Ryan Harris is Australia's Mr Irreplaceable

By Tim Holt / Roar Guru

The more I cringed at the complete and utter obliteration of the Australian team at the hands of Pakistan, the more I realised Ryan Harris is irreplaceable.

Harris is a bowling spearhead who inspires others through his leadership, as well as eclectic brilliance in all conditions.

His absence against Pakistan was profound, with a bowling unit that propelled Australia to number one in the game reduced to an embarrassing rubble, as seen in only 20 wickets in the series at an outrageous average of 76.7.

Mitchell Johnson’s devastating potential was nullified, with the Pakistani batsmen able to see him off. Onlookers might put this down to the conditions, which has a degree of justification, but the absence of Harris’ relentless pressure coupled with his lethal threat was a greater issue.

The secondary effect was the demands on others to fill the void, with Nathan Lyon the stand-out. He is very effective in his role as a situational bowler coming on with the scoreboard in his favour. But under the expectation to take a more prominent role and be a difference maker he is found wanting. Similarly Peter Siddle and the rest of the bowlers were exposed.

The more damning aspect was how a bowling unit lauded for its cohesion and tightness as a group, meekly imploded. It was if they were resigned to fate, with little or no desire to make a stand and try to turn around a raging tide. This overwhelming defeatist aura was due to the lack of Harris, the bowling unit’s leader, making them find that little extra, or at the very least show a certain pride in the baggy green through unrelenting effort, even while copping a pasting.

The big picture does not bode well for Australia in the near future – Harris is 35, with a bone china body to boot, meaning the end is nigh. When you factor in how reliant the team’s brittle batting has been on its bowling unit to carry it, it puts a direct focus on finding a replacement.

The devotees will talk up Australia’s fast bowling depth in response, and dismiss it as a non-issue. One can buy into this if all are fit and able, with James Pattinson a perfect replacement for Harris in both skill and leadership potential. Factor in Pat Cummins as his lieutenant to go with Mitchell Johnson and the stuff of cricketing wet dreams are realised.

But before one drools too much over that prospect, reality is both Pattinson and Cummins are in the treatment room more than on the ground. Even now, both have real doubt attached to their long-term Test futures.

So, who else?

Maybe Chadd Sayers, Josh Hazlewood, Nathan Coulter-Nile or Mitchell Starc? All have great potential, but no real performances to pin hopes on as difference makers. It would also be unwise to exert such an expectation on players in their infancy.

The Crowd Says:

2014-11-05T16:43:48+00:00

Abubakr Mela

Roar Rookie


scaring the bejesus out of those little Indians! - hahahaaha

2014-11-05T14:17:53+00:00

Tom from Perth

Roar Rookie


He's missing out on 2 rounds of the Shield playing the T20s. Assuming he's fit enough to play 4 days cricket. Same with Boyce.

2014-11-05T13:45:44+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


No doubt about Cummins future but he should play some Shield cricket before we vault him ahead of the 12 contenders that are already doing well.

2014-11-05T13:28:04+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


The one area we need never worry about is our quicks. Rhino was great but no less replaceable than Graham McKenzie, Dennis Lillee or Glenn McGrath. Two good years. Remember how many years he was just a good bowler at SA and Qld without being anything special? We have many that good.

2014-11-05T09:02:10+00:00

Doc Disnick

Roar Guru


The only guy more susceptible to injury was Bruce Reid. Perhaps we should sticky tape him back together as good old Billy Birmingham would say. :)

AUTHOR

2014-11-05T00:39:03+00:00

Tim Holt

Roar Guru


There is from a test point of view, due to doubts about his body standing up to its demands.

2014-11-05T00:26:37+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


As for Cummins - he's playing the T20 tonight. Not sure there are doubts about his long term future.

2014-11-05T00:25:54+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Ronan was saying yesterday that Patto is probably out for the season.

2014-11-04T22:40:33+00:00

Bucks

Guest


When is Pattinson due back?? He and NCN could be a bright future.

2014-11-04T21:21:14+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


I can't wait for the big Rhino is back this summer scaring the bejesus out of those little Indians! Let's hope he can keep on until the next Ashes and gives them another hiding! As for replacements, well I like the looks of this Rainbird character! Some people will probably say he's only pulling down trees due the advantage of bowling on the Hobart Green tops! But I think he's a hot prospect!

Read more at The Roar