Did Pirelli ruin the Russian Grand Prix?

By Rodney Gordon / Expert

Lewis Hamilton led a processional Russian Grand Prix after both a new track design and uninspired tyre choices suffocated any potential for spectacle on the inaugural race weekend.

A botched over-taking attempt by teammate Nico Rosberg on the opening lap provided a rare highlight.

Carrying much more speed into the second corner, Rosberg did all the right things by ducking into Hamilton’s slipstream, using the tow to pull past him on the inside of the following corner and positioned himself beautifully to take the lead.

Or at least that would have happened if he hadn’t slammed on the breaks with both feet, sending the car into a slide that thrust him off the track and flat-spotting the tyre so badly the team decided to pull him directly into the pits without passing ‘Go’ or collecting his $200.

Now unexpectedly on the harder compound, Rosberg could run until the end, however finding himself in last place the German had to rely on a combination of brave overtaking and competitor pitstops. These allowed him to climb back into second place and complete 52 laps on the same tyres with ease, highlighting a serious organisational flaw.

Fans have called the racing dull, and it’s not just the disappointment of yet again being denied a satisfying battle for the lead to blame. Anecdotal evidence suggested that the softer compound would easily last half the race distance, suggesting to this amateur sleuth that Pirelli’s choice to bring the Soft and Medium compounds was ill-advised.

Soft and Super-soft tyres would have livened up the team strategies and spiced things up in the mid-field.

Pirelli motorsport director Paul Hembrey denied the tyre choice was to blame for the lack of action and reminded audiences that only last year the company were being blamed for drastically degrading tyres.

“I think people just have short memories, and that is one of the problems. It puts us in an impossible situation, as you can imagine,” he said.

While there were fundamental issues with the tyre compounds last year, the selection of compounds varies from race to race. In this case there were other options readily available and I can’t help but feel that Hembrey knows this all too well and, frankly, doth protest too much.

On a new track that did little to bunch up the field, offering the correct tyre options was essential. More pitstops alone would have broken up the monotony of the race. As it was all we could rely on was the occasional shot of Vladimir Putin looking uninterested, or intensely focused – I’m not sure how you tell.

Williams driver Valterri Bottas was a quiet achiever, rounding out the podium, again impressing without the blistering pace that the car teased us with during his final lap of qualifying. Were it not for some understeer in the final corner the Finn could have found himself on pole, a tantalising prospect before the race.

While Hamilton’s victory dampens Rosberg’s hopes in the drivers’ championship, their one-two finish was enough to deliver Mercedes the 2014 constructors’ championship, ending Red Bull’s reign at the top of the sport.

And while I’m all for healthy competition between the drivers, Lewis Hamilton posting a photo of Rosberg locking up while celebrating the team’s achievement was perhaps uncalled for.

The Crowd Says:

2014-10-15T04:37:00+00:00

Jawad Yaqub

Roar Guru


And that is a fair arguement about what was being said last year. Next year I guess Pirelli will have a better idea of how these new cars work with their compounds and then make changes which are appropriate.

2014-10-15T03:57:46+00:00

Distant Knight

Guest


Yeah, I agree that next year they should bring the 2 softer compounds, and they will. But I still think they made the correct decision to play it safe this year. I think the biggest factor in Pirelli going with the soft / medium combo this year was the 180 degree left hander. They were probably thinking that it was going to kill the front right tyres.

AUTHOR

2014-10-15T03:37:49+00:00

Rodney Gordon

Expert


Some are suggsting that complaining about Pirelli is hypocritical, considering they were criticised for their over-degrading tyres last year. What a load of nonsense! I'm not surprised Massa is complaining about tyres, although it is one of his favourite pasttimes....

AUTHOR

2014-10-15T03:34:56+00:00

Rodney Gordon

Expert


I'm not sying they are the devil incarnate, just that the tyres they chose were wrong - and probably played a big part in audience's dissatisfaction. I'm not sure why teams would run out of softer compound tyres and not finishing... you seem to agree though that they should change to soft and super soft for next year. So......?

2014-10-15T03:04:17+00:00

Nicholas Belardo

Roar Guru


Imagine the old regs these days: Pirelli brings two compounds, the teams are allowed to use either compound during practice, but must decide on ONE compound for both qualifying and the race, and are then limited to 6 (or maybe it was 7) sets for both qualifying and the race. To make that work though, Pirelli would need to have a very big jump between all the compounds. I also guess it worked best during the tyre-war era of Formula 1 as well.

2014-10-15T02:08:10+00:00

carnivean

Roar Rookie


Let the teams work out what they want to run on. Bring all 4, but still only allow them to use 6. Racers like Perez could run Hard for 85% of the laps and then switch to Supersoft for a blitz at the end.

2014-10-15T00:41:30+00:00

Jawad Yaqub

Roar Guru


It would be better for next year's race to have the supersofts instead of the mediums, but when you look at it from a safety point of view of course, then the reason to have conservative tyres is justified. In other news, Felipe Massa has just slammed Pirelli over their hard tyre choices for Interlagos.

2014-10-14T22:50:30+00:00

Distant Knight

Guest


Bit hard to blame Pirelli for playing it safe here isn't it? Considering that they didn't get a chance to do any sort of testing on the new circuit, I think they made the right choice of tyre compound for this year. What would be worse, a one stop race like we got, or teams running out of softer compound tyres and not finishing at all? Now that they know they can get away with the super soft / soft combo, I'm sure that's what we'll get for next year and beyond.

Read more at The Roar