Bird, Abbott and Mennie in the mix after Starc goes down

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

Finally, a contest. After two matches which offered minimal intrigue, this first day-night Test is in a fine position after Day 1.

This series had looked set to be a fascinating battle between a rebuilding Australian team and a New Zealand outfit which was settled and laden with talent. What a let down it has been so far, with a lopsided match at the Gabba followed by maybe the most uneventful WACA Test in history.

FULL SCORECARD

Many people had feared that the day-night experiment could ruin this series. Now it has the potential to lace it with some belated vibrancy.

While it is far too early to make a judgment on the merits of day-night matches or the pink ball, this was the most engrossing day of Test cricket seen in Australia since Day 5 of last summer’s Adelaide fixture.

The pitch was greener than usual and offered both pacemen and spinners enough assistance to challenge the batsmen. The much-analysed pink ball held up quite well and behaved much the same way as does the red Kookaburra.

There was no outrageous swing, just sufficient to make the likes of Trent Boult and Mitchell Starc a threat with the new ball. It was still moving through the air in the final over of the day too, at 22 overs old, with Tim Southee earning some nice shape, even when bowling from wide on the crease.

Earlier, Australia had bowled better than they have all summer. As I flagged in the lead up to the Test, the retirement of star quick Mitchell Johnson had the potential to be a blessing in disguise due to the lack of balance in the Australian attack when he and Starc played together.

His replacement, veteran seamer Peter Siddle, doesn’t have anywhere near the same pace or penetration as Johnson. The opposite of the wild left armer, though, Siddle is predictable and consistently builds pressure which can be exploited by more dynamic bowlers like Starc.

Yesterday, Siddle and spinner Nathan Lyon showed the value of such accurate, frugal bowling when they reeled in Kiwi prodigy Kane Williamson after he had made another fluent start, cruising to 19 from as many deliveries.

The Australians have struggled to bowl dot balls, let alone maidens, at Williamson this series and as a result he has batted under very little pressure. In the first two Tests he had scored at the swift strike rate of 71 without undue risk.

After cantering to 19 yesterday, Williamson scored just three runs from his next 39 balls. Lyon and Siddle bowled perfectly to a tight field set by skipper Steve Smith and after their suffocating tandem effort was finished Starc entered the attack and dismissed the subdued Williamson.

Since their brilliant efforts on the Test tour of the Caribbean early this year, the Australian attack rarely has operated as a unit. All pulling in the same direction yesterday, they cut through a strong New Zealand batting line-up which had monstered them at the WACA.

It was an impressive showcase of the depth in Australia’s pace ranks. In the space of six months, Australia have lost their two best pacemen of the past five years in Mitchell Johnson and Ryan Harris.

Most teams would be crippled by such retirements. Imagine how England would fare without Stuart Broad and James Anderson, New Zealand missing Southee and Trent Boult, or South Africa minus Dale Steyn and Morne Morkel.

But that depth looks set to be challenged once more, with Starc’s troublesome ankle finally giving way. He has been delaying what seemed like inevitable surgery, and after breaking down yesterday it looks likely he will undergo that operation now and miss a couple of months of cricket.

That will leave Australia without the three bowlers who looked set to form their first-choice attack in the opening Test of the recent Ashes – Starc, Johnson and Harris. With leading backup quicks James Faulkner, Pat Cummins, Jason Behrendorff and Nathan Coulter-Nile all currently injured, Australia’s pace stocks are limited.

It is just 12 days until the first Test against the West Indies in Hobart. It would seem logical that Siddle, Josh Hazlewood and James Pattinson, who is in the current Test squad, would form their pace attack in that match.

But Hazlewood’s stamina is an issue, so much so that there was talk he would be rested for this Test in Adelaide. It may well be that the only reason he is playing is because, with Johnson’s retirement, the selectors would not have wanted to have to make two changes to the attack.

It seems very unlikely though that Hazlewood will play all three Tests against the West Indies. Ditto for Pattinson, who is just two first-class games back from another major injury and will need to be handled with care.

There is next to no chance that both Hazlewood and Pattinson will be risked in all three Tests against such a weak opponent in the West Indies, who Australia mauled away from home earlier this year.

There will be generous opportunities for a rookie quick to get their chance in the baggy green, making this round of the Sheffield Shield particularly relevant. With leading quicks like Faulkner, Coulter-Nile, Cummins and Behrendorff all injured, we could well see a real bolter running in to the crease against the Windies.

An unexpected Test debut could be on the cards for one of the likes of New South Wales seamer Sean Abbott, or prolific South Australian pair Chadd Sayers and Joe Mennie. Probably the leading contender to act as a backup for Hazlewood, Siddle and Pattinson would be a man who has already had a taste of the top level in Jackson Bird.

After a disappointing two years marred by injury, Bird is back fit and grabbing wickets. With 13 wickets at an average of 27 for Tasmania, he is second on the Shield wicket taking list behind only Mennie. With his consistent outswing, unerring accuracy and lofty height, Bird has impressed in his brief international career, taking 13 wickets at 23 from three Tests.

Just six months ago he was a long way down the pace pecking order. But retirements and injuries are going to offer opportunities for the likes of Bird or perhaps a rookie. It will be yet another test of Australia’s pace depth.

The Crowd Says:

2015-11-30T01:27:04+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


That's where Freo is. Mind you, I'm suggesting Boland is the next form bowler in line for selection. NCN is the best...just hasn't played much. Maybe the Windies is a good way to geed him back into the system.

2015-11-30T01:20:49+00:00

davros

Guest


ha ha youre not from WA by any chance ?

2015-11-30T00:36:16+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Their answer would be NCN.

2015-11-30T00:27:02+00:00

davros

Guest


Id like to see a comparison rating of the most underated shield bowlers etc guys that don't get a wrap that much and see how they were rated by their piers...ie who does warner n smith and several other top batters don't like facing

2015-11-29T22:25:01+00:00

dan ced

Guest


Boland looking great this season, didn't look bad last season mind you.. just.. about on par with Clint. I'm starting to talk about bowlers, because my mate M.K. failed this round, no captains knock for him, and because Shaun the Sheep almost got a 50 (talk about bignoting mediocrity) he's the new messiah again. I still believe you should follow the form, but with the selectors loving "that century he got 10 years ago for Australia".. you'd have to thing Bird is a lock with his test experience. but I'd love to see Mennie get rewarded for a couple of unsung shield seasons.

2015-11-29T12:35:11+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Faulkner is injured and not playing. Boland for mine...out of those that are fit. 7 for 30 today and takes the bowling honours for Vic almost every innings. Out bowled Pattinson.

2015-11-29T11:41:41+00:00

jammel

Guest


Pattinson in for me - Bird into the squad. Wouldn't mind if Faulkner got a run though in the squad.

2015-11-29T11:33:32+00:00

HB

Guest


Bird would be a good swap for Hazlewood, should he be rested. If Pattinson can't be expected to get through three consecutive tests against the West Indies, then he shouldn't even be in the squad.

2015-11-29T06:10:55+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


How would you know? Remember you are pretending to be an Australian.

2015-11-29T01:30:46+00:00

Republican

Guest


Don of Freo Yes, so the Kiwis keep telling us, esp when they lose. Seriously, Cricket doesn't rank anywhere as highly in NZ as it does here. If you take this into account together with our subsequent grassroots resources our advantage should be insurmountable. That aside, NZ still are a good chance to win this. If their tail can wag which i reckon they will, their attack should be able to put our very undisciplined batting lneup to the sword i.e. not including our tail who actually show some grit. So all over with a day to spare. I reckon the day night concept compromises Test Cricket to the extent, results will be the rule rather than the exception, which is what the public want however this means that the nuances, strategies and skill set of the test version of Cricket will be rendered extinct.

2015-11-28T23:33:41+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


If a new bowler is to come into the squad for Hobart I would give Bird another run, he would be playing on his adopted home deck.

2015-11-28T22:46:55+00:00

davros

Guest


when conditions suit Sayers and he is in form ...yeah he bowls good swing ...but he was given an op for aus A and then everyone realised how slow he bowls ...the keeper stands up to him ! I watched him and mennie at the gabba recently ...mennie looks to be at least a yard quicker and bowling really well this season and is at least 2 yards quicker than Sayers ...it beats me why Sayers is given every chance with opening the bowling with the new rock every time choosing his end etc Wonder how Mennie would go with the new rock ? Last time they gave it to him because of injuries etc he took 7 first innings wickets against WA

2015-11-28T21:39:34+00:00

Gav

Guest


Barking up the wrong tree. Hazelwoods got the goods

2015-11-28T21:15:59+00:00

Perry Bridge

Guest


Why was Starc allowed to play the Matador cup?? Pattinson was forced to sit out a shield game but Starc said "No, I'm playing" and now he's broken down. Yep - solid move. And to think the NSW media was pumping him up for it. Guess what - he's still fragile. Hazlewood has looked better this test - but what is apparent even in this 2nd inns so far is the pressure getting applied. Siddle last night bowled tight, was desperately unlucky a couple of times but was again key in drying up the runs. We then see slightly loose shots played to get out - they look silly in the highlights replay but we know that because our bowlers are bowling better in partnership that someone will benefit from the attempt to break the shackles - and on this pitch with a little bit of swing/seam you have to be patient both with bat and ball.

2015-11-28T17:15:44+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Do you think the game has little status in NZ? Did you stop watching Day 2 at sundown? Pub man...you must have missed the last session.

2015-11-28T12:46:04+00:00

dan ced

Guest


Paris is looking good back from injury again.

2015-11-28T12:45:23+00:00

dan ced

Guest


Mennie is leading shield wickets so far, I thought it should've been Mennie or Bird in the squad instead of Pattinson (coz he has a history of breaking down)

2015-11-28T12:44:08+00:00

dan ced

Guest


Let's pretend he meant "They'd go for an uninjured Behrendorff"

2015-11-28T11:40:33+00:00

vineet kumar

Roar Rookie


Would love to see Billy Stanlake in the mix.....and Joel Paris is quite impressive too..

2015-11-28T11:38:18+00:00

VivGilchrist

Guest


He's been down this season for sure. I think he'll be perfect in NZ conditions if he can get some form up.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar