BBL Weekly: The national recall edition

By Ryan Buckland / Expert

Five games into BBL05 and there’s been plenty of action in the 200-odd overs of cricket played. Want to sound like a T20 connoisseur? Read on.

Since Thursday night’s Sydney Smash, there’s been 1631 runs hit, 62 wickets taken, 1171 balls bowled, and two performances that should result in national recalls.

Here’s how things stand on the league ladder.

There’s not a lot to read into it at this stage, given the Scorchers are yet to play a game and most of the competition have only played one game, but don’t let that stop you from getting excited, Thunder Nation!

League table

Team Games W L Points Net run rate Next Date
Sydney Thunder 2 2 0 4 0.925 v ADS 28 Dec
Sydney Sixers 2 1 1 2 1.475 at MER 23 Dec
Adelaide Strikers 1 1 0 2 0.950 at PER 21 Dec
Melbourne Renegades 1 1 0 2 0.436 v SYS 23 Dec
Perth Scorchers 0 0 0 0 0.000 v ADS 21 Dec
Brisbane Heat 1 0 1 0 -0.436 at HOB 22 Dec
Melbourne Stars 2 0 2 0 -0.500 at SYS 27 Dec
Hobart Hurricanes 1 0 1 0 -4.750 v BRI 22 Dec

Flipping the script
How ‘bout them Thunder!

A 2-0 start, against the far more fancied Sydney Sixers and Melbourne Stars, is easily the best way the western Sydney boys have begun a season since the BBL’s inception.

As predicted, a large part of the Thunder’s success has been thanks to their very good, very deep fast-bowling stocks, with the team defending the two lowest first innings scores made so far this season (158 in Game 1, and 177 from Game 2).

There was a fair dose of luck and poor batting in Game 1 against the Sixers, but in last night’s thriller it was as much about making the big moments count as, well, just being a better team.

If it weren’t for Kevin Pietersen’s 76 from 42 balls – 25 of those runs coming in his final seven deliveries – this one would have been all over at the halfway point of the second innings. Where the rest of the competition has gone with two tweakers, the Thunder have gone all in on crafty pace bowlers, with Gurindher Sandhu and Clint McKay particularly stellar exponents of slow variations. Shane Watson is bowling like a 25-year-old, while Jacques Kallis, well, he’s bowling.

The Thunder’s next assignment isn’t until next Monday, when they face the volatile Adelaide Strikers on their home deck. They could still be on top of the ladder at that stage – something which even the bravest of pundits wouldn’t have predicted.

What of last night’s losers, the Melbourne Stars? The pre-tournament favourites sit at 0-2, and in a very tough spot even at these early stages of the tournament.

Their first-up loss to the Adelaide Strikers was on account of a loose bowling performance in the second half of the first innings, as well as some ambitious strokeplay from Adelaide’s Alex Ross. Last night’s loss was a little more troubling though, in that the much-vaunted batting line-up failed from top to bottom (excluding Pietersen, and Marcus Stoinis, who was done in by a combination of Andre Russell’s hand cannon and some neuraliser-worthy LBW judgement from the men in black).

Melbourne have a week off to ponder their next move. With a very strong line up on paper, where do they go from here?

Khawaja’s in, but what about Lyon?
If there were any doubts that Usman Khawaja would re-take his position in the Australian Test team from Shaun Marsh on Boxing Day, they were made to look even more foolish on Sunday evening.

Khawaja opened for the Sydney Thunder, and put on a clinic as he scored the tournament’s first century for the year.

It wasn’t even the number of runs he scored – in a game that is often criticised for slogs and cross bats, Khawaja rarely mishit the ball. He played all around the ground, including a couple of ramp shots towards the back end of his innings, and sewed up his return to the pinnacle of cricket.

But there could be another national selection story brewing at this early stage of the tournament: Nathan Lyon.

No, not in the Test team, but in either or both of the ODI and Twenty20sides.

The reluctance to play Lyon, who is quite obviously the country’s best spinner in the international reckoning, appears mostly to do with the national team’s desire to have batting all through the line-up.

Well, two games into the BBL and it’s clear Lyon’s power to vary his deliveries with bounce and flight is not limited to the red ball. He was arguably the Sixers’ best bowler in both games he played, even though his figures make for better reading in the second outing (5-23 off 3.5 overs) compared to his first (1-28 off 4).

Bat him at 11 and watch him hold up an end in either format – make it happen selectors.

The old guard have still got it
If T20 cricket is supposed to be the young man’s game, someone forgot to tell three of Australian cricket’s old stagers.

It started with Mike Hussey, who went all classical in his 80* from 59 balls on opening night. Coming in at number three, Hussey looked like a man who’d been playing for months – but nope, it was his first competitive game of cricket for many months. They call him Mr Cricket, but a more appropriate name would be Mr Natural.

Then on Friday night it was Brad Hodge’s turn, as he saved his Strikers with a cool, calm and collected 56 from 41 after coming to the crease at a precarious 3-38 in the sixth over. His initial partner, Travis Head, lasted a few overs more as the Stars’ Adam Zampa and John Hastings put the squeeze on. After making it through this tough period, he played anchor to the chain chomp that was Alex Ross’ ridiculous 65 from 31. Crucially for Hodge, more than half of his runs came in ones and twos.

Capping off the old fogey trifecta was Brad Haddin on Sunday, who played a well-paced, powerful innings of 72 from 54 deliveries. He also won man of the match, in what could be described as controversial circumstances. It was Haddin at his white-ball best, slapping fast bowlers with a paddle-straight bat down the ground and blasting elegant drives through cover-point.

And we’re yet to see the grandest daddy of them all, the Scorchers’ George Bradley Hogg, who suits up tonight at the tender age of 44. You know, the World T20 is only a few months away…

Still would’ve reviewed it

S.R. Watson

LBW: Glenn Maxwell

One from two balls.

Source: Cricket.com.au

Renegades batting depth comes into play
Coming into the tournament, the question mark lingering over the Melbourne Renegades was their bowling line up, which looked remarkably thin. That theory was put to the test and proven, if not equivocally, on Saturday night, as the Brisbane Heat put up 180, with a top score of 35 from Chris Lynn.

But as shallow as they look in defence, they are deep with the willow in hand.

Led by a sparkling 65 from Aaron Finch, who was well supported by discarded star Cam White’s 55, the Renegades batting line-up reeled in the ton 80 with relative ease. The run rate never dipped below seven, and accelerated around the halfway mark, as Chris Gayle (sporting a gold bat and a triple-digit jersey), Matthew Wade and Dwayne Bravo combined for 56 runs from 31 balls.

Substituting a three overs, no maidens, 1 for 47 from Guy Walker for four overs, no maidens, 1 for 30 Peter Siddle may make this team a threatening proposition.

Brad Haddin was man of the match
The Sydney Sixers eviscerated the Hobart Hurricanes on Sunday, piling on 186 runs before bowling their opponents out for just 91. It was one of the biggest victories in the BBL, and a very unusual result – it’s not often a team bats so well relative to their opponent.

As above, Brad Haddin showed he’s still very good at cricket in hitting a powerful 72 from 45 balls. His former Australian counterpart, Nathan Lyon, took 5-23 from his 3.5 overs (taking the last wicket of the match). According to some, Lyon was more deserving of the man of the match award, because he’s a bowler and he took five wickets, whereas Haddin is a batsman and he hit a measly 72 runs.

That argument ignores the role each participant played in victory: Haddin batted for the first 12 overs, scoring 72 of his team’s 115 runs to that point, as those around him struggled with a very good Hobart Hurricanes bowling attack. If he hadn’t played his innings in the manner he did, the platform for a final six-over assault, which got the Sixers to a very strong total, wouldn’t have existed.

Meanwhile, Lyon took four of his five wickets by virtue of batsman error.

So yes, five-fors don’t happen very often, and Lyon looked very good with the white ball in hand. But that’s why it is recorded in the scorebook as a ‘five-for’. Haddin’s role in the match was far more influential on the outcome.

Tonight’s game: Strikers at Scorchers
The Perth Scorchers finally take the field in BBL05 tonight, but do so without a couple of their more important everyday players, as Jason Behrendorff and Sam Whiteman are out with back and finger injuries, respectively. The reigning champs will be at near-full strength otherwise, with their four current Test representatives Nathan Coulter-Nile, Shaun Marsh, Mitch Marsh and Adam Voges suiting up for what could be the only time in the tournament.

The line out of the WACA is that Behrendorff is missing this one mostly due to the availability of the internationals – with their inclusion allowing him to rest a little longer than required. We’ll see.

The Strikers, on the other hand, come into town having knocked off the Stars at home in their opening game, and so will be full of confidence. Adelaide got over the Scorchers in their BBL04 match in Perth, with that man Hodge all-but guiding his team to victory.

Will Perth’s defence be as strong without the Dorff killing off any chances of scores during the power-play overs? That looms as the critical question in this one.

I’m not game enough to back against a team that includes the Marsh brothers (who are very good at cricket, people), Adam Voges and Nathan Coulter-Nile; and Adelaide’s line-up is vulnerable to early collapse, as we saw on Friday night. So I’ll back the Scorchers.

Enjoy the week of cricket, and that other thing that happens this time of year. Christmas, or something.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2015-12-21T06:51:40+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


Stoinis looks like a very handy pick up for both the Stars and Victoria; he's got a real sense of power about him, but it doesn't come at the expense of technique as you say. If he can become a handy medium-fast bowler, he might just crack the ODI/T20 team with a bit of luck within a couple of years.

2015-12-21T06:35:00+00:00

Paul Nicholls

Roar Guru


I can't argue with that. I am already hanging out for tonight's game...

AUTHOR

2015-12-21T06:21:20+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


Beat me to it! Its not strictly like for like, but the crowd numbers are excellent.

2015-12-21T05:56:17+00:00

Ash

Guest


Record crowds in BBL history for the pre-Xmas period. Attendances are up a massive 30% on last year at the same stage while TV Ratings are up 17% => BIG BASH MAKES A BIG SPLASH http://www.bigbash.com.au/news/big-bash-league-crowd-ratings-viewers-record-numbers-bbl05/2015-12-21

2015-12-21T04:13:46+00:00

Chris Kettlewell

Roar Guru


This is the week that a lot of people are starting to take holidays, schools are out, so one way or other parents have to work out how to manage them, so while plenty of people are still working it gives enough people free for games like that I guess.

2015-12-21T04:07:29+00:00

jamesb

Guest


School holidays have started. And many people would have started their leave this week as well.

2015-12-21T04:07:01+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


A further issue if that's the case, is the development of players such as Kurtis Patterson watching from the sidelines. At the Stars Wright's involvement is pushing the talented Handscomb down the order. He should be listed in the top 4 ahead of the majority of ego's littered amongst thet top 6. Dave Hussey, unlike his brother, is getting worse with age. Agree about shifting Maddinson down the order, Maxwell played a strange knock last night not dissimilar to Maddinson's in the season opener. If you are 1-90 in the 11th you'd send either in but I'd have them in at No.5/6. Handscomb will probably get a chance once the ODI's start and Maxwell, Faulkner etc. are out of the picture. Possibly Stoinis too, who looks technically sound.

AUTHOR

2015-12-21T03:39:57+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


They're both getting a little older, and don't seem to be of the same stock as the Hussey/Hodge/Haddins of the world (although in checking, Wright is only just 30 years old, so that can't be right). The problem would be these international guys sign multi-year deals, so teams are sort of stuck with them even as their performances aren't worth the price tag. I think Haddin is a better go as the opener, anyway, and I'd put Nic Maddinson down the order a little.

AUTHOR

2015-12-21T03:17:19+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


Things are tough over here - a lot of people are probably not needing to take early marks...haha, its not that bad. I reckon half of the city is on holiday already though - my ride on the train this morning was far more spacious than usual.

2015-12-21T02:33:46+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Should've played tonight's game as the second game of the double header yesterday, logic would've suggested. But still if it's near a sell-out tonight, then clearly Perth people have no issue taking early marks!

2015-12-21T02:15:12+00:00

Ron Swanson

Roar Guru


Good article Ryan. I hoped the Sixers used Had's to open as the Maddinson/Lumb combo is like watching a car wreak. Is it just me or are the influence of the Lumb & Wrights starting to wear a little thin?? Only 2 games in but I suspect most sides have a fair idea how to restrict both players scoring strengths. Leg stump line to Lumb and he can't hit it off the square not to mention his inept fielding, on display again yesterday when he headed the wrong direction to a Bailey boundary! Fair suck of the sav if he had the blazing sun in his eyes but he was his as usual nonchalant self not even offering an apology to the bowler. Sure the game was won, but he comes from the Phil Tufnell school of outfielding. Usman's knock was sublime, that shot through gully/point dissecting the field was a magnificent cricket shot of the highest quality. And on whilst on the subject of elegant batsmen, Kane Williamson proved he is close to the world's No.1 steering the Kiwi's home this morning. Averaging just over 90 for the calendar year and only playing 8 tests to reach over 1,000 runs is a fair achievement in anyone's language. What a great day of cricket yesterday, Womens WBBL, Test in Hamilton, back 2 back BBL games. Christmas came early & it was tempting to crack open the half leg of ham in the fridge whilst the missus went Christmas shopping for the 8th consecutive weekend for over 7 + hours. Thank you Jesus :)

AUTHOR

2015-12-21T02:06:16+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


It was Haddin in the end, and for the reasons above I reckon he deserved to get it. Lyon took the wickets, sure, but many of them were batsman error (four in my estimation). Haddin's knock, on the other hand, was what allowed the Sixers to post a very good score, and that's why I think the selectors (whoever they are) were right to go with him. Re the crowds, I'm not sure how much you can read into them at this early stage of the tournament. I've not seen anybody saying they're bad though, and I have read Thunder v Sixers on the opening night was one of the Thunder's bigger crowds in recent years. Funny what happens when you play at a half decent stadium!

2015-12-21T01:28:35+00:00

Paul Nicholls

Roar Guru


Nathan. Agreed. A double header with a East Coast match starting at 7:10 AEST with the Scorchers game straight after. I would stay up and watch it. The kids and a lot of parents are on holidays - we don't all go to bed at 9:30

2015-12-21T01:26:21+00:00

Paul Nicholls

Roar Guru


Nice write up Ryan. Who was man of the match? When I was leaving the SCG the interview said that they were talking to the man of the match Nathan Lyon. To me, Hobart would have given themselves a chance to win when they started batting - it was Lyon who took the wind right out of their sails - ("enviscerated" - oooh that doesn't sound much fun) Was a great opening few days. Are the crowds a trifle disappointing?

AUTHOR

2015-12-21T00:49:58+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


It would be the Marsh-iest way to end his test career, there's no doubt about that! I guess the problem would be punting on Burns leaves the team a little heavy on middle order bats. Marsh has opened before, but he's not an international standard opener, while Burns has shown enough to be given time to develop into that role. So its a shame, because I'm a SOS booster, but he has to make way. I tend to think Marsh is a better exponent of short form batting, too, and would be surprised if he didn't make the WT20 squad based on his track record alone (even though he didn't play in the ODI World Cup). On your second one, I'll admit I haven't watched enough SOK to give you a good answer. But I know there's been big wraps on him in the past; Lyon has turned into an excellent tweaker where he was perhaps seen as a bit of a long shot to do well. O'Keefe could be the bowling equivalent of Brad Hodge - a product of poor timing by his parents.

AUTHOR

2015-12-21T00:42:08+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


It was looking really dicey at the end there for sure. KP was using the pace of the ball brilliantly in getting ball to the leg side boundary (which was just as he intimated he would do to the commentary team). It really could've fallen apart for them, and I'll admit when I saw it was Kallis coming into bowl the last over to Faulkner (who eats medium-fast for breakfast on the leg side) I thought it was game over (I even changed the sub-heading of the first story from "Flipping the script" to "Flipping the script, almost" as I was writing). Faulkner's brain fart of a scoop shot attempt was one of the worst cricketing decisions I've seen for a long time. Ahmed is really, really crafty. His action looks pretty effortless, but the way he can vary the angle of the ball is really dangerous.

AUTHOR

2015-12-21T00:37:46+00:00

Ryan Buckland

Expert


Yeah I don't get that one at all. In the past they've done the early season Scorchers games as Sunday double-headers or just on the weekend (I believe, don't quote me); so the crowd can get there at the start and so its still in the sweet spot on TV. Still, its apparently a sell out, so we'll have to wait and see what the crowd looks like at the first ball. I, for one, would love to get to a Scorchers game but they're just too early in the day during the week.

2015-12-21T00:20:42+00:00

TheCunningLinguistic

Guest


Good article, Ryan. Couple of assumptions I would like to question, though... Does Khawaja come back in at Marsh's expense, or do the selectors give Burns the punt, just for a while? I've heard all the arguments for & against, my thinking is that the selectors might back Marsh, more for his fighting 49 than the Hobart knock. I reckon they're hoping he has turned the corner and finally achieved some consistency, which I tend to (cautiously) agree with. The other question is whether Lyon is Australia's best international spinner by default? Not taking anything away from Lyon, he has done an admirable job for Australia, and is a very good spinner. He deserves his place now, but I believe that we could have had an even better international spinner, had O'Keefe been given a go. We'll never know unless Lyon suffers a major injury and SOK has an extended run, not that I would ever wish an injury to a player! It would be nice to see if I was right, though... For the record, I'm talking about the Test format, as I don't believe SOK excels in the shorter variants.

2015-12-21T00:13:56+00:00

Nathan Absalom

Roar Guru


I thought the Thunder almost threw it away last night by not bowling their spinner. KP doesn't have many flaws, but he often fails to pick wrong 'uns from leggies and I really thought that Ahmed should have been bowled an extra over. He only went for 20 in his three overs, and the change of pace and spin on the ball would have made it that little bit harder to score. I think he's an essential part of the Thunder attack, even though their seamers are all quite different as they need that extra variety that the spinning ball of the leggie provides.

2015-12-21T00:05:58+00:00

Nathan of Perth

Guest


4pm on a monday afternoon start for the Scorchers. Truly mad fixturing...

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar