Should the Boks spring even higher Heyneke?

By Armand van Zyl / Roar Guru

During the course of Springbok rugby history there has been a constant recurring blemish called inconsistency. Going hand in hand with inconsistency is our good old friend, progress, or rather lack thereof.

Always accompanying these two familiar faces is an angry Springbok fan. My fellow South Africans will know what I’m talking about.

It has been our curse to watch our beloved Springbok team fall into the bowels of mediocrity for years on end, refusing to follow the path of evolution. Entrusted with the imponderable conundrum of Springbok rugby and its intricate design is Heyneke Meyer, a good coach, a good leader and a great man.

Unfortunately, he is a man of the past. He believes in his game plan, he believes in his tried and tested players and he believes in his philosophy. By all means that is good for him, you can never trust a coach who doesn’t believe in what he’s doing. Meyer has his standards and his vision for the Boks and that is his right.

But when Meyer can’t see that this team needs progress then I start to doubt his abilities as a coach.

Forget the dubious calls from the officials in Perth, that’s just the way these things go. Rather ask yourself, did we really deserve to win? Some will say yes we some will say no. I believe we did but not convincingly so. We did dominate the scoreboard for most of the match, we did dominate the set phases and we did possess Duane Vermeulen.

It took a yellow card to down us in the end and it did take a very silly penalty to decrease our points differential to less than a converted try, but really we should have secured the game easily with the ascendancy we had.

Playing the blame game would be duplicitous to our cause, we have to start playing rugby. We expected more from the Springboks and they did not deliver. I don’t particularly enjoy putting the heat on referees but I do acknowledge a stupid decision when I see one.

But honesty must prevail here, the Wallabies came out to play ball and the Springboks came out to play a punting contest.

There was one particular sequence of play that told the whole story for me. It was a few minutes after the Vermeulen penalty. The Boks worked their way up to inside the Wallaby half. They received a penalty advantage for a Wallaby player being offside and their ball was completely secure.

Now, with that in mind I thought to myself, well we have the penalty advantage and we are inside their danger zone. Now we just grind out all the little metres we have left until we eventually crash over their line. That must be what they’re thinking, right?

Wrong.

The stage was set. As I mentioned we were so close. A monsterous Eben Etzebeth carry ate up a couple more metres and we had them on the ropes. The Wallaby line was retreating back toward the offside line and suddenly we had good, front foot ball from which we could attack, sending it down the backline.

And that’s what the Springboks did, but there was a twist to the tale.

Etzebeth went to ground, Ruan Pienaar (I know, right?) got there quickly and distributed the ball to Springbok scout master general Morne Steyn. Steyn looked to his left and saw a flying Jan Serfontein to his right. Don’t ask me how he could do that.

Jan Serfontein saw a blitzing centurion to his right and as an added bonus a lonely Adam Ashley-Cooper was the only one (who was still onside) standing between them with about 20 metres to the line. I say to myself, Serfontein can put Habana in space. Serfontein can grant Habana a masterful try in his big game. Serfontein will do what I think he will do.

Jan Serfontein does the unthinkable.

At full tilt he receives the ball and fires a massive up and under. Israel Folau makes it back on time, he catches, he marks, the referee remarks there was no advantage, he blows, we kick, the scoreboard is plus three for the Springboks.

Now everyone who has been reading my articles from the start will know that this is only my third year of watching the greatest sport on Earth, but I have never in my life heard, read or even seen an outside centre standing flat, taking the ball up at speed only to boot it up into the air while inside the opponent’s 22 with a penalty advantage as backup.

I dunno, it just seems wrong to me.

Anyhow, that just summed up the game and it got me thinking, is that really the game plan Meyer believes in? Make no mistake I have seen this type of thing before, just not from an outside centre.

Last year in the Ellis Park game the Boks were also under a penalty advantage inside the All Blacks’ 22 metre line and lo and behold, Fourie du Preez takes a box kick with the try line barely 15 metres away.

Eben Etzebeth is 205 centimetres tall, he could practically just stretch his arm out and score the try. Are the Springboks just so afraid of the ball that they believe that they look much better without it than with it?

The only real explanation I have is this, the team is called “The Springboks”. Maybe Meyer just takes it literally.

A Springbok is a cute little antelope that likes jumping very high, higher than Andries Bekker in Japan. Spring means jump so basically my Australasian friends you could call them the “Jumpbucks”.

Meyer wants his Jumpbuck team to act like they are Jumpbucks. They should jump. Come hell or high water whether if it’s in a lineout or when chasing an up and under, Heyneke wants Jannie du Plessis, Duane Vermeulen and Willie le Roux to jump like they have never jumped before.

But Heyneke, can you defeat the All Blacks by jumping them into submission? I firmly agree that Richie McCaw does not have the legs for jumping but, my Lord, Julian Savea sure does!

You cannot beat them this way. You cannot answer the phone if it isn’t ringing.

On a serious note though, Nick Mallett did mention something very worrying. The Springboks haven’t changed anything since the last World Cup based on their past few performances.

Former Springbok flyer Ashwin Willemse added another thing. Meyer keeps playing an inside centre at outside centre. Look back at when Jean de Villiers played at 13 in 2012, look at Damian de Allende’s showings the first few games and then look at Serfontein last weekend. Or even go one further, look at JP Pietersen’s time at 13.

In all those games the defence out wide was completely non existent.

As hard a pill as it might be to swallow for the majority of the country, the only real hope at 13 rests on the shoulders of Jaque Fourie. Only he has the ability to shape up defensively at 13 and as an added bonus he can jump.

The Springboks are in trouble and it is up to Meyer, his management and his team to rise above their current standards. Failure to do so this weekend will be catastrophic.

Failure to do so might end up making the Wallaby performance in New Zealand look like a masterpiece.

The Crowd Says:

2014-09-14T10:18:30+00:00

Greaper

Roar Rookie


yes, though as a percentage as isolation would have limited the number of games for the SBs.

2014-09-14T08:53:22+00:00

Jerry

Guest


Yeah, but the alternative is saying that the number 1 side lost more matches and won less than the number 2 side.

2014-09-14T05:58:20+00:00

Greaper

Roar Rookie


Yes true, those stats don't lie. All I'm suggesting is that I think it is a bit pointless saying that one team is no.1 when they're certainly no.2 head to head with another team.

2014-09-13T20:30:38+00:00

Jerry

Guest


SA unquestionably had the edge head to head (though by 1995 it had evened up a bit). But when you're talking about who the overall best side was, results against everyone else come into play. And NZ was better overall, by a significant margin.

2014-09-13T13:41:28+00:00

Greaper

Roar Rookie


percentages don't mean much when you a) don't have a better win loss record against the team and b) never won a tour on their soil. Considering this is a period built on tours and that SA won in NZ and NZ couldn't do the same I'd say percentages don't really hold up.

2014-09-13T09:35:20+00:00

Jerry

Guest


SA - Win % to 1995 = 63.9% NZ - Win % to 1995 = 71.2%

2014-09-13T08:24:32+00:00

Jim Boyce

Guest


Gee thanks for the constructive comment. Why waste your breath.

2014-09-13T07:40:56+00:00

Jim Boyce

Guest


Rugby Tragic - For my pains, I am he. The Boks are not good at injecting younger blood into their side and while the pack looks capable of giving the 2015 RWC a shake , the backs do not. The try the Boks scored in Perth was impressive but after that not good. There is nothing like the fear factor which the All Blacks have in away games but the Boks have frittered away.

2014-09-13T07:04:20+00:00

Android-angler Cartman-brah

Roar Rookie


Watch the young Naas it was much later when playing for the northern transvaal he started kicking

2014-09-13T06:09:53+00:00

Greaper

Roar Rookie


very informative, cheers mate. By your astute powers of deduction, that would be no-one ;D

2014-09-13T00:50:51+00:00

wazza perth nz ex pat

Guest


Ah the history...and Colin Meads, starting a test match against the Boks in SA with a broken arm in a cast, Keith Murdoch who started a test in SA 3 days after an appendix was removed from his stomach..and scored a try.. and Fergi McCormack who re-arranged Syd Nomis' dental work with a well aimed forearm !! . or Morne De Plessis (the Captain) who pulled an AB lock down to the ground in a lineout then stomped on his head... those were the days ....men were men, boys were boys and the sheep were nervous !! .

2014-09-12T23:33:27+00:00

Jerry

Guest


The team with a better record than them.

2014-09-12T22:18:14+00:00

Mielie

Guest


It might be constant Johnno, but can we do better? Why are the ABs sofar ahead of us? They are our meter stick. Nobody else. To lose a game where new and younger players are being tried out and new game plans introduced, is acceptable. But to lose a game where players from two world cups ago are still playing and the same old game plan is being used that opponents know oh so well , is not acceptable. It is heart breaking. With the plethora of excellent young players that are presently available and HM feels that he needs to use Victor Matfield and Morne Steyn for their experience and calming effect on the new players, or what ever, South African Rugby is in big trouble. Armand's article is excellent. Let us not rest on our laurels because of past successes. Let us aim higher and build a Springbuck reputation that will; like the present ABs; be the envy of the world. We will not achieve that under the present coach. Imo, I cannot see the Springbokke in the top 5 teams in the world in 10 years time because of the country's politics. Lets go out with a bang

2014-09-12T22:14:22+00:00

etienne marais

Guest


The Iceman. What a wonder. (Ok, and Zinzan, Kirwan, Kronfeld, Williams, Mexted)

2014-09-12T22:11:59+00:00

etienne marais

Guest


On Superbru I have Boks to win 3 and Argentina by 1. A weekend of upsets. Just hope that I am not myself too upset after the weekend. Tackling: other than the poor tactical kicking decisions and its equally poor execution (last week), the biggest issue was the tackling. Too many above the nipple-line tackles (momentum-slowing) instead of momentum-stopping tackles (waist and below). In the end, it takes three to tackle one and the eventual stop only happens 7-12 metres out. Accurate tackling and Pienaar/Reinach sharpness behind, is my wish for the weekend. Still hoping that Heyneke is going to pull a surprise with Reinach or Hougaard starting. Like many times before, this is going to be a long night. Probably sleepless. What a wicked contest!

2014-09-12T21:53:22+00:00

etienne marais

Guest


Astute observations. It's really just the centre pairing that is worthless...and pienaar. Solve that, and particalrly with a scrumhalf that can give pollard sharp service, and you have a completely different animal.

2014-09-12T21:03:47+00:00

etienne marais

Guest


grin! (from a saffer)

2014-09-12T17:05:11+00:00

fredstone

Guest


Maybe there was a little bit to much kicking, but that's how you generally play wet conditions. Due to it being rather wet it was never going to be error free. Arm wrestles are part of rugby sometimes and I did not find it boring at all, frustrating due to the lack of execution maybe, but was I snoring, no until the last three minutes when I wish I was.

2014-09-12T15:50:11+00:00

wazza perth nz ex pat

Guest


Na Harry - this lady told me - Once you go Black you never go back !

2014-09-12T15:38:29+00:00

Brendan Hope

Roar Guru


Total legends you've just named there match. ABs have produced such wonderful teams over the years. Enjoy the game and good luck to you blokes!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar