Rugby league's premier event has become tragically sanitised

By Tim Gore / Expert

State of Origin is, and has always been, about passion and parochialism. It is about the honour of wearing the sky blue or the maroon and the true devotees of the cause would surely play for nothing.

That passion was forged and validated by the 18th player: the thousands of hardcore fans who turned football grounds in cauldrons. Now the NRL is showing their contempt for these very fans by jacking up ticket prices to ludicrous levels.

It is strange to reflect that at its beginnings many thought that Origin was a gimmick that wouldn’t take off.

“To the Queensland hillbillies in Premier Joh’s Bananaland, the State of Origin match might be a big deal, but to those in the land of the living, here in Sydney, it’s just another match without much meaning,” Ron Casey of The Daily Mirror said before the first ever State of Origin match in July 1980.

Ironically, the parochial and hostile manner in which Casey got it totally wrong helped forge the bitter rivalry that has made Origin the very biggest thing in Australian rugby league.

Back in the early 1990s I was lucky enough to know a guy called Trevor who somehow managed to get 50 tickets in a group and bussed a herd of us up to the Sydney Football Stadium each year. I know it is politically incorrect to say it, but those trips were beer-fuelled mayhem. It was as big as going to a grand final that your team was in.

The excitement and anticipation was massive. By the time we got to the ground we were at fever pitch. The atmosphere was electric. Joined by another 700 bus loads of equally hyped up zealots, we made the atmosphere that the players fed off, that drove them to yet greater efforts. That in turn made the spectacle that captured the attention and passion of so many.

The big hits, the tries and especially the fights sent the crowd into a frenzy. It was a celebration of footy and life. Those trips are the legends of my memory.

But times have changed when it comes to Origin.

Back in 1980 Bob Fulton made a few predictions of his own in The Daily Mirror, “Rugby league’s non-event of the century will be staged in Brisbane next month, a totally useless State of Origin clash between NSW and Queensland. Only the A$30,000 gate could make it acceptable to administrators… As far as I’m concerned it’s strictly a non-event and will achieve absolutely nothing.”

The future NSW coach got it almost as wrong as Ron Casey, but he got one thing right: if it made money it would go a long way to entrenching the concept. And it has certainly made lots of money.

That first match at Lang Park had a sell-out crowd of more than 33,000. The 1987 series was watched by an average of 36,000 fans. By 1996 that figure hit 40,000 and in 2002 it was 60,000. Just in ticket sales State of Origin was huge. These figures don’t even start to consider the TV revenue streams.

Origin had become a rolled gold cash cow.

Now the NRL is milking that poor beast for all it is worth and in the process are pricing the sort of hardcore league fans that made the event the colossus it is out of the market. Back in the early ’90s it cost me $100 for the bus trip and entry to the game combined. The seats were great too. We were on the 22, just five rows back. The equivalent quality ticket today costs $280. That is just under a 600 per cent price rise, half of which has come in the last five years.

In 2008, in an indication of their prioritisation of finances over fans, Geoff Carr at the NSWRL warned the supporters, “When we get through these current run of contracts, the games are up for grabs. It would be great if the people of NSW voted with their feet… As much as we’d like to have two games in Sydney every second year, there’s pressure on us commercially because other governments are interested in this event.”

These words, reported in Fairfax Media, made it clear that the mindset of the NRL was clearly on cash and if the fans didn’t stump up then they’d sell to the highest bidder, no matter how irrelevant to the game they were.

It is no surprise that in 2015 we have a match scheduled for the MCG.

Last year I made a plea for NRL boss David Smith to make Origin tickets cheaper for paid-up NRL club members. To my delight that has actually happened. While club members only receive a six per cent discount on the cheapest category, it is a 22-26 per cent discount across all of the other ticket classifications.

That takes a Diamond ticket down from an obscene $280 to the offensive price of $216.13. A Platinum ticket plummets from an outrageous $224.29 to a ridiculous $171.28. And a Gold ticket tumbles from an outlandish $137.63 to an unreasonable $101.95.

Basically, the discounts mean that the NRL club members can pay the 2013 prices instead. It has been decreed that they can eat cake.

Over the past four seasons ANZ Stadium has bulged at the seams with near capacity crowds of 83,000, however about 20,000 tickets remain unsold for Origin 1 just over a week out. Just like the extra weight placed on Phar Lap’s back that eventually brought him back to the field, it appears the NRL’s blatant cash grab has finally hit the point where fans aren’t prepared to pay.

When I asked the NRL’s general manager of media and communications, Brad Burden, about the ticket price rises he replied, “Prices have risen by about $5 to $10 in some categories but the $50 ticket is now available, making it cheaper than last year to attend Origin.”

It is true that there are Bronze classification seats on sale for $56.07. However, these seats require the use of oxygen tanks as they are relegated to the nosebleeds at the top of the northern, western and eastern stands.

As well, they account for less than 10 per cent (8,500) of the seats in the stadium. Roughly another 18,000 seats are in the Silver category at $100-plus a pop ($78 for NRL club members). These seats are either in the lower nosebleeds or at either end of the ground. So only around 30 per cent of the seats in the stadium – and the worst seats at that – are allocated to the fans that actually bring the atmosphere that is so vital to the spectacle.

The sheer number of seats that aren’t available to the general punter at all is horrific. By my count there is the equivalent of 141 full-sized bays at ANZ Stadium. Of those a massive 66 are designated to private suites, NRL corporate hospitality and ANZ Stadium members. That’s roughly 40,000 seats (47%). As I lamented last year, to a large extent these seats are filled with mildly interested spectators.

The ANZ Stadium membership costs $743 a year, after a one-off joining fee of $1247. Now that gives you tickets to every game played at the stadium in very good seats. It works out to be very good value. However, it’s a big investment – especially first up – that would price most rugby league supporters out of the market.

Rugby league is tribal. The foot soldiers that turn up every weekend are the lifeblood of the game. They love it. They are the ones who threw the cans onto Lang Park in the ’80s. They are the ones who chant ‘Bullshit’ when the officials make decisions that they don’t like. And they are the ones who roar when fisticuffs erupt across the ground.

But you can’t get a plastic cup onto the ground from up in the nosebleeds. And the type of person who can afford $280 a ticket doesn’t generally chant “Bullshit” – he’s too busy eating his hors d’oeuvres.

And to my dismay they’ve wiped the biff out of Origin. The game that was built on Artie Beetson punching Peter Wynn in the face would now sin bin the great man.

When Billy Moore yelled out “Queenslander” he was daring the NSW boys to take him on and we rightly celebrate it every damn year. When Tommy Raudonikis yelled out “Cattledog” Andrew Johns got the hell punched out of him and it’s constantly in the highlights. When Martin Bella grabbed Brad Clyde’s nuts he got belted soundly. And when Nate Myles pushed Paul Gallen too far he deservedly got thumped.

The stink is – and must continue to be – an integral part of Origin.

And don’t give me some garbage that ‘we want to get that element out of the game and make it more family friendly’. For a starter, if you wanted it family friendly why are you charging the equivalent of a weekly mortgage payment for a family of four to attend?

Further, has it occurred to anybody that there are some events that simply aren’t for kids; events that are essentially adults only? That’s not a crime you know. Just imagine if they tried to take fighting out of ice hockey. There would be uproar. But somehow they’ve done it for our Origin.

The Nanny State is the totally wrong state for the State of Origin. If you are offended by it, just go have another pinot gris at the art exhibition instead and keep your nose out of our business.

And if you are really concerned by violence then I expect you to be trying to ban Game of Thrones, The Walking Dead and Breaking Bad. Alternatively, you can just put up an MA 15+ warning before Origin comes on.

Origin is becoming a sanitised event run by marketers in suits who were hired by an ex-banker, with the seats reserved for rich people. It is now in real danger of losing its passion and its way.

The goose that laid the golden egg is now just crapping on our dinner tables and Big Artie will be rolling in his grave.

Yell it with me boys: “Bullshit, bullshit, bullshit, bullshit!”

The Crowd Says:

2015-05-22T11:48:16+00:00

Punter76

Guest


The stink is boring. Watching Queensland score runaway tries is entertaining.

2015-05-22T03:22:29+00:00

HarryT

Guest


I thought the main premise for banning the biff was to clean up grassroots league. In my area an age group cohort will start with around 30-35 teams in the U8s and reduce to 4 teams by the time they reach the U16s. You see good players get whacked, and either their parents take them away immediately, or more often, they just don't turn up the next year.

2015-05-22T03:10:04+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


That's an interesting point Wayne. I'm not sure which side I come down on with that one. I think footy players have always used boxing training to get in shape. I saw David Barnhill destroy a pest at the Clovelly Hotel one Sunday night but when you watched him and Billy Moore go at it you would never have thought he had any boxing skill. How would Gallen fare against a Les Davidson or Ian Roberts. Who knows?

2015-05-22T03:06:36+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


It's all very amusing Dav. JT can't whinge if Beau Scott spends the rest of his career wanting to bury him. In the immortal playground vernacular "he started it".

2015-05-22T01:10:04+00:00

MJB

Guest


Just look at the reaction people have to throwing punches now. When Danny Green is out making TV ads telling kids not to even think about it and to just walk away, you have to acknowledge that people's attitudes have changed. When I was a kid, throwing punches in school would get you detention or suspension at worst. Now you're lucky if the police aren't called in. You can cling to the idea of a world where it's socially acceptable to smack someone across the chops, but the world has definitely moved on.

2015-05-21T18:16:36+00:00

chris

Guest


As I said before the drop in crowds for both Rugby League and Rugby Union in Australia, New Zealand and also Rugby Union in South Africa should be sending alarm bells to those in charge....some thing better change in the word of The Stranglers.

2015-05-21T18:08:21+00:00

chris

Guest


Sheek wish you were in charge of the ARU, NRL and World Rugby.

2015-05-21T16:38:28+00:00

Chuznut

Guest


I think that the main issue is that it feels like there is a lot more niggle nowadays compared to before they brought the 'no punching' rule in a couple of years ago (see game 2 of last year). Players now know that other players can't hit them without getting sent to the sinbin, so they spend the whole game trying to bait the opposition. If they're not going to allow punching, they at least need to find a way for either the ref and/or the tribunal to cut down on the excessive niggling.

2015-05-21T13:50:24+00:00

Wayne Lovell

Roar Guru


The bias in me wants to ask whether the edict would even have been handed down had Gallen been binned. I loved watching the biff. But the reality is, twenty years ago we had goons throwing wild punches in mostly one on one situations (yeah there were quite a few at the same time but mostly one on one) now we have trained boxers on the field, it would only be a matter of time before we see a well timed and intuitive one-two land flush on an unsuspecting chin and end someones career, or worse their life.

2015-05-21T13:13:03+00:00

Johnno

Guest


MJB Who says the World has moved on from the biff, Dave Smith? So it's moved on coz Dave Smith and a few soccer mums said so?

AUTHOR

2015-05-21T11:53:13+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Seriously, go look at the ticketing map for origin

2015-05-21T11:29:55+00:00

Wayne Lovell

Roar Guru


The main difference is when a fight breaks out in Hockey, its strictly one on one, no one jumps in, everyone just stops and watches and the combatants are guaranteed "5 for fighting" both will be sent into the sin bin and they leave before even being told because its just accepted.

2015-05-21T11:27:21+00:00

Wayne Lovell

Roar Guru


A Power Play is when a the oppositions player has been taken off the ice, its always because of a foul.

2015-05-21T11:25:49+00:00

nerval

Guest


Here's the article, Tim. A wonderful time was had by all in the Smith family, it seems. The setting, the atmosphere and, of course, the wonderfully sanitised and chivalrous sport of ice hockey. Maybe there was no violence of any stripe on this occasion and, had there been, Smith would have changed his tune? http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/ceo-dave-smith-is-convinced-more-nrl-games-need-to-be-played-in-front-of-sellout-crowds-at-smaller-stadiums/story-fni3fbgz-1227242160560

2015-05-21T11:21:25+00:00

nerval

Guest


Here's what you needed, Tim. http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/ceo-dave-smith-is-convinced-more-nrl-games-need-to-be-played-in-front-of-sellout-crowds-at-smaller-stadiums/story-fni3fbgz-1227242160560

2015-05-21T10:44:03+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


Tim, a good mate works there and mentioned Corporate seating all up occupies about 6,000 seats and approx 20,000 for Membership.

2015-05-21T10:04:05+00:00

Organiser

Guest


Anybody here fancy going to an NRL match to watch old women knit? That's what happens at Broncos games!!!!

2015-05-21T09:53:00+00:00

Doc79

Roar Rookie


And NHL uses their version of the sin bin regularly but they also have regular 'power plays' where a player is is excluded for no reason but to allow the opposition more opportunities to score. I don't get it but some of the dour origins of recent years I'm coming round.

2015-05-21T09:48:17+00:00

Mcthug

Guest


there is a difference between two guys standing toe to toe and someone running from across the other side and throwing a round arm from behind or the side.

AUTHOR

2015-05-21T09:28:10+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


No, seriously Zero. Write an article. I don't disagree with a lot of what you've said at all. There's no way I condone violence in general. I'm just annoyed that it's been wiped out as a knee jerk in origin. Write. Submit. I'd love to see it. Really. Ask jay c

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar