Indigenous All Stars deserve more fixtures

By Billy Stevenson / Roar Guru

Last Friday night the Indigenous All Stars put in arguably their best performance since the inception of the All Stars format in 2010.

Scoring the highest number of points to be awarded to any side in an All Stars game and equalling their 26-point win margin of 2013, it was a scintillating introduction to the full-length footy year.

Earlier in the week, Johnathan Thurston suggested that the Indigenous side should be given more opportunities throughout the year.

Watching the boys as they took the field on Friday night, it was hard to disagree.

From the very outset, their communication was utterly seamless.

Club allegiance never seems more fickle than at the beginning of the NRL season. Pretty much every club has to get used to a slew of new faces and say goodbye to a slew of old faces.

It was even more dramatically clear, then, that the Indigenous side were playing for something more than a club.

Even the Kangaroos don’t always match that level of synergy and common purpose.

The connection was all the more incredible in that the Indigenous side had only had two training sessions in the immediate buildup to the match – a preliminary one-hour practice and a Captain’s Run of about forty minutes.

Their elegant efficiency was therefore a tribute to the heritage and cultural events that have been implemented to bond the team, as well as the wider visibility around the indigenous community in the buildup to the match.

Stan Grant’s speech, in particular, seems to have resonated, with Greg Inglis citing it as key to his motivation in the build up to the match.

Playing on the brink of a record-breaking heatwave just seemed to create an even more urgent sense of solidarity and communion.

Over the first half, we were given a lesson in pure footy professionalism, with barely an error in judgment from the Indigenous side.

Inglis, in particular, always brings something extra to All Stars clashes.

In his pride, presence and stature on the field, you can glimpse how it would feel for the Indigenous community if they were always afforded this kind of visibility and inclusion.

It’s not hard to see why he’s such a pillar of strength, both at the Rabbitohs and beyond.

With him and Thurston as co-captains, the Indigenous side must have had an invincible sense of belief.

Add to that the fact that Andrew Fifita clearly had something to prove to Mal Meninga in the wake of his Four Nations snubbing – and the stage was set for a powerhouse performance from the Indigenous side.

Before the game even started, however, it felt as if the Indigenous players had won with their war dance.

More complex and choreographed than recent years, this was an utterly spine-tingling spectacle.

I found myself wondering why the haka has managed to become so integral to rugby union and yet this kind of Indigenous ceremony has never made its way into rugby league.

With each player gathering in a circle and then adopting their own particular postures and expressions as they faced the World team, it felt as if they were channelling their positions and proclivities on the field into a cross-section of Indigenous pride.

I can’t think of a better ceremony to express both the unity and the diversity of Indigenous peoples.

Following straight on from that momentum, Joel Thompson and Jack Bird set up a try in the opening minutes, which was just as rapidly converted by Thurston.

For Bird, it must have been a satisfying experience to get one down for the Indigenous boys as soon as he got ball in hand for his first All Stars appearance.

Minutes later, Blake Ferguson found open space in the middle of the opposition’s sliding defence, taking advantage of the poor communication between the World backline and halves to plant the Steeden over the line.

Granted, it was more a matter of World sloppiness than Fergo’s ingenuity, but it still felt continuous with his stint for the Kangaroos at the end of last year, among the very best in the Four Nations.

It was with the third try, however, that things really started to get sublime.

Recovering the ball from a fumbled tackle, Thurston passed it to Taylor who passed it back again only to receive it from J.T. for a second time and bring the score to 14-0 after only twelve minutes.

Those kinds of back-and-forward exchange would prove to be characteristic of the Indigenous side, who often felt as if they were having a conversation with the Steeden, leaving the World side to stumble in their wake.

Admittedly, World started to recover again towards the end of the second half, with David Mead and Nene Macdonald bringing in the only World tries of the night, even as Jarrod Croker failed to convert either.

That said, there was still a lack of conviction.

Mead’s try, in particular, felt conjectural, with the referee calling it and the Bunker only allowing it because they didn’t have sufficient evidence to overturn it.

Macdonald’s four-pointer was more impressive – a perfectly timed putdown ten seconds out from the bell.

Still, the World backline were struggling to keep up with the Indigenous side.

A bomb from Thurston at the fifteen minute mark was fumbled by Mead and only saved by Mitchell Moses at the last minute from what would otherwise have been a certain Indigenous try.

As Gus Gould put it, there was “no semblance of cohesion” to the World side.

To some extent, that was a result of more unfamiliar combinations for World.

After all, the Indigenous boys had more of a Maroons pedigree and synergy to draw upon, especially among Thurston, Inglis and Dane Gagai, who put in some Origin-worthy moments.

Yet the Indigenous platers should also be commended for how well they unsettled the World players, in the way that an ultra-organised outfit can often breed disorganisation among their opponents.

Accordingly, they responded emphatically to Macdonald’s four pointer less than a minute into the second half, with their deftest moment of the night.

Choosing to run the ball on the final tackle, Thurston passed the Steeden across the left side of the field where it finally found Bevan French, who in yet another counter-intuitive moment of genius chose to relinquish his trademark speed to banana kick it back to Thurston, who was still coming up the middle.

Bookended by Thurston, who converted just as effortlessly moments later, it was a pure example of why people love rugby league.

For me, it already stands of one of Thurston’s best moments this year.

Yet the GOAT arguably put in an even greater move at the one hour mark, receiving the Steeden from Inglis at dummy-half and chipping it across the field to Gagai, who managed to catch it on the full and comfortably ground it behind the goal-lines, setting J.T. up for another effortless conversion.

So brilliant was Thurston’s ability to pinpoint just where Gagai would be that his split-second judgement seemed to defy any single sporting skill set, sending the commentators in search of analogies from other codes and games, from soccer to Tom Brady.

Even Gagai himself seemed more dumbfounded than excited at realising he’d put down a four-pointer, telling the interviewer that he had pretty much stayed onside and allowed Thurston to work his magic.

Still, it was a testament to Gagai’s ability to seize the moment as well, a worthy sequel to his Origin-esque dash down the field in the first half.

Still, it wasn’t all about the four-pointers.

Inglis busting through the line at the 48th minute off the back of a Fifita flick pass was every bit as good as a try, as he managed to dispose of Mead (twice) and Tepai Moeroa along the way.

Drawing on Fifita’s energy, who had managed to scramble the Steeden out from under a pile of World defenders, and seguing into Thurston’s brilliance, who took over from G.I. downfield, it was a perfect testament to the synergy of the Indigenous team.

The final try of the night was from Leilani Latu.

It may not have been as sublime as the previous Indigenous efforts, but it didn’t have to be.

Following on from Latu’s try last year, it cemented the heritage and longevity of the Indigenous outfit.

After such a perfect game of footy, the question on everyone’s lips seemed to be – when next?

With the All Stars match expanding beyond Queensland for the first time, it felt like a watershed in elevating the Indigenous team to a new visibility.

During the match, Gould suggested that the Indigenous boys might find a berth at the rugby league World Cup.

In the last couple of days, Thurston has suggested that the team might be better suited to playing Papua New Guinea, New Zealand or one of the Pacific Island Nations.

Personally, I think Thurston is on the money.

Setting up a regular series with other Pacific nations would be a great way to expand the format and to celebrate the other Indigenous voices that go into the rugby league community.

Whatever the format, the time has come for an expansion of what the Indigenous side can do.

When the final siren sounded on Friday night, I found myself wondering if I had already watched the most passionate and professional eighty minutes of footy this year.

That kind of experience and spectacle needs to be repeated. Now that the Indigenous-World format has been around for half a decade, it’s time.

In the minutes before kickoff, Stan Grant told the Indigenous side that “we are a successful people and we need to reclaim that success.”

In their pride and determination, the Indigenous players translated Grant’s voice directly into footy. Let’s hope that voice now finds an even wider audience.

The Crowd Says:

2017-02-15T00:24:37+00:00

up in the north

Roar Rookie


Given the number of world players not made available or who pulled out, maybe there should be more incentive for those coaches to be a bit more flexible with their players. This game 'means' something for the indigenous players, at best the world guys are just making up the numbers.

2017-02-14T09:51:04+00:00

sammy

Guest


I don't see how a racially defined contest would be interesting to the general Australian / Kiwi / UK population. The selectors of the World All Stars must drop this ridiculous idea of trying to maximize the heritage foot-print and just select the best 20 players from the NRL / Super League. They need to restore the pride of the jersey which should in theory have a higher status than representing NSW, Qld, NZ and UK. Then the Aboriginal team will have a worthy competitor. One match per year is enough.

2017-02-14T03:25:18+00:00

Tigranes

Guest


Realistically, the World Team is just a punching bag for the Indigenous All Stars. I reckon they should consider getting rid of the World Team and replacing it with a Pasifika team, with guys from Fijian, Maori, Tongan, Samoan and Cook Islander heritage. Just like Aboriginals, Islanders are overly represented in the elite level of rugby league. This would give the game a hell of a lot more interest.

2017-02-14T02:12:16+00:00

Oingo Boingo

Guest


Without knowing the intricacies of the selection process , I guess we'll never know .

2017-02-14T01:34:06+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


I think it's more a case of the "better" players pulling out. Eg Hayne, Reynolds etc. It's also clear that the Indigenous side was dripping with talented, in-form players that would've brought the fight to any side they faced.

2017-02-14T01:01:30+00:00

Oingo Boingo

Guest


I totally agree that The players themselves are in no way involved in politicising the game. It begun as what you say a celebration of culture, but it is ( in my opinion) starting to be piggybacked by people with an agenda . Stan Grants use of the word " reclaim " is an insight . There is also a feeling among many that after the defeat last year this was a contrived victory to balance the books . You couldn't possibly argue that the opposing team was one of " all stars " , now could you .

2017-02-14T00:54:21+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


The world side was only a bit ordinary this time around. I'd like to see it be a true World All Stars team - pick the very best from Australia, NZ and England plus any other internationals that are good enough. Another opportunity would be to play a touring side every couple of years or to play the four nations qualifier as a four nations warm up. The Indigenous boys could even go on tour themselves.

2017-02-14T00:51:49+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


Mate, you seem to be drifting into tinfoil hat territory. It's just a celebration of culture and our shared history. You can't deny they're an exciting side to watch either. They aren't really trying to "Push" some kind of ideology.

2017-02-14T00:47:31+00:00

Epiquin

Roar Guru


I don't think we'll see the indigenous side play in the World Cup. Not only will it be racially divisive, but it also kind of makes the world cup look a bit silly. People already criticise the RLWC by using "heritage" to include more nations that make up the numbers. Splitting Australia into Indigenous and non-indigenous will just add more fuel to the fire. besides, I'm sure most, if not all, Indigenous players dream of growing up to represent the green and gold so it's a bit rough to say "Sorry you can't represent your country, only your culture." I can't see it happening personally and the players, while keen to play more games, don't seem keen on playing the RLWC either.

2017-02-13T23:32:04+00:00

Oingo Boingo

Guest


Mate I am in awe of the talent that comes out of the small percentage of indigenous guys that play league, they are massively over represented at the elite level . And I also have no issue with them doing a bit of a jig before their games . These guys have risen to the highest level and in most cases against the odds and deserve respect in spades . But I feel there are opportunistic snakes in the shadows who claim to be in their corner but are only their to benefit their own cause .

2017-02-13T23:14:25+00:00

Sleiman Azizi

Roar Guru


As opposed to an inclusive right-wing ideology? But I agree that there shouldn't be two 'Australian' teams. The Indigenous team is more akin to the Harlem Globetrotters. Eventually, though, the need for such a team will no longer be seen as necessary and at that point, Australia will have matured and moved beyond its divisions. That's why I like the idea of the Australian team incorporating an Aboriginal dance before their games.

2017-02-13T23:09:10+00:00

up in the north

Roar Rookie


I was asked if this was a good game, and I was a bit flumoxed. The way the murri boys played was great, not so good were the second rate opposition. If they're going to continue with this concept then ditch the world side and play against other indigenous teams. Keeping in mind that it is an NRL sanctioned game I wonder if there are enough Tongan, Samoan or PNG playreers running around to field a side.

2017-02-13T22:57:58+00:00

Oingo Boingo

Guest


I smell the stench of devisive leftist ideology creeping into league and using these guys as pawns to power its cause . To suggest we now have two Australian teams in some form would be extremely damaging .not only to the game itself but to the fabric of Australian society. Stan Grants views are well known and his push to delegitimise Australian history should be kept well away from sport.

2017-02-13T22:43:50+00:00

Squidward

Roar Rookie


1. They shouldn't have to pick. 2. It would greatly disadvantage Australia in a World Cup 3. Being Indigenous is not a country I'd like to see the team play more. But that's already a massive amount of games a year for JT, Thaiday, Inglis, JBird etc which they wouldn't knock back playing but for their own wellbeing

2017-02-13T18:19:11+00:00

Craig

Guest


If the Indigenous team played in the world cup, who do Thurston, Inglis etc represent? Australia or the Indigenous? In my opinion, they shouldn't be forced to choose between the two. I love watching the Indigenous team, but the excitement from this year needs to be checked somewhat. The team they were playing was weaker than the majority of NRL teams. It is a weaker team than the city-country teams, which is a complete farce of a game (for the last 10 years or so). If this team (the NRL all stars) played in the NRL I'd have them finishing bottom 3, probably above Newcastle with about 3 wins. Also remember, it was talked up about how little training time the Indigenous team had together, this team had even less - I'd suggest there are more players in this team who have never played together than the Indigenous team. 2 David Mead, 19 Akuila Uate, 3 Gerard Beale, 4 Jarrod Croker, 5 Nene Macdonald, 6 Mitchell Moses, 7 Moses Mbye, 8 Jordan McLean, 9 Jake Friend, 10 Reagan Campbell-Gillard, 11 Gavin Cooper, 12 Bryce Cartwright, 13 Tepai Moeroa.Interchange: 14 Damien Cook, 15 Paul Vaughan, 16 Sam Lisone, 17 Mitch Aubusson, 18 Sione Mata'utia, 20 Jordan Turner, 21 Chris McQueen All of that said, I'd love to see them play more games. I'm just not sure how, or who against.

Read more at The Roar