The Wrap: Ash Dixon stands tallest in a ‘wow moment’ weekend

By Geoff Parkes / Expert

To use the modern vernacular, it’s been a ‘wow’ of a few days. Ever since Margaret Court dropped the bombshell that female tennis is “full of lesbians”, there’s been a procession of ‘knock me over with a feather and call me Al Baxter’ moments.

Fresh from the success of the recent Chiefs versus Crusaders match in Suva, I tuned into the Blues versus Reds match expecting to see half of Apia crammed in tight, enjoying their first taste of Super Rugby. But no, something was awry, and it soon emerged what.

The housing market in Auckland determines that anyone who owns property there is a millionaire, and anyone who rents there needs to be one. In that context, ticket prices ranging from NZ$20 to NZ$250 might be seen as fair value. But to maintain the same pricing structure for the Blues home game in Samoa? Wow, that’s some serious arrogance or incompetence, or both, right there.

The minimum wage in Samoa is Tala2.30, or around NZ$1.25 per hour, which provides for the rough but telling estimation of 16 hours work required to cover the minimum NZ$20 ground entry, or 200 hours work, or five weeks’ wages for a grandstand seat.

Think about that for a second; five weeks’ pay for a seat at a rugby game. The Blues and the Reds no less. That’s just for dad – make that five months’ pay to take mum and the two kids.

By comparison, the cheapest seat at AAMI Park for a Rebels fixture is $25, or $80 up with the suits. With Australia’s minimum wage at $17.70 per hour, that’s less than 1 1/2 hours’ work equivalent to ground entry, or around five hours for premium. Which either illustrates just how wrong the Blues got this, or that the Rebels have no idea how to run a business.

(AAP Image/Julian Smith)

(As an aside, upon checking prices online for the upcoming Rebels versus Jaguares match, I was greeted by red flags telling me “hurry, only 35 tickets left” and “tickets are likely to sell out soon”. Really? Why is the world full of so much rubbish?)

As for the game itself, no wow moments there, unfortunately. It took only six seconds for Henrick Tui to turn over possession for the first of three successive kickoffs, which set the scene for a messy match that resembled a pre-season warm-up fixture, both sides struggling to hold on to the ball with teammates looking unfamiliar with each other.

With the Lions tour match looming, that Tana Umaga could afford to rest a number of starting players, make four changes at half-time and still win probably says more about where the Reds are at. They were disrupted too, losing captain Samu Kerevi early with an ankle injury. He will be absolutely devastated to miss the Test match against Fiji next weekend.

New Zealanders, as a rule, hate dropkicks with a passion. They are looked down upon as an admission of failure and a yellow-bellied lack of intent. They’ve had some important ones kicked against them; JPR Williams in 1971 to win the final Lions Test and the series, and Joel Stransky to win the 1995 World Cup final spring to mind, although there have been a couple of notable ones for as well; Zinzan Brooke’s stunning effort against England in the same World Cup, and Dan Carter’s cool, spin on a dime party trick in the 2015 World Cup final against Australia.

But nobody in Christchurch was prepared for what Mitch Hunt did, in the 84th minute of another classic southern derby, breaking a 22-22 deadlock, after his pack had tried hit up after hit up but been repelled by a Highlanders’ defence which clearly wasn’t letting them advance anywhere.

Hunt’s impulsive decision to try to break the deadlock that way was astonishing enough, although one key factor which marks the dominance of New Zealand Super Rugby sides is the license given to players to try things.

That Hunt should connect, from 43 metres out, plus the angle, with the kick of his life, was a ‘wow moment’ that he, nor anyone present, will ever forget. The sheer excitement, the mobbing, the fact that fifteen minutes later, Kieran Read, with a Lions series about to start, couldn’t contain his excitement, shows exactly what keeping their unbeaten record intact means to this Crusaders side.

They had been well and truly rattled by the Highlanders who simply refused to go away, and while Hunt stole the spotlight, there was also much to like about Luke Romano’s dominant presence, and a high quality second half cameo by Israel Dagg.

And what about the Highlanders’ Ash Dixon, whose post-match interview epitomised all that is great about sport? That a young man in the aftermath of a heartbreaking loss, to a freak moment of individual brilliance, could throw away the book of clichés and so honestly and charitably speak from the heart about what it meant to compete, was truly special.

In a weekend full of ‘wow moments’ this was the one that stood tallest.

At the risk of turning this column into a regular Damien McKenzie love fest, anyone seeking a ‘wow’ 40 minutes should watch his first half against the Waratahs, where he handled the ball as many times as some players do in a season; every single touch a potential electric moment which the Waratahs were barely unable to contain.

To the predictable grizzlers harping about the Waratahs’ unwillingness to tackle or Nathan Grey’s inadequacies as a defensive coach, take a moment to think about the context. When ridiculously talented young men like McKenzie and James Lowe get a glint in their eye and play with such intent to attack at pace at every single opportunity, this isn’t the same game of rugby that armchair warriors might understand or have played themselves.

(AAP Image/Craig Golding)

Indeed, the Waratahs discovered in the second half that secure handling, fast ball movement and good backing up of their own made the Chiefs’ defence appear just as flimsy as theirs had done. Although once again, by then too much damage had already been done on the scoreboard.

Congratulations by the way, to halfback Jake Gordon, called into the Wallabies to replace the injured Nick Phipps. He’s far from the full deal yet, but that’s just recognition for hard work and on-field initiative.

This match also provided another stunning ‘wow moment’; Wallabies prop Sekope Kepu charging 60 metres, batting off Lowe, Aaron Cruden and McKenzie before scoring in the corner, in what is surely a hot contender already for ‘prop try of the century’.

Another ‘wow moment’ came with the realisation that I’d somehow agreed to a night out at ‘Murder on the Puffing Billy Express’, on a Saturday when there was so much rugby on. Leaving my phone at home to avoid the temptation of checking scores, a few reds and solving a murder proved a worthwhile distraction.

For the record it was (SPOILER DELETED) wot did it, although that was later forgotten, settling in for an ‘all-nighter’ back on the couch, catching up on the missed matches.

On the plus side, the British and Irish Lions achieved something no Australian side has managed this year; a win in New Zealand, 13-7 against a provincial Barbarians selection.

On the downside, well, take your pick. Unable to dominate a scratch team at set piece, too static, unable to transition quickly from defence to attack, poor passing in try-scoring situations were among the failings.

They Lions looked like a bunch of tired players mostly unfamiliar with each other, which is of course exactly what they are. Whatever the lazy and predictable press headlines, they will acclimatise and, despite the brutal itinerary, with better players to be added, hopefully rediscover the zest they will need to be competitive in the Test series.

Patience is required on all fronts.

(Mike Egerton/PA Wire)

It took a lot of patience too, to sit through the Brumbies versus Rebels match, this one going the way most predicted, 32-3 to the home side. The difference was mostly down to better organisation in defence and better ball handling, the Rebels turning the ball over 26 times to the Brumbies’ 14.

There was a ‘wow moment’ here as well, unfortunately of the bad variety. Marika Koroibete again showing that he has yet to master rugby’s kicking game. His seventh-minute chip kick, while flatfooted, with all of his teammates in front of him, was possibly one of the most unnatural acts seen on a rugby field in years.

The Force dished up plenty to the Hurricanes though they were unable to squeeze out the points that would have really made things interesting. What sets the very best sides apart is their ability to soak up pressure and then strike when they invariably do get chances at the other end, which is ultimately what won the Hurricanes this torridly competitive match, 34-12.

For the Force tragics seeking to blame referee Rohan Hoffman for the loss, I understand the siege mentality that has developed over the appalling situation with the ARU. Any outcome that sets the development of rugby back in WA is unambiguously unjust, and damaging to the game. But… here’s another ‘wow moment’ just for you.

Dane Haylett-Petty’s yellow card came after Vince Aso’s try made the score 22-7 with 12 minutes to play. The Force weren’t winning the game from there.

The card, insisted upon by TMO Damien Mitchelmore, was, on balance, justified. Haylett-Petty already committed? To what exactly? He wasn’t trying to charge Perenara’s kick down, nor was he trying to tackle him or bracing to protect himself.

What Mitchelmore saw was exactly what happened; Haylett-Petty turning his shoulder in to initiate late, no-arms contact that didn’t need to be made.

Not near the top of heinous rugby crimes, but meeting the guidelines for yellow card foul play nevertheless. Sure, on another day with another official he might have got away with it. But that’s the subjective and interpretative nature of rugby. Cop the call and move on.

As for Perenara being compared to Nicholas Sanchez and Marty Banks? Please. In what was a collision of some force, the notion that Perenara wasn’t blindsided and knocked clean off his feet but instead manufactured a dive shows little understanding of the combined laws of physics and common sense.

In the wash-up, the statistically minded will have noted three more wins by New Zealand Super Rugby sides against Australian opposition, taking the season tally to 23-0.

At the risk of applying the Baxter feather to myself, I can see a trend emerging. That this is now viewed as normal business and not a ‘wow moment’ is, in itself, a sorry indictment.

Get in touch with a Daikin dealer today so you don’t sit and suffer through another cold winter while watching the rugby this year. Trusted by many and suitable for the Australian lifestyle, Daikin really is The Best Air Anywhere.

The Crowd Says:

2017-06-06T05:44:32+00:00

concerned supporter

Guest


Hi Geoff, Jack Maddocks is 6 ft 4 in, and is normally a Full Back.

2017-06-06T03:55:46+00:00

piru

Roar Rookie


He wasn't chasing the ball he was tackling Perenara It used to be we allowed a tackle on a player who'd just passed the ball if they were already committed. Now we penalise them for a late hit, unless they try to pull out and still make contact, then we card them for no arms.

2017-06-05T23:54:00+00:00

Jibba Jabba

Roar Guru


Seriously i do know an optometrist who can assist you shop... :)

2017-06-05T21:45:12+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


Kepu played backrow before he switched to the front row. Not surprised that he had that in his locker

2017-06-05T21:43:07+00:00

Bakkies

Guest


Ireland have a lot of players out and two more have pulled out of the last pool game. Not an ideal time when you have a new coach as well

2017-06-05T18:40:45+00:00

Shop

Roar Guru


He wasn't turning to chase the ball, he was tracking TJP to tackle him. It was a very clever kick and it was done at the last minute which is why at normal speed it doesn't look that bad. DHP stepped across as the kick was made and in that split second he realized he couldn't make the tackle so he braced himself for the impact as anyone would.

2017-06-05T15:11:09+00:00

Brizvegas

Guest


You missed the head high on Riccetelli

AUTHOR

2017-06-05T13:09:25+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Yeah, I'm not sure there were too many other fullbacks stopping him either Nick!

2017-06-05T13:05:19+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


yeah demented rhino time!

2017-06-05T13:01:35+00:00

davSA

Guest


Ha Ha . It was simply sensational Nicholas and I will take my medicine but not sure if once Kepu could sniff that tryline after all those yards any fullback Damien Mackenzie or otherwise was going to stop him. He had hit deranged mode.

AUTHOR

2017-06-05T12:36:36+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Yes Fou, I forgot him. He never got out of the starting gates. I guess you could count English as a winger too. Kodama I mentioned. I actually asked about him at training, they like him but he's really very young and very slight. He was zipping around and obviously has a bit of speed, but physically looks at least another year, maybe more away from being able to mark up against some of the more powerful wingers.

2017-06-05T11:45:16+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Very pleasantly irreverent Geoff - and all the better for it! Surprised more hasn't been made of Sekope Kepu's stunning try. 73rd minute, tight-head prop runs in from 60 odd metres while beating three Chiefs backs in the process. And people wonder why Damian McKenzie isn't considered as an All Black contender at full-back. There you have it. No other prop in the world could have scored that try, esp at that stage of the game. :D

2017-06-05T11:36:09+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


Very good point Jumbo. If the same amount of time and energy was put to actually find ways for referee's to do a better job, things would most likely look glorious by now. World Rugby should take a long hard look in the mirror first, and after that look themselves into a room and not come out until they actually have an idea how rugby can be referred better. It is so obvious that pro rugby has evolved much faster than anyone responsible for rules and referees will admit. As it is today, it is an impossible task for a ref to be even close having a perfect game.

AUTHOR

2017-06-05T10:32:26+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Cheers Tony. Trust me I understand your frustration, particularly with all that is going on in the background. And some nights things don't run your way. But it's rare that a referee or a referee's decision actually determines the outcome of a game. Almost always it's the players. Like Peter Grant missing touch twice from penalties, the 2nd one right on halftime, which would have given the Force an attacking lineout, a few metres out from the try line. A try there would have had far more influence on the outcome than anything Hoffman did or didn't do.

2017-06-05T09:57:58+00:00

Tony

Guest


Thanks for the reply Geoff. You're right - I'm sure I know the game a lot less well than you, let alone Hoff. So maybe I've been too one-eyed. I don't have a problem with DHP's yellow, but you could consider it a 50:50 call, especially as Hoff had to be talked into it. What was galling, at least at the time, was that decisions went against us that did not seem to be "50:50". The blatant deviation to obstruct Verity Amm chasing the kick down the sideline at 20 min (replayed on the big screen, so don't see how the TMO missed it, let alone the AR) seemed a clear penalty - and then a penalty try would have to be at least considered. I checked the replay and yes, from 57 min the Canes did cop four penalties in five consecutive passages of play, the last three right on their own tryline. Having already being warned about persistent infringements, a YC did not seem a 50:50 decision to me. Nor could I understand the Tessman no try. But as most neutrals here seem to think these were genuine 50:50 decisions, I'm happy to concede I was wrong. I should also re-emphasise that the Canes were thoroughly deserving winners. I was just frustrated and felt that we deserved a closer scoreline, especially with enough problems on our plate already.

2017-06-05T09:56:57+00:00

In brief

Guest


How many people can wrap their arms around their own back? DHP was facing the opposite direction and let's get one thing clear- perenara didn't get hit with a shoulder at all, he ran into dhp's back.

2017-06-05T09:51:26+00:00

In brief

Guest


The hoff had made his decision, done and dusted, you could clearly hear his rationale as he ran towards the try line. Then without request and out of the blue the TMO comes through saying yellow card. So the TMO actually wasn't responding to a query, he was challenging the referee's final decision. That's why it was so wrong.

2017-06-05T09:51:03+00:00

Jumbo

Guest


Does everyone really think officials would be bias? I highly doubt it in this professional era.Just shows the incompetence by certain officials, aswel as faults in the current rules and regulations. The competition between referees is fierce, every body wants to look good for their boss and be seen to be the policeman.

AUTHOR

2017-06-05T08:52:55+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Hi CUW, Yes, good win for Clermont, I think they needed that. It's one thing to be consistently excellent, but also important to rack up some wins.

AUTHOR

2017-06-05T08:49:51+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Hi andrew This one's been done to death in the past, and has actually settled down a lot. Basically it's all about getting in position early to contest the catch. The law favours the player who is set to receive the catch, and if he leaves the ground in attempting the catch, no other player can make contact with him until he lands. The exception is if another player, from the kicking side, also arrives at the contest early and is also set, and jumps for the ball. This is deemed to be a genuine contest, even if they bump each other, and refs are mostly calling this as play on. Where the confusion and the potential issues you are talking about arises when a chasing player arrives just a wee bit late, or perhaps is looking at the ball and doesn't have full awareness or regard for the defending player's jump. In the past those instances were forgiven as accidental contact with no intent, but what happened was that, accident or not, too many players were being hurt and there was potential for very serious injury. The crackdown predictably caused outcry about the game going soft, but also predictably, has settled down quickly as players have got used to it. The golden rule for the chasing player is get there early, stop and jump and compete equally, and you're fine. But get there late, entering the area at speed, then you're setting yourself up for a problem. So best to hang back and let the catcher come to ground.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar