Pro wrestling and why more sport should be fake

By Sam Brown / Roar Guru

The soap opera for men, the ballet for blokes; you can call professional wrestling many things, but the one I hear the most is ‘fake’.

Alright, let’s get it out of the way early. When two ‘sports entertainers’ walk out to the squared circle (pro wrestling likes its oxymorons) they know exactly who is going to win and who is going to lose. The competition of the fight – or ‘performance’ – is a charade.

So yes, there is no way around it, pro wrasslin’ is ‘fake’ and for some that will be a deal breaker.

However its fakeness is in fact the sport’s greatest strength.

Once you look beyond the initial cringe of knowing it is as real as your child’s school play you may be able to see that removing the competition from sport can create some of the most compelling sporting characters and moments.

Now don’t get me wrong, the baby oil doused melodrama of the WWE isn’t for everyone, but ask yourself this: what is it that you like about sport?

Is it the skill of the athletes? Is it the characters and the stories of the participants? Is it the twists and turns and last minute brushes with triumph and disaster in the final minutes of a close game?

Every one of these aspects of sport is better when sport is fake.

Instead of two individuals or teams competing against each other, you have athletes working together to showcase their skills in the best light.

Sure, you may admire the Melbourne Storm’s ability to slow down the other team’s ruck speed with dodgy wrestling tactics. Or you may be in the minority that enjoys watching the Springboks constantly kicking the ball away and taking the reliable penalty goal option.

(AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

But take away the competition for a result and I can guarantee you a free-flowing match that goes down to the wire, where both sides are motivated to make one another look best.

And how many times has it been said that today’s sportsmen are too bland and never show any character?

In the WWE right now you can expect to see some of the following: an Irish bloke possessed by a demon that takes over him during big matches, two policemen who while beating their opponents issue tickets for fashion crimes, a cult leader, a wrestler who sidelines as an A-list movie star and a man who claims to be the ‘Modern Day Maharaja’ (King of India).

You may not want your footy players wearing face paint and luchador masks this weekend, but at least we could guarantee the Honey Badger and his post-match interviews a life spot in the Wallabies.

And all it comes with is the slight dirty aftertaste of knowing it was all organised beforehand.

It is like cough medicine: you take the initial nastiness because you know it is ultimately what’s best.

Historically wrestling is just ahead of the curve with this transition anyway, having evolved at the beginning of the 1900s from early carnival catch-wrestling.

Back then enterprising promoters realised they could make more at the gate (and with the bookies) if they could control who would win or lose.

And let’s face it, how do you know your favourite sport isn’t pre-determined already?

Tell me you didn’t raise an eyebrow when the Patriots came back from 21-3 down at the Super Bowl, Roger Federer, everyone’s favourite player has suddenly had a career renaissance after being unable to win a major for years and South Sydney have now shown the only way they could possibly have ever won a premiership was if the other teams let them.

So as the WWE’s second biggest event of the year Summerslam approaches if you think reminding me that the sweet science inside the squared circle is fake I will simply take it as a compliment and expect to cheer along with you come August 21.

The Crowd Says:

2017-08-15T09:33:57+00:00

J.C.

Roar Pro


True

2017-08-14T11:34:51+00:00

Matt

Guest


I think he learned that lesson with the Brawl-for-All.

2017-08-09T02:00:39+00:00

Chris Kettlewell

Roar Guru


Although that wouldn't necessarily even be learning from Pro Wrestling. Plenty of other sports have done those sorts of things for years. In the NBA finals they announce players onto the court one by one. (I think they might do the same in other US sports. So maybe it's just more of a US thing). Boxing (which is sometimes seems almost as rigged as WWE) has often had the big entrances of the opponents with music blaring and the like. I don't know that UFC would want to go that way, because in a way it's almost a reaction to both Boxing and WWE, trying to just be really raw, pure fighting using whatever techniques a fighter has at their disposal. And I think it's that rawness that draws a lot of it's supporters who then probably wouldn't want it to go overly flashy.

AUTHOR

2017-08-08T09:26:10+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


Ba'h God

AUTHOR

2017-08-08T08:12:24+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


Yeah, unfortunately there is no putting that one back in the bottle & I doubt in today's society with all the forms of communication we have it would remain a secret long even if the big organisations would try to keep it secret. If nothing else the WWE is a publically traded company and it is illegal for them to lie to their share holders. Now I think the most engaging angles tend to be when art imitates life, like when CM Punk blew up, Daniel Bryan at WM30 or this WM with Cena v Miz. Then again if things are presented seriously and without a wink and a nudge pure fiction can still be compelling. Look at the ongoing story between Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins or even just the series between The Revival and DIY, people are seriously emotionally engaged in those angles. As Mac Landis says, it is 'no more fake than Game of Thrones' and we still get caught up in that.

AUTHOR

2017-08-08T08:06:34+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


You caught me out! How'd you guess? Honestly though I think insulting pro wrestling by calling it fake is pretty weak, if nothing else there are so many better reasons to insult it sometimes! Sport could for sure learn from the thwarted of pro wrestling I think of entrance music in the UFC, they've only occasionally made a big deal of it and a great entrance gives your contender a feeling of importance and gravitas which will help people think they are a big deal and ultimately help the UFC make more stars. In Australian sport I'd love to see players get individual announcements for big games like a Grand Final or State of Origin. They could all learn how to put together an emotive video package from pro wrestling too - especially rugby union.

AUTHOR

2017-08-08T07:50:59+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


Wasn't fake though, was a legit sports league. Vince actually looked into buying the UFC at one point but ultimately declined he said it was because he couldn't control who were the stars. Much easier to build someone up as the best in the world when you don't have to worry them some how slipping and losing.

2017-08-08T04:43:51+00:00

J.C.

Roar Pro


Whats your point??

2017-08-08T04:35:43+00:00

Mike Julz

Guest


Wait didn't we saw something similar with the XFL. The XFL was a football league ran by Vince McMahon and the wwe around early 2000s and it ended after just one season.

2017-08-08T03:44:00+00:00

J.C.

Roar Pro


Maybe its time to into reality mate, actually no don't your better off that way

2017-08-08T03:07:46+00:00

Jerry

Guest


It's still real to me, damn it.

2017-08-08T01:40:26+00:00

J.C.

Roar Pro


Summerslam is number 3, Vince McMahon has admitted that several times. But in regards to your article i think that the stupidest thing the wrestling industry, not just WWE ever did was throw back to curtain to give the fans the truth that wrestling was in fact nothing more than a stage play on human growth hormone. Kayfabe is dead as the walls of the illusion that wrestling is real are now gone. Wrestlers both baby face ( good guys) and heel ( bad guys) are seen together before and after shows together as many of them are mates. Back in the 80s and til late 90s the wrestlers stayed in different hotels and were fined or even fired in they were seen together before or after a shows. These days they are eating dinner after beating each other up in the ring that night. And worst of all back in the day if you said to a wrestler that pro wrestling is fake they would of knocked your head off, now they asked well what rock have you been under?? It never should of happened as over the last fifteen years the not just wwe but wrestling in general has been in a steady decline as people are turning away from wwe in favour of the UFC as the ufc is real. Well that are that bloody stupid PG era that has been going on for the last decade.

AUTHOR

2017-08-07T23:16:52+00:00

Sam Brown

Roar Guru


I'll give you that the Rumble can potentially be bigger than SummerSlam but Survior Series? Come on now, not even close. Just look at the respective main events over the last 5 years. Aside from Goldberg last year I think SummerSlam is always the bigger one. As for Jinder. What are your thoughts on him generally. He is as juicy as Vince likes his male wrestlers so it's clear why he is getting the push he is getting but I still don't see anything beyond his physique.

2017-08-07T22:36:35+00:00

Wayne

Roar Guru


You had me until I read that Summerslam is 2nd biggest event of the year... The 2nd biggest is easily the Royal Rumble. The start of the Road to Wrestlemania. Summerslam is in reality 4th of the BIG FOUR (Rumble, Mania, Summerslam, Survivor Series). Also love WWE wants us to forget that the 'Modern Day Maharaja' is in fact, from CANADA! Still, he falls into the category of "Big Sweaty Men" then Vince McMahon loves.

2017-08-07T21:54:34+00:00

Eden

Guest


I agree that wrestling gets a bad wrap for being fake. The wrestlers still get pretty battered and bruised. I get this is a bit tongue in cheek but still disagree with the main concept that other sports should be have pre determined drama. Part of what makes drama in sport so dramatic is the fact that it is real. However I think all sports could borrow the theatre from wrestling. For fear of motivating the opposition every interview with a player or coach is dead boring. Willie mason Was great for being a character that you loved or hated but ultimately wanted to watch. I want the players to get into the emotion of the fans.

Read more at The Roar