Manly Sea Eagles greatest XVII

By The Boss / Roar Guru

Today I continue my series my naming Manly Sea Eagles all-time team.

Manly have been one of the most consistent NRL teams, winning a premiership in every decade since the 70s. So it’s no surprise they have had some great players to make a solid team.

1. Graham Eadie
20 caps for Australia, one cap for NSW, fullback of the year, Rothmans Medal Winner

It was extremely difficult to leave out Brett Stewart but Eadie pips him with his rampaging running style and ball skills. Eadie beat the Sharks all by himself in the 1978 grand final, was an accomplished goal kicker and a was key figure in the ’70s Kangaroos team.

2. Tom Mooney
Mooney was a key piece in Manly backline in the ’70s, he was top try scorer on multiple occasions. A very safe and smart player.

3. Bob Fulton
35 caps for Australia, 16 for NSW, RLW player of the year

Fulton, who is one of the eight Immortals of rugby league, used his amazing ability to read the game and had blistering pace and upper body strength to make breaks with ease. It seemed at times Fulton could score whenever he pleased. Greatest player to play for Manly.

4. Jamie Lyon
10 caps for Australia, eight for NSW, four-time centre of the year, three-time RLIF centre of the year and Man of Steel

Lyon has been the best centre for last five years, he has a great knack of setting up his winger and great touch and poise. Lyon has an unusual chubby body shape which made him hard to tackle. He has been the driving force behind Manley’s success over the last eight years.

5. Michael O’Connor
18 caps for Australia, 19 for NSW, three-time centre of the year

He played centre for Manly but on the wing for rep teams. O’Connor a dual international, had great evasiveness and chip and chase made him most talented backs ever seen.

6. Cliff Lyons
6 caps for Australia, 6 for NSW, two-time Dally M Medal Winner, RLW player of the year, Clive Churchill Medal Winner, two-time five-eighth of the year

Cliffy was a Brookvale favourite and he won multiple awards despite not playing many rep games. He found a way to set up his teammates, most notably Steve Menzies. Lyons also used his waving time to score some great tries.

7. Geoff Toovey
10 caps for Australia, 15 for NSW, hooker of the year

Toovey played with immense passion and heart. His small frame made him elusive and he had great spark in attack.

8. Roy Bull
23 caps for Australia

Bull played like a bull. He had a hard, straight running style and was heartless at times where it seemed he really wanted to hurt his opponents.

9. Max Krilich
13 caps for Australia, 8 for NSW

Great leader who captained the 1982 Invincibles. Krilich was a hooker that played well both in attack and defence.

10. John O’Neill
10 caps for Australia, five for NSW

He was known for brutally punishing his opposition with his runs and hits. Was a force who made Manly a feared pack.

11. Terry Randall
11 caps for NSW

Randall was the hardest hitter in the 70s. He was very aggressive player who inspired Manly to play smash mouth football and he was also a rock in defence.

12. Steve Menzies
13 caps for Australia, 20 for NSW, rookie of the year, three-time second rower of the year, lock of the year and Brad Fittler medal winner

A Manly legend who from a very young age showed the makings of a class player. He had a great face for his position. Menzies had great support play and ran the prefect lines and was very good in defence.

13. Malcolm Reilly
9 caps for Great Britain

Fiery Pom who had a rare mix of aggression and ball playing. He was also known for his kicking game which is uncommon for a lock. Led Great Britain to many victories over Australia.

Bench
Des Hasler, Paul Vautin, Anthony Watmough and Alan Thompson

Manly have an awesome squad. Their pack is full of fiery, super aggressive, hard hitting old school players who will bash and bruise opponents. Their elusive halves pairing of Toovey and Lyons would be very hard to contain with their darts and elusiveness.

Their outside backs are all class, from the unreal talent of Michael O’Connor to the excellence of Jamie Lyon and Graham Eadie. Then there’s the utter brilliance of Immortal Bob Fulton who can tear teams apart at will.

Manly’s all-time team is the real deal with no weakness, they are no doubt one of the best all-times, but are they the best ever? That will be remain to be seen.

The Crowd Says:

2015-08-19T09:49:43+00:00

Rob

Guest


Stewart Boustead Fulton Lyon O’Connor Lyons Cherry Evans Roberts Toovey Randell Boyd Cleal Menzies Carroll Watmough Stewart Hasler

2015-08-18T00:43:00+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


agree

2015-08-17T21:41:51+00:00

jamesb

Guest


Forgot Owen Cunningham as well. That just tells you how much depth Manly has throughout its history.

2015-08-17T16:51:38+00:00

kevin dustby

Guest


nik kosef, what are you smoking Johnno? you are a special for a left field selection

2015-08-17T12:14:22+00:00

Jason Hosken

Guest


The Two-Iron with Ears.

2015-08-17T12:02:31+00:00

Johnno

Guest


Adrian JWH was starting to play well at Manly. Richie Fa'asso did some godo work. And T-Rex's impact when he was at the club is undeniable, he was the best forward in the game when he was at Manly around 2010-12. He'd be pushing for a 2nds spot in best ever Manly, he was the man in 2011.

2015-08-17T10:12:41+00:00

Bearfax

Guest


Stuart Davis played for Manly 1981 and 1983-89 scoring 39 tries. Played for Easts in 1982.

2015-08-17T09:41:37+00:00

Adrian

Guest


How about Jarrod Warehea Hargreaves? Ken Irvine has to be on the wing two time premiership winner and robbed of his immortal status by Andrew Johns and the incessant talk about Thurston -- Comment from The Roar's iPhone app.

2015-08-17T09:24:28+00:00

Birdy

Guest


Wow TB you are a guru , good work. I used to watch him with my brother and I used to rave about him. He thought I was losing it. Probably the most talented , under the radar player I've ever seen . Ps my brother was a hooker, he hated wingers!!!!!

2015-08-17T08:51:24+00:00

Johnno

Guest


And no love for Matt Dunford or Graham Mackay

2015-08-17T08:49:38+00:00

Johnno

Guest


jamesb No love for Paul Shaw/Frank Stokes/Craig Field/Sean Townsend/David Ronson/Billy Weepu lol Can't believe you left out Rothman's medal winner Mal Cochrane lol

2015-08-17T08:45:27+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Stewart Davis. He was skinny, bald and was missing teeth. He looked like a homeless guy but was a good finisher

2015-08-17T08:11:12+00:00

jamesb

Guest


D.Whare, not Whatever.

2015-08-17T07:40:05+00:00

jamesb

Guest


Another Manly XIII 1.P.Sigsworth 2.D.Moore 3.K.Iro 4. D.Whatever 5.David Williams 6. Dennis Ward 7.J.Gibbs 8.L.Boyd 9.K.Schubert 10.M.Bella 11.S.Haumono 12.D.Gartner 13.N.Kosef

2015-08-17T07:31:48+00:00

Birdy

Guest


There was a winger in the eighties for manly , I don't think he represented state or country. Davis I think. Nothing extraordinary but very safe and reliable, never seemed to make mistakes. Good finisher. No superstar but could fit into any team.

2015-08-17T07:29:44+00:00

Ron Jeremy

Guest


I can only count 5 of the starting 13 who'd fall into that category (which wouldn't be too different from most clubs surely except maybe the Roosters ... ) ... ie Mooney (Souths), Lyon (Parramatta v UK), O'Connor (St George), Lyons (Norths), and O'Neill (Souths). And even of these guys you could argue that at least Lyon and Lyons were lesser known players at their former clubs, who then kicked on further once they went to Manly. Unlike say Ribot, Dorahy, Boyd and Ray Brown who were all nicked from Wests by Arthurson but never really became better players at Manly.

2015-08-17T07:21:35+00:00

jamesb

Guest


Here is another Manly XIII 1.B.Stewart 2.Darrell Williams 3.C.Innes 4.S.Matai 5.C. Hancock 6.K.Foran 7.Daly Cherry Evans 8.B.Kite 9. M.Ballin 10. I.Roberts 11.T.Iro 12.A. Watmough 13. G.Stewart

2015-08-17T07:11:29+00:00

jamesb

Guest


Here is another Manly XIII, with players not including from my previous post or the boss' side. 1.M.Ridge 2.J.Ribot 3.T.Hill 4.R.Branighan 5.J.Hopoate 6.P.Blake 7.M.Orford 8.I.Roberts 9.J.Serdaris 10. M.Carroll 11.N.Cleal 12.B.Kennedy 13.P.Vautin

2015-08-17T07:00:02+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


agree johnno

2015-08-17T06:50:46+00:00

john neeson

Guest


I thought about that too...wombat ,russell, snake and Gift, bozo,Matai, cliffy, tooves, cherry bomb, kermit, beaver, Terry Randall, Choc, Max, Crusher, Moose, the Gibbs boys, kosef,.... jeez ... but then I realised The Boss wouldn't be able to pick an easts team to write about .

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar