From ambition to austerity: The A-League adjusts its agenda

By Tony Tannous / Expert

If the A in A-League stood for ‘ambition’ at the start of the 2012-13, when Alessandro Del Piero, Emile Heskey and Shinji Ono were paraded around Parramatta Stadium to hundreds of journalists and photographers at the season launch, then ahead of tonight’s Season 11 kick-off, the A now stands for ‘austerity’.

Gone are the big-name attention-pullers and the lavish, big-spend launches where coaches and players are flown around the country for a few video and sound-grabs.

They’ve been instead replaced by virtual media conferences and a player montage described as a “cloud-based digital collaboration display”.

All that was missing was the slogan: “It’s the A-League coaches and captains, but not as you know them.”

Given the financial state of clubs like the Brisbane Roar, Newcastle Jets and Central Coast Mariners, and the general lack of a marketing budget, it’s perhaps more prudent of the game’s administrators to take a measured approach to building up the season.

Patently, they had no choice.

This correspondent long argued that the powers that be took their foot off the gas in the two off-seasons since Del Piero’s arrival.

Rather than work harder to consolidate the foundations laid in that great Season 8, the powers spent the next off-season relaxing and patting each other on the back.

Talk of taking over the world tomorrow soon started to emanate from the likes of David Gallop.

Granted, the FFA had put a team in western Sydney, but it was only on the back of the train wreck that was Clive Palmer’s Gold Coast United in Season 7.

Besides, it was the football fans of the western Sydney and the chance capture of Del Piero, rather than any masterstroke from headquarters, that made Season 8 the success it was.

For one season, at least, every Tom, Dick and Harry in Australian football, sport and media wanted to ride the western Sydney and Del Piero juggernauts.

The newspapers suddenly took an interest. Crikey, even Channel Ten were sending reporters down to Parramatta Stadium for a few ‘questions’ to ADP.

The A-League was sexy. Everyone wanted a piece. But rather than reflect on that position and remain humble, the game’s administration got ahead of itself.

Fast-forward three years and we’re back at Parramatta Stadium for the season kick-off, but the mood is far less buoyant.

On Tuesday, Gallop addressed only a handful of rusted-on football journalists at the season launch. Contributing to the current mood of gloom is the tense stand-off created by the Frank Lowy and Gallop regime with its various stakeholders.

Whether it’s the national club identity policy (NCIP), the issue with the players association, ongoing recriminations over the failed World Cup bid, poor relations with its free-to-air TV provider and many club administrators, or the over-policing of the active terraces, tensions abound.

These are all issues that could have been addressed through proactive engagement, but instead head office has looked more interested in engaging ‘independent’ consultants to help Lowy continue to control the game from afar.

With FFA leadership so immersed in the politics of control and ego, and the game’s fans effectively left out of the debate, it’s little wonder a sense of pessimism prevails ahead of the season.

In his preview on Tuesday, Mike Cockerill argued that mood at home towards the A-League is always more pessimistic, suggesting the league had more credibility overseas.

The reality is that three seasons ago the mood for the A-League and Australian football was never as high, both at home and overseas. That had been largely the case for the past five seasons.

But the powers that be got far too carried away with ‘their’ success, and are now paying the price for ball-watching.

Last season saw some of the metrics decline. The TV product, both on Fox and SBS, is struggling to say the least, but FFA are seemingly unable to find an alternative on free-to-air.

This season, Friday night free-to-air has been relegated back to SBS2. The game’s administrators and TV executives ought to be feeling the pressure. Far too many have been far too comfortable for far too long.

It’s time to start listening again.

And no doubt there’ll be a prayer or two at headquarters that the on-field product diverts attention from the issues off it, even without the marquee bite.

After the highs of Season 8, the past two have been over-hyped and failed to deliver the type of football and buzz that had people clamouring for a piece in 2012-13.

It’s been good to great in some pockets, such as the eye-catching football of Kevin Muscat’s Melbourne Victory last season, Wellington’s flow under Ernie Merrick, Josep Gombau’s Spanish style in Adelaide, and the quality of Milos Dimitrijevic for Sydney last season.

But equally, the standard hasn’t been as deep in the past two seasons as it was in Season 8.

Take for example the fact that Melbourne City and Brisbane Roar made the bloated finals last season when they were never consistently functional.

The hope of course is that with so little expected this season, perhaps the muted build-up might actually work in the league’s favour and the standard will surprise.

We can only pray.

While no big names have arrived, the hope is that the foreigners that have come, and managers like John Aloisi, Tony Walmsley, Guillermo Amor and Scott Miller, can boost the quality of the on-field product, delivering a proactive, high-tempo template with creativity and function at the core.

Certainly when you look at the pedigree of the arrivals – like Filip Holosko, Diego Castro, Corona, Jeffrey Sarpong, Milos Ninkovic and Bruno Fornaroli – you hope at least a few can have the impact that Fahid Ben Khalfallah, Matthieu Delpierre, Milos Dimitrijevic and Roly Bonevacia did last season.

Even returning Australians like Oliver Bozanic, Ivan Franjic, Michael Zullo and Dario Vidosic should make an impact, and make up in some way for the loss of Nathan Burns, Matthew Spiranovic and Mark Milligan.

It might be a more economical period for a league starting it’s second decade, but if the standard of coaching and play can improve across the board, then the end to Season 11 might not be as doom-and-gloom as its beginning.

Tony’s team-by-team low-down

Adelaide United
Josep Gombau is gone and the big question is whether Guillermo Amor can build on his foundations. He’s still got some guns in Isaias, Sergio Cirio and Marcelo Carrusca about, but the evidence of Adelaide’s work in the FFA hints at a bit more of a struggle.

Brisbane Roar
Lots of turmoil off the pitch, but one of my teams to watch on it. Jamie Maclaren and Devante Clut should have bumper seasons and be knocking on Ange Postecoglou’s door soon enough. Meanwhile, after a couple of years to reflect and upgrade his learning, John Aloisi should be a much better manager. Expect a high-octane game which should have them pushing the top few for much of the season.

Central Coast Mariners
Once again they’ll be tipped by most to finish toward the bottom, but it wouldn’t surprise me to see Tony Walmsley’s side turn a few heads with a vibrant, attacking philosophy. Gone will be the dour approach of Phil Moss as the Mariners take a risk or two in defence. If Walmsley can get the right balance between attack and defensive control, then the Mariners could be knocking on the finals door. I’m particularly keen to see how Harry Ashcroft, Josh Bingham and Mitchell Austin fare at this level.

Melbourne City
John van ‘t Schip gets a final chance to prove he can cut it as a coach at this level, having assembled a very deep squad. Strong in all the thirds with an experienced back three, pacey fullbacks and plenty of options at the creative end, there are no more excuses. Aaron Mooy and Fornaroli loom as keys, and Rob Koren is due a big year. But given what van ‘t Schip has produced in the past, it’s impossible to be sure how he’ll go, or tip City to finish high.

Melbourne Victory
The team to beat. Have strengthened in goals with the capture of Danny Vukovic, and I’ve long been a big Bozanic fan – he’ll be a great complement for Carl Valeri. The big question marks loom over the Asian Champions League campaign and the fact assistant Jean Paul de Marigny has moved to Newcastle. It’s a huge test for Muscat, but he’s built on his already deep squad and poses big threats in attack, plus continuity.

Newcastle Jets
The squad looks stronger and deeper than it has for a while, and my sense is that the Jets are ready to start turning the corner. Nigel Boogaard, Mateo Poljak and even Cam Watson are good defensive men for a rebuild, so Miller had done well there, while de Marigny could also be a prize capture. But for the Jets to give a spot on the finals a shake, much hinges on the front four connection of Leonardo, Enver Alivodic, Milos Trifinovic and Labinot Haliti. A season on the up.

Perth Glory
After the turmoil of last season’s salary cap breaches, the Glory have lost some big names and it’s hard to see them challenging.

Sydney FC
Graham Arnold had built a crash-hot midfield in Mikael Tavares, Dimitrijevic and Ninkovic, while Holosko looks a great capture up high. But I’m not convinced about Jacques Faty – yeah, he’s the coolest kid in the Fox studio, but I’d rather focus on the football. The defence is the biggest question mark over Sydney. That and the ACL campaign, and it’s hard to see them challenging for the top two.

Wellington Phoenix
They’ll be written off by the usual sources, but in Merrick they have a proven man pulling the strings, and I expect then to be in the top few for much of the season. Bonevacia was a revelation last season, while the improvement of Roy Krishna was eye-catching. The prolific Blake Powell looks ready to make the step up from NPL level and looks a good fit. If Sarpong can also settle in, the the Nix will offer plenty of potency up front. Exciting times.

Western Sydney Wanderers
After falling short in the transfer market last season and getting a chance to fix it, the pressure’s on Tony Popovic. If Federico Piovaccari is more Poorvaccari, and the Spaniard trio of Dimas Delgado, Andreu and Alberto Aguilar don’t bring control and a forward trigger, then the Wanderers are in for another tough season. If the Spaniards can provide the control in defence and prompt the attack, then much will hinge on how creative and clinical Mark Bridge, Vidosic, Mitch Nichols and Romeo Castelen can be up high. Pressure abounds in the dugout and on the pitch.

Tony’s tips
1. Melbourne Victory
2. Wellington Phoenix
3. Brisbane Roar
4. Sydney FC
5. Melbourne City
6. Western Sydney Wanderers
7. Central Coast Mariners
8. Newcastle Jets
9. Adelaide United
10. Perth Glory

The Crowd Says:

2015-10-12T04:42:15+00:00

RBBAnonymous

Guest


I think this is shaping up to be a super season if the season opener is anything to go by. I thought there was terrific football being played in all the matches I saw and I think this will be a super competitive season. Unlike the author I am not bothered one bit that we do not have a "big name" player. In fact this crop of foreign players is quite possibly the best collection of foreign talent we have had in the league and it seems to be spread out across all the clubs. Even though my team lost I am excited for the season ahead, we will win our fair share of games but it wont be easy. I think what we are seeing more of is teams are being punished for any mistakes being made in the defensive third. A season or two you might have gotten away with the odd mistake here or there but not with the games on the weekend. Looking forward to the rest of the season, bring on next week.

2015-10-12T04:35:52+00:00

wanderingkooka

Guest


Glad I didn't put any money on the above tips. 0 from 5...some great tipping to start the season

2015-10-12T03:43:38+00:00

Fussball ist unser leben

Roar Guru


"64.5K for an opening round is the lowest in years." Have you bothered to check when was the last time Round 1 opened with the following trifecta: a) MVFC not in Melb b) CCM at home c) NIX at home? CCM is a team from a regional town with a population of around 160k. NIX is a team from NZL. They draw the lowest home crowds in ALeague. Unlike the AFL, the ALeague doesn't create a biased fixture to maximise attendances. Every team plays every opponent once at home and, every 2nd year, every team plays 5 opponents twice at home.

2015-10-12T03:11:12+00:00

Perry Bridge

Guest


AFL has the issue over last couple of years of introducing live against the gate FTA coverage. Including finals. It certainly seems to have bitten during the regular season, cooler months - but certainly Carlton in the doldrums and Essendon under their particular flavour of cloud haven't helped. The A-League doesn't have the same FTA coverage to 'compete' with - the Round 1 crowds seem pretty ordinary - 64.5K for an opening round is the lowest in years. It was interesting checking SMH for example leading in - while a Michael Cockerill was upbeat, while some other scribes were far less so. Hard to get an accurate 'read' on this.

2015-10-10T14:59:32+00:00

Gentile

Guest


Crowds in domestic competitions will vary based on which teams are doing well. The a-league stagnated last year as wsw and brisbane bombed. Same with afl stagnating in average crowd numbers as traditional big clubs essendon and carlton have been crap for the last few years.

2015-10-10T10:21:34+00:00

Evan Askew

Guest


Sorry I have just looked at some of the playing rosters. This season to see who is new because we haven't signed players like Del piero and Heskey. Fiip Holosko, 144 appearances and 42 goals for Besiktas as well as 65 appearances for Solvakia, aged 31. Milos Ninkovic, 109 appearances for Dinamo Kiev as well as a season with Red Star Belgrade (which may not be as big a deal as it was before the collapse of the iron curtain) and 27 appearances for Serbia, aged 30. Aaron Hughes is older than I would like but he has played over 400 times in the EPL. Corona with over 200 appearances in LA Liga. Piovacari, who I hesitate to Include but I mention him on the basis of two seasons in Serie A, A full season in LA liga and a full season with Staeu Bucharest which included in full 43 appearances with 16 goals. 12 appearances and 5 goals in the champions league. Castro, 230 appearances in la Liga. Leonardo with 55 appearances for Feeyenord and 40 appearances for Ajax (injury afflicted) and 40 appearances for Red Bull Salzburg. There are some quality cvs there and most of those players are in the 29 to 32 age bracket, a time when a footballer is still at his peak. Since when do we deem clubs such as Feeyenoord, Ajax, Dinamo Kiev and Staeu Bucharest as underwhelming?

2015-10-09T13:56:46+00:00

suave

Guest


looks lie an amateur league when u look at ISL - Indian Super league !

2015-10-09T13:34:09+00:00

suave

Guest


well u need money to bring big name players ..which isn't forte of A - league !

2015-10-09T13:16:19+00:00

Realfootball

Guest


MF, I thought the same from the start - not a hope in hell - and I didn't need to go to KL to form that view.

2015-10-09T07:53:56+00:00

Pat malone

Guest


No it's not

2015-10-09T07:51:48+00:00

Pat malone

Guest


You obviously do by the number of comments

2015-10-08T21:48:39+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Jesse had a break down his marriage feel apart and he said many things.... he went from being a very positive writer to become in the end a very toxic one.. it was a whole series of stuff he wrote .. at first it suited SBS and Les because at that stage SBS were in their sulking super league war in the most part why about 40 folk from different forums put together half time heroes... Jesse may have been right on the WCB but he was so toxic in the end about everything to do with Football in Australia he left ... it was good for him I think .. In fact it was Jesse who asked me to come over to the Roar and start posting here we exchanged a few emails about this site and were it would go... I miss the early Jesse

2015-10-08T21:09:06+00:00

jbinnie

Guest


Fuss -This reply is beneath your intelligence and surely points out a deficiency in not only reading but understanding the written word,Where did I say that "the people who came to see ADP ended up becoming "members" of MVFC.????" You then go on to introduce,(and again I am left wondering why) another season's figures into the debate when I thought it very clear I was specific in naming ADP's initial season in the HAL. You go on to talk about "the common sense" test and I put it to you that for some reason or other you appear to be mixing up what is normally deemed as a "member" with what I term as a "new face" to the game. The mighty Arsenal appear to have the same problem giving out full house attendances to all home games when it is quite obvious to any onlooker that there are empty seats in the ground. Their explanation?. The "members" have coughed up for their seats so from a financial point of view the seat is taken!!!!,to me a case of "mind (money) over matter". You appear to work under the same consideration,if one is not a member one cannot be a fan. Cheers Your mate jb ps Have to say it Fuss, I am not a member of any club in the HAL,so I am not "a fan".of the game.

2015-10-08T20:50:15+00:00

jbinnie

Guest


Philip - As you are aware I have great respect for your comments and like you am quite prepared to agree to disagree on certain issues but in this instance where we are discussing the pros and cons of what is deemd a marquee player and why the idea was introduced in the first place, I find it incredible that both you and that other regular contributor Fuss appear to belittle the effect ADP's visitation had on the home crowds of nearly all HAL clubs in his initial season at Sydney FC. Let's for a minute forget ADP,his age and his overall contribution to Sydney FC's football playing style during those years there.If by some stoke of genius I ,Fuss, or you,or David Gallop, could come up with an idea that would increase crowds by not hundreds,but thousands, at 80% of the grounds being used by HAL identities would it not be worth some consideration as a perhaps novel,but nevertheless successful way of attracting "new" faces to the game,whether you care to call them "theatre goers" or "event chasers". Surely that is the base reasoning behind paying out a fortune to "marquee" players is it not? If however a club management is incapable of cashing in on that transaction is that the fault of the "marquee" or is it a sign of tardiness on the management who came up with the arrangement? You have your thoughts and I have mine so yes,we will agree to disagree. Cheers jb

2015-10-08T13:53:13+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


Ok, I thought Tony may have been involved with Half time orange as well. It's an interesting story about half time orange, it put Jesse Fink on the map and he eventually got full time work as a writer from it. At one point it was immensely popular, then one day the tide started to turn, and slowly over time, Australian soccer fans turned against him, for no other reason that he was always an independent voice and spoke his own mind (as we see from the reaction to Tony's article here, Australian soccer fans will turn on any soccer writer who is not looking at things through rose tinted glasses). Interestingly, Jesse Fink wrote on the Roar for a while, and when I went looking through his articles, I found a great one where he describes his participation in an Asian confederation event, and he could see first hand how lowly Australia was looked upon by the movers and shakers - he knew there and then that the Australian WC bid was sunk. He wrote back in November 2009 with amazing prescience: "During the week your blogger flew to Kuala Lumpur as a guest of the Asian Football Confederation, ostensibly to attend the AFC Annual Awards. But it was also an opportunity for me to see how Asian football actually works and I came home convinced Australia has Buckley’s chance of getting the 2018 or 2022 World Cup. Les Murray, who was also with me in KL, assures me otherwise and believes Australia has a very good chance to get 2022, and he’s probably in a better position to judge, being involved with FIFA’s ethics commission and serving as chairman of the Asia-Pacific Broadcasting Union Sports Group (ABU)." Jesse was basically hounded out of Australia for calling it the way he saw it.

2015-10-08T13:02:24+00:00

fadida

Guest


The first half of the threasd was NBL heavy AR. It was as tongue in cheek in joke :)

2015-10-08T10:47:03+00:00

c

Guest


in afl both both crowd figures and results are tipped

2015-10-08T10:14:08+00:00

c

Guest


i do not think that there is basketball tab

2015-10-08T10:07:37+00:00

c

Guest


bet you this will be the best season to date

2015-10-08T09:21:43+00:00

AR

Guest


"The warpath these 2 were on when Ronaldo owned Melbourne for a week in July for a practice game was just a joke.." War path? Excuse me? I went to that game! You sir, are truly deluded.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar