Write the Sharks off at your peril

By Tim Gore / Expert

When it comes to great Australian movie scenes, few are as iconic than the opening of Mad Max.

The Night Rider has escaped custody in Sun City and, along with a floozy called Marmaduke, has stolen a police HQ Monaro Coupe, causing mayhem on the post-apocalyptic streets of outback Australia.

All the while he is screaming into the police radio about his escapade.

He is unstoppable.

And then Max turns up and the party ends abruptly in death and flames.

There is a comparison between this scene and the Cronulla Sharks’ season.

Between Rounds 4 and 20, the Sharks beat all comers, including the Cowboys, Raiders, Bulldogs, Broncos, Panthers, Titans and Storm. They were on top of the table and it looked as though they were good things to overcome their demons of the past and finally bring a premiership home to the Shire after 50 long seasons.

And then, just like the Night Rider, the wheels started to wobble… (Click to Tweet)

In Round 21 they went up to the Gold Coast and were held to an 18-all draw by the Titans.

They were still undefeated in 16 games though.

However, the next week they were beaten by a dominant Raiders at home, and followed that loss up with a flogging at the hands of the ne’er-do-well Dragons in Wollongong.

The panic bells surely have started to ring at Shark Park following their 12-6 loss to the Bunnies on Monday night. All of a sudden, they are virtually no chance of winning the minor premiership and could even forfeit a top two spot to the Raiders.

Social media is going crazy with memes like “Are you a Cronulla Fan? Depressed? Ring 1800 10 10 10 (thats 1800 won nothing, won nothing, won nothing).”

Back before season’s start, ageing warhorse Paul Gallen was stung when teased publicly about the Sharkies’ empty trophy cabinet. His team’s resultant run of top form looked to be the best possible response.

However, this month Gallen turned 35 years old and he has missed the last two games with a calf strain – also known as ‘the old man injury’. His side has lost both games in his absence.

Surely the Sharks are cooked and the dream is over. Right?

Not necessarily. This could very well be a hiccup on the road to glory. For starters, there are very good reasons for most of those recent losses.

The draw against the Titans was a cracking, high-quality game that could have gone either way, but in the end went neither. Both sides missed five field goals apiece.

The next week, the Sharks lost Michael Ennis – who has been a huge part of Cronulla’s success this year – not long before the game and the Raiders took full advantage.

The Sharks were also backing up just five days after the gruelling 90-minute game against the Titans. Further, the Raiders are in top form and reinforced that the following week when they beat Melbourne.

Gallen pulled out very late for the match against the Dragons with a calf injury. The Sharks then had their worst match of the season in defence, missing 38 tackles. Every side is allowed an off day.

Following their 50-point flogging at the hands of the Raiders in Round 21, the Rabbitohs’ form has been through the roof as they try to regain lost pride. They nearly beat the Storm, and destroyed the Warriors in Auckland. In the wet against the Sharks they pulled off a six-point win, with the last try coming in junk time.

Losing that match, again without Gallen, is understandable.

However, commentators, fans and trolls have taken it to mean that the Sharks are gone.

Don’t you believe it. And you’d better hope your team doesn’t believe it, or they’ll find themselves getting a football lesson.

A wobble going into the finals is not unusual. Just look at these examples:

Year Premier Run into the finals Ladder finish
2015 Cowboys Lost three of last five 3rd
2014 Rabbitohs Lost two of last four 3rd
2013 Roosters Lost two of last four 1st
2012 Storm Won eight straight to take title but had lost five straight directly before that and fell to 3rd 2nd
2009 Storm Lost two of last four 4th
2006 Broncos Lost five of last eight 3rd
2005 Wests Tigers Lost two of last four 4th
2001 Knights Lost three of last five 3rd

Given these examples, the Sharks’ losing streak, while not ideal, is no cause for panic.

Further, not finishing the home-and-away season in first position isn’t anything to worry about. Just take a look at these figures:

Year Premier Ladder finish Recent grand final experience? Year Premier Ladder finish Recent grand final experience?
2015 Cowboys 3rd No 1998 Broncos 1st Yes, 1997
2014 Rabbitohs 3rd No 1996 Sea Eagles 1st Yes, 2005
2013 Roosters 1st Yes, 2010 1995 Bulldogs 6th Yes, 1994
2012 Storm 2nd Yes, 2009 1994 Raiders 3rd Yes, 1991
2011 Sea Eagles 2nd Yes, 2008 1993 Broncos 5th Yes, 1992
2010 Dragons 1st No 1992 Broncos 1st No
2009 Storm 4th Yes, 2008 1991 Panthers 1st Yes, 1990
2008 Sea Eagles 2nd Yes, 2007 1990 Raiders 1st Yes, 1989
2007 Storm 1st Yes, 2006 1989 Raiders 4th Yes, 1987
2006 Broncos 3rd No 1988 Bulldogs 2nd Yes, 1986
2005 Wests Tigers 4th No 1987 Sea Eagles 1st No
2004 Bulldogs 2nd No 1986 Eels 1st Yes, 1984
2003 Panthers 1st No 1985 Bulldogs 3rd Yes, 1984
2002 Roosters 4th Yes, 2000 1984 Bulldogs 1st No
2001 Knights 3rd Yes, 1997 1983 Eels 3rd Yes, 1982
2000 Broncos 1st Yes, 1998 1982 Eels 1st Yes, 1981
1999 Storm 3rd No 1981 Eels 3rd No
NOTE: 1997 results not included

As you can see, in the NRL era (1998-present) no side has won the flag from outside the top four.

However, whereas 14 of the premiers over the last 36 seasons (39%) have also been the minor premiers, in the NRL era that has dropped to 33 per cent.

Since 1998 the average ladder finish for the premier has just been a tic over second. The Sharks are still a very good chance to finish in second spot, and at worst will finish in third. They could still come first if the Storm lose to the Broncos and the Sharks beat them in the final round. All is far from lost.

Another stat that people say is against the Sharks is that they haven’t played in a recent grand final. Pre the NRL era, that did seem to be a big factor. However, eight of the 18 (45%) premiers in the NRL era have not had recent grand final experience. That includes the Cowboys in 2015 and the Rabbitohs in 2014.

Further, the Sharks have quite a few players with grand final and big game experience:

Player Experience
James Maloney 2011 grand final loser, 2013 grand final winner, NSW Origin
Matt Prior 2010 grand final winner
Chris Heighington 2005 grand final Winner
Luke Lewis 2003 grand final Winner, NSW Origin, Australia
Michael Ennis 2012 grand final loser, NSW Origin
Ben Barba 2012 grand final loser
Andrew Fifita NSW Origin, Australia
Wade Graham NSW Origin
Jack Bird NSW Origin
Paul Gallen NSW Origin, Australia

Cronulla have six players who have featured in a grand final, and only two of them weren’t victorious. Further, six members of the team played Origin this year. Three have represented Australia.

There is plenty of very good big-game experience in this side.

The stats are clear: Cronulla aren’t gone by a long shot. This could still be the year of the Shark.

Write them off at your peril.

The Crowd Says:

2016-08-26T05:23:31+00:00

Crosscoder

Roar Guru


Where do I start. Palpitations for the early rounds of 2016. Then 15 sweet weeks of telling anyone who wants to listen(and grew did BTW),teh sharks are the real deal. For the last 3 weeks the palpitations came back,and the Sharks became the real meal. Can't put my finger on it,but it appears the forwards are making the inroads into the opposition defences as they used to,with plenty of 2nd phase work.The result the pacy backs are stymied with lack of attacking space,and being hammered in defence. If i were Flanno and than the Lord I'm not sir,I would be instructing forwards to attach themselves like limpets to JWH,and Corder and snuff the attacking prowess of Pearce and his new 5/8th and Ferguson. Getting beaten by the Raiders was no insult,and to a lesser extent the Bunnies,but to be humbled by the Dragoons left me gobsmacked. They need to beat the Roosters well and cross my legs etc ,serve it up to the Southern Salary Cappers in purple. The only saving grace ATM is a top 4 spot is in situ.

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T11:11:38+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Yes. Hard to equate Flanagan to Bennett...

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T11:10:34+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Underneath your sticks watching Maloney convert another Sharks try.

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T11:07:27+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


I think you are too harsh on the Sharks, but I see your point of view We love our Blake...

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T11:05:38+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Roosters game is the real litmus test

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T11:00:44+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Not to the raiders they aren't...

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:59:32+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Blake's hammy is suspect for sure. Not sure how bad the hand is. Sammy is ready. He can play. Defence not as good but passing better.

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:57:26+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


50 years. It's time. Cleveland broke the curse.

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:56:24+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Indeed. They needed a bigger boat

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:55:42+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Sharks have been very good. You don't win 15 straight without being very good.

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:54:23+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


They might. It's 50/50 OB

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:52:38+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Lol. He's in Gungahlin.

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:51:34+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Wait. Where did David go?

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:50:24+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


I'll be interested if Gal actually plays.

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:47:39+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Very tough. Cos I'm winning.

AUTHOR

2016-08-25T10:46:44+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


Only the Dragons loss was poor. The rest were all close. I reckon they could click again against the Roosters.

2016-08-25T09:57:03+00:00

JVGO

Guest


So you have lost Blake Austin and you are worried? Cronulla have lost a few games without Ennis and Gallen and they are being written off. Gallen and Ennis are clearly much more significant losses than Blake Austin.

2016-08-25T08:59:38+00:00

monday QB

Guest


You can't write anyone off who makes the finals but the sharks are looking average and a long campaign (with months of expectation on them to deliver a first premiership) seems to have taken its toll. It's not so much that they're losing, but how they're losing. The way they lost to the Dragons was telling and will have the alarm bells ringing big time. They looked flat against the Bunnies last week Right now i'd put the Sharks behind everyone in the top 8 but the Panthers. I really can't believe (the way the last month of football has gone) that you can get $2.45 or there abouts for the Roosters on Saturday night!

2016-08-25T08:33:37+00:00

AGO74

Guest


The Cows perhaps but Friday night Broncos on 5 day turnarounds?? When compared to the rest of the competition I don't think so...... I do agree that this weekend is a huge game for the Sharks. If they lose this weekend then they are a lot closer to crisis than contenders.

2016-08-25T08:14:46+00:00

Jacko

Guest


Hi Tim, Can you please tell me where "your peril" is as I would like to write the Sharks off

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar