Who will win this year's Rising Star?

By Anthony D'Arcy / Editor

In exactly the sort of situation that Coldplay would love, this year’s race to be the AFL’s Rising Star isn’t down to just one or two, but a Sky Full of Stars.

It’s rare that the first handful of picks in a draft can have such an immediate impact, with last year’s top five selections Jacob Weitering, Josh Schache, Callum Mills, Clayton Oliver and Darcy Parish all contributing on a regular basis, and to a high quality.

Sydney’s academy draftee Mills has slotted in seamlessly into the Swans’ seemingly eternal talent machine, already offering the sort of dependability expected of a 100-game player.

The ease with which he has operated at half-back has come as a nice surprise for John Longmire, given it’s a position that with the loss of Rhyce Shaw and Nick Malceski in recent years they otherwise lack depth in.

Parish, at just 73 kilograms, has managed to be an important factor in Essendon’s understandably undermanned inside midfield, somehow averaging 21 disposals across his 12 games, only falling below 20 disposals twice.

His class – from bursting through a pack and firing off a handball to the advantage of a teammate in space, to smoothly kicking on his opposite foot – has been more than welcomed by the folk down at Tullamarine.

While second-year pair Christian Petracca and Caleb Daniel have worked their way into Rising Star contention, the former boasting a physical presence that defies his youth, and the latter exhibiting the calm decision-making skills of a veteran.

Yet at this admittedly early stage, the clubhouse leader is a certain defender that your Blues friends may have mentioned to you, in that typically modest Carlton way that they do.

Handed the task of living up to the hype of being the number one pick, Carlton’s Weitering has been superb for the Blues.

Weitering’s entire game from his draft year has immediately transferred straight to the AFL, where he has already become an important component of Brendon Bolton’s backline.

The 195-centimetre key defender has already shown the three-dimensional ability of some of the best current defenders in the competition, being able to lock down on an opponent, peel off to intercept opposition entries and offer assured rebound with ball in hand, averaging 16 disposals, six marks and three rebounds a game.

It should come as no surprise that such an improvement in such a crucial position has helped streamline Carlton’s unexpected climb back up the ladder.

In their most recent win – admittedly against cellar-dwellers Brisbane – Weitering was one of the best on ground, acquiring 14 marks and 24 disposals at 79 per cent efficiency, cutting off numerous inside 50s.

Not often is a young player able to so quickly perform to a high level, but it’s even rarer that they can do so from a key position on the ground, where there is a such a significant natural advantage for stronger, more physically mature bodies.

Which makes Weitering’s season thus far – much like Rising Star winner Jesse Hogan’s last year – all the more impressive.

Of course, it is still only halfway through the footballing year.

As there are still ten rounds to go in the home-and-away season, it’s still very possible for one of Daniel, Parish, Petracca, Mills or even Giants young gun – another one, really guys? – Jacob Hopper to overtake the Blues defender.

But if Weitering can keep performing to the same standard he has managed for the majority of the year and avoid any significant injuries, he’ll be difficult to run down.

At this stage, despite his position on the ground, Weitering has put his best foot forward.

The Crowd Says:

2016-06-22T14:02:43+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Freo now has more out than Essendon...even if they counted the suspended 12 plus their injured 4.

2016-06-22T05:20:23+00:00

Richard

Guest


Agree, he`s kicked 19 goals and if he klcks another 10-15 he`s nailed it..

2016-06-22T04:02:46+00:00

the all rounder

Roar Pro


They would indeed!

AUTHOR

2016-06-22T03:39:34+00:00

Anthony D'Arcy

Editor


Compared to previous years, there's a lot of guys this year who you could make a strong case for. Blakely's last six games have been really strong, and if he can continue along those lines then he'll definitely move up towards the top of the ranks. As you say, the headstart he gave might hurt him a bit, but it also might help him through the second half of the season as some other young players will no doubt start to tire.

2016-06-22T03:32:44+00:00

Balthazar

Guest


Maybe, however I was conversing with them rather than taunting. 5 this week (3 seemingly season ending) is not a good return... I hope the club scrutinises the strength and conditioning team closely - i think at one stage this year 6 of the 7 calf injuries were at Freo. More calves done then at your standard abattoir... And what's with putting young Grey back out there on Sunday when he was clearly in intense pain? The kid is as tough as they come but that was pretty stupid of them - now he'll be out for months. Sonny took a very long time to recover from the same injury

AUTHOR

2016-06-22T03:32:20+00:00

Anthony D'Arcy

Editor


Thanks mate. Something happened in editing, but it seems to be all sorted now. I like Blakely's chances a little more than Weller's. So far, Blakely seems to have been given more midfield time and as such is getting a lot more chances to shine. Weller seems to have been playing a bit more up forward and is as a result getting a little less of it, understandably drifting in and out of games. Although his performance against Brisbane the other week was brilliant. Either way, Freo should be pretty happy because they've picked up two guys who are going to add a fair bit to their midfield over the coming years.

AUTHOR

2016-06-22T03:25:21+00:00

Anthony D'Arcy

Editor


Sicily has completely surprised me with how effective he has been at AFL level so quickly. His impact has been pretty damn good so far, and two of his best games have come against quality opposition in the Bulldogs and Kangaroos. Daniel was a top 20 talent in his draft, but as is generally the way, slid down the order because of his height. You're absolutely right about him. He's fantastic and the ball is always safe when its in his hands.

2016-06-22T01:40:55+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


Oh and Balt, you know it's been carnage since you taunted the footy gods with your "no injuries" invocation. :(

2016-06-22T01:26:29+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


Yeah Blakely's been fantastic. Unfortunately for Weller's chances, although I reckon he's been just as adept at fulfilling his role, he's on that half-forward flank, which can be more difficult to play in many ways and harder to stand out. I'm pretty much thinking neither of them will win it as the award can rely so much on publicity and they're pretty anonymous in the wider footy world so far. Weitering has also started very very strongly, along with being a top draft pick at a spotlight club makes him a very safe bet at this point.

AUTHOR

2016-06-22T01:19:41+00:00

Anthony D'Arcy

Editor


Not sure what's happened there at all mate. There's been a few issues this morning but hopefully they're all sorted now. Needless to say, the blues would be very happy if Petracca and Daniel were both playing for them.

2016-06-22T01:12:06+00:00

Balthazar

Guest


I assume it will be Weitering - because he is very good but also the failure to even mention Blakeley (who has been ripping it up) is instructive. He did give the other youngsters a decent head start of a few games but his consistency and disposal numbers are second to none.

2016-06-22T01:05:33+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


Nice summary, but you might just amend who Christian Petracca and Caleb Daniel play for, not really a Carlton pair. The second half of the year will be interesting to see if Freo's Lachie Weller and/or Connor Blakely get any sort of media-oxygen that might bring them into calculations.

2016-06-22T01:03:12+00:00

the all rounder

Roar Pro


'Carlton’s second-year pair Christian Petracca and Caleb Daniel'?

2016-06-22T00:51:11+00:00

Beau

Guest


im putting a cheeky $10 on james sicily from Hawthorn. twice now been the match winner, has played all 13 games to date and also can play forward and back. the others (weitering, mills, petracca, hopper) have all missed a number of games. I also like Caleb Daniel.. think the young fella is a ripper.

Read more at The Roar