Richmondy: The unfortunate term for spectacular and continued failure

By Mathew Langdon / Roar Pro

It’s rare that you go to a podcast hosted by a comedian and TV star for in depth AFL knowledge.

But for over a year, one Aussie podcast has pointed out a disturbing trend for the Richmond Football Club – and it’s only getting worse.

A term coined by famous Australian comedian Wil Anderson and current Home and Away star Charlie Clausen on their AFL podcast ‘2 Guys, 1 Cup‘, Richmondy has come to symbolise the unfortunate plight of Tigers fans in seeing their team consistently fall to heart crushing defeats.

It’s not enough just to lose a game, it must be lost in a manner so unforgettable that it plagues their fans minds for the days, weeks and years that follow.

As one of their fans pointed out, the history of Richmondy goes well into the archives, but it appears to have reached its peak in the past three weeks.

For those who are unaware of the trend, let me explain.

Following a thumping and subsequent crashing back to earth against Adelaide, Richmond appeared to have the better of reigning premiers the Western Bulldogs.

In the third term it appeared that the form that had seen the team go 5-0 was back.

But the Dogs came hard in the final term, taking the lead for the first time in the game.

With less than 30 seconds to play, the ball flies into the Richmond 50 for one last roll of the dice, only for the Tigers valiant efforts to fall to the newest and arguably most contentious rule in the AFL, deliberate out of bounds.

Tigers lose by 5.

Then came a return to the MCG to take on a Fremantle side with it all to prove.

It doesn’t start well, with Freo kicking away to hold a 30-point three-quarter-time lead.

But the Tigers come roaring home, kicking five straight goals to seemingly steal victory thanks to a Brandon Ellis goal with less than a minute remaining.

The elated Richmond fans in the stands erupting with their team on the field, the euphoria was unquestionable.

(AAP Image/Julian Smith)

But it did not last long.

Fremantle win the centre clearance and hammer the ball forward into their 50, into the arms of a well known Tiger villain, David ‘ice man’ Mundy.

In a painful repeat of 2015, the former Docker captain steps up to slot a goal after the siren to break Richmond hearts once again.

Tigers lose by 2.

Then came GWS.

The Tigers had the better of the Giants all day, leading by 25 points at the final change.

They had to break the streak.

Toby Greene kicks the opening goal of the term for GWS, Richmond fans know they can get one back.

But then Sam Reid kicks another goal for the Giants, then Tim Taranto, then Matt de Boer, it couldn’t possibly be another heartbreaker for the Tigers, surely.

Richmond first-gamer Shai Bolton ends up with the ball in his hands and snaps at goal. It sails through, Richmond look to have done enough to stave off the Giants.

But it gets overturned, the ball was touched. GWS have one last shot a little over a minute remaining.

GWS couldn’t possibly do it? After two weeks of pain, Richmond had learned what it needed to do, they had practiced two minute drills all week.

But to quote Game of Thrones: “If you think this has a happy ending, you haven’t been paying attention.”

GWS go down the gut, coast to coast for a match winning goal off Jeremy Cameron.

Tigers lose by three.

The sad part about it is that there is no formula to being Richmondy. It isn’t a lack of ability, lack of pace or lack of stamina to run out the game. It’s just something that is almost undefinable.

And to add to the idea of Richmondy, these losses come in a season where the team started 5-0, with fans hoping this was a sign of how good this football club could be.

Insane and euphoric highs must be immediately followed by soul destroying lows.

The worst part about it is historically, this isn’t even abnormal for the club. the 1982 grand final where they lost following a streaker, the 2013 Elimination Final where they lost to a team that finished ninth, or the numerous seasons where high expectation off seasons are met with a thumping at the hands of Carlton in Round 1 of the next season.

As a WA boy living in Victoria, my heart breaks for my friends who support this football club. They are some of the most prideful and passionate AFL supporters I have ever met.

But if you need a team that can somehow snatch defeat from the jaws of victory, or do something so bizarre that it makes you question your reality, remember, it’s so Richmondy.

The Crowd Says:

2021-04-13T06:51:03+00:00

Ron The Bear

Roar Rookie


Correct. Cotchin is a Brownlow-winning three-time premiership leader while Selwood has the worst finals record of any captain in history.

2017-05-26T14:30:43+00:00

Gecko

Guest


'They lose through exceptional play from the other side'. No. A late run of opposition goals on so many occasions tells us it's not just bad luck (note that in almost all the scenarios Richmond is a few goals up with minutes remaining). It's got to do with poise - about key players going missing (Cotchin is no Selwood) and inexcusable lapses in defensive structures.

2017-05-26T10:52:30+00:00

Milo

Roar Rookie


Agree. Still have a chuckle about 97 and dogs supporters queueing for GF tkts at 3/4 time.

2017-05-26T10:43:22+00:00

Philby

Guest


Ah, yes, I recognise your fear. We are one successful era away from becoming one of the all-time most successful clubs in the competition. But you knew that already, didn't you? And it's coming.

2017-05-26T10:32:21+00:00

Philby

Guest


Neither that nor 'Richmondy' will catch on....though they may qualify as the worst attempts at a catchphrase in the history of language.

2017-05-26T08:00:27+00:00

J.T. Delacroix

Guest


As a Bulldogs' supporter, so-called comedian, Wil Anderson should be quite an authority on sustained failure.

2017-05-26T04:34:49+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Wins weren't lucky or even surprising, only had to look at the fixture and see that 5-0 was the bare minimum of acceptable considering they played last years 16th, 17th and 18th placed clubs and another whose MCG performances rank about 18th. Can't see them winning more than about 5 more games the rest of the year.

2017-05-26T04:30:08+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Not in the least. If you said 'gotta laugh at them' I'd have agreed.

2017-05-26T04:22:01+00:00

Milo

Roar Rookie


No. You don't.

2017-05-26T04:14:48+00:00

Swannies

Guest


Gotta feel sorry for Richmond...

AUTHOR

2017-05-26T04:01:00+00:00

Mathew Langdon

Roar Pro


Well said Milo. That's exactly the point, they aren't losing through lack of quality, they lose through exceptional play from the other side or moments of sheer serendipity.

AUTHOR

2017-05-26T03:59:35+00:00

Mathew Langdon

Roar Pro


It's a great ride, but must take it out of the old ticker.

2017-05-26T02:59:42+00:00

Wayne

Guest


The unnanswered questions, capital R, little r, noun or verb? Maybe it is one of those special words that is both?

2017-05-25T23:54:27+00:00

Milo

Roar Rookie


Garbage. Carlton was almost 50/50 with expectations of significant improvements to Bolton's list. Collingwood beat Richmond in same game last year so was perceived as favorites given how close they'd run the Bulldogs week before. Brisbane at the gabba were showing signs of improvement under new coach Fagan, WCE were favorites and Melbourne was 50/50 and 20 points up leading into the last qrtr. Easy to be an expert in hindsight. Coulda shoulda woulda won the last three and the story changes. No excuses for those three though, but improvement on the ground is clear. Perhaps not so much in the head coach but that's another story.

2017-05-25T22:03:01+00:00

Rob

Guest


Carlton, collingwood, brisbane, west coast on the MCG and melbourne who hsd a ruckman and a tall forward off the groung by 1/2 time. Richmonds first 5 wins have been fools gold at best anyways...

2017-05-25T21:46:14+00:00

Neil from Warrandyte

Guest


It's the great conundrum- when the Tigers win (as in the first 5 weeks), they were lucky. When they lose, they were unlucky. As a passionate tiger supporter, there is no greater ride as you go through all the emotions X 10. Going through the lows magnifies the highs. How much sweeter will it be when we experience that ultimate success.

2017-05-25T21:12:27+00:00

Mark

Guest


Couldn't happen to a nicer club.

2017-05-25T20:45:00+00:00

Slane

Guest


I prefer 'Richmondesque'.

Read more at The Roar