Dodgy DRS doings arrive right on time for World Cup

By Dane Eldridge / Expert

Sri Lanka were fleeced by modernity in Dunedin on Sunday when shonky circuitry caused the Decision Review System to crap out when needed most, thus returning the topic to conversation with perfect timing right before the game’s grandstand event.

In the fourth over of the sixth Generic Trophy ODI, the hustling Dhammika Prasad trapped Martin Guptill flush in front with an LBW shout acknowledged all over the universe as glacially DOA.

However, despite having the best seat in the house, umpire Derek Walker was seemingly elsewhere in said universe at the time of questioning, possibly peering deep in to the Milky Way for comets and front-foot no-balls when he should’ve been looking up.

This daydreaming left him without evidence to arbitrate the elementary claim, so he played it safe with a negatory based on the doubt surrounding exactly which stump the bullseye-tracker was going to snap clean in half.

Sensing the knockback was a monstrosity typical of the role that the review system was born to play, an audit was immediately demanded by a frantic Prasad – a man who’d already given a snap-birth to kittens upon disapproval before dancing down the pitch like a TV evangelist.

Like Prasad, we home viewers acknowledged too that it was a scrapbook clanger, yet relaxed when remembering that we live in heady times flush with innovative smart people unaffiliated with the BCCI. Yes, the DRS would fix his mess.

However, it was not to be – unfathomably, the system was on the blink at Prasad’s end of the ground, even despite reinstalling the app and calling IT.

The bad news was confirmed mid-chaos with Walker’s whisper that ‘DRS is down’, an approval of shambles delivered in the kind of low tone usually saved for a suspect who’s hiding under their bed from the Feds.

In a further bizarre turn of events, abstruse skipper Lahiru Thirimanne was apparently already hip to the Reject Shop electronics on hand, and he confirmed the bombshell to the flustered quick in the middle of the team going mental.

Like a man suspecting of his own Candid Camera punking, an already-crazed Prasad assumed the fluid was being taken and naturally cracked it. He was partnered in this cracking by the legendary Mahela Jayawardene, who was heard on the stump mics remarking accurately that the whole thing was “crap”.

After the dust settled, the cold transparency of the replay confirmed the moment for what it was: an unaccountable balls-up the kind for which 25th year public servants are renowned.

And to make it worse, once the thing was rebooted and operational, an opportunity for equal footing was dismissed. Instead of writing it off for the game, New Zealand were given full rights to the tool when they were in the field.

It was crook, and nobody would’ve begrudged Sri Lanka for goin’ right orrrrfff. Luckily the ripples went nowhere and they ended up getting pumped.

Overall, knickers are not to be knotted. This is more a storm in a teacup than a precursor to six weeks of big stage brainfarts. However, it was an ill-timed oddball that could’ve been done without, especially considering the guys paying for the whole shebang hate the thing.

On the eve of international cricket’s prom night, a time where everything’s usually so steady and polished, this was a televisual tits-up reminiscent of an NRL video referee, an AFL goal review, or even worse, the fake baby in American Sniper.

Best be keeping these bloopers for the cutting room floor when the production goes live.

The Crowd Says:

2015-01-27T03:12:00+00:00

Cantab

Guest


Obviously a bulls up, but goes to show how important the DRS is. The number 1 focus needs to be making sure that this technology error doesn't happen again.

2015-01-27T01:51:47+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


I've got an idea..... We have penguins standing at each end looking like right old geezers dressed up in bowling hats with no where to go..... How about we use them for something other than store mannequins like we have since 1844? Otherwise just stick Joe the Cameraman at each end and let him commentate "Scott Muller" style!

AUTHOR

2015-01-27T01:11:17+00:00

Dane Eldridge

Expert


Sure is, Ray.

2015-01-27T00:03:26+00:00

Ray Bullock

Guest


Is the DRS operating in the WC?

AUTHOR

2015-01-26T21:04:56+00:00

Dane Eldridge

Expert


That kinda foresight will get you a high-ranking executive role at NZC. Keep it up!

2015-01-26T18:08:45+00:00

Targa

Guest


What makes it worse is that apparently the ball-tracking was still working and could've been used: http://www.odt.co.nz/sport/cricket/331177/graphics-would-have-upheld-review

2015-01-26T10:02:25+00:00

Targa

Guest


Nah, we (NZ) should've saved our 'DRS malfunction card' for a WC quarter or semifinal. Maybe get AB DeVilliers sawn off and then tell him he can't use a review - c'mon NZ cricket, get with the programme! In all seriousness it was a bad look for the game, and shouldn't have happened. On a brighter note, how good are Williamson, Anderson and Ronchi? I reckon Corey Anderson will be a good call for player of the World Cup

2015-01-26T09:13:44+00:00

Hayley

Guest


Id also like to point out if they just scraped it for the entire game then Jayarwardene would have been given out earlier and Sri Lanka would probably have had an even shorter innings.

AUTHOR

2015-01-26T08:22:35+00:00

Dane Eldridge

Expert


I just reckon if it can't be given equal use by both teams, then it seems unfair to continue using it, even though it was only on the blink for a small window of time. Perhaps a closer match or a bigger contribution from Guptill may have caused more significance. However, as per usual, there's valid points made by The Roardom that are making me think! And no, I'm not a genius, and I may be a BCCI official, pending a criminal check and a funds transfer.

2015-01-26T08:01:45+00:00

Bobbo7

Guest


Fair point Dane. Australia needs more mountains!

2015-01-26T06:48:39+00:00

Sylvester

Guest


If SL were upset with that decision, they certainly wouldn't have been impressed had Guptill gotten his second reprieve because they decided to leave DRS off for the whole game.

2015-01-26T06:46:32+00:00

Sylvester

Guest


Keeping Guptill out there actually benefitted SL. I'm surprised they even wanted to review... Simon Doull in the Sky commentary team kept going on like it was the biggest travesty in the history of sport until some wiser heads, aka Mark Richardson, reminded us all that we coped without DRS for more than 100 years without the sky falling down.

2015-01-26T05:59:11+00:00

Clark

Guest


It was off for 13 overs. And it was just the front facing camera so they could have still used it for caught behinds (in theory)

2015-01-26T05:45:08+00:00

bigmick1

Guest


Maybe not allowing a NZ review, for a period of time, would be fair. Maybe. But switching it off? What are you, a BCCI director, or similar genius? How would that be fair to SL?

2015-01-26T03:31:11+00:00

Nick

Guest


Yeah that was the concensus from the Nz commentators too. They mentioned though that ICC rules state that once it's back on, its used

AUTHOR

2015-01-26T01:04:26+00:00

Dane Eldridge

Expert


Good point Bobbo, SL's shortcomings are concerning. But for a larf, let's just make a mountain out of a molehill anyway.

AUTHOR

2015-01-26T01:02:08+00:00

Dane Eldridge

Expert


This is true. But after a blatant shafting, they should've just switched the thing off for the rest of the game, just to avoid hassles in the event of a tight one. That's my two bob anyway.

2015-01-25T23:30:11+00:00

Bobbo7

Guest


Sometimes technology fails and it was only off for a bit. Guptill made 28 and SL lost by over 100 runs. Think SL have far bigger issues than DRS not working at one end for half an hour.

2015-01-25T20:25:10+00:00

Nick

Guest


It was on for the vast majority of NZs innings.

Read more at The Roar