The new Benji is better than the old Benji

By Dane Eldridge / Expert

Even after belting the Roosters around the inside of an esky on Saturday, this Dragons winning streak is still only causing a mild commotion in league circles rather than the wild premiership countdown with tequila shots that it deserves.

Nobody is quite prepared to brand them as fair dinkum top-four material quite yet, concerned that this six-week run is a freak incident ready to fizzle to an anti-climactic 10th place finish and a panicked kneejerk push to reinstate Brian Smith.

In light of this rational circumspection, I feel a responsibility to give St George Illawarra what they’ve earned: a deserved April premiership. So standby as I talk them up, hence sending their chances before a black cat and under a ladder.

In all seriousness, it must be acknowledged that the 2015 Saints are a new-look outfit that is nothing like the bunch of impotent pacifists of recent years, and I say good on ’em.

Their fresh makeover is built on a defence that is hungrier than a catwalk model, and it’s sending wild their hordes of unwavering, rusted-on, dyed-in-the-wool fans who’ve always kept the faith despite planning a revolt only weeks ago.

So who’s the catalyst for this unexpected revival in fortunes?

Many of their faithful have narrowed it down to three candidates: Paul McGregor, Benji Marshall and anyone else as long as it’s not Peter Doust.

Much has been documented about the chrome-dome coach and how he’s so loaded he doesn’t even need the job, so I’m here to make mention of the fine work of Marshall, rugby league’s latest recycled rugby reject reborn.

Painfully obvious scoop alert: Marshall 2.0 is totally unlike the mid-noughties garden variety Benji.

Gone is the wet-haired OzTag rake who’s idea of a safety-first pass was one that only cut-out three blokes, and in his place is a team-first percentage player who’s the boring and safe type you take home to meet mumma.

I know I’m going to be labelled a cardigan-wearer for saying this, but despite all of the jaw-dropping moments from his former self, the marketable highlight reel allure and that sensational fairytale premiership, I’ve got to say I like the new Marshall better than the old.

Now just before you launch, no, I am not a stiff who is completely devoid of life. Like the everyman, I receive thrills from an acrobatic side-step. A good chip and chase arouses me. After all, I do live and breathe.

I was enthralled by the Marshall flick passes, the trick shots and the no-look triple-pump passes to the bloke in the third row. I’ll never forget the day he lined up every Sharks player and beat them all one-on-one like Bruce Lee doing over a ninja convention, mainly because I stuck forks in my eyes out of pure disbelief and the pain afterwards was unspeakable.

Old Marshall was the original selfie-generation footballer; it never really happened unless there was flash. He was so slick, Weeties nearly became a thing in Australasia just so his face could be splashed across the packaging (possibly untrue).

He was ahead of his time in showtime, but he was also ahead in coach-killing. While always capable of pulling something out of his arse, he is also responsible for too many holes through fibro, and this is why his reincarnate shades him.

Rocks and diamonds gambling began dying in footy long ago. That’s why the chunkier, less whippy and more prudish bloke who came home from the Auckland Blues with his tail between his legs and humbly inserted himself in to a team-orientated game plan is what I’ll take 11 times out of 10.

While he won’t single-handedly win games and spike sales in jerseys and overpriced footy cards, he will play to orders, kick for touch and tackle. I don’t know about you, but that’s the way I like my ball-handlers – steady, gentle and reliable, and always prepared to implement instructions and share with Gareth Widdop.

The new Marshall guarantees a solid 6.5/10 performance every time, and that’s what the ultra-restrained environment of modern league demands.

Nothing selfish, nothing flashy, just meet those KPIs. Plus take a load off my vital signs. That’s the Benji I prefer.

Now turn down that music and pour me a Bex, it’s past 6pm.

The Crowd Says:

2015-04-29T11:58:44+00:00

Jeff

Guest


Yes , Walter I can. I`m glad you do as well.

2015-04-29T10:19:25+00:00

CW

Guest


Spot on Jim. A 50 year Dragon fan and I am starting to believe. Paul McGregor is the catalyst for the remarkable turn around of this club. He is making this misfit bunch believe in themselves. He even has Benji playing some decent footy. He was dreadful last year trying to find his feet and get something working with Gareth Widdop. The last three games I have seen some of the old Benji magic. Less passes a half a metre above or at the knee of a player and his defense even has some starch in it. Benji has always been an ad lib player who can produce some wonderful plays and not so wonderful plays. I would like him run more than he does. Still has a bit of toe. Widdop is, imo, the superior structured play organiser of the attack. Once Benji and Gareth gel to really get this attack moving I expect lots of points by the boys.

2015-04-29T08:53:48+00:00

Ryan O'Connell

Expert


I actually tend to agree, mate. Good piece.

2015-04-29T06:17:18+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I agree. I wonder how good he could have been if he'd encountered a coach like mcgregor earlier in his career to temper his brilliance with control and good game management.

2015-04-29T05:06:18+00:00

Jim

Guest


The 'i know what i'm doing on the 5th tackle, but do you?' will always be part of Benji's game, and a big reason why Benji is Benji. As a dragons fan, I thought he was beyond dreadful last year and didn't hold out a lot of hope for an improvement this year. But he is gradually finding a nice niche alongside Widdop, where they share duties as apporpirate, and neither are trying to really dominate the play all the time. I agree with when you say he is slower, so it is better - he is maybe showing signs of developing into that more 'masterful' style half that the very best do as they get older. Good to see him having a good run, as even at the tigers, I always enjoyed watching him play one way or another.

2015-04-29T03:54:01+00:00

spruce moose

Guest


He's slower. It's better. It gives him more time to think, and his teammates more time to prepare. he's still a bit prone to the whole "I know what I'm doing on the 5th tackle, but do you?" thing, but on the whole I agree. Benji 2.0 is much better.

2015-04-28T23:28:37+00:00

Eden

Guest


His kicking game was most impressive on Saturday. He made Tuivasa Sheck look like an amateur full back, always out of position and chasing every kick back into the in goal. Also I think he has a few interesting backline moves which he and Widdop are perfecting. Some slick runarounds and decoy movements that are refreshing to see in this era of second man; second man.

2015-04-28T23:05:37+00:00

matth

Guest


Reminds me of Steve Mortimer. In the early days it was all about the speed and flash, the chip and chase, the dash from the scrum base. In later years it was will power and strategy. The later years were when he captained the Blues to State of Origin glory.

2015-04-28T23:03:59+00:00

matth

Guest


I was thinking the new Phil Blake

2015-04-28T22:57:05+00:00

MAX

Guest


Benji is the tideturner StG - I. needed. He has come the full 360.

2015-04-28T22:44:50+00:00

Steve

Guest


He did speak recently about the different weight training he did at the blues. -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2015-04-28T22:41:42+00:00

Targa

Guest


So John Kirwan achieved something! Still can't believe he let Fekitoa go! PS I don't think he was chunkier when came back from union - he was 10kgs overweight when he turned up at the Blues from Tigers reserve grade

2015-04-28T22:14:05+00:00

Crashy

Guest


His time in rugby ensured he came back a better player. -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2015-04-28T21:39:08+00:00

Walter Penninger

Roar Guru


The new Billy Smith if anyone remembers Billy.

2015-04-28T21:34:47+00:00

Kirk

Guest


Benji will probably go down as the greatest youtube player ever.

2015-04-28T19:40:32+00:00

Walter Penninger

Roar Guru


I am a believer. Benji, is worth every dollar. He has brought the team a new confidence which money cannot buy. This is now a team that works in defence in confidence that Benji will deliver in attack and the attack was starting to get together against the Roosters. Going into the game against the Rabbittohs I have every confidence that they can win, which is a rare condition for a Dragons supporter.

2015-04-28T17:31:49+00:00

Russell Johnson

Guest


"The new Benji is better than the old Benji" Obviously like all players who spent time kicking for claps among the Vichies are far better players and much more skilfull and often a wee bit faster because of the much more demanding game across the Rubicon! :-)

Read more at The Roar