Winners and losers of the summer transfer window

By Christian Montegan / Roar Pro

Football’s summer transfer window has just concluded. Here’s how everyone fared.

Winners
AC Milan

In February next year, it will mark four years since Milan played their last competitive game in the Champions League. For such a massive club, it hasn’t been acceptable and the previous owner, Silvio Berlusconi, had a lot to do with that by not investing in the club like he once did.

That resulted in a change in ownership in May, as Milan were bought out by Chinese owners with an ambition to bring the club back to the top of world football. Judging by the transfer window, the $260 million they have spent have suggested that they are deadly serious about their new project.

Eleven new signings were made, most notably the purchase of Leonardo Bonucci caught everyone by surprise. Others such as Hakan Calhanoglu, Frank Kessie, Andre Silva, Ricardo Rodriguez and Andrea Conti have all been quality purchases and for this reason they can challenge for the scudetto.

Milan are indeed the biggest winners of this transfer window. Watch out for them this season.

Remarkable.

PSG
The Parisian owners have done a fine job this summer, recruiting two of the hottest prospects in world football. The signing of Neymar from Barcelona sent shockwaves across the world.

The huge $262 million transfer fee forced fans to take notice and appreciate that Paris Saint-Germain will be one of the favourites to win the Champions League. He will give the club a lot of goals and creativity on the pitch as well as brand exposure off it.

Only three weeks ago was Kylian Mbappe linked to a move to his dream club Real Madrid. However, Paris Saint-Germain once again found a way to lure another talented prospect to the French capital on loan, with the option to buy next season for over $210 million.

Oh, and don’t forget the purchase of Dani Alves. The Brazilian full-back will give Paris Saint-Germain some much needed experience in they are to challenge for the Champions League.

Both Neymar and Mbappe have become the two most expensive transfers on history, sending strong warning signs to its European rivals that they mean business.

Ridiculously good.

Juventus
Whenever a season goes past, Juventus always seem to find a way to strengthen their squad with even more depth. The depature of Bonucci was disappointing for the club, but they were able to replace him with experienced German Benedikt Howedes, as well as keep hold of prize assets Alex Sandro and Paulo Dybala, rejecting bids from Chelsea and Barcelona for $83 million and $190 million respectively.

Then there’s Italian and Brazilian wingers Federico Bernardeschi and Douglas Costa. Both are extremely talented players with a lot to give going forward. Finally, Blaise Matuidi would have to be the bargain of the summer, costing as little as $25 million. The Frenchman will be consistent and offer accurate passing and awareness in Juve’s build up play.

Expect another strong season from them this campaign.

Solid.

Bayern Munich
In the past few seasons, the main objective for the German champions was specifically to win the Champions League. That hasn’t happened, but winning the Bundesliga will always be an easy task for them.

In terms of their new signings, it has created depth and new problems which is a good thing for Carlo Ancelotti. The loan signing of James Rodriguez caught everyone’s attention, and the Colombian will be a valued addition going forward.

As well as the acquisitions of Corentin Tolisso and Niklas Süle, Bayern were able to keep hold of their main stars such as Arturo Vidal and David Alaba.

Putting Renato Sanches out on loan to Swansea will see the Germans benefit as he has the potential to become one of the best midfielders in the world. He will only grow stronger.

Smart business.

(AP Photo/Andres Kudacki,file)

Losers
Arsenal

After the signing of French striker Alexandre Lacazette from Lyon, fans and pundits were actually having second thoughts about if Arsenal could maybe challenge for the title.

Instead, they have since suffered throughout the summer by not being able to sort out the Alexis Sanchez saga firstly. By him staying, it will only cause disharmony and unnecessary tension in the locker room.

Not being able to complete the Thomas Lemar deal on deadline was nearly as embarrassing as the $120 million they were prepared to pay for him.

They also weren’t able to strengthen the midfield and defence, which is a real concern.

Disappointing.

Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang
It was only at the start of June that Aubameyang was inches away from completing his move to Paris Saint-Germain for a hefty price. The Paris club pulled out at the last minute, and since then it has caused a domino effect as clubs have started becoming hesitant.

The player wanted to leave, but Dortmund just didn’t want to let him go. He revealed that he wanted to return to AC Milan, but Dortmund refused any offers.

The Gabon international is just going to have to work a bit harder this season to force a move next summer transfer window.

Unfortunate.

Barcelona
Yes, the loss of Neymar would have come as quite a shock for the club, but that was no excuse to not find a suitable replacement.

All Barca did this summer was panic. Offering silly amounts of money to clubs to lure players such as Lorenzo Insigne, Paulo Dybala and Philippe Coutinho for $119 million, $190 million and $178 million respectively which showed just how desperate they were.

They were able to purchase the 20-year-old Ousmane Dembele making him the third most expensive transfer in history. A talented player, but Barcelona are taking a risk just hoping on potential. Same goes for right-back Semedo. Paulinho was also a terrible purchase from the Chinese Super League, showing just how far Barcelona have fallen.

Embarrassing.

Financial Fair Play

Seriously, no words can describe how pathetic this FFP rule has become. No one understands how it works or what are the actual regulations behind it.

How Paris Saint-Germain can spend nearly $500 million on two players makes the FFP an absolute joke.

Ludicrous.

The Crowd Says:

2017-09-05T02:36:59+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


Good to hear.

2017-09-04T23:47:38+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Rellum Thanks and health is fine now.

2017-09-04T23:46:56+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Mods You actually removed my post that listed 62 Football posters and their names that posted on a thread.... You then removed comments about it .... Wow nay mega Wow to the extreme wow

2017-09-04T22:00:29+00:00

chris

Guest


MF had a read (cheers) and interesting to see many of the posters that basically dont exist anymore (or they've changed names). I come to this site to read & discuss football with people that are passionate about the game. I hope we dont lose that.

2017-09-04T10:02:59+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


The club is slowly moving on from Rosella. It is taking time. If the Stadium ever gets up then I think you will see the sales start to slow down. And some of those sales are a direct result of FFP issues I believe still stem from the Rosella years.

AUTHOR

2017-09-04T09:46:09+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


I'm sorry to say but Roma won't win any major trophy for years to come. It doesn't help when you turn into a selling club and have no direction whatsoever. No heart in that team besides De Rossi and Florenzi. Draw too many games and drop points to average opposition. Juventus are too consistent

2017-09-04T08:35:05+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


Very kind words from you Mid. I know we used to have our different opinions on Fozzy and SBS but I always respected your opinions, passion and knowledge for the game. I hope you have fully moved on from that heart scare as well mate. The cricket discussions on this site are still generally good, but can descend into the same two topics too quickly. The league discussions are getting overrun by ref whinging at times now but there is still a decent level of discussion there.

2017-09-04T08:31:34+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


That all depends on Di Francesco and how he adapts. He is wedded to a 4-3-3, but with the buys we have made he needs to be more flexible with his tactics. We also need to stop the endless ACL's with the wing backs. If those two things happen then I can see us easily being in the top four and again pushing Juve for the scudetto.

2017-09-04T08:27:54+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


When the mods get thr with the post it list 62 posters on the article of which 55 were Football posters and most regular posters... then adds another few who did not post on that thread...

2017-09-04T08:23:24+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


mods why the moderation

2017-09-04T07:09:27+00:00

Grobbelaar

Roar Guru


That was a pretty good discussion, over 200 comments, many different posters and opinions. It's hard to believe it could have changed in such a short space of time.

AUTHOR

2017-09-04T06:43:13+00:00

Christian Montegan

Roar Pro


Don't see Roma making the top 4. Key departures such as Salah and Rudiger haven't been properly replaced and with a new coach it will take time to get to understand the football he wants Roma to play.

2017-09-04T06:42:09+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Nem & Chris Also and this is very important, PLEASE read the comments in the above article, you will go a long way to find hhhmmmm thread disturbers, the site was well moderated... A similar article today would be bombed with certain posters... I hope the mods are taking note ... of these posts.

2017-09-04T06:37:12+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Chris and others new to this site, maybe you see what I am posting and maybe you need an example. This is an example of what i am talking about, Ok its one of my articles, but look at the quality of the discussion and many if not most of the these posters have now left. http://www.theroar.com.au/2013/03/05/is-football-in-australia-at-a-tipping-point/

2017-09-04T06:21:54+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Rellum Like a lot of posters who have left, your posts and comments where always insightful and you had an ability to express yourself very well, along with many others who have left I miss the discussions that once took place on this site.

2017-09-04T06:04:18+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


I don't discussing football on here any more Mid as it is just not worth, too much anger and little thoughtful discussion.

2017-09-04T06:01:11+00:00

nachos supreme

Guest


In recent memory, Talking the 90's and early 2000's. When Serie A was truly the top of the tree in terms of quality players and managers including a top 6 sides who's rosters included the who's who of the worlds finest. It's quality was NOT defined by goals scored. I can take a step or two away from your perspective and say that a comp that averages more goals means that it's full of sub standard defending and lacks managers that are tactically aware.

2017-09-04T05:12:19+00:00

Midfielder

Guest


Without doubt this was the best football site in Australia nothing came close to it and nothing came close to the quality of the writing and the articles There was lots of very intelligent articles and very intelligent discussions today that is certainly not the case

2017-09-04T04:02:33+00:00

chris

Guest


Thanks for the clarification. I'm relatively new on this site so not sure what it was like previously.

2017-09-04T03:42:37+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


I would think it would be Juve, Napoli, Roma and Inter in the top four. Obviously not in that order as Roma are obvious specials this year :).

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar