Hot heads, the NRL bunker and the impotent Dragons

By Tom Rock / Expert

Hot heads. Loose cannons. Powder kegs. You know the type. These are the blokes fuelled by aggression and raw emotion, the type of players that takes every tackle personally.

They see red mist at the slightest provocation, and seem to be the third man in for every stoush, regardless of where they were on the field when it started. Their fiery disposition can captivate fans and inspire teammates, but unfortunately it can also betray them.

So who are the fieriest customers in the game today? Here are five of the best (or is it worst?).

Martin Taupau
Over the last couple of seasons, big Marty has become one of the most intimidating enforcers in the NRL, delivering more swinging arms than an octopus being tenderised.

Renowned for his short fuse, Taupau garnered international infamy when he performed a throat slitting gesture in the direction of Sam Thaiday after rising from a contentious tackle. Disciplinary action against Marty was suggested, yet no one was game enough to tell him.

David Klemmer
Klemmer announced himself on the national stage when he erupted into the State of Origin arena like the second coming of Mark Geyer. His wild intensity and unhinged physicality got under Queensland’s skin faster than a bag full of scabies. Maroons veteran Corey Parker took particular exception to the gargantuan Bulldogs prop, mounting his high horse and channelling his inner Aretha Franklin, proclaiming his actions were “disrespectful.”

Klemmer eloquently responded in true rugby league fashion with “Get f—ed you c—”.

Josh Reynolds
The man they call ‘Grub’ has epitomised the brain explosion in recent seasons. In fact, fans sitting in the front few rows of Bulldogs games have taken to wearing spray jackets, protecting them from the inevitable spattering of grey matter.

Reynolds himself recently admitted that the pressure of retaining his NSW No. 6 jersey brought out the worst in him, leading to a John Hopoate-esque six suspensions in 12 months. While a summer of cognitive aerobics cooled his volcanic temperament, Reynolds still handles pressure worse than a Faberge egg.

Greg Bird
Consider this one more of a lifetime achievement nomination. Bird’s impressive tally of 29 weeks spent on the sidelines through suspension compares favourably to some of the dirtiest players of all time.

Bird studied a Bachelor of Niggle under Professor Gallen early in his career, learning the intricacies of the eye gouge and squirrel grip, among other colourful tactics. Age may have slowed him, but the fire still burns.

Andrew Fifita
My nomination has to go to Cronulla firebrand Andrew Fifita. The Sharks forward has a magnetism for controversy, making him almost impossible to ignore. Whether it’s a tackle-busting rampage, a careless dropped ball or baffling brain snap, there is just something about the man which bears watching.

While scouring the depths of Wikipedia, I stumbled across some little known metrics which encapsulate Fifita’s style of play to perfection. Through five rounds this season, Fifita leads the league with an average of 2.5 error-induced opposition head rubs, 1.8 pushing melees and 3.1 open handed slaps.

Debunking the Bunker – Greenberg’s secret plan
Ridiculous conspiracy theory alert!

Perhaps the most infuriating aspect of rugby league is the perceived influence the officials have in determining the outcome of a game. But, much like overpriced mid-strength beer and the second-man play, blaming the ref has now woven itself into the very fabric of the game.

Coaches and fans are quick to shift the blame from their players to the whistle-blowers, lamenting botched decisions instead of focusing on missed opportunities. Monday mornings see talkback radio hijacked by disgruntled fans, arguing with whoever will listen that their team would have won on the weekend if only a few 50/50 calls had gone their way.

So who in their right mind would want to become a referee? Spend 80 gruelling minutes running up and down, back and forth, making hundreds of snap decisions on the run. And if you make a mistake, the whole thing is televised live across the country.

Enter Todd Greenberg, new CEO of the National Rugby League. As a long time referee sympathiser, Greenberg was determined to preserve the men in pink. And so with a blank cheque written by his predecessor Dave Smith, Greenberg formulated the most expensive ruse in the history of the NRL.

The launch of the $2 million dollar Bunker was seen as a new dawn in rugby league officiating. Efficiency, accuracy and consistency. State of the art technology to ensure every decision was the right one. But did Todd Greenberg have an ulterior motive?

The word around the traps is the Bunker is simply an elaborate front to deflect criticism from the on-field officials. After a successful launch, the Bunker made a few calculated blunders, such as the ruling on the forward pass in the Bulldogs versus Eels game, allowing fans and coaches to shift their crosshairs away from the cowering referees and instead lock on to the faceless Bunker.

And hasn’t it worked!

The officials are now referring even the most rudimentary decisions ‘upstairs’, ensuring the stinging criticism is heaped on the broad shoulders of technology.

And the best part? Unlike its human counterparts, if the Bunker starts to malfunction, Greenberg can simply follow the same process applied to all haywire technology. Turn it off, and turn it on again.

Dragons need to start hanging with Mr Cooper
The Dragons have long had problems in attack. In the five years since they won the 2010 Premiership, St George Illawarra have ranked no higher than eighth in points scored, including ranking 15th in 2013 and dead last in 2012.

The signing of Gareth Widdop was designed to address their flaccid attack, yet his pairing with Benji Marshall has been patchier than Donald Trump’s tandoori tan.

St George fans and their coaching staff have previously defended their attacking ineptitude, but surely the ostrich-sized egg from their game against the Cowboys will end all debate: big changes are needed at the Dragons.

For the second time this season, an opposition team has criticised the Dragons attack during post-game media commitments. Following their game against Cronulla a couple of weeks ago, coach Shane Flanagan confessed that the Dragons “didn’t throw anything at us,” before NRL Golden Boy Johnathan Thurston confirmed this week the Saints “didn’t offer much.”

In a sport where extracting honest and original comments during post-game interviews is harder than a woodpecker’s lips, this is a massive indication of just how much strife the Dragons are in.

The solution? I believe they need to sell their soul for Cooper Cronk. While the mercurial Melbournian is getting a little long in the tooth, he has shown no signs of slowing, as running down Valentine Holmes from behind clearly displayed.

His clinical kicking game and underrated running game would instantly put fire back in the Dragons’ bellies. Reuniting Widdop with his former Storm teammate will immediately boost the Dragons’ ability to post points, and complement their already formidable defence.

Cronk would not come cheap, but he would be worth every cent. And while early reports suggest he is negotiating only with Melbourne, Cronk knows this will be his last contract, and is likely to want to maximise his earning capacity before hanging up his boots.

Finishing his career in Sydney allows media opportunities and third party agreements which just don’t exist in Melbourne. If Peter Doust ponies up enough cash, this seems like win-win scenario.

The Crowd Says:

2016-04-05T04:46:39+00:00

Ken

Guest


No, they didn't. McCrone is definitely a better defender, very strong for a half. In attack though he offered little, while Marshall at least had a few moments and could have created something if the rest of the team were giving him options. It could possibly be said that McCrone being on the field forced Widdop to take more control, but that's damning with faint praise isn't it? Also McCrone must have the worst kicking game of any active half. It's not just the kicks themselves but the decision making, 3 times in 2 games he executed beautiful 3rd tackle kicks straight to a defender.

AUTHOR

2016-04-04T23:37:12+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


The dude seems to have more demons that a gothic church. Queensland will be hoping we pick him. Good for at least 3 penalties and a couple of dropped balls each game.

2016-04-04T23:24:26+00:00

Dogs Of War

Roar Guru


Fifta is head and shoulders above Gallen. The guy is just looking for trouble.

AUTHOR

2016-04-04T23:16:43+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


Gallen certainly does belong on this list. My mistake. Although when I watch a Sharkies game, I still think Fifita is head and shoulders above the rest as the biggest grub on the field.

2016-04-04T14:40:41+00:00

Michael l

Guest


If your gonna name name professor Gallen in there, surely he has to be on the list.

2016-04-04T07:05:00+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


lol I didn't realise it was today. That's crazy.

2016-04-04T06:13:21+00:00

Squidward

Roar Rookie


All this WWE reference is fitting on Wrestlemania 32 day of all days

2016-04-04T05:33:48+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


Well if anyone knows there way around wrestlemania, it's Queenslanders.

2016-04-04T04:08:19+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


You need depth. I don't have a problem with the signings of Mann or Lafai. McGregor needs to come up with game plans that his team can play to. Dugan isn't a ball playing fullback? Neither is Brett Morris or Hopoate and it hasn't stifled the Dogs. Mead isn't a ball player - he's in the best form of his life. There's ways around it that McGregor doesn't seem to be or is incapable of searching for. If Marshall is getting old then either devise a game plan for him or get rid of him. Soward barely gets tackled at the Panthers these days but still controls the game masterfully. Marshall was doing it better last year - don't tell me he has deteriorated that much in five months. All I'm saying is the personnel they've got on the park belies a team that is averaging 8 points a game after five matches.

AUTHOR

2016-04-04T04:07:49+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


Where is Steve Price when you need him?

AUTHOR

2016-04-04T04:06:52+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


I am sure a host of Queenslanders will be lining up to give Bird some Sweet Chin Music come Origin time.

2016-04-04T04:00:17+00:00

Walter Penninger

Roar Guru


McGregor needs to shoulder some blame here. He has the team he wanted and he tried the experiment with Dugan at centre despite being swamped with centres. McGregor chose Widdop as Captain. McGregor played Aitken on the Wing and then dropped him. McGregor failed to make any effective changes last year and is still making vague warnings now. Benji is not the Captain and he is not a Magician so why all the focus on him? The whole team is playing like a mob of sheep so the coach is responsible. Backing your defence is one thing but it does not leave any room for error. The Dragons are not done yet and are doing better than I expected from a tough draw but it is time to drop Lafai who has done nothing in the centres and promote a young back and a forward. Carr and McCarthy could be worth a try.

2016-04-04T03:57:27+00:00

The eye

Guest


That was a Frank Paul shove..all venom..Ryan James jumped in to try and save Birdy..and you saw what became of that..

2016-04-04T03:55:42+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


One of the reasons the great Shawn "The Heart Break Kid" Michaels was considered a legend of the WWE was not just because of his own skills in taking down opponents, but also because of how good he could make an opponent look when he was supposed to. Bird could give him a run for his money.

AUTHOR

2016-04-04T03:53:47+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


I agree with the recruitment of the forwards, adding to an already strong pack. But if they planned on switching Dugan to the centres to give them a ball playing fullback, then why spend money on Lafai, especially when you already have depth in Mata’utia? I am not sure what the definition of tier one internationals is, but having Benji sitting anywhere on the podium, let along tier one of anything, is shocking. I understand he used to be a great player, an international, a game changer, and he had his moments last year. But it just isn't there anymore. What's worse, he seems to be stifling Widdop at the same time.

2016-04-04T03:48:03+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I don't think there's too much wrong with recruitment. They have tier one internationals in the 1, 5, 6 & 7 jerseys. Add Lafai and Mata'utia who played for Samoa when they acquited themselves so well in the four nations. The other player in the backline is up and comer Aitken. So there's nothing wrong with that backline - other than how they're playing. Same with their forward pack. Packer and Cooper are internationals. Frizell is on the cusp of a NSW jersey. Rein and De Bellin are playing as well as they ever have. The rest are solid professionals at worst. Yet they look like a rabble when they take the field.

AUTHOR

2016-04-04T03:41:34+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


It is getting a bit ridiculous. I saw him cop a slight palm to the face from an opposition player when they were playing the ball, and he almost hit the back fence with how far he flew backwards through the air. Maybe soccer would suit him better.

2016-04-04T03:33:08+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


Greg Bird has turned his attention to acting. Having dished out his fair share of niggle over a long career, he has had a long time to study his victims and can now "sell" better than any superstar in the WWE. A wayward forearm slides off the ball? Watch in amazement at the way Bird clutches his throat, gasping for air. A slight leg twist? Watch him spasm around the field like a dying fish, his face twisted in agony. I'm surprised his name wasn't read out at the logie nominee announcements.

AUTHOR

2016-04-04T03:23:31+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


I'm not entirely sure Mary knows what he is doing. I don't know how much say he has in recruitment, as Doust is running the show in that area, but the players they brought in didn't seem to address a need. And his fiddling around with Dugan, easily the Dragons best since shifting back to fullback, makes me think he is out of his depth.

AUTHOR

2016-04-04T03:21:00+00:00

Tom Rock

Expert


Put a fork in Marshall. There is a reason no one is chasing him, and the Dragons are only offering him chump change to stick around. Just not effective anymore.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar