India face grim prospects ahead of Australian tour

By Bimal Mirwani / Roar Rookie

India looked like a boxer that had taken too many blows by the time their five-Test series against England had come to an end.

Sure they played brilliantly during the first two Tests in Nottingham and Lord’s, but it’s not how you start the series, it’s how you finish.

England came roaring back in the third Test and pummeled India into submission. In fact, India looked as if they had already given up even before the fifth Test at The Oval had gotten underway.

However, England finally put India out of their misery, and did so in brutal fashion. They landed a devastating knockout punch when they skittled them out for 94 in the second innings of the fifth Test, which is now their third-lowest score in Test history.

I will never forget the look of humiliation and embarrassment on the face of each Indian player, especially captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni and opening batsman Murali Vijay. This is because they fought with all their might to try and soften the blows that the national team were taking throughout the series.

They were eager to be the heroes that stood tall among the rubble, but due to the team losing by such a large and convincing margin their contributions are likely to be forgotten and become a thing of the past.

As an Indian fan, I was disgusted with India’s performance. To go from being 1-0 at the end of the second Test to 3-1 by the time the Test series was over was a humbling and infuriating experience. Honestly, it was gutting to watch India constantly brought to their knees and made to suffer before England finally delivered the kill shot.

It was a major relief when the series came to an end since I knew that India could be tortured no more. However, it was at that point in time that I realised what dangers were lurking just over the horizon in a place known as the Land Down Under.

If India perform like the way they did in the last three Tests against England when they tour Australia in December, then the baggy greens are going to have a field day and will likely whitewash the Indians 4-0. This got me thinking about how badly India are going to struggle in Australia.

If England showed no mercy, imagine what the baggy greens are capable of doing. One just has to remember the state of disarray England were left in when they travelled to Australia for the Ashes series in November last year. Furthermore, if India don’t show the urge or determination to fight back after being knocked down, then they will feel the full wrath of the baggy greens.

It was also extremely frustrating to watch India continuously make the same mistakes over and over again. Batsmen like Virat Kohli and Cheteshwar Pujara, who were supposed to be the duo to watch out for during the Test series against England, were made to look like headless chickens. They seemed to have no idea where their off-stump was, which resulted in them continuously being caught in the slip cordon.

The same thing can be said about the Indian bowlers. They didn’t focus on bowling the right line and length like the England bowlers did. Instead, they constantly tried to use the short ball to surprise the English batsmen. However, this failed miserably, and if you were to look at the bowling maps shown on Sky Sports it became even clearer that India’s line and length was all over the place.

One person who the Indians might find unplayable during their tour of Australia will be left-arm pace bowler Mitchell Johnson. If India’s batsmen struggled against England’s pace duo of Stuart Broad and James Anderson then they will have an absolute nightmare when facing Johnson. He is lightning quick and gets incredible bounce. However, Ryan Harris and Peter Siddle will also relish bowling at the Indians since they can bolster their own bowling statistics by channelling a lovely line and length.

In addition to this, England all-rounder Moeen Ali, who was dubbed as a part-time spinner at the beginning of the Test series, took 19 wickets at a superb average of 23. India are meant to be the best when it comes to playing spin since all their pitches at home are spin-friendly. However, one other question this raises is how much success Australian spinner Nathan Lyon will have.

Not only has Lyon been training with the legendary Muttiah Muralitharan, who is arguably the best spinner in the history of the sport, but he has also invented a new ball only known as ‘Jeff’. I shudder to think what kind of damage Lyon can inflict if Ali managed to pick up 19 wickets.

India also shot themselves in the foot by not agreeing to use the Decision Review System (DRS) during their Test series against England. There were many decisions that would have gone their way if the technology had been available, but as usual they decided to stick to their stubborn ways and paid a hefty price for it.

The exact same thing might happen in Australia if the DRS is not available. India have to stop clinging to their ideology about the DRS not having a positive influence on the game and learn to accept and cherish it.

Another reason why India will struggle in Australia is simply down to the fact that they have never really excelled in foreign conditions. This has been true for years now and one only has to look at their last couple of Test series which have taken place overseas.

They were beaten 1-0 by South Africa in December, 1-0 by New Zealand in January and then 3-1 by England in August. The worst part about this is that India have done nothing to rectify the fact that they constantly lose when playing in foreign conditions. Just training with the ball they will use during the series is not enough to guarantee them a win.

They have to go way beyond. For example, they might have to change some of their pitches at home to be more pace-friendly so that they master how to play fast bowling.

Futhermore, India also have to take full advantage of all the practice matches they have prior to the start of the series.

Instead of fielding a second-tier side, the national selectors should encourage all the main members of the team to participate in practice matches. It will allow the players to get accustomed to the conditions and learn what to expect from those types of pitches.

Remember what happened the last time India toured Australia in 2011-12? If you don’t, then let me refresh your memory.

India were whitewashed 4-0, but it was Australia’s dominance that captured the world’s attention. Australia captain Michael Clarke and his predecessor Ricky Ponting were run-scoring machines during that series. They amassed 626 runs at a magnificent average of 125.20 and 544 runs at an average of 108.80 respectively.

In fact, Clarke scored his career-best of 329 not-out during the second Test in Sydney. The pace duo of Ben Hilfenhaus and Peter Siddle also excelled during the series as they took 27 wickets at an average of 17.22 and 23 wickets at an average of 18.65 respectively.

Overall, it is clear that there are many reasons why India will struggle when they tour Australia in December. Not only is their team not up to scratch in all departments, but Australia have been unstoppable in the longest format of the game of late.

They whitewashed England 5-0 and even dethroned South Africa as the top-ranked Test team for a while after beating them 2-1 in March. If India bring the same kind of attitude and mindset they had during the last three Tests against England, then they will once again be manhandled and left battered and bruised at the end of yet another torturous series.

The Crowd Says:

2014-09-28T06:27:41+00:00

Broken-hearted Toy

Guest


Flatter or at least far less green pitches for starters. He'll do ok in Australia. He was the only bright spark for them on the last tour to Aus from what I remember.

2014-09-20T13:44:03+00:00

Ken

Guest


Not conditions so much - the strange Aussie selections and a cultural issue with the Coach

2014-09-19T09:37:39+00:00

Yusuf

Guest


Kohli will come back strong, he is too good not too

2014-09-19T04:26:25+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Naman Ojha should play regardless of whether he keeps or not. India desperately need to field some players who are not scarred either by their 4-0 flogging last time in Australia or their recent capitulation against England. They need some guys who will come in with a positive mindset. Ojha should have just that after absolutely slaughtering the Australia A bowlers in their home conditions recently.

2014-09-19T03:40:15+00:00

Armchair Expert

Guest


I'd still pick N.Ojah as a batsman if Dohni keeps, on that A series form.

2014-09-19T00:44:49+00:00

jammel

Guest


Agreed! My preferred three quicks to lead the dismantling process would be Harris + Johnson + Bird. Cummins and then Pattinson would be next cabs off the rank imo.

2014-09-18T14:29:31+00:00

Suneer Chowdhary

Roar Guru


Gautam Gambhir won't/shouldn't get a chance for sure, he needs to start scoring prolifically in first-class cricket in order to even have a sniff. But two wrongs won't be making a right, Sehwag's ship has also sailed as far as Test cricket is concerned (unless again, he scores runs by the tons in domestic cricket). The reason for dropping him was a correct one - he had forgotten to score and bowlers kept out-thinking him. The reason for bringing any cricketer back needs to be a combination of run-scoring/wicket-taking and a bit of gut instinct that those runs are meaningful. For now, Sehwag fulfills neither of these two criterion. This leaves India in a dicey situation and instead of going back, it will be a good time to try things out with untried ones - starting with the series against West Indies.

2014-09-18T12:13:31+00:00

nanda

Guest


Sadly Badri does not seem to be in the selectors good books. A little like Brad Hodge. Scores tons of runs in the first class level but never given a fair run. I dont think Manij Tiwary will be in the team either. He must be one of the most un lucky guys around. Just when he gets considered for selection he breaks some part of his body. He has missed the train. Cuances are they will give Dhawan 2 tests before looking at other options. Post that they may change. Also Rahane seems to be more comfortable at 5 or 6. So they have to try another full time opener. Not many on the horizon and facing Rhino and Mojo may not be on the wish list of a youngster making their debut. Also given the frailty in the bowling they may just play 5 bowlers. JADAJa will get a run although I cannot see him scoring runs in Australia.

2014-09-18T10:38:41+00:00

Jameswm

Guest


OK, no doubt there's a chance he won't be there. If they're in the process of rebuilding, what better for us to do than dismantle them?

2014-09-18T10:00:05+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Kumar was one of India's best 3-4 players against Eng there is no chance he'll be dropped. He doesn't have much pace but he's more dependable than any of the other Indian pacemen. They need at least one quick who is accurate.

AUTHOR

2014-09-18T09:29:30+00:00

Bimal Mirwani

Roar Rookie


In fact, I even wrote a piece during the India vs England Test series saying that the BCCI should drop Kohli. http://www.cricket365.com/soapbox/story/9421710/Opinion-Drop-Kohli-he-s-not-irreplaceable

2014-09-18T09:29:10+00:00

Quitwhinging

Guest


that was mainly done by very late swing, which there will be very little at the gabba unless massive humid, besides at his pace he'd just be clobbered all over the place

AUTHOR

2014-09-18T09:26:52+00:00

Bimal Mirwani

Roar Rookie


If the pitch at the Gabba will be extremely quick and offer the pace bowlers a lot of bounce, then India should be worried about a lot more than just psychological scars. Just look what Johnson has done to Ryan McLaren. He gave him a concussion during the Test series in March and a broken forearm in the recent ODI tri-series. It seems to me that the Indian batsmen are going to need a lot more protection than they normally wear.

AUTHOR

2014-09-18T09:24:07+00:00

Bimal Mirwani

Roar Rookie


I would definitely pick Aaron over Yadav because he bowls a much better line and length and does not leak runs all the time. Yadav has been given numerous opportunities, but all he ends up doing is allowing the batsmen to help themselves to boundaries, which eventually makes them a lot more confident at the crease.

AUTHOR

2014-09-18T09:20:39+00:00

Bimal Mirwani

Roar Rookie


I agree with you Ronan. If he is not showing any interest or respect towards the game, then bring in someone who will. There are plenty of talented batsmen in India who are eager to make their mark at the international level. The BCCI have to stop being scared and show Kohli that he is not untouchable. They have to send him a message that he can be dropped and will be dropped unless he performs well. If he only averages 13.40 like he did in England, then India might as well pick Sehwag because I'm quite sure that he will score more runs and end up with a better average at the end of the series, even if he is 36. The bottom line is that Kohli has to wake up and start showing a lot more passion and interest towards representing his country in the best and toughest format of the game. Otherwise he might as well retire from Test cricket and become a limited overs specialist.

2014-09-18T08:43:09+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


If Johnson bowls even 90% as well as he did against Eng and SA he will tear the series apart. The pitch for the first Test at the Gabba will be very quick as usual. He might inflict psychological scars in that first Test that will haunt the Indian batsmen from then on. India are very fortunate there is no WACA Test this summer. I think CA decided that a 3-day Test would be too costly for their coffers.

2014-09-18T08:40:51+00:00

Brains of a bimbo (Atgm)

Guest


This article dererves a read! http://www.theroar.com.au/2014/09/18/sad-farewell-young-fan/comment-page-5/#comment-3136094

2014-09-18T08:38:36+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


If a batsman fails to a historic level against pace in English conditions what would make you think that he would immediately then plunder against a dominant pace attack in Australian conditions? Strange logic atgm.

2014-09-18T08:30:52+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Atgm I said Ojha (the spinner) was a better left arm option than Jadeja, which he is. But I don't think any of their spinners will trouble the Australian batsman and at least Ashwin (who bowls as well as any of them) is also a very good Test batsman who has shown the technique to make runs against quality quicks. Rahane has played a lot of cricket as an opener at domestic level and has shown the best temperament of any of the Indian batsmen, along with Vijay and Pujara. India desperately need to have their best, most reliable batsmen at the top of the order against Australia to give themselves the best possible chance of blunting Australia's quicks.

2014-09-18T07:50:16+00:00

nanda

Guest


Rohit Sharma will probably play all the tests. We will probably see a couple of attractive 30 s or may be even a 50. But he is a guy who does no justice to his talent. I will give Sanju Samson a shot. Very good head on his shoulders and excellent temprement besidès being a good stroke player. Rest of team should do ok. Bowling will remain a challenge

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar