Finals sides make for better Friday nights and other observations from Round 7

By Josh / Expert

Finals sides make for entertaining Fridays

This will probably come as a shock to whoever designed the AFL’s fixture this year but Friday night footy is a lot more entertaining when you put two teams worth watching on it.

This was the first Friday night game of the year to feature two of last year’s finalists and not coincidentally it was the best watching of any Friday-nighter so far.

In case you haven’t been watching – and who could blame you – the Friday night time slot has been a wasteland so far in 2015. In the five Friday night games prior to this one, we’ve seen an average margin of 58 points – that’s almost a ten goal thrashing on average each week.

North Melbourne’s 11-point win over Essendon broke the trend – not only was it a tight finish but it was great viewing, with a handful of high-flying marks and more than a few moments of drama breaking out during what was generally a close-fought game.

Don’t worry, it’s not about to become a trend. In the remaining fifteen Friday night games left on the fixture before Round 23, we have only six more clashes that exclusively feature the finals sides of 2014.

And to give you something to really look forward to, the next two Friday night matches both feature Carlton, who have lost by margins of 69 and 75 in their two Friday games so far.

I can understand from a financial point of view why the AFL centres the fixture around the teams that draw the biggest numbers, but surely at this point even the Blues fans themselves would rather watch two quality neutral teams go at it than a pair of near-inevitable spankings at the hands of Geelong and Sydney.

Jack Ziebell could be North’s superstar

Probably one of the most regular criticisms going around regarding North’s flag chances in the off-season was the suggestion that the side lacks any genuine ‘A-grade’ or ‘superstar’ players.

While I find such arguments a bit semantic, it is a fact that the Kangaroos were the only finals side last year not to have a player in the All Australian squad.

Whether you think they’re lacking one or not, North might have found their next superstar player in Jack Ziebell. The midfielder has long shown flashes of brilliance but has also had his fair share of setbacks – a couple of broken legs, a couple of lengthy suspensions, and a bung shoulder for most of 2014.

His 29-possession, 11-clearance, 2-goal performance on Friday night capped off what has been a strong month of form, made all the more impressive by the fact that at the start of the month, he was lying in a hospital bed, bleeding from his lungs.

Sure, as a North fan I’m prone to a bit of optimism, but if Jack keeps putting together performances like this, the recognition can’t be too far away.

Jack Watts needs a change

The only thing surprising about seeing Jack Watts dropped from Melbourne’s side this week was how long it has taken the Dees to make the call.

Of course, even that was altered a bit by the claims after the fact from Paul Roos that it was Watts himself who had decided that he needed to return to VFL level to build form.

When Roos first arrived as Melbourne’s senior coach, Watts was facing a tricky decision – pursue a trade to a rival club, or re-sign with the struggling Demons.

Watts eventually decided to stick with Dees, in no small part due to the influence of Roos, and while a lot has gone right for Melbourne in the time since then, this hasn’t.

The number one pick of a highly talented 2008 draft, Watts has never really been at the standard of many of the players picked after him. But the trouble for him isn’t that he’s failed to become elite. It’s that he’s failed to even become average.

The last chance for him I think to become a quality player is to switch clubs and see what a change of pace can do for him. It’s a chance he probably should’ve taken eighteen months ago, but it’s not too late to take the leap.

Mick Malthouse is done at Carlton

You can probably mark down this weekend as the time Mick Malthouse’s career at Carlton ended. That’s not to say that he’ll get the sack this week, he almost certainly won’t, but I think we’ve officially gone past the point where there’s any chance he’ll still be at the club in 2016.

For me this has a similar feel to the Mark Neeld saga of 2013. From about Round 2 onwards it was well and truly clear that Neeld’s time as Melbourne’s senior coach was going to come to an end sooner or later, and it simply became a matter of when the axe would fall.

Like Neeld, Malthouse’s eventual departure from the Blues at some point this year now has a sense of inevitability about it. The success they were hoping for when he was first appointed has not materialised, and it’s becoming pretty clear he is not the man they want to back in for what will need to be a long and patient rebuild.

So when will it happen? Carlton president Mark LoGiudice has repeatedly said that Mick is safe for the rest of the season, which is a very political way of saying “I’m going to sack you at the end of the season.”

Of course, that doesn’t technically stop them officially announcing mid-year that they won’t renew his contract, which historically has seen most coaches immediately resign.

The Crowd Says:

2015-05-19T06:38:46+00:00

Brian

Guest


Its a good point. Geelong v Collingwood & Essendon v Hawthorn are 2 fixtures which probably draw bigger crowds then Carlton. I think Carlton v Essendon drew a lot less then those other 2 games this year

2015-05-18T07:29:09+00:00

AR

Guest


It's an absolute shocker for the AFL. It obviously hoped that a) Carlton would get better; and b) it would provide blockbuster matches on Fridays involving traditional Victorian rivalries. 17k Carlton fans turned up to watch the GWS game.

2015-05-18T05:57:59+00:00

andyl12

Guest


I would go one step further and end the tradition of Carlton, Collingwood and Essendon always meeting each other twice- at least at times when one of them is playing bad football. Otherwise the AFL are basically saying to the Western Bulldogs "No matter how well you play, Carlton will always be more important" and if they're going to say this, they may as well give up on their equalisation programmes.

2015-05-18T05:48:09+00:00

jax

Guest


I agree with you Josh. I think a move might just be what he needs and to be fair it's not all media.

AUTHOR

2015-05-18T05:33:09+00:00

Josh

Expert


Personally I think the media can get overly-demonised in cases like this, but it's fair to say that there are a few media personalities who regularly cross the boundary between doing honest reporting and just looking for someone to bash up on, and Jack has been a victim of that on a few occasions. I agree with you very much in that I'd like to see Jack have a chance to enjoy his footy and find some success, and I reckon moving to another club is his best chance to do that.

AUTHOR

2015-05-18T05:30:48+00:00

Josh

Expert


I reckon Friday's game could actually have a big impact on the ladder at the end of the year - it could be the difference in a lot of key finals set ups, such as whether or not either side makes the finals, or has a home final, or (if they are lucky) makes the top four. There's just a single win between second and ninth right now and I'd say all the teams in that bracket (except probably Collingwood), and a few outside it, have the potential to make an impact in September. Any game between these kind of sides is going to be important come the pointy end of the year.

AUTHOR

2015-05-18T05:23:45+00:00

Josh

Expert


It's worth noting that McCartney is a development coach at the Demons right now and it hasn't helped Jack much - though he's only been there half a year or so. Melbourne's player development has definitely been massively below league standard over the last decade or so.

AUTHOR

2015-05-18T05:22:06+00:00

Josh

Expert


They have 6 for the season, 7 if you include the Easter Thursday game as Tom pointed out, and potentially 8 if Round 23 has Hawthorn and Carlton scheduled on Friday night. Given finals sides like Fremantle (1) Essendon (2) Port Adelaide (2) North Melbourne (2) and Sydney (3) are only featuring rarely at best, it's very lopsided despite the AFL's general message that the best performing teams will be rewarded with good fixtures.

AUTHOR

2015-05-18T05:13:17+00:00

Josh

Expert


Ha ha, I'm always up for some vigorous North talk, but I figured people around here have probably heard me yammer on about it for a while now so I thought I'd try not to let it take over the article. IMO it depends very much on what you call an A-Grader and how highly you rate certain North players (hence semantic)... but I will of course concede that we don't have any players on that out-and-out, undeniable superstar level like Ablett, Fyfe, Franklin etc etc. Personally when I say A-Grader I'm thinking only of the seriously elite players in the competition, but I reckon Harvey, Petrie and Goldstein are all arguably in that category for North - and hopefully Ziebell soon will be too. Of course, what I'd really like is to see Jack push his way into the absolute upper echelon - I reckon his game on Friday night was at that level and I reckon he is capably of producing that kind of form on a consistent basis.

2015-05-18T05:07:19+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


I'm surprised to hear Josh finds the argument about North's lack of A graders 'a bit semantic', as he appeared quite keen to discuss it in great detail not long ago. Ziebell was mighty on Friday night. I'm not sure I agree that he is 'the next superstar' but if he can reach that level of output regularly he could well be.

2015-05-18T05:01:01+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


Plus the Easter Thursday game in round one, which is effectively a Friday night game.

2015-05-18T04:38:39+00:00

AR

Guest


How on earth did Carlton secure 4 Friday night games in the first 9 rounds? We've got to endure them for the next 2 weeks..!

2015-05-18T02:42:41+00:00

jax

Guest


Watts has been a victim of trial by media and the weight of public expectation might bring an end to his career. He would have to be thinking of giving it all away I would have thought. The spotlight of being a #1 pick hasn't sat comfortably with him and the media has to lot to answer for. Tom Swft walked away for similar reasons and is now studying medicine where he will earn a lot more money whilst living a normal life. Not sure what's going to happen to Jack but I'd like to see him happy and enjoying his career, whatever that career may be. No-one deserves to put up with the crap that has been dished out at him. He was still in high school when this circus started.

2015-05-18T02:26:52+00:00

Daws

Guest


If Jack Watts was at the Bulldogs when Brendan McCartney was coach I guarantee he would be a better player. Melbournes development team aren't doing their job.

2015-05-18T01:52:25+00:00

kick to kick

Guest


This year's Friday Night games have been poor. Even last Friday night's which was entertaining enough was of limited consequence. It was close because it pitted 9 on the ladder against 11. Don't expect either team to have much influence on the season though it's likely that the Kangaroos will take Collingwood's spot in the bottom half the current top 8. Meanwhile next weekend the game of the round, a grand final replay, is at the MCG. Just not on Friday night.

Read more at The Roar