The NRL is broken, so it's time for drastic change

By Alex Green / Roar Guru

After two rounds of the 2015 NRL season, rugby league is clearly in trouble.

With a terrible on-field product, the NRL’s finances in a deep hole, a mass player exodus and crowds and television viewers down, there needs to be some changes if the code is going to survive into the next year.

We must take action. Here are some proposed rule changes that would enhance the greatest game of all.

Unlimited tackle count
All these tries from kicks are getting boring! Remove the dull five hit ups then a bomb by giving teams all the tackles they want in their attempt to get up the field and score a good old fashioned, through-the-hands, four pointer. Or a penalty goal if the opportunity arises. Oh, hang on…

No offside
The structure of the game is making it too good a television product and it’s having a negative impact on crowds. We aren’t using enough of the field to make seeing the game at the ground trump watching it on the box.

We need to combat the AFL in the fight for bums on seats damn it. Let’s open up the entire field by removing the need to be behind the player with the ball. Bring Israel Folau and Karmichael Hunt back to the game, give the middle finger to the AFL by stealing Buddy Franklin and Gary Ablett, and embrace their skills by letting them stand 40 metres downfield and let the ball be kicked to them.

Add a stipulation that you can’t score a try from such a ‘kick pass’ and presto, the crowds will flock back to the stadiums.

Allow forward passes
While we’re at it, let’s encourage more try scoring opportunities and get on the front foot against the NFL stealing all our superstars by letting teams score by throwing the ball forward.

We can then have a hybrid international game against the Americans, boosting the profile of the newly named NF(r)L (National Football Rugby League). Jarryd Hayne can return to the Eels with his new skills and be even more of a celebrity, boosting his ego to a level he finds satisfying enough to keep him in the game.

Unlimited bench and interchange
We need to speed up the play as much as possible, because as that fantastic season of Super League taught us, the faster the game the better. Obviously the only way to do this is by eliminating the wrestle through the refereeing interpretation of the ruck, as we know fatigue has no place in the modern game – players not getting set for defence or missing tackles creates a lacklustre spectacle.

Allow a team to bring on as many fresh players, as often as they like, to ensure no player is forced to play more than two minutes and risk missing a tackle that might result in a, *gasp*, try.

Height and weight restrictions
The fans don’t want to see skills or, god help us, a small and nimble man taking advantage of tiring forwards to make a break. They want to see big bodies running into each other. To totally eradicate the un-entertaining little guy from the game, let’s add a rule that stipulates all players must be over six foot in height, and weigh in at over 100 kilograms. That way, the game can evolve to the point that every team is made up of back rowers, as we all know that would provide the best entertainment.

Outlaw the tackle
The game is getting too violent, way more than back in the 1970s and ’80s, so we need to think of the mum’s and kids. Any physical attempt to stop the attacking team that is considered a ‘tackle’ is prohibited and will result in an immediate send off and life ban.

Defending players must stop the opposition by touching their belly button, getting in their way, putting them off their game with sledging, pre-approved by the NSIU (NRL Sledging Integrity Unit) of course, or forcing a knock-on by tickling them.

Open the war chest to keep the stars
Hundreds of our best players are leaving the code to go and play rugby, AFL, NFL, football and hockey in what can only be described as a mass exodus. Don’t let the small number of players leaving since Wendell Sailor and co. made the switch fool you, the three superstars that left at the end of last season are definitive proof it’s becoming an epidemic.

It’s a #crisis you fools. We have to do something about it, as obviously there is never any young talent coming through, and we’ll be left with teams full of players like Beaver Menzies and Freddy Fittler. Use the discretionary funds Mr Smith, I beg you, so that every time any representative player comes off contract their agent can spruik offers from rival codes and we can pay them well over the top to keep them in the game.

Ditch the cap
And speaking of player wages, get rid of the salary cap. It’s broken, so let’s just scrap it altogether. Let clubs pay players what they want, then use the discretionary funds to keep the best players in the game and playing for only those rich clubs who could afford them in the first place.

If clubs can’t afford players and go broke, leaving just a few wealthy Sydney teams plus the Broncos, then perfect, a more streamlined comp. And supporters from the other teams will definitely support another team they previously hated anyway.

Dessie as referees boss
The referees are not a problem, they are the lifeblood of the game and need protection. Dump Tony Archer and appoint Des Hassler as the referees boss. Let him have a press conference after every game to use his wit and guile to abuse coaches and players for every stuff-up, turning the tables so their performances are the ones dissected and cross examined to the nth degree.

The result will be that players and coaches are crucified for every knock-on, forward pass, poor set move or unsuccessful game plan, putting the pressure back on them to be held accountable for results of games.

Hadley for NSW Origin
Pick Ray Hadley in the front row for the NSW Origin team. Let him bask in the glory of being called upon as the saviour of his state, let him talk up his skills from playing in the Under-10 Bs, hell, even make him captain-coach to entice him to play. Hopefully after one hit up, we never, ever have to hear him comment on the game again.

Rothfield to run the game
Replace Dave Smith with Phil Rothfield, a man who clearly has the vision, strategy, and credentials, but more importantly is composed, calm and rationale in the face of a scandal. Phil has all the answers and only he can take the game to the next level. He will also have the NRL media at his disposal to sprout his wise words of wisdom to the masses.

Roarers, what other changes are required to pull our beloved game out of the dark depths of despair it is currently in?

The Crowd Says:

2015-03-20T12:05:48+00:00

Birdy

Guest


Matth, you can't have unlimited tackle unless we have competitive scrums. The only way we can have competitive scrums in the short term is to bring on RU forwards just for the scrums and bring straight off before the crowd falls to sleep. ( sorry rah rahs just having fun ) Also I agree with your prediction for the dragons but the tigers will take out the trophy this year. This week they will put 20 points on the bunnies to announce their arrival.

2015-03-20T03:10:50+00:00

Johnno

Guest


What rule changes your proposing, sound like AFL lol.

2015-03-20T03:03:35+00:00

matth

Guest


I am shocked and horrified at how many posters could not tell this was a comedy article. Crowds are down!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Might just be luck of the draw up to this point, anyone thought of that. Maybe we need more entertainment - all half time entertainment to be arranged by Todd Carney and Joel Monaghan. On a serious note it would be great to see a heritage round where the teams play unlimited tackle with the 5 metre rule. Maybe as a pre-season thing or if the Tigers and Dragons are out of top 8 contention (like by round 4) they could stage their next scheduled meeting at the SCG.

2015-03-19T07:37:32+00:00

Kirk

Guest


Im not 100% sure why the roar visitors are down so far this year... Is it the economy being a bit flat? I dont think so as the roar costs nothing to use, except a miniscule amount of data the roar must do some market research. I suspect we have multiple causes. 1. Poorly thought out articles 2. The same tired rugby league articles again and again RE: how to fix the NRL, why are NRL crowds so low, why are people turning away from NRL etc etc 3. The very obvious pro rugby union, anti League agenda of the site 4. Mainstream doesn't care a hoot about rugby union and is following league in other ways.

2015-03-19T07:22:09+00:00

Paneer

Guest


Im not 100% sure why NRL crowds are down so far this year. Its a worry frankly. Is it the economy being a bit flat? I dont think so as NRL tix can be acquired quite cheaply if u sign up as a member. the NRL must do some market research. I suspect we have multiple causes. 1. Losing Hayne, SBW and Burgess. This inadvertently tells the market that the NRL isnt the pinnacle of football. 2. Drugs controversy with the GC players 3. Oversupply of football. Drop the WCC and Auckland slap n tickle! 4. Constantly changing lineups and uniforms - my Raiders never look the same for 2 years in a row in terms of squad nor jersey. 5. Competition from the A League and AFL. 6. Neck tatts and poor English. NRL players dont match the average man in the street anymore. The average Sydneysider is a white collar worker who probably went to uni or TAFE at least. 7. Todd Carney

2015-03-19T04:25:51+00:00

Kirk

Guest


hilarious, its like saying coca cola needs to remove the sugar and change its flavor to root beer or something.

2015-03-19T02:12:34+00:00

clipper

Guest


Crowds were down 0.2% H & A while the population keeps increasing. Don't think many of the anti comments actually read the article or saw the HA tag, Alex!

AUTHOR

2015-03-18T21:11:32+00:00

Alex Green

Roar Guru


The dives are hilarious though! Maybe the NRL could bring in the comedy factor by encouraging them?

AUTHOR

2015-03-18T21:05:54+00:00

Alex Green

Roar Guru


Brilliant! Another - Bennett is on the committee that brings in the rule. Then Broncos v Knights in round 26, fighting it out to avoid the spoon. Broncos clearly score in the 79th minute to win the game, but upon referral Stone calmly hits the red button, handing Bennett the spoon, who then complains that rule changes are ruining the game.

2015-03-18T11:29:55+00:00

Twatter

Guest


Finally someone has pointed out that the king has no clothes. A smart move would be to bring it back closer to union laws. Keep 13 players but bring in the rest.

2015-03-18T10:06:58+00:00

Muzz

Guest


What do you mean? : )

2015-03-18T10:02:44+00:00

Patrick Effeney

Editor


Whoosh for some. A good laugh for others.

2015-03-18T09:33:53+00:00

Tom

Guest


NRL survive??? The NRL had its biggest year in 2014 and the comp has continued to improve every year. Stop trying to spread ridiculous anti league propaganda....

2015-03-18T08:01:49+00:00

John Hamilton

Roar Pro


I love the idea of Des Hasler being referees boss. I would pay admission to see him at the press conferences

2015-03-18T05:46:51+00:00

Martyn50

Guest


Great humour. Try the same type of article with the soccer crew and see what reaction you would get. Like ah don't mess with a game that has not changed in 150 years and doesn't want to move with the times. That is why soccer is so boring.

2015-03-18T05:06:13+00:00

Rob

Guest


Ha alex nice gee up. Have you been hanging out with the Gold Coast Titans lately?

2015-03-18T05:03:34+00:00

Jara W

Guest


In my perfect world scenario: Tooves rules out a Bulldogs try due to a conspicuous obstruction. Manly win by 2. Des is granted permission to run all post match interviews. It would be the stuff of legend!!

2015-03-18T04:44:52+00:00

bigbaz

Roar Guru


and the 3 yard rule.

AUTHOR

2015-03-18T04:34:44+00:00

Alex Green

Roar Guru


The perfect solution Jara! It would provide exceptional theatre too. Imagine a coach's credibility hanging onto pressing the green or red button on a clear try in the 79th minute to seal up the game for the opposition, it would be riveting!

2015-03-18T04:24:09+00:00

Birdy

Guest


Yep that's a like

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar