AFL Power Rankings: Round 8

By Michael DiFabrizio / Expert

The swagger levels around the streets and suburbs of Melbourne will be elevated this morning. Collingwood and Richmond are back on the winners list.

Will it take the pressure off their coaches? In the short term, absolutely.

The Pies were expected to face a tough challenge at the Gabba, but they put the Brisbane Lions away by quarter time. Nathan Buckley can breathe a little easier.

As always, drama wasn’t far away from the Tigers at the MCG against the Sydney Swans.

Sam Lloyd’s after the siren bomb has doubled the win tally and given Damien Hardwick some space, too.

Throw in Carlton’s four game win streak and you’ll find there’s a noticeable buzz in the Victorian capital.

It didn’t start out as a year with too much to brag about for Melbourne’s traditional power clubs.

Their legions of supporters will no doubt take the opportunity this week.


No change // Ladder: 2nd (7W, 1L)

The Cats haven’t settled on a back six yet, but the resting strategy seems to be working. They allowed the Crows and their impressive collection of forward targets just eight marks inside 50 on Friday. A good interstate win that could have been more comprehensive (see the 5.13 to 5.1 half time score line).

No change // Ladder: 3rd (6W, 2L)

Bring. On. The. Next. Month. We’re about to find out just how serious the Giants are this season. Western Bulldogs (home), Adelaide (away), Geelong (away) and Sydney (home) await. Good timing for Jeremy Cameron (seven goals against Gold Coast) to start hitting form.

+2 // Ladder: 5th (6W, 2L)

Tom Liberatore equalled the tackle record with his 19 against Melbourne. Not too bad for someone who also had 25 disposals and seven clearances. Big game coming up this week against GWS.

No change // Ladder: 1st (8W, 0L)

The Roos led 8.6 to 0.4 at half time against Essendon. After that, foot and pedal became well and truly separated. Brad Scott described it as a win that felt like a loss, but you have to ask the question — do North even remember what a loss feels like?

-2 // Ladder: 4th (6W, 2L)

That’s the second below-par game against below-par opposition in three weeks. Luke Parker has had his quietest two games of the season in the last fortnight after his hot start to the year. Buddy Franklin keeps on keeping on, though.

No change // Ladder: 6th (6W, 2L)

Last week we highlighted Liam Shiels laying 16 tackles and how it was rare for someone to have as many tackles as disposals in a game. Well, against Fremantle, he was at it again — 15 and 15 — and complimented it with a record-equalling 10 tackles in the third quarter.

+2 // Ladder: 7th (5W, 3L)

Nothing like a 103-point victory to restore spirits. West Coast made a statement in the first quarter against St Kilda, kicking nine of the game’s 23 goals. Josh Kennedy led the way with five.

-1 // Ladder: 8th (4W, 4L)

The Crows were in the contest late against the Cats, perhaps helped on by the Cats’ inaccuracy in the first half. But across the four quarters, the Crows had 56 fewer disposals, a lower disposal efficiency, 17 fewer inside 50s, two fewer clearances and 18 fewer intercept possessions. Oh, and 12 more free kicks. Are we still keeping count of those?

-1 // Ladder: 10th (4W, 4L)

The Power haven’t been at their best, but could they be letting a golden opportunity slip? They are a third of the way through a nine game stretch that features only two opponents from the current top eight. You can build a season off such runs — if you take care of the sides like Carlton, the ones you’re expected to beat. (And it’s particularly the case when sides like Carlton are battling in-game injuries.)

+1 // Ladder: 9th (4W, 4L)

Were outplayed by a better team against the Western Bulldogs. A positive was youngster Christian Petracca, who had 20 disposals, seven inside 50s and a goal.

+2 // Ladder: 11th (4W, 4L)

Four wins in a row and suddenly we’re tempted to ask, is this really a side at the beginning of a rebuild? The Blues may have only won by two but they went at 76 disposal efficiency compared to Port Adelaide’s 68 per cent. And they had 79 (yes, 79!) more disposals in the first place. They won almost any stat you care to mention, actually.

+5 // Ladder: 12th (3W, 5L)

As good a performance as you can ask after a week in the spotlight. Comprehensively destroyed the Lions and even showed a few answers to the questions that had been asked of them. The Pies had 19 marks inside 50, only the second time this season they had more than 10 in a game.

-3 // Ladder: 14th (2W, 6L)

There have been weeks where St Kilda have looked like their three-figure defeats were behind them. But inconsistency remains.

+1 // Ladder: 15th (2W, 6L)

To see every Tiger player sprinting from all directions to get around Sam Lloyd, their second victory in two months secured, was a great footy moment. Big tick for Ben Griffiths, who had a career-high night for disposals (20) and goals (five).

-1 // Ladder: 18th (0W, 8L)

The winless Dockers had the reigning premiers on the back foot in Launceston. The Hawks, as expected, found a way. Perhaps hosting Richmond at Domain Stadium is an opportunity to get on the board.

No change // Ladder: 13th (3W, 5L)

The monster losses continue. This time it was the competition’s other expansion club — the one starting 12 months behind the Suns — handing out a 91-point hiding. Ouch.

-5 // Ladder: 16th (1W, 7L)

A car wreck of a performance. Collingwood had 21 scoring shots before the Lions finally got on the board half-way through the second quarter. In that time the Pies had seven players with double-digit possessions to Brisbane’s one. Contested possessions were -23. Inside 50s were -29. They simply hadn’t come to play. For a side with every right to feel within reaching distance of their second win, that’s unacceptable.

No change // Ladder: 17th (1W, 7L)

If you’re in Essendon’s position, you look for positives. They were there in the second half against North Melbourne. Never mind the club’s lowest first half score in 101 years.

The Crowd Says:

2016-05-19T01:34:34+00:00

Arky

Guest


I understand all that - but North's win over the Dogs was only 2 rounds earlier. Seems a bit too knee-jerky even for a power ranking.

2016-05-17T00:41:03+00:00

csh

Guest


Can you explain your thinking about keeping the swans above the hawks? I know you've said there's not much in it in those top slots, but the swans performance away against struggling sides has a few of us worried.

2016-05-16T12:32:20+00:00

Macca

Guest


Gorringe might be the next man in - he is still fit isn't he?

2016-05-16T11:28:12+00:00

Swampy

Guest


Starting to get my hopes up the bombers can sneak another win against one of the qld teams

2016-05-16T09:57:45+00:00

Sami

Roar Rookie


And that has what to do with Adelaides midfield?

2016-05-16T08:40:52+00:00

steve

Guest


We seem to be running out of ruckmen for this week Macca, I think we are down to Wood, and he didn't even play on the weekend I think. As long as we see the structures remain in place for the next couple of games and we continue to develop our players and get games into them I will be pretty happy, As long as we don't see what the Lions and Suns are dishing up effort wise I will remain optimistic about where we are heading mate.

2016-05-16T08:36:49+00:00

steve

Guest


Haha, mate my crystal ball only seems to work on Carlton games, cant seem to get a result anywhere else, not the ones I want anyway.

AUTHOR

2016-05-16T08:13:31+00:00

Michael DiFabrizio

Expert


BigAl, I'm not sure reading absolutely nothing into a side losing a half to Essendon by six goals is entirely wise. Top sides in theory should be able to regroup quickly when the likely-wooden-spooners get on a run like that. Obviously I'm with you in that they got the four points and did what they had to do and it wasn't an overly consequential fixture, but it's worth taking note of what happened.

AUTHOR

2016-05-16T08:07:51+00:00

Michael DiFabrizio

Expert


Thanks for reading Dan. You're spot on about this week. There's barely anything between Hawthorn and Sydney in these week's rankings, so you can probably guarantee the winner will pull ahead. GWS have a bit more of a buffer over the Dogs but not much. I'm with you on St Kilda. Can't see them not responding but we'll see.

AUTHOR

2016-05-16T08:05:40+00:00

Michael DiFabrizio

Expert


Can I borrow your crystal ball, steve?

AUTHOR

2016-05-16T08:04:57+00:00

Michael DiFabrizio

Expert


You must be happy with this run macca. Good for Blues fans to see a glimpse into the future early into the Brendon Bolton era.

2016-05-16T07:13:53+00:00

hal

Guest


Well maybe when Richmond beat Hawthorn, West Coast, and Adelaide they may get close to top spot. Don't forget Richmond could not even beat Port. Reality check: Richmond have only won two games. Magoo has been saying for years Geelong are done. He had to admit this morning that Geelong are not done. Even Patrick Smith pulled him up as a Geelong hater. It aint Tiger time yet. Enjoy the win but don't get carried away.

2016-05-16T07:10:16+00:00

swansfan

Guest


ANZ Stadium is a terrible place to watch AFL, I stopped going out there a while ago. I'd be happy to watch at Spotless though. It would have a great atmosphere when packed.

2016-05-16T07:04:44+00:00

Macca

Guest


Steve - the wins will stop for sure - after the bombers wins I mentioned that bewtween Phillips, Casboult & Kreuzer the blues were really starting to get an advantage in contested marking around the ground - being able to go to the bail out kick down the line with reasonable confidence - we will go in this week with all 3 sitting on the injury list which will cause us all sorts of problems (especially going in against north). But the effort and the structures along with the development of players like Plowman, Byrne, Lamb et el still give us plenty of reasons to smile even if the losses do start mounting again for a while.

2016-05-16T06:48:00+00:00

steve

Guest


Another really good win, I'm up a fair few dollars I have backed them for the four wins in a row. I would expect the wins to stop for the next couple of weeks until we come up against the Lions would be our next real chance. As long as the structures and effort and grit remain for the next two weeks I will be happy. Its a real shame for Casboult too, after what was probably his best game last week. I actually think Carlton will miss his general play around the ground, which was excellent over the last few weeks.

2016-05-16T06:45:40+00:00

big four sticks

Guest


Tigers should be number one as we knocked off the Swans. The Tigers will storm into the eight. K.B told me this morning. We don't need a rebuild.

2016-05-16T05:47:36+00:00

Doc Disnick

Roar Guru


Depends really. I wrote an article 2 years ago about being offensively geared relative to the average AFL score. You might find it interesting. More offensively geared teams have won the AFL premiership vs defensive. It's probably 65-70 percent split now taking in the last 2 years of data since I wrote it. The phrase: 'Premierships are won on defence', is not exactly true. It's more like: 'Premierships are more likely to be won based on sound defence, with a solid attack'. It's just statistics really, but when you break it down, more offensively geared teams relative to the baseline average score have won the premiership. A much vaunted attack is critical to sustained success in the AFL, which is why the Cats and Hawks have managed to climb to the the very top (multiple times), yet teams like St Kilda and Freo haven't. The Swans are the only pure defensive outfit to break the trend, but they could easily have joined the long list of bridesmaids if luck had gone the other way. Luck played no factor in most of the Cats and Hawks triumphs.

2016-05-16T05:35:52+00:00

Sami

Roar Rookie


Neither is key. The key is being good at both. You can't be all attack and no defence nor can you be so defensive you can't score yourself.

2016-05-16T05:29:55+00:00

Doc Disnick

Roar Guru


"Basically, it means unless your team averages more than 100 points and concedes fewer than 86 points, it won’t taste the ultimate success." Kingy keeps banging on about this. Offence is key though, built around sound defence. Lake summed it up nicely last week on AFL 360: 'You don't necessarily need to have the best attack or defence, more the right balance between the two. North - lack defence; Bulldogs - limp bite; GWS - limited experience; Hawks - look bored; WCE - poor consistency; Crows - all or bust; and Swans - average at best... ...which really just leaves the almighty concurring Cats. No bias of course there in my stellar analysis. GO CATS!

2016-05-16T05:07:16+00:00

Sami

Roar Rookie


What are you basing that on tom m? Certainly not true during H&A and I very highly doubt it is much different in finals. Don't have much data to go on because the Cats have only been allowed to host a single final.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar