The Wallabies' do or die battles against England

By Greg Mumm / Expert

There are three main areas for Australia and England where this Test match will be won or lost.

Two are a test of skill, a balance between chancing our hand to gain an advantage or playing it safe to minimise risk.

The other will be a test of brawn, which if done correctly will tip the scales of the other two to create opportunity and allow this team to play its naturally attacking, in your face style.

The three areas I am talking about are;

1. Attack: Our ability to create enough depth in our wide-wide attack to get around the English defence.
2. Defence: Whether we can pressure the breakdown without giving away kickable penalties.
3. Scrum: Do we have the muscle and mentality to prevent the English using their scrum to exit their own half.

Wallabies’ attack
It is obvious through coach Michael Cheika’s chat and the players’ comments in the press that the Wallabies are going to win playing rugby or die trying. Hats off to them, and I salute them for this commitment to attacking rugby, playing the game as it should be played.

As we have seen, though, this does pressure our skills; especially against a team that rushes us in defence… enter England.

If England’s defence works, as it did against Fiji, it pressures teams in to mistakes or forces them to adopt a kicking strategy. If it doesn’t work, as it didn’t against France in warm-ups and Wales on the weekend, they leave themselves exposed on the edges.

To get around this outside up style defence, the French and Welsh needed to create considerable depth to open up the outside channels. Great if you pull it off, terrible if you don’t as you are now 15-20 metres behind the advantage line.

When you compare that to Australia’s depth in recent games, we play considerably flatter in attack, particularly with Bernard Foley at 10.

If we are not careful, we are going to be caught around the 15m channel, 15m behind the advantage line and struggle to ever regain momentum against a physical English team – and that’s if we maintain possession.

If there is one salvation though, learnt from the Uruguay game, it is that Australia seem to have identified the importance of inside balls/plays and will have this in their armoury to mix it up. A good inside ball will sit this style of defence down and maintain the space out wide for the next phase of attack.

Our defence
Our defence has been a strength to date, with physical collisions and a much greater emphasis on contesting on the ground with Izzy even winning a turnover against Fiji.

The downside of this has been an increase in defensive penalties at the ruck as our newfound enthusiasm draws the attention of the pedantic World Cup referees.

What we are also finding is that without the advantage law to while away the indiscretions, we are getting caught in the instant with our had in the cookie jar, and against England and Wales this will cost us in points, not just field position.

As you can see by the positions of the goals from both England and Wales in their recent contest, anything within 50m is fare game and will be penalised ruthlessly.

Our scrum
Firstly, outside of key situations, I think this will be an even contest as will the lineouts, but there is one situation where Australia’s ability to step up will make the biggest difference.

England use their scrum as a key weapon to get out of their own half, holding the ball in for long scrimmaging plays to draw a penalty which piggy backs them out of trouble.

If Australia is to maintain long periods of pressure in England’s half, allowing us to chance our hand to get around their defence, and push the limits and the breakdown without fear of Farrell’s boot, then this weapon has to be taken off them.

Nothing short of a committed, eight-man, 15-second effort here will do.

Fail this and we can expect to spend more time in our half, where we can’t risk our wide-wide attack, and Pooper is put on a leash.

Get this right and we can let the animals out of the cage at the breakdown, force England to kick out of their own half, and take as much depth as we need to get around their rushing defence… and win!

The Crowd Says:

2015-09-30T14:31:21+00:00

Rt

Guest


You're gonna make millions.

2015-09-30T14:30:05+00:00

Rt

Guest


I don't know if you're tryin to convince me or yourself.

2015-09-30T14:12:10+00:00

Roberts

Guest


Well his first of his most recent yellow cards against Argentina was a team yellow. Previous penalties from the rest of the team meant the next person to give away a penalty was also going to get a yellow card. Aaron smith, yep he took him high trying to knock the ball out and was exhonerated by his coach. Most recent yellow was ludicrous. Should never have been a yellow so much so that the wallabies were considering appealing. Won't matter anyway as he won't be selected unless there are injuries.

2015-09-30T13:08:08+00:00

Noodles

Guest


If you were to pick just one thing it would be handling. The WB frustration of the past year and more is about that basic skill. If they settle and play their basic game the WBs would flog England provided they reduce the handling errors. No small matter but it's the biggest issue IMO. They really have fixed the scrum. The line out is good when Simmons is on the track. Breakdown gets better each game outside of Eden park. Backs are running into firm and cohesion. On each point I would question England form and especially the breakdown and the backline cohesion.

2015-09-30T10:56:32+00:00

Savvy

Guest


England to beat Australia. Australia to beat Wales. Wales to beat Fiji. Australia go out due to lack of bonus points.

2015-09-30T10:28:48+00:00

PeterK

Roar Guru


good analysis, I agree and another reason why Cooper should play if the wallabies hope to win by scoring tries, well at least in the backs.

2015-09-30T10:17:37+00:00

Shane D

Roar Rookie


Agreed on Foley Peter K. standing still & throwing a long ball is inviting an intercept or a big hit on the receiver when facing a rushing defence line.

AUTHOR

2015-09-30T09:41:33+00:00

Greg Mumm

Expert


There are a few comments about Foley/Quade being flat (Yes I know the image has Quade in it - comment was performances in general). The depth of alignment needed will not come from these players, it will come from the players outside them.

AUTHOR

2015-09-30T09:39:12+00:00

Greg Mumm

Expert


Agree totally and a very good post. One of the current criticism of the English coaching is that they are not empowering their players to make these decisions on field and this is affecting their creativity and self belief. The opposite could be said of the Wallabies - two philosophies warring...may good prevail!

AUTHOR

2015-09-30T09:30:47+00:00

Greg Mumm

Expert


Agree - great questions My thoughts 1. Keps - more tries as others have said, and Marler was up against an inexperienced 4 test, 1st year of premiership welsh tight-head. 2. Don't discount a 6 - 2 split with Carter, Mumm, McMahon - I doubt Chieka will go for McCalman, McMahon as well as Pooper, I think he will be concerns about overall size considering the loss of Skelton 3. Foley has deserved this spot in my personal opinion and will get the job done if the people outside him create suitable depth. 4. I think Gits will be looked to in these occasions 5. I think Mitchell will get the nod. I think AAC and Horne are both great defensive options, but against a rushing English defence I think Mitchell will offer an inside option off his wing and goes looking for work. England's wide threats won't worry the Wallabies as much as out ability to break down their defence. Just my thoughts.

2015-09-30T09:28:44+00:00

Jameswm

Guest


Yeah. All those line breaks, line break assists, offloads and tries by Folau are fiction right.

2015-09-30T09:22:37+00:00

Jigbon

Guest


2 left foot kickers in Mitchell and gits is valuable. Horne has dash though and great defence and has played well at wing all year. Cooper certainly gives us wide ball but is he consistent enough. ???? There's the rub.

AUTHOR

2015-09-30T08:14:31+00:00

Greg Mumm

Expert


It's a good observation - I think the referred are so focused on the ruck that they are missing a lot of offside play, with the touches eaglets eyed looking for any hint of foul play. There's no point having fast rucks if everyone is offside, and fans wan to see the ball in play with Advantage...only 12min of ball in play in the NZ v Namibia 2nd half.

AUTHOR

2015-09-30T08:09:55+00:00

Greg Mumm

Expert


I do think the line out will be an important battle, but I think they will be fairly evenly matched, I don't think England's line out is one of the best in the competition, and against Fiji our line out looked very good until the three losses in a row. More variations, 4, 5, 6, & 7 mans, mauls and spin out plays mixed with off the top deliveries. With Hooper as a genuine option I think oppositions also have to defence more and therefore will get up less. Mauls also evenly matched. With more time together and more settle selections I think we will see the errors reduced as well.

2015-09-30T07:15:46+00:00

soapit

Guest


well he lines up there anyway

2015-09-30T06:53:29+00:00

Oz Rugby fan

Guest


Thank you TWAS! I have been saying this to mates as well, people just don't get this.

2015-09-30T06:32:31+00:00

bazza

Guest


Yes it was Dave S....I struggled to contain my anger .If i wasnt staying in a plush apartment on the goldie i would have put my stubbie through the tv. I was that ropable that they dismissed Quades GOOD contributions and only focused on his negatives...

2015-09-30T06:29:36+00:00

PeterK

Roar Guru


during the uruguay game not once did Kafer praise QC setting up tries or his game management, he did go on about Beale when he did a short pop pass for a try and ignored QC doing all the hard work before that.

2015-09-30T06:27:21+00:00

PeterK

Roar Guru


Foley has little game vision and struggles to put players through gaps. When standing still he can pass long like the Horne one, running at pace he cannot pass long

2015-09-30T06:23:56+00:00

bazza

Guest


Yes

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar