1998 top ten AFL draft reorder

By Conor / Roar Guru

It’s been 19 years since the 1998 AFL draft. Here’s how it should have looked, with the benefit of hindsight.

Pick 1 – Lenny Hayes – Brisbane (Originally Des Headland)
Hayes was a legend for the Saints across 16 years. He was originally taken with pick 11, playing 297 games and kicking 95 goals. He was the 2010 Norm Smith Medallist, three-time club best and fairest, two-time second in the club best and fairest, three-time third in the club best and fairest, three-time All-Australian, one-time third in the Brownlow Medal, Madden Medallist, and the St Kilda captain in 2004 and 2007. Imagine Hayes running around in a Lions midfield in the 2001-2003 three-peat.

Pick 2 – Brendan Fevola – Fremantle (Originally Justin Longmuir)
Fevola was a fantastic forward for the Lions and Blues across 13 years. He was originally taken with pick 38, playing 204 games – 187 for Carlton and 17 for Brisbane – and kicking 623 goals – 575 for Carlton and 48 for Brisbane. He is a seven-time club leading goalkicker, one-time Michael Tuck Medallist, two-time Coleman Medallist, and three-time All-Australian. Imagine Fev and Pav playing in the same forward line.

Pick 3 – Craig Bolton – Sydney (Originally Nic Fosdike)
Bolton was a fantastic player across 11 years. He was originally taken with pick 33, playing 199 games – 29 for Brisbane and 170 for Sydney – and kicked 25 goals – 10 for Brisbane and 15 for Sydney. He is a one-time premiership player, two-time All-Australian, and the Swans’ co-captain for 3 years.

Pick 4 – Brett Kirk – Sydney (Originally Ryan Fitzgerald)
Kirk was a great midfielder for the Swans across 12 years. He was originally taken with pick 40 in the rookie draft, playing 241 games and kicking 96 goals. He is a two-time club best and fairest, one-time All-Australian, two-time International Rules representative for Australia, one-time premiership player, Madden Medallist, and the Swans’ co-captain for 5 years.

Pick 5 – Brady Rawlings – Port Adelaide (Originally Michael Stevens)
Rawlings was a fantastic midfielder for the Kangaroos across 13 years. He was originally drafted with pick 15, playing 245 games and kicking 62 goals. He was a three-time club best and fairest, but unfortunately missed out on the 1999 premiership.

Pick 6 – Jude Bolton – Carlton (Originally Murray Vance)
Bolton was a fantastic midfielder across 15 years. He was originally taken with pick 8 by the Swans, playing 325 games and kicking 196 goals. He is a two-time premiership player, a one-time International Rules Series representative, a one-time Madden Medallist, and held the record for the most tackles in a career until Lenny Hayes surpassed him.

Pick 7 – Steven Baker – Port Adelaide (Originally Josh Carr)
Baker was a fantastic tagger across 13 years. He was originally drafted with pick 27, playing 203 games and kicking 35 goals for the Saints. He is a one-time club best and fairest and one-time third finish in the club best and fairest.

Pick 8 – Andrew Embley – Sydney (Originally Jude Bolton)
Embley was a great winger for the Eagles across 15 years. He was originally taken with pick 57, playing 250 games and kicking 216 goals. He is a one-time premiership player, one-time Norm Smith Medallist, and a one-time International Rules Series representative for Australia.

Pick 9 – Josh Carr – Essendon (Originally Mark McVeigh)
Carr had a nice career across 11 years at Port Adelaide and Fremantle. He was originally taken with pick 7 by the Power, playing 207 games – 124 for Port Adelaide and 83 for Fremantle – and kicked 109 goals – 65 for Port Adelaide and 44 for Fremantle. He is a one-time premiership player, one-time Peter Badcoe VC Medallist, one-time Ross Glendinning Medallist, Port Adelaide vice-captain for one year, and Fremantle vice-captain for two years.

Pick 10 – Brett Burton – West Coast (Originally Brandon Hill)
Burton had a great career across 12 years at the Crows. He was originally drafted with pick 16, playing 177 games and kicking 264 goals. He is a two-time club leading goalkicker and the 2009 Mark of the Year winner.

The Crowd Says:

2017-07-27T13:35:24+00:00

Bunney

Roar Rookie


I'd take David Wojcinski over Baker, and maybe a couple of others too. Played in three premierships - '07, '09 & '11, and had great run off HB. Jude was the better Bolton @ Sydney, and I have no idea why you've rated Rawlings so highly.

2017-07-21T03:35:00+00:00

johno

Guest


No way would Baker be in the top 10. Top 20 maybe

AUTHOR

2017-07-20T06:38:36+00:00

Conor

Roar Guru


JamesH, I have been doing a series of draft reorders from 1995 up until roughly around 2013/2014. This is the 4th in the series.

2017-07-20T02:41:06+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Guest


I reckon Kirky no.1 of that lot. Got delisted at least once. The draft is a funny old thing. Would like to see a best value list done by someone smarter than I. For example Big Brownie, currently 3rd in the Coleman was pick 47. He's only one or two decent midfielders away from toppling megastar Franklin and megahyped Daniher.

2017-07-20T00:50:34+00:00

Gordon Smith

Guest


Agree on Embley - Norm Smith medallist if I can recall correctly. To put baker or Rawlings ahead of him is an injustice.

2017-07-19T23:26:20+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


I'm curious about why you picked this year. It's not one of the better years IMO. Anyway, I think you have a couple of players too high/low. This is my order: Hayes Fevola Kirk J Bolton Embley C Bolton Rawlings Carr McVeigh Burton/Scotland Embley deserves to be top 5, while I have no doubt that the Bombers would still have taken McVeigh even if Carr had been available at pick 9. I couldn't decide between Burton and Scotland at 10 but Baker didn't quite make the cut. I'd have him at 12.

2017-07-19T23:16:12+00:00

Aransan

Guest


The problem for Fevola was always the d-head factor and the gambling didn't help.

Read more at The Roar