Recent sporting quotes that don't make any sense

By David Lord / Expert

Top of the no sense quotes belongs to the vastly experienced Shane Richardson, South Sydney’s general manager of football.

I, along with the rest of our club, have the greatest of confidence in our medical and coaching staff to make the best possible decisions about our players well being“.

That being the case, how did Souths skipper Greg Inglis spend 50 minutes playing on one leg against the Wests Tigers on Friday night before either the medical staff, or coach Michael Maguire, replaced him?

In the seventh minute Inglis fell awkwardly in what appeared to be quite innocuous, but Inglis was in agony.

He’s as tough as they come, and what should have alerted the decision makers, the agony was in his good knee.

It’s been his right knee that has caused concern in the past, never his left.

And for those watching, they didn’t need a doctor’s degree to realise Inglis was in serious trouble.

That scans proved yesterday morning he had ruptured his ACL, came as no surprise

So why was he playing for those extra 50 minutes?

The net result is the skipper is out for six months, a huge blow to South Sydney’s season.

Darren Lehmann owns the next nonsense quote.

It will be a close call between Matt Renshaw and Usman Khawaja to open at Pune“.

For starters, Lehmann as a selector, shouldn’t have talked publicly about any selections until after the team was announced, and then it’s the chairman’s prerogative.

And secondly, the team should never have been tampered with after a Test win over South Africa, and three wins at Pakistan’s expense.

The team ain’t broke, so don’t fix it.

But the selectors did tamper, leaving out Khawja and naming Shaun Marsh.

That not only showed no loyalty to a winning side, but it changed the successful batting order.

Instead of David Warne, Matt Renshaw, Usman Khawaja, Steve Smith and Peter Handscomb, it became Warner, Renshaw, Smith, Marsh, and Handscomb.

Sure Australia won against all odds by 333, but Marsh didn’t contribute with 16, and a second innings duck.

Yet Marsh has been picked again in the current Bangalore Test and will bat sometime today. Another failure and he must be sacked and the status quo resumed.

Marsh’s career has been blessed by selectors who have treated Khawaja shabbily before.

Pre-series, Mike Hussey suggested the Australians don’t sledge champion Indian batsman Virat Kohli, while champion sledger Steve Waugh thought a few well chosen words might stir up Kohli’s volatile nature.

Both were making their suggestions after Kohli became the first Test batsman in history to score double centuries in four successive series – 200 against the West Indies at North Sound, 211 against the Kiwis at Indore, 235 against England at Mumbai, and 200 against Bangladesh at Deccan.

In the end both suggestions didn’t matter, Kohli self-destructed.

At Pune in the first dig, Kohli chased a wide delivery from Mitchell Starc and was caught at slip by Handscomb for a second ball duck – India scored 105.

In the second dig he failed to play a shot and Steve O’Keefe cleaned up his castle for 13 off 37 balls – India all out 107.

And yesterday at Bangalore, Kohli shouldered arms and departed leg before to Nathan Lyon for 12 off 17 – India all out 189.

No need to sledge Virat Kohli, he’s only scored 25 runs in three digs, and when he fails so do India, scoring only 401 in three as well – very containable.

But have-a-chat Lehmann has been busy.

Lyon and O’Keefe are playing off for an Ashes berth next summer,” were his latest words of wisdom prior to the Bangalore Test and after O’Keefe had captured 6-35 in both Pune digs, with Lyon 1-21 and 4-53.

Spin twins O’Keefe and Lyon took all ten wickets in that second dig for the first time since Shane Warne with 5-82, and Tim May 5-89 at Edgbaston in 1993.

But Lyon will be mighty hard to dislodge next summer as Australia’s first-choice spinner.

Yesterday he posted a career best 8-50 to take his tally to 241 Test wickets, just eight away from moving past Richie Benaud’s 248 to be second only to Shane Warne’s 708 among Australian spinners.

But Lyon is well ahead of former offies Hugh Trumble 141, Ashley Mallett 132, Bruce Yardley 126, and Tim May 75.

No doubt Lehmann will make some more memorable quotes before this series is decided.

The Crowd Says:

2017-03-07T10:28:34+00:00

Rod

Guest


As a Souths fan I certainly did not like seeing Greg out there . But with his history of knee injuries over the years and his ability to recover quickly, possibly this clouded the judgement of the trainers .

2017-03-06T04:12:34+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Something holy?

2017-03-06T04:06:45+00:00

MAX

Guest


TB, I knew there was something Holy about you. (Smile)

2017-03-06T03:29:17+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I'm trained and qualified as a RTW Coordinator but work as a workers comp consultant at the moment. I don't have any medical or allied health qualifications so I'm in no way an expert in injury recovery or rehabilitation. I have experience in managing people with injuries back to work, working with doctors, applying injury treatment guidelines, etc.

2017-03-06T00:48:16+00:00

DonJohnston

Roar Rookie


Roberts is a New South Welshman.

2017-03-05T23:59:37+00:00

Wolly

Guest


I remember reading somewhat recently that you work in worker's compensation, and you seem to have a fair bit of knowledge in regards to post injury recovery. Would I be correct in guessing you're a RTW Co-ordinator?

2017-03-05T22:03:48+00:00

Silvertail47

Guest


Same , he shouldn't be there ,

2017-03-05T03:49:10+00:00

Chui

Guest


And what should the NRL policy be in regards to what happened to Inglis?

2017-03-05T02:37:18+00:00

Silvertail47

Guest


Yep ,while dogs like Roberts are protected by there club /state and the NRL I do believe that Fafita was made a whipping boy , you can't see it because balance and diplomacy is foreign to those who live north of the boarder , For the record Fafita is imature , but he never laid hands on a woman ,,

2017-03-05T02:28:18+00:00

Jim

Guest


If he wanted to come off he would've. He's a very experienced senior player and the captain of the team. The staff would refer to him first on his own welfare. The acl injury is naked by the muscles surrounding the knee. If one is to point the finger ( not that I would) you could accuse Inglis of bravado for staying on when he clearly couldn't make tackles and the Tigers were targeting his position

2017-03-05T02:25:52+00:00

sham

Guest


True playing with an ACL means playing with an unstable joint he could have destroyed his cartridge or worse.

2017-03-05T02:23:27+00:00

sham

Guest


Not true the joint is usually unstable after you rupture an ACL.

2017-03-05T01:42:07+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


You can have a partial tear of the ACL and that would certainly be made worse by staying out there. But there could have been other things wrong as well that could be made worse. Other structures in the knee can be damaged. But even forgetting the player welfare side, what was the point of leaving a bloke on one leg out there? It was poor coaching thinking a one legged Inglis was a better option than a fit player and a reshuffle.

2017-03-05T01:17:52+00:00

Eelsalmighty

Guest


Jim, seriously? You stated in your comments above, correctly I will add, that you can only diagnose an ACL with a scan, and now you're arguing it was an ACL, so leaving him on for the extra 50 mins made no difference. So how did they know it was an ACL, and they weren't making it (his injury) worse by leaving him on? Inglis was clearly in agony, and it was an incredibly stupid, irresponsible, pathetic decision to leave him on. As for the man himself, and I'm not pretending to be a mind reader, but I thought it was pretty evident he wanted to come off.

2017-03-05T01:09:23+00:00

Jim

Guest


Stop bleating about player welfare. It wasn't a head injury. Once an ACL is torn you're not gonna make it worse by attempting to run on it. Staying on the field would've had no effect on the injury whatsoever. Ultimately the information on whether he feels ok or not comes from Inglis. That is the major part of a diagnosis, what the patient tells the doctor.

2017-03-05T00:51:40+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


This one is for all the coaches. "You have the full backing of the board".

2017-03-05T00:26:03+00:00

Maroon Blood

Guest


I'm sorry, "poor Fifita"?

2017-03-04T23:58:16+00:00

Silvertail47

Guest


If Greg Inglis was a greyhound or a horse there would be outrage ,,,, someone must answer questions , at least

2017-03-04T23:53:02+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I don't think you needed medical training to see he was in serious trouble. Scans confirm the diagnosis but there are other tests. The trainers and medical staff really should have done better. Leaving someone on the field for 50 minutes with a torn ACL wasn't good enough. It's not as if he was running freely so they couldn't tell.

2017-03-04T23:43:20+00:00

Birdy

Guest


There was a play when Ingliss took a loose ballwith a gap in front of him.He couldn't run through it , instead he looked at the defence and called a surrender tackle. Not replacing him from the first minute of his injury, especially in the first game will always be a mystery. You have to give it to him though, chasing that kick and scoring before half time .what a competitor.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar