Move Zach Tuohy into attack

By Aron / Roar Pro

Zach Tuohy looks, and is, fiercely competitive. Sweat pours from his beard down to his body. His eyes dart left and right, scoping out every section of his perimeter.

Due largely to a lack of defensive pressure from the midfield, the ball comes rapidly into his area. He’s matched up on an opponent who is, far too often, bigger and stronger or faster and craftier. Not scrappier though, for he tenaciously scraps and claws and struggles with every ounce of aggression that he possesses to force the ball away.

But, often enough, Tuohy’s endeavour is unsuccessful. He’s outgunned, loses the contest and the ball lands comfortably in the opposition’s hands. His head falls down, hands go on thighs and the last vestige of frustration – an image which projects one hundred thousand words – is the pointing. Sometimes at Sammy Rowe, for he is often, in some capacity, to blame.

Following a huddle, head bounces back up and he returns to his defensive post. The dreadful process repeats ad infinitum.

Now, did all of this actually happen with Zach Tuohy, or is it just a scenario I, with too much time on my hands, made up? While it’s almost definitely the latter (particularly regarding his sweaty beard) I think the one point remains salient. Hard as he tries, he has the propensity to lose contests against the second, third or fourth forward inside his defensive fifty.

He has one tremendous asset, though, which is his penetrative, accurate right peg. And he gets to use it really productively every fortnight or so.

A guy like Levi Casboult will take a strong mark around the forward 50 arc. His first thought is to have a crack but, after missing the first few, he’ll look to alleviate the responsibility from himself and hear Tuohy screaming for the ball.

He’ll lay it off to the Irish dynamo and, with a monumental strike, the ball will sail through the big sticks from outside fifty. Muscles are pumped, Tuohy will release a guttural roar with the Carlton fans and his teammates will jump and crush him because this is apparently a pleasant sign of affection.

Here’s my point. Well, it’s more of a prayer. Please, benevolent football Gods, move Tuohy closer to goal. He’s tough, strong around the contest and has great skills. He’d be such an asset forward of the centre square and it’s a shame we don’t get to see him kick these goals more often.

Let him follow in the footpaths of great Irish forwards like Setanta O’Hailpin and, um, others.

Now, I can almost hear the cries of distress.

First, I hear you murmur, how can we reallocate the guy named by the venerated coaches as the All-Australian back pocket last year? Well, my pragmatic and really well thought-out theory is that they recognised how valuable he could be to the mighty CFC closer to goal, and named him in the back-pocket in a sneaky attempt to keep him there. A massive, collusive conspiracy took place and all we can do is watch.

The second hurl of abuse that I hear from this noise in my head – which I’ve anthropomorphised to be a hodgepodge of angry Roarers – is that we can’t release Zach Tuohy from his cage, because we don’t have the luxury of a replacement. Like Bret Thornton at full-back for much of the 21st century, he’s just indispensable for us back there.

The only response I have for this is to get another Irishman, Ciaran Byrne, in there. It’s time for us to start feeling the Byrne.

The Crowd Says:

2016-04-22T09:05:34+00:00

hal

Guest


Totally agree. Casboult cannot kick whereas Tuohy can. They have nothing to lose.

2016-04-19T05:11:23+00:00

macca

Guest


I think he has been as impressive as ever. Bolton is trying to use him more "outside" than he has been in recent years which has seen him getting a bit more of the ball. I would also like to agree with your summation of Rowe - now that Plowman has come in I think Rowe's days are numbered, he dropped numerous marks that he should have taken on Saturday night and that is turning a rebound opportunity into a goal against to often. On numbers Touhy, Simpson and Docherty are all averaging career high rebound 50's with 4, 5.2 and 5.2 respectively.

AUTHOR

2016-04-19T05:02:51+00:00

Aron

Roar Pro


Out of curiosity, what have you made of Simpson's impact this year compared to previous years?

2016-04-19T04:50:48+00:00

macca

Guest


So far this year Kade Simpson has averaged 26.2 disposals and 7.8 marks (career highs for both) and Sam Docherty has averaged 24.2 disposals and 8 marks (again career highs) while Tuohy has averaged 19 disposals (career high) and 4.2 marks (just down on last years career high of 4.9) - I think Tuohys reliability and ability to defend greatly assists the other 2 in providing run and drive. Interestingly Tuohys disposal efficiency of 75% is the lowest of the 3 with Docherty going at 78.4% and Simpson at 82.9%.

2016-04-19T03:29:31+00:00

Darren

Guest


Aron that is more to do with the teams inability to execute team offense and defence. This will improve over time. For example Burgoyne is an attacking asset for Hawthorn (even though named in defence). But he still does what the team needs from defence. To me, Tuohy is definitely of greater value in the back half of the ground setting up attack/counter attack.

AUTHOR

2016-04-19T03:01:36+00:00

Aron

Roar Pro


Totally understand that. The issue I have is that, in playing a key defensive role, he doesn't get as much freedom to use his elite kicking as I'd like. I think he'd be more of an asset to the team kicking inside the forward 50 more often.

2016-04-19T02:52:42+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Most sides are trying to deploy an elite kick across the half back line these days.

2016-04-18T23:33:44+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Shades of Daniel Rich – one of the best kicks in the competition and yet spends far too much time away from goal.

2016-04-18T23:26:56+00:00

macca

Guest


Can't agree with this, Tuohy is very good defensively and provides plenty of run off half back, still pushes high enough to get the handball from the bloke just to far out to score and most importantly he uses the ball very well which is what we want from a running defender. I don't see throwing him forward will solve any problems for the blues and definitely won't make best use of his assets.

Read more at The Roar