Round 2's biggest winners and losers

By BillyW / Roar Rookie

Every week there are nine winners and nine losers, but for some clubs the wins are worth more than four points.

Breaking a hoodoo, arresting a slide or a win against the odds can give a team an immeasurable confidence-boost that can last for weeks and lead to more wins.

Conversely, there are losses that can engulf a club and cause more damage than meets the eye, potentially wrecking a whole season!

With that in mind here are this week’s winners and losers.

Winners
Port Adelaide had to win big against a lower club – as opposed to winning ugly or losing – to reinforce what we saw last week and start to believe it might be what we’ll get every week.

The Crows broke a long-running hoodoo, now have two good scalps, and proved they are serious contenders.

The Demons won a game they may well have lost previously, especially when seriously challenged by a determined Blues.

Losers
The Suns were always going to lose, but like that? Some big issues on the Gold Coast.

Saint Kilda led nearly all day, played really well, but didn’t get the chocolates and now fall to 0-2. I thought they would lift themselves into the eight this year, but it’s really tough from here.

The Swans played two very entertaining games and played well. They are good enough to recover from 0-2, but picked up another injury. Kurt Tippett is not a huge loss but if Sam Reid has to ruck a bit it hurts their forward structure.

In keeping with the same theme, which teams have the most to gain from a win and which will feel the most pain from a loss in Round 3.

Most to gain
After a stirring win away over an under-cooked Swans, followed by a four-quarter clinic over a hapless Dockers, Port have made a terrific start. If they can upstage hometown rivals the Crows, they will force 90 per cent of the footy community to rethink where they predicted this previously up-and-down side might finish.

The Wolves at Ken Hinkley’s door have retreated slightly, this could send them back to the forest!

Richmond are another club that were under the pump at the start of the year that have gone 2-0 – but then so they should have, with wins over a developing Blues and a wayward Pies outfit. This is a week for the Tigers to bank four points against a quality side, one that has been rated by many as top four and most as definitely top eight.

As above, a win would ease external pressure, gain them considerable confidence, and have them in the frame for September action!

Melbourne had a good win against the Saints, a team in an equal stage of development, and a ‘job’s done’ win after a scare against the young Blues. A win against an opponent considered to be a step above would be massive for the Dees. They didn’t make their job any easier with some undisciplined acts from leaders last week.

For clubs that were hoping to be in the hunt for spots in the lower positions of the eight, a 0-3 start would be just about fatal. So in that regard, the Saints, Pies and Roos will be desperate to turn things around and earn themselves a win this week.

The Crowd Says:

2017-04-07T01:33:53+00:00

King Bob

Guest


I had St Kilda in 9th spot behind Eagles and Melbourne. After only 2 games it's premature to state "it's really tough from here" because they have lost to 2 top 8 sides. The season injuries and dramas are yet to play out and affect teams final chances. If I was a Saints fan I would be still very positive about this year. Wait at least and see if they beat the Pies in round 4, that's a must win game.

2017-04-05T03:48:49+00:00

Rocko

Roar Guru


Agreed - shame first half of last year he was awesome as a ruck forward.

AUTHOR

2017-04-05T03:12:24+00:00

BillyW

Roar Rookie


I think the Crows are the real deal....the way their 2nd tier has lifted so far there is no glaring weakness......they are definitely in the mix as contenders. The problem with Port last year was inconsistency...so although they're playing like 2014 fans fear 2016 is just round the corner! I like to think of them as playing like it's 2017.......and who know's how far they can go!

AUTHOR

2017-04-05T02:48:16+00:00

BillyW

Roar Rookie


I think he's important structurally I just don't think they'll miss his ability....he is far from footy smart and tends to break down a bit.......

2017-04-05T01:58:32+00:00

Gyfox

Guest


The Showdown will be very interesting. Are Port Adelaide back to their 2014 form? It seems so. But are the Crows really that good? Most of us are not sure.

2017-04-05T01:49:47+00:00

kick to kick

Guest


Tippet is a big loss for the Swans and his injury was a turning point against the Bulldogs. It severely altered the Swans clearance set-up which was dominating and there-after took Reid away from a specialist centre-half forward presence. It also removed Tippet as an accurate goal-kicking tall forward. Commentator Gerard Healy has in the past identified Tippet as one of the Swans most important players structurally and I think he's right.

Read more at The Roar