Five takeaways from a full Super Rugby first round

By Elisha Pearce / Expert

We are back! They are playing real games that matter and it’s great.

The first week of Super Rugby yielded a mix of rugby, a lot of points and plenty of tries. That’s a win for us viewers.

I’ve got five quick takeaways from Round 1.

Rugby is fun – so much rugby is even more fun
There are significant issues with the Super Rugby competition with the way it is set up. The imbalance of it and confusing alignment of some teams are real issues. However, one benefit of how this happens is the amount of rugby on.

With 18 teams and the new addition of teams in Japan and Argentina the effect is like an avalanche of rugby. The schedulers were creative and skilful this week – providing us with three games on Friday night and a back-to-back-to-back etc run on Saturday that rivals Michael Jordan’s Bulls championships for continuity.

Unlike Brett, I didn’t sit on the couch for 13 hours straight because unfortunately I had family and friends to attend to. But the option of doing so is fantastic, and I was definitely paying far too much attention all weekend.

For rugby lovers out there the new set up is definitely a win. The strange competition certainly took a back seat to the pleasure of having more games than you could poke a stick at this weekend. Maybe the odd alignments or confusing seeding will raise its head further down the track.

Jaguares won!
Speaking of new teams, the Argentina side notched up a win in their first outing. What an achievement.

In terms of rugby quality, the Jaguares left a bit to be desired. They were on the wrong end of a number of cards and penalties and could have been more harshly dealt with. A player has already been suspended for a week.

Raul Perez will have a lot to think about and try to improve after scraping through against the Cheetahs, but winning away in Super Rugby is always tough and to do so in the first game of a club’s existence is a fantastic achievement.

So strong is this Jaguares squad, which is full of Argentina national team players and Rugby World Cup stars, it’s not out of question they could sneak into the playoffs. The Africa 2 Conference is guaranteed an entry into the playoffs. They are up against the Sharks, Lions and Southern Kings – not a group of death by any means.

Apart from winning their conference, what should be a good home ground advantage and some other weak South African sides means there is a clear path to at least seven wins in their debut season.

The team to beat is probably the Sharks, who are coming off a poor Super Rugby year. They flogged the Kings 43-8 on the weekend, but that fixture is more like an extra pre-season battle than a Super Rugby match.

All this means the Round 2 clash in Durban is important for the Jaguares. Is it too early to call it a double points game?

Hurricanes aren’t that good
Last week I predicted the Hurricanes were going to act like a buzzsaw and chew through this Super Rugby competition for a second season in a row. I went as far as to say they might be better than last year’s team. That’s obviously not the case.

The Hurricanes of last year weren’t unbeatable, but they certainly weren’t going to lose 52-10 against anyone, let alone in a statement game against another early-season favourite.

After the first round, my impression is the New Zealand conference is close again this year. I’ll stand by my thoughts that the Hurricanes, Highlanders and Chiefs will separate themselves eventually, but it’s going to be something like a peloton for a while.

Brumbies are the front runners
A few people didn’t agree with my assessment last week that the Brumbies were the team to beat in Australia, preferring to back the Waratahs in.

Their first game against the Hurricanes was certainly enough to put that to bed surely. The Brumbies are the February Favourites and have stolen an early-March march.

What was particularly enjoyable about their demolition effort in Canberra was the speed with which they went about their work. There was an intent and familiarity about their performance, something not all that common in week one.

Which brings me to the other side of the equation – if the Waratahs were to be early-season favourites they should have beaten the Reds by at least 40 on Saturday night. The Reds were penalising themselves into the ground all night and generally allowing the Waratahs to run whatever they wanted.

It wasn’t a poor performance by the Waratahs, but the second half showed a lot of rust to be worked through.

Rebels, don’t get too excited too early
Last year the Rebels were everyone’s darling side and they improved on previous seasons’ results. Some of that gloss rubbed off into how people viewed them at the start of this season as well, as something of a dark horse.

A 25-19 win against the Force is job done, but wasn’t too much to be excited about. The game was a bit of a typical mid-season Aussie derby; everyone tried but it wasn’t the stuff of rugby dreams.

Nic Stirzaker has been, somewhat prematurely, talked up as a star. He has been given the captaincy and missed the first game and is likely to miss Round 2 as well. Mike Harris and Colby Fainga’a have come home instead of going to South Africa as well.

While they are a young team trying to take the next step up, the Rebels aren’t on as solid footing as some might want to believe. Having potential is nice, but Super Rugby doesn’t play nice.

It’s still going to be a long year for the Rebels if the first couple of weeks are anything to go by. Any small improvement, even without making the finals, is a good result for them in this very tough competition.

The Crowd Says:

2016-03-03T00:31:10+00:00

NGM

Guest


I think the new bonus point scenario is a major bust. Reward strong teams for caning weak teams, but penalise two strong teams playing each other that score plenty of tries each. Whoever came up with this brain explosion should go back to watching soccer

2016-03-02T16:29:45+00:00

Nobrain

Roar Guru


For Jaguares to win away games is very stressfull, they are at least 12 hrs on a plane from home while for NZ teams for exaplle they take a couple hours by bus. My predictions are 7/8 w/l for the first year and if they make it 8/7 they can be playoff contenders. The NZ tour will tax them and they have to go to Japan right after that, that means they will be 1.5 month away from home.

2016-03-02T14:02:25+00:00

Die hard

Roar Rookie


ooops, confused so much already

2016-03-02T14:00:46+00:00

Die hard

Roar Rookie


No I cannot Peter. I need overhead cameras, slow motion, your and PeterC's analysis and a good wine to fully understand what happened post game most times. I was just saying, thats all. Maybe also copying something I read in the papers. Maybe venting against and infective referee also a bit. The Brumbies deserved the win but do not deserve the February champions title/chalice either.

2016-03-02T12:26:09+00:00

MatthewSkellett

Guest


Is anyone else irritated by the 'new improved' " rugby 360'" on fox ?

2016-03-02T09:18:29+00:00

Johnny J-Dog

Guest


You forgot one - Reds will finish above the Waratahs.

2016-03-02T09:06:46+00:00

Kasey

Guest


I'm from Adelaide so nominally a football (AU) and AFL(crows) man, but after a two year stint in Canberra in the late 1990s, when I watch rugby I barrack for the Brumbies. I still don't understand the nuances of the 15 man game and perhaps I never will but do enjoy watching it and I will always prefer Rugby over League so bring on the Waratahs this Friday night :) I hope the ARU can bring the Wallabies to Adelaide Oval soon even though oval venues aren't the best for rectangular field sports. Do the Australian second XIV still exist? aka Australia A. A game vs a Pacific Island team if we cant have the first fifteen vs the Springboks for example:)

2016-03-02T08:56:47+00:00

redbull

Guest


6. Umaga manna lifts blue Blues?

2016-03-02T07:06:02+00:00

PeterK

Roar Guru


jaguares play every single NZ team , and you watch the NZ teams

2016-03-02T07:05:11+00:00

PeterK

Roar Guru


can you point to specifics where the scrum rulings were wrong?

2016-03-02T07:03:27+00:00

PeterK

Roar Guru


Not a big leg up at all for the oz teams actually. NZ teams plays 5 oz teams and 6 NZ teams. Oz teams play 5 NZ teams and 6 oz teams, hardly a BIG difference. They both play 4 SA conference teams.

2016-03-02T05:29:18+00:00

Die hard

Roar Rookie


I am dying to see the Jaguares and am so disappointed they are mainly playing SA teams.

2016-03-02T05:27:38+00:00

Die hard

Roar Rookie


The ref really took the wind out of the Hurricanes sails at crucial times. The Canes scrum shunted the Brums in the first few exchanges and then Toomaga Allen suddenly was penalised out of the game. Pocock forgot to release the tackler every time in his own half and killed the game and got away with it till a few minutes to go. Richie would be reviled for such a game but suddenly ours are alright with it. For sure the Canes really dropped their bundle but I am not reading too much into the one sided nature of it all. I suspect a more even result if they could play it again this weekend.

2016-03-02T05:22:19+00:00

Die hard

Roar Rookie


Many teams playing the Force away cop them on the way home from SA which somewhat advantages the Force.

2016-03-02T05:20:49+00:00

Die hard

Roar Rookie


Yes I think that we might see plenty of losing bonus points but no try bonus points from NZ this year. That will be a big leg up for teams here and in SA where each conference has a few easy beats.

2016-03-02T04:59:27+00:00

Dean

Guest


Fainga'a will be the big improver for the Rebels this year, stood out from the rest when he was on the park on Saturday. Much better than he was previously, though it was only a brief stint to judge.

2016-03-02T02:40:13+00:00

Simon Bedard

Roar Pro


I think it is a wee bit early to be talking favourites or to be dismissing any particular teams. Week 1 is rarely a reflection of what the season entails, but I agree that it is great to be back into Super Rugby and can only hope we continue to see quality rather than just quantity. Despite being a Waratahs fan, I am particularly hopeful we will see some good performances from the Force, the Rebels, the Sunwolves and Jaguares.

2016-03-02T01:26:38+00:00

hambone

Guest


Thanks for the write up and what a Saturday it was.. A moooonster, kept Nana napping only to wake up to more rugby, twas really a thing of beauty.. Japanese crowd was a highlight, looks like it could really be the engine that drives the team, interesting to see crowd super pulls in Singapore though. Brumbies have had a massive preseason and really hot the ground running, my ole faves the rebels could push the bulls and grab that elusive first win in the republic, but we need our halves back, aleast one of them... It's good to have rugby back in our lives. Ha-ha

2016-03-02T01:06:26+00:00

Digby

Roar Guru


Thanks EP. I am not to down on my lads, think credit has to be paid to a very good Brumbies performance. Generic stats as those posted about the match on the Sanzar website suggest the same but then I would manipulate it in that way ;)

2016-03-02T01:06:15+00:00

Sandgroper

Guest


Hey EP, Nice aliteration early in the first half. Keep the faith and let's see some onomatopoeia. I love that word. Sounds like a Polynesian village! The conditions in Perth were probably about 10 degrees too hot. The real problem seemed to be the playing surface was slippery like it had been over watered. Something I wouldn't recommend when playing a Melbourne team. The ball was spilling out like a greasy pig. Both teams also blew some easy points. The Brumbies looked awesome to me, let's see if they can do it week in week out on the road.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar