The Cowboys will miss the playoffs again

By Sam Rigney / Expert

You don’t have to be glued to SportsCentre or constantly scrolling through NFL.com to know there’s been a lot of hype around the Dallas Cowboys this season.

That’s nothing unusual, of course. They are, after all, America’s team.

A recognisable brand in one of the largest markets in the US, with an often deranged, always headline grabbing, 72-year-old billionaire owner and the league’s most contrasting quarterback.

Win or lose, good or bad, you are always going to hear about the Cowboys. But this season the hype surrounding Big D has been louder than usual and primarily positive. They won six straight games to go to 6-1, before losing the next two against the Redskins and Cardinals.

The Cowboys’ season stabilised somewhat against a horrible Jaguars team in London on Sunday and they can now enjoy a bye before taking on the Giants in New York.

Their success in 2014 has been forged on the back of a surprisingly good defence, a dominant offensive line and running game and a relatively mistake-free Tony Romo.

But, despite all this, the Cowboys are destined for an unremarkable regular-season record – not much better than the 8-8 they achieved in 2011, 2012 and 2013 – and they will miss the playoffs again in 2014.

Here is why.

Romo’s niggling back injury
It wouldn’t be a promising Cowboys season without a timely injury to their star quarterback. Romo is tough, but he seems to regularly take a beating behind the line of scrimmage. He missed the loss against the Cardinals after suffering two fractures in his back against the Redskins in Week 8.

He needed a painkilling injection to return in that overtime loss and has since been trying to limit his pain and improve his function. Romo tossed three touchdowns against the Jags, but looked stiff early and unable to use his legs to extend or make plays. He missed a wide-open Jason Witten on what would have been the game’s first touchdown and looked either in pain or very ginger every time he took a hit.

Strangely, the Cowboys kept Romo in for some of the fourth quarter despite the blowout and he took his first sack. The Jags came in with 27 sacks on the season, but their pass rush was almost non-existent. Romo might struggle to stay on the field against a team that can consistently put hands on him.

The run home
The Cowboys play two pivotal games against the Eagles in a three-week span later in the season before finishing the year with tough games against the Colts at home and the Redskins away. They only play two more games at AT&T Stadium in the regular season and will have to pick up key wins on the road. Dallas is 4-0 away from home this season, but apart from the impressive 30-23 victory over the Seahawks those wins have come against teams out of playoff contention.

The Cowboys are 7-3 at present, but could easily be 9-7 by season’s end. The NFC East always seems to come down to a game between the Cowboys and Eagles and this season should be no different. While you could argue there is room for both teams in the playoffs, 10 wins might not be enough to progress in the NFC. Which brings me to my next point.

It’s crowded in the NFC
If the Eagles win the NFC East then two of the following teams miss the post-season; Green Bay, Detroit, Seattle, San Francisco, Dallas and Arizona. It’s not ridiculous to say the Cowboys could be one of those teams. The emergence of the Cardinals will hurt the Cowboys through more than just their Week 9 defeat.

The NFC West boasts three contenders and you can not rule out either the Seahawks or 49ers making a run to the playoffs and taking up one of those wildcard spots. In the NFC North, the Packers and Lions are neck-and-neck and both look like playing playoff football. I think the Cowboys need to win the division to play post-season football.

The blueprint on how to stop Murray
DeMarco Murray has had arguably the best start to a season for a running back in NFL history. He rushed for more than 100 yards in eight straight games to start the season, setting an NFL record. But against the Cardinals he managed just 79 yards. You could argue he only got 19 rushes and averaged an efficient 4.2 yards per carry, but Murray had the same amount of touches the week prior against the Redskins and rushed for 141 yards.

Murray’s limited workload in Week 9 confused a few people, who assumed with Romo out the Cowboys would rely on the run to keep back-up quarterback Brandon Weeden out of trouble. But the Cardinals loaded the box and limited Murray to 28 yards from 12 carries on first down, this made for longer second and third downs and put pressure on Weeden to move the ball down the field. The Cardinals stopped Murray from breaking out by adjusting their scheme to match the Cowboys’ talented offensive line.

After lining up in a 3-4 front for the past four years, the Cardinals switched to a primary 4-3 look and nose tackle Dan Williams and Calais Campbell dominated the league’s best offensive line. They also felt confident enough to stack the box on 39 per cent of Murray’s touches, compared to 16 per cent on the rest of the season.

If Romo spends any more time on the sideline then more teams could employ this technique and put pressure on the Cowboys to throw the ball, especially if they have adequate cover corners and safeties.

The success of an old rival
I still see the Eagles as the best team in the NFC East. They are 6-2, with their two losses coming by five points or less on the road against the Cardinals and 49ers. The Eagles might have lost Nick Foles for the majority of the season, but Mark Sanchez proved more than capable when he took over against the Texans.

Sanchez stepped in after Foles was injured in the first quarter and wound up throwing 202 yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions, including the game-clinching touchdown to Jeremy Maclin. The Eagles have a capable defence, two elusive running backs and the deep threat of Maclin. Their run home includes games against the Titans, Panthers, Redskins and Giants. They should finish with a record of 13-3 or 12-4 and that might be too many wins for the Cowboys to match.

A season-ending injury to a key member of the defence
The loss of weak side linebacker Justin Durant to a season-ending torn bicep should not be underestimated. Durant played in only six games this season, but was the Cowboys’ top tackler when he went down. He also had an interception and two forced-fumbles and had formed a good partnership with comeback kid Rolando McClain.

The Cowboys’ injury situation at linebacker has been horrible for sometime, with promising player Sean Lee tearing his ACL three times, but they did manage to have two out of the trio of Durant, McClain and Bruce Carter available for every game except one this season. That is set to change and the impact of the loss of Durant will soon be felt.

The Crowd Says:

2015-01-05T05:36:15+00:00

abe

Guest


Ok please repeat the reasons again just for the record .......i guess on the green bay

2014-12-01T04:41:57+00:00

Daniel DeLuca

Guest


I just hope that if the Cowboys do make the playoffs, that all you Cowboy haters come back on here and eat crow, but I seriously doubt you will.

AUTHOR

2014-11-12T00:49:10+00:00

Sam Rigney

Expert


You make a good point. Perhaps it should be the top six teams from each conference. That would mean horrible divisions are punished instead of rewarded and we would have a better overall playoff spectacle. Then again, like you say, we would miss out on things like Lynch's crazy run or Tebow to Demaryius Thomas for the walk-off OT touchdown against the Steelers in 2011-2012.

2014-11-11T09:58:09+00:00

Ash

Guest


Does anyone think that the playoff system is heavily flawed? I think losing teams shouldn't be permitted - although with that rule 'Beast Quake' would never have happened.

2014-11-11T08:15:39+00:00

Cameron Palmer

Roar Guru


As an NFL fan, who cannot love the theatre of another Cowboys 8-8 season. But the reality is that this is too good a football team to only win one more game this year. They actually have a pretty good record at Metlife and I think they get win number 8 this weekend. The Bears are rightly taking their place among the worst teams in football this year and Dallas should win at Solider Field too. It is almost impossible in the modern NFL which is so even to win twice in three weeks against the same opponents so I think a split with Philly is a likely outcome. That leaves 10 wins before you consider 50-50 games at home versus the Colts and away at the Redskins. Is 10-6 enough for playoffs? I say yes. The NFC has eight contenders fighting for six spots. Philly I think will win the NFC East, Green Bay and Detroit will both end up 11-5 with tiebreakers deciding the NFC North champ, Arizona will hold on for the NFC West and some woeful team will unfortunatley make playoffs by winning the NFC South. So given all that it leaves Seattle, San Francisco and Dallas fighting for the last playoff spot. Seattle still have five division games and San Francisco three division games. Those teams beat up on one another and cannot see either team winning out their division games. Hence I think you are looking at San Francisco finishing 9-7 and Seattle 10-6. Seattle 10-6 versus Dallas 10-6... Who would have thunk it, but Dallas going into Seattle and conquering the 12th man is your most important non-divisional NFC match of the season. Arizona 12-4 Philly 12-4 Detroit 11-5 New Orleans 8-8 Green Bay 11-5 Dallas 10-6 Seattle 10-6 San Francisco 9-7

AUTHOR

2014-11-11T03:56:37+00:00

Sam Rigney

Expert


Correct, Chop. Who cares if Foles is healthy, as long as "Big Daddy" Sproles plays the Eagles should be sweet. I'm being flippant, of course.

2014-11-11T02:36:40+00:00

Chop

Roar Guru


He's certainly doing ok right now against Carolina....

AUTHOR

2014-11-11T01:42:07+00:00

Sam Rigney

Expert


Thanks Pete. I hope Sanchez atones for his earlier sins. Eagles defense is better than people think, too. As for the quarterback circle of life - Foles replaced Vick, Vick replaced Geno, Geno replaced Sanzhez, Sanchez replaced Foles, Foles replaced....

AUTHOR

2014-11-11T00:47:35+00:00

Sam Rigney

Expert


But the NRL and the refs will rob them!! #allSydneyGrandFinal

2014-11-11T00:43:45+00:00

PGNEWC

Guest


"The Cowboys will miss the playoffs again" Nuh Thurston will make sure they're in the Semis again :-)

2014-11-11T00:35:58+00:00

Andrew Kitchener

Roar Guru


"often deranged, always headline grabbing" best description of Jerry Jones I've read in a while. As a bitter Giants fan, I hope the Cowboys implode :)

AUTHOR

2014-11-11T00:13:20+00:00

Sam Rigney

Expert


Hey Philipp. Appreciate it. The Cardinals secondary is not that good, in fact I had Cromartie as one of my free agent busts of the year in a piece that is yet to be published. Because their run defense is so good, the Cards opponents prefer to target them through the air. There is a story here from mid-October about Peterson and Cromartie's struggles. I was surprised pretty surprised to read it. http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000412210/article/patrick-peterson-admits-he-must-play-better

2014-11-10T23:38:09+00:00

Pete McAloney

Roar Pro


Well done Sam, a well measured response to a very rude and patronising comment. My initial thought reading your article was that you were exaggerating the abilities of the Eagles but you are right about Chip Kelly, and the Cowboys have a solid history of imploding. After the crazy times at the Jets I really hope Sanchez comes good. It's ironic that he's at the Eagles and leading the team, while Vick now seems to have taken the helm at the Jets! Ha.

2014-11-10T23:37:32+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


Sam is right, the Cows have got off to good starts in previous years only to implode in the second half of the season. I guess the difference this year is a much improved 0 line and running game. It will be interesting to see if Sanchez and Stanton can keep the respective ship's sailing. The Seahawks have regained there mojo and will challenge the Cards for the division.

2014-11-10T23:00:57+00:00

Philipp

Roar Rookie


first, I really enjoy reading your pieces, even if I dont always agree. I just want to add that using the Cardinals tactics as a blueprint to stop the Cowboys rushing game is hardly possible for most Teams because most teams dont have such a talented secondary like the Cardinals. Players like Peterson Cromartie or Mathieu can handle even top receivers on their own while lesser defensive backs might need help. The Presence of Dez Bryant and Jason Witten prevents most teams from committing too much defenders against the run. They dont want their defensive backs 1 on 1 against a guy like Bryant. the Cardinals secondary is a big part of their success. I'm not sure if the Cowboys will reallly miss the playoffs. A lot will depend on how the Cards and Eagles deal with the Injuries to Palmer and Foles. I think that if the Cowboys Defense keeps playing reasonably well they could make it.

AUTHOR

2014-11-10T22:12:44+00:00

Sam Rigney

Expert


Nah, the Giants aren't going to make any noise. But I do think the Cowboys could lose to the Eagles (at least once), Colts and Redskins. That's a finish of 9-7 or 10-6 and will not be enough to win the division. The Cowboys have been in good positions before at the mid-point of the season and found a way to through it all away. It wouldn't be the biggest surprise if they did it again.

AUTHOR

2014-11-10T21:35:53+00:00

Sam Rigney

Expert


Oh, a Cowboys fan. I must say I wholeheartedly disagree, sir. Was it luck when the Eagles beat the Giants 27-0? Or when they came back against the Colts in Indy in Week 2? What about when they lost their starting quarterback to a broken clavicle after one quarter in Houston? Now that was really lucky. The good luck literally started when Foles went down. It's fortunate they have a decent back-up quarterback to take over under centre. I would argue they have a better shot than the Cardinals do now without Palmer or the Cowboys would if Romo goes down again. The Eagles will win the NFC East because Chip Kelly is a great head coach and a true offensive guru. He will maximize the talent of Mark Sanchez. Sanchez is blessed with an abundance of playmakers in Philadelphia; LeSean McCoy, Jeremy Maclin, Darren Sproles, Jordan Matthews and the Eagles' tight ends are legit weapons that keep defensive coordinators up at night.

2014-11-10T20:52:06+00:00

julio

Guest


You really think the cowboys could lose the next 6 games.... . Next youll be saying the giants will be making a run for the playoffs...

2014-11-10T20:28:41+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


The NFC is indeed very crowded, I can see the West and North getting two teams in while the East getting the one along with the worst division in a football, the south with the other. The Saints at 4-5 lead the division ?

2014-11-10T18:18:38+00:00

Clancy

Guest


It's cute how you believe you understand the game. Even before Nick Foles went down, the Shegles were exposed. They've won mostly by luck, so far, and that luck just ended with Foles' injury. Sanchez can't sustain the one good game he's had so far. Predicting 12 or 13 wins for this team is the best joke I've heard this week. Now with Palmer out for the year, Arizona is likely to begin a downward spiral that will find them on the outside looking in come playoff time. Dallas (as you say, as long as Romo is healthy) should see a season that ends with them in the playoffs at 10-6, or in the third seed at 11-5. I wouldn't put it past them to go even 12-4, but I'm not going to predict that as a lock. If they manage the 3rd seed, then they should get a win in the first round. After that, anything is possible. Murray won't get the record this year, but he might break 2000 yards, and Bryant will have the Cowboy's record for most touchdown catches in a season. McClain will win comeback player of the year.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar