and look at it, these guys have lost about 1 game in their last 35 or so. How does any team in any sport do that?

2014-08-25T02:45:02+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Scary team these ABs

2014-08-25T02:36:04+00:00

ohtani's jacket

Guest


Their performance was better than at Ellis Park, but they actually met some resistance in Johannesburg so Joburg was the better result.

2014-08-25T02:27:37+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Were the ABs any better at Eden Park this weekend than they were at Ellis Park last year?

2014-08-25T02:22:56+00:00

Rob9

Guest


I’d say it still delivers an accurate judgement of the context of your original quote, wouldn’t you? Or are we going to pretend you didn’t mean ‘everyone’ now?

2014-08-25T02:11:57+00:00

kesmcc

Roar Pro


I'm referring to you quoting me saying 'all' in your first comment. Have another look

2014-08-25T02:11:06+00:00

atlas

Guest


"White should have pulled himself off last week when he got injured." Is this an Australian thing? Would it necessarily have helped?

2014-08-25T02:00:46+00:00

Rob9

Guest


Ahhh I copy and pasted word for word what you typed. Hence the quotations.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar