Why Round 18 is shaping as the AFL's Round of the Year

By Tommo Willo / Roar Pro

What is not to love about this AFL season?

At least six sides still have claims to flag contention and a final eight declared sealed by some commentators even before the halfway mark of the season now lies slightly ajar. Every came is vital and even the slightest slip-up can be season defining.

Round 18 is shaping as the pinnacle of the regular season with none of the matches involving top-8 sides appearing to be shoe-ins and even some of the lower profile games holding some importance.

Here is a breakdown of each of the matches and their importance for the clubs involved.

Collingwood versus North Melbourne
Although it would take a miracle for Collingwood to now reach the finals, their recent improvement in form and their remaining matches could hold significant importance for future opponents.

Collingwood’s pressure appears to be back with the Magpies winning the tackle count in each of their last four matches, including a combined differential of plus 52 in their last two. Despite a win putting Collingwood within two games of North Melbourne, their poor percentage means that they would still likely three more wins than North Melbourne to overtake them.

On the flip side, North Melbourne are in freefall. The Kangaroos need a win to sure up their finals position and just as importantly, to remind themselves that they can be a decent side.

Lose and they could be just one game inside the eight with matches against St Kilda, the Bulldogs, Hawthorn, Sydney and GWS to come.

Prediction: Collingwood by 10 points

Sydney versus Carlton
Sydney will enter all matches remaining as favourites with only one being against a current top-eight team (North Melbourne) and cannot be dislodged from the top-four so long as they remain undefeated.

Sydney simply must come to Saturday’s game switched on. By contrast, Carlton will not play finals in 2016, but have a nice opportunity to test themselves against quality opposition away from home. The Blues displayed some excellent spirit against the West Coast Eagles, but the Swans at the SCG is a must tougher task.

Prediction: Sydney by 40

Gold Coast versus Fremantle
Nothing to see here in terms of finals. Gold Coast are again crippled by injuries and have been resigned to hope against the team that they upset in Round 2. Similarly, Fremantle will be out to find out how they can prepare for a better 2017. Backing up their improved performance against Geelong last round in order to gain some momentum heading into next year would be valuable.

Prediction: Fremantle by 20

West Coast versus Melbourne
Just when we thought that West Coast had got their act together by defeating North Melbourne at Domain Stadium, another unconvincing performance away has raised serious questions. The Eagles find themselves with a chance to be in the top-four by Sunday night, playing a team who they should beat.

If they can’t get up, a top-four finish suddenly looks unlikely with a challenging final three games against GWS (away), Hawthorn (home) and Adelaide (away). Melbourne’s decent percentage means that pending some highly favourable results which would include an acceleration of North Melbourne’s fall and the failure of Port Adelaide or St Kilda to rise, they could be playing finals.

The Demons would need to win games such as their difficult fixture on the weekend to have any chance of September action, especially when you consider Hawthorn (home) and Geelong (away) awaiting them on the run home.

Prediction – West Coast by 35

Western Bulldogs versus St Kilda
The Western Bulldogs have a task on their hands to tackle a St Kilda side fresh off of an impressive win against Melbourne. Should they win and Adelaide lose, the Bulldogs will find themselves in the enviable position of being a game inside the top two.

However, the Bulldog’s poor showing against Richmond brought against St Kilda’s strong Etihad Stadium form could create an upset. The Saints are actually a chance to snatch a top-8 spot simply because of a reasonable draw to follow and the patches of scintillating football they displayed against Melbourne.

Should they upset the Dogs on Saturday night they will find themselves just a win outside the eight with an important game against their prey, North Melbourne, to follow. If everything goes right, the Saints could be in the eight in three weeks’ time.

Prediction: Western Bulldogs by 155

Geelong versus Adelaide
Undoubtedly, the game to watch in the round of the year.

Two and a half weeks ago, Geelong were unbeatable at home and had a great record against fellow top-eight sides. however following a shock loss to Sydney at Simmonds Stadium and a rather poor victory over Fremantle away, significant questions over the Cats’ poorly functioning midfield and forward line, both of which have shown themselves to be over reliant Patrick Dangerfield, have been raised.

A win on Saturday could place Geelong among five or six teams each with 12 wins separated by percentage and give the Cats a box seat for top-four with a seemingly smooth draw.

Adelaide claimed a top-two spot with their eighth consecutive win last round, however they have arguably not played their best football against quality opposition since their pre-bye upset of West Coast in Round 12.

If they enter the clash against the last team who beat them unprepared, they could find themselves seventh, but a big win would see them second at worst. With their greatest challenges being the Showdown and West Coast (home), a win would put them in an almost unbackable position for the top-4 and a real chance to solidify their top-2 credentials.

Prediction: Adelaide by 10

Essendon versus Brisbane
Forget finals here – coach sackings, wooden spoons and number one draft picks are at stake. If Brisbane lose, they will likely achieve all three, while a loss for Essendon will grant them the latter two. A win for either would be moral boosting at most and give their supporters a week-long reprieve.

Prediction: Essendon by 20

Hawthorn versus Richmond
Hawthorn are a game clear on top of the ladder and realistically could probably afford to drop a game without risking their top-four credentials, however a poor performance may allow other teams to gain some insight into stopping the Hawks juggernaut for the Premiership.

On the other side, Richmond are essentially four wins outside the eight and although mathematically a chance, their team selections of late have demonstrated that their priorities are apparently in 2017.

Prediction: Hawthorn by 50

Port Adelaide versus Greater Western Sydney
Another game with a large bearing on finals, Port would fancy themselves at home against a GWS side with questions still hanging over them from the Collingwood loss.

A win to the Power and a loss to North Melbourne would see them one game outside of the eight. However, to do so, the Power need to consistently deliver good football, something which they have struggled with so far. On the other hand, GWS are very much in the mix for a top-four finish and win against Port would solidify their chances with a run home that could be both the making or undoing of the young side, with ‘8-point games’ against West Coast (home) and North Melbourne (away) still to come.

Prediction: Port Adelaide by 10

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2016-07-22T09:54:17+00:00

Tommo Willo

Roar Pro


Depends on who you go for I guess.

2016-07-22T09:34:12+00:00

justinr

Guest


This is a fairly ordinary round imo. The wooden spoon play-off may be the most intriguing, with a bad Lions loss putting Leppa on the hot seat. We'll probably find out if GWS are genuine contenders this year.

2016-07-22T07:42:08+00:00

gameofmarks

Roar Guru


Well Simpson has gone and done it again! Named a side that doesn't make any sense! Why on earth do you name Dom Sheed as an Emergency when we only have 6 rounds left? Surely if he is fit enough to name as an Emergency you name him in the side and give him a chance to find his legs after missing the whole year and only playing 3 games in the two's prior to this round. Who's place does he take? I would have sent Redden back to the two's and played Sheed. But just in case Simpson wants to give Redden a final chance, and I think this week's game is his last chance before he is sent back to the two's for good if he doesn't perform, I would have played Sheed instead of Nelson. We know what Nelson will bring when selected, so there is no harm in keeping him down in the two's for another week. Then if Redden blows his last chance Nelson comes back in and Sheed keeps his spot and has a game under his belt. The side is starting to look better balanced and when Nic Nat comes back all we need to find is a wingman to take Masten 's place. Of course Schofield is my preference to McKenzie and I hope Simpson gives Schoey his spot back once over his soreness.

2016-07-22T07:01:42+00:00

mattyb

Guest


Well that's disappointing Tommo. I read the headline best round of the year then saw the Doggies by 155 and put two and two together. I must say your comment about errors has left me feeling rather flat.

AUTHOR

2016-07-22T06:19:08+00:00

Tommo Willo

Roar Pro


The editors can take the hit for that one, still says 15 in my document. I think the Bulldogs are similar to Adelaide in that the main thing standing in their way is Hawthorn, whom neither have beaten for years. I wouldn't be confident on either of them against the Hawks in a final, especially on the MCG.

AUTHOR

2016-07-22T06:13:00+00:00

Tommo Willo

Roar Pro


I used the term 'at least' to avoid opening Pandora's box, but for the record I can't see the Eagles winning it. Sydney, Hawthorn and Adelaide are equal favorites for mine.

2016-07-22T05:18:05+00:00

mattyb

Guest


This a very very good article and I'm happy the Dogs are being tipped to win by 155 points,this will be the clubs highest ever victory which will sit well with us having our most ever seasons victories. As a bulldog fan I see every game as a danger game and this one was no exception. This huge victory will do wonders for both our percentage and confidence. I'm assuming Boyd or Redpath will kick a few and maybe Bontempelli will play forward and do the same. Clay Smith looked dangerous up forward last week so maybe he will have a huge game,or maybe Tory Dson will get back to his goal scoring ways in the lead up to the finals. This will be a huge result for the Doggies and I'm looking forward to this result immensely.

2016-07-22T03:05:27+00:00

Paul W

Guest


We'll need Tommy Boyd to kick 15 and Redpath 8.

2016-07-22T02:23:43+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


Yep. Now that is a fearless tip.

2016-07-22T00:47:52+00:00

Lamby

Roar Rookie


Western Bulldogs by 155 Wow. I'd like to see that :-)

2016-07-22T00:14:30+00:00

Aransan

Guest


As a Bombers supporter I am hoping for a win against Brisbane but I would prefer to play well and lose than play badly and win. Let us hope for a high standard game with the young players giving supporters confidence for the future.

2016-07-21T22:58:56+00:00

paul

Guest


Doggies percentage is going to get a healthy boost with that margin.

2016-07-21T22:35:12+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Leppa shouldn’t get the sack on the spot if they go down – but if the players really did want to get rid of him, it is in their power to do so this weekend in the manner of their loss, if it eventuates. Should be a fascinating study in human behaviour.

2016-07-21T20:25:10+00:00

Monopoly Man

Guest


"At least 6 sides still have claims to flag contention"? Good article, but outside of North who are you writing off? The Eagles? Whilst I agree that they would seem the most off the pace, let us not forget that Hawthorn 2008 had not beaten a single member of the top 4 before the finals that season yet would go on to win the whole thing. Add to that they made it last year and they are still in it for mine. If it's GWS you have selected then I will remind you of Essendon 1993 and that whilst experience is no doubt important this group is talented enough to get it done. Whilst there are some teams I would rank above others (Hawthorn, Sydney & Adelaide) I still think any of the 7 could still win it on their day.

Read more at The Roar