2013 top ten AFL draft reorder

By Conor / Roar Guru

Only four years on from the 2013 draft, there are a few changes that could be made with the benefit of hindsight.

Pick 1 – Marcus Bontempelli – GWS Giants (Originally Tom Boyd)
‘Boy oh boy wowee’ as Brian Taylor would say, isn’t Bontempelli a promising talent?

He was originally drafted with pick four, playing 84 games and kicking 78 goals to date. He is a one-time premiership player, one-time Charles Sutton Medallist, and one-time All-Australian. ‘The Bont’ has the potential to become a Brownlow medallist one day.

Pick 2 – Josh Kelly – GWS Giants (Originally Josh Kelly)
Despite his future being up in the air and discussed often this year, Kelly has gone from being good to being great.

He was originally selected at this pick, playing 80 games and kicking 52 goals to date. He is a one-time rising star nominee and is in contention to be an All-Australian and the Giants best and fairest winner this year. He has potential to become a Brownlow Medallist one day.

Pick 3 – Zach Merrett – St Kilda (Originally Jack Billings)
Merrett has become a star for the Bombers. He took a few years to act on his potential, but when he did, it was fantastic. He was originally taken with pick 26, playing 79 games and kicking 27 goals to date. He is a one-time club best and fairest and certainly looks like having the potential of being a future Brownlow Medallist.

Pick 4 – Ben Brown – Western Bulldogs (Originally Marcus Bontempelli)
‘Sideshow Bob’, as many people call him due to his hair style, has become an important part of the Roos line-up this year as the number one forward.

He was originally drafted with pick 47, playing 76 games and kicking 147 goals to date. He is a one-time club leading goalkicker and is in contention for All-Australian selection this year. He certainly has potential to be a Coleman Medallist later in his career.

Pick 5 – Jesse Hogan – Gold Coast (Originally Kade Kolodjashnij)
Despite his challenging run of injuries, with his 2014 season ruled out due to a back injury, and this year disrupted by suspension, his father’s death from cancer, being diagnosed with testicular cancer, and a collarbone injury, he is still seen as one of the best forwards in the game.

He was originally selected with pick two in the 2012 mini-draft, playing 50 games and kicking 105 goals to date. He is a two-time club leading goalkicker, one-time Ron Evans Medallist, and one-time Harold Ball Memorial Trophy winner. Like Brown, he has the potential to be a Coleman Medallist later in his career.

Pick 6 – Patrick Cripps – Collingwood (Originally Matt Scharenberg)
Gee, hasn’t Cripps become a great midfielder?

Filling in greatly since Chris Judd retired in 2015, he was originally taken with pick 13, playing 59 games and kicking 23 goals to date. He is a one-time club best and fairest and the 2015 runner-up in the rising star award. Like Bontempelli, Kelly, and Merrett, he has the potential to become a Brownlow Medallist in his career.

[latest_videos_strip category=”afl” name=”AFL”]

Pick 7 – Kade Kolodjashnij – Brisbane (Originally James Aish)
Kolodjashnij has been a fantastic player for the Suns since debut. He was originally drafted with pick five, playing 70 games and kicking 13 goals to date. He is a one-time Harrison Medallist and one-time rising star nominee.

Pick 8 – Matt Crouch – North Melbourne (Originally Luke McDonald)
Crouch, the brother of teammate Brad, has been a fantastic midfielder for the Crows. He was originally selected with pick 23, playing 68 games and kicking 15 goals to date. He is a one-time rising star nominee.

Pick 9 – Charlie Cameron – Melbourne (Originally Christian Salem)
Cameron has been a terrific small forward for the Crows alongside Eddie Betts in a dangerous Adelaide forward line. He was originally taken with pick nine in the rookie draft, playing 69 games and kicking 75 goals to date. He is a one-time rising star nominee.

Pick 10 – Jayden Hunt – Collingwood (Originally Nathan Freeman)
Hunt has become an important rebound defender with his thrilling speed for the Demons, as shown in their loss to Sydney in Round 15 when he played up forward with no success. He was originally drafted with pick 57, playing 40 games and kicking ten goals to date. He is a one-time Harold Ball Memorial Trophy winner.

The Crowd Says:

2017-08-24T10:27:40+00:00

me too

Roar Rookie


Dunstan is better than Acres and has been from the get go. Hit a rough patch this year but been the Saints best since his return and in the best every week. The guy will go on to have a great career.

2017-08-24T10:25:03+00:00

me too

Roar Rookie


Gee Billings easily ahead of the last four and continuing to build. Go have a look at their current season stats. charlie cameron ahead of billings? wow!

2017-08-24T09:47:30+00:00

David C

Guest


I'd put Hogan ahead Merrett as well.

AUTHOR

2017-08-24T08:44:55+00:00

Conor

Roar Guru


Thank you Mattyb, also, once the top ten reorder series is over, I know people have wanted me to list the unlucky players, however there is a reason I haven't. I'll go back again to 1995 and I'll reorder pick 11-20.

2017-08-24T05:16:58+00:00

Mattyb

Guest


Just on that Conor,your series has been excellent in acknowledging just how many rookies have made substantial contributions to their clubs while also outlining how many past top ten picks havnt lived up to the original hype. I've thought some of your reorders have been excellent,but some I've disagreed with,but I think that's the nature of the excercise. The series has been thoroughly enjoyable and you have displayed some wonderful knowledge and opinion.

AUTHOR

2017-08-24T04:09:03+00:00

Conor

Roar Guru


Col from Brissie, Zac Williams (Pick 10) and Dane Rampe (Pick 6) in the 2012 top ten draft reorder - http://www.theroar.com.au/2017/08/24/2012-top-ten-afl-draft-reorder/ Rory Laird (Pick 9) in the 2011 top ten draft reorder - http://www.theroar.com.au/2017/08/22/a-reorder-of-the-2011-afl-draft/ Jeremy McGovern (Pick 5) in the 2010 top ten draft reorder - http://www.theroar.com.au/2017/08/17/a-reorder-of-the-2010-afl-draft/ Ed Curnow was originally taken by Adelaide in 2007 rookie draft, and didn't make the 2007 top ten reorder. I did not include him in the 2010 top ten draft reorder due to the fact he was previously drafted by Adelaide. - http://www.theroar.com.au/2017/08/11/2007-top-ten-afl-draft-reorder/ Zak Jones was also unlucky not to make it into my top ten reorder. Been good for the Swans so far.

2017-08-24T03:25:23+00:00

Mattyb

Guest


Yep,and Conor selected Rampe at 6 and Williams at 10 in his reorder article relating to the year they were drafted.

2017-08-24T02:46:29+00:00

Ian Whitchurch

Guest


Brown and Hogan are both from the same draft class and are dminating games the way Tom Boyd isnt. Just as well he had a great agent :)

2017-08-24T02:06:21+00:00

Lyndon

Guest


This is all wrong. Hogan better than Brown, Cripps after Hogan, followed by Sheed, Crouch, Brown, Kolo and then Cameron. I'm embarrassed for you that you had Hunt ahead of Sheed.

2017-08-24T02:01:17+00:00

Col from Brissie

Roar Guru


I would have Sydney's Zak Jones as an unlucky omission as well. There were some pretty decent Rookie upgrades that year as well - Jeremy McGovern, Ed Curnow, Rory Laird, Dean Rampe and Zach Williams to name a few.

AUTHOR

2017-08-24T01:36:24+00:00

Conor

Roar Guru


Yeah, Billings, Acres, and Fantasia, I struggled to fit in so they were unlucky, as well as Tom Langdon. At pick 9 and 10, I chose between Billings, Acres, Fantasia, Langdon, Cameron, and Hunt. Wasn't easy to decide

AUTHOR

2017-08-24T01:33:27+00:00

Conor

Roar Guru


Boyd hasn't lived up to expectations yet, but I do have hope that he will come good as he matures. History has shown big men take longer to develop

2017-08-24T01:21:10+00:00

Brian

Guest


THe more recent ones are more up for debate, a guy like Boyd could stil be fantastic or he may just remain a dissapointment.

2017-08-24T01:11:50+00:00

Mattyb

Guest


This was a fantastic draft year and you've done an excellent job Conor. I'd probably leave out Cameron. On potential I'd still have Billings in the top ten and an argument could be put forward for Acres and Fantasia. I'm a big fan of Fantasia though,I think he's a little ripper. Would be really interesting where Tom Boyd would go if this draft was done again now. I think a club would take a punt and he'd still go top 10,you were correct leaving him out of your top ten though.

2017-08-24T00:47:12+00:00

Liam

Guest


I'd appreciate an explanation as to why you have Merrett over Cripps. Could be due entirely to one playing for a side about to play finals; short memories and all that.

Read more at The Roar